Skip to main content
Print

Efrain Reyes

Snapshot

Efrain “Stone” Reyes was Jeffrey Epstein’s final cellmate at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York. He shared Epstein’s cell after psychological observation ended on July 30, 2019, and was transferred to the Queens Detention Facility on August 9. No replacement cellmate was assigned. Epstein was found unresponsive the following morning.

Reyes’s August 16, 2019 interview preserves an unusually close account of Epstein’s final days. It describes shared meals, practical help, concerns about suicide, a disturbing incident involving a clothesline and failures in prison supervision. Reyes was no longer at MCC when Epstein died. He did not witness the fatal event or the discovery.

  • Name: Efrain Reyes.
  • Reported nickname: Stone.
  • BOP register number: 85993 054.
  • Role in the Epstein records: Cellmate and investigative witness.
  • Relevant cell: Cell Z06 220, commonly described as Cell 220, on the SHU’s L Tier.
  • Shared cell period: July 30 to August 9, 2019.
  • Transfer destination: Queens Detention Facility, a contract facility managed by GEO Group.
  • Recorded interview: August 16, 2019, under a proffer agreement.
  • Criminal case: United States v. Nelson and others, case 18 cr 454, with Reyes’s proceedings before Judge Katherine Polk Failla.
  • Reported death: November 27, 2020, in the Bronx, aged 51.
  • Evidence status: His death is documented. The precise medical cause is not established by the prosecutor emails reviewed here.
  • Coverage date: October 11, 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Reyes was Epstein’s final cellmate, rather than the cellmate present during the July 23 neck injury incident. That earlier cellmate was Nicholas Tartaglione.
  • His August 9 departure was a transfer between detention facilities. It was not his release into the community.
  • Two August 8 Marshals Service emails gave MCC advance notice of the transfer. The prison therefore had an opportunity to arrange another cellmate.
  • Reyes’s interview records concerns about Epstein harming himself. Those concerns coexist with his description of Epstein joking and sharing food on their final evening.
  • He described intervening when Epstein handled a makeshift clothesline. The notes document a concerning observation, but they do not establish a completed suicide attempt during that incident.
  • His account distinguishes formal inmate counts from frequent observation rounds. He described the rounds as inadequate even when counts occurred.
  • His guilty plea transcript confirms cooperation with prosecutors and a request for secrecy based on safety concerns.
  • Reyes died after investigators had interviewed him. Claims that he died before anyone could obtain his account are incorrect.
  • Reporting connected his death to COVID. A prosecutor separately speculated about a possible drug connection while expressing uncertainty. Neither substitutes for a medical determination.
  • His account is important evidence about prison conditions and warning signs. It does not make him an eyewitness to Epstein’s death or establish that he participated in a killing.

Why Efrain Reyes matters

Reyes occupied a position that most investigators, lawyers and commentators did not: he lived inside Epstein’s cell. He saw where Epstein slept, how he interacted with officers, what he ate and how his mood changed.

His departure also removed a specific safety measure. Psychology staff had directed that Epstein have an appropriate cellmate. Prison officials had selected Reyes through a process involving senior leadership. When he left, that process did not produce a replacement.

The investigation into Epstein’s death therefore requires attention to Reyes’s observations and to the institutional decisions surrounding his transfer. The key question is not simply why Reyes left. It is why the prison left Epstein alone despite knowing that Reyes was leaving.


Identity and criminal case

The Justice Department’s 2018 narcotics announcement identifies Efrain Reyes, nicknamed Stone, among 12 defendants accused of participating in a Bronx drug distribution conspiracy. It lists him as 49 at that time.

The alleged activity involved crack cocaine, heroin and marijuana around the Murphy Houses and Lambert Houses between 2016 and June 2018. These were narcotics allegations, not charges involving Epstein’s trafficking operation.

His August 26, 2019 plea transcript documents his guilty plea proceedings concerning Count One. He told the court he was 50 and had obtained a GED while incarcerated in New York State.

Search results for the same name include unrelated criminal cases. The BOP identifier, Bronx case, nickname and Judge Failla’s docket provide stronger identity markers than a name match alone. An unrelated person’s sentence or conviction should not be added to Reyes’s biography.


Cooperation and placement in the SHU

Attorney Marlon G. Kirton’s statements at the plea hearing establish that Reyes was entering a cooperation agreement. Kirton said his client had met with the government about his own conspiracy and other criminal matters.

The parties requested delayed docketing and a sealed transcript for safety reasons. Judge Failla asked for an explanation before granting that request.

Reyes’s cooperation is relevant when evaluating his statements and why officials protected parts of his court record. It does not establish that authorities planted him beside Epstein to conduct a covert operation. The reviewed documents do not supply such an instruction.


How officials selected him as Epstein’s cellmate

The final DOJ Inspector General report explains that the MCC captain compiled and vetted possible cellmates. The warden identified two candidates and tentatively chose the person identified in the report as Inmate 3.

The warden said he passed that choice to the BOP director’s chief of staff and later received approval to assign Inmate 3. The interview, movement records and BOP register number identify that inmate as Reyes.

No substitute had been vetted in advance. Senior staff described a process that would require reviewing another list if Reyes left MCC. That lack of preparation became consequential when his transfer occurred.

Reyes’s placement was thus part of an acknowledged safety arrangement. It was not merely an incidental shared cell assignment with no significance for Epstein’s supervision.


July 30 and the move to Cell 220

The OIG’s housing chronology places Epstein’s return from psychological observation on July 30. Epstein and Reyes were initially assigned to a cell on J Tier, then moved to Cell 220 on L Tier to accommodate the electrical requirements of Epstein’s personal medical device.

The report explains that SENTRY contained inaccurate information about the date and cell assignment. A database entry suggesting July 29 should not displace the investigated chronology.

Cell 220 was approximately 15 feet from the officers’ station and had a direct line of sight toward it. That proximity did not mean officers could see every part of its interior.

Reyes described Epstein’s floor mattresses as partly outside the view available through the closed door. The location of the cell and the visibility inside it were separate issues.


Reyes’s concern about becoming an informal suicide monitor

The handwritten interview notes on PDF page 2 record Reyes’s reaction to discovering who his new cellmate was. He knew Epstein had recently been on suicide watch and objected to being placed in that situation.

According to Reyes, a lieutenant told him Epstein was okay and asked him to keep an eye on him. Reyes questioned whether he was being expected to serve as a suicide prevention advocate. He said the concern was brushed aside.

The OIG report includes this account. It does not describe Reyes as formally assigned to provide continuous suicide watch inside the cell.

An inmate’s presence could offer companionship and another chance to notice distress. It could not replace required staff rounds, clinical assessment or an effective emergency response.


Sleeping arrangements and cell conditions

Reyes’s account on PDF pages 2 and 3 states that he had a bottom bunk pass and Epstein slept on mattresses on the floor. Reyes said staff brought two mattresses for Epstein.

He recalled offering Epstein the lower bunk because the floor area was difficult to see and the cell had pests. Epstein declined. Reyes also described helping him make his bed.

His statements record extra blankets and writing implements that he regarded as unusual. These observations bear on property control and living conditions, but his description alone does not establish how every item was authorized or obtained.

The OIG separately documented deficient cell searches and excess linens. Those investigative findings are stronger support for institutional failures than an assumption that every unusual item proves bribery.


Shared food, practical help and commissary money

The interview notes describe ordinary exchanges within the cell. Reyes helped with bedding, shared food and recalled Epstein obtaining a radio and soap for him.

On PDF page 9, Reyes said Epstein told him he had put $200 on his commissary account several days before Reyes left. Reyes said he spent $50.

This is Reyes’s account of a commissary payment. It should not be treated as a verified account ledger unless the transaction record is separately produced.

The exchange does not establish a payment for silence, participation in Epstein’s trafficking crimes or involvement in his death. It documents the relationship Reyes described developing during their brief time together.


What Reyes said Epstein told him about July 23

PDF pages 6 and 7 of the interview package record statements Reyes attributed to Epstein about the earlier neck injury incident. Reyes said Epstein denied trying to kill himself and said his previous cellmate had not attacked him.

Reyes was not the cellmate present during that event. His account is therefore evidence of what he said Epstein later told him, rather than a firsthand reconstruction of July 23.

Other records contain different statements attributed to Epstein. The BOP inquiry did not conclusively resolve whether the earlier injury arose from self harm, assault or another cause.

Reyes’s account should be preserved alongside those discrepancies. It does not justify presenting either an assault or a suicide attempt as conclusively established by his testimony.


The clothesline incident

The handwritten account on PDF pages 8 and 9 describes Reyes waking to find Epstein sitting on his bed and handling a makeshift clothesline. Reyes questioned him, objected and recalled flushing the material down the toilet.

Epstein reportedly offered an explanation that he was trying to fix something. Reyes nevertheless interpreted the conduct as concerning and told him not to harm himself in their cell.

This is a significant warning account. It combines an observed action with Reyes’s interpretation. The notes do not establish that Epstein had already suspended himself, lost consciousness or completed a suicide attempt during that incident.

Descriptions that convert the entire event into a proven attempted hanging go beyond what these notes establish. The observed handling of material, Reyes’s intervention and the uncertainty about intent should remain distinct.


Despair and reassurance

Reyes’s interview records Epstein expressing distress about confinement and believing his life would never return to normal. Reyes encouraged him to believe that life in custody remained possible.

Reyes repeatedly asked Epstein not to kill himself while they shared a cell. He explained that he expected a chance to go home and did not want to wake to find his cellmate dead.

According to Reyes, Epstein reassured him that he would not cause trouble. Reyes later offered the opinion that Epstein might have been getting officers accustomed to seeing less of him.

The distress and reassurance are reported conversations. The proposed explanation of Epstein’s strategy is Reyes’s interpretation, not an independently established plan.


Medical concerns before the transfer

PDF page 6 records another incident in which Reyes thought Epstein looked pale and unwell. He said he called for assistance and staff eventually arranged medical attention.

The same page records a conversation before Reyes’s Friday departure about whether Epstein felt like hurting himself and whether he wanted suicide watch. Some identities and details are redacted.

These notes preserve potentially important warning information. They are not a medical chart, a diagnosis or a verbatim recording of every exchange. They cannot establish which clinician received each statement without further corroboration.


What Reyes observed about prison checks

Reyes’s account on PDF pages 4, 7 and 8 distinguishes formal counts from observation rounds. He described officers sleeping at night and said frequent checks were often missing.

He also said scheduled midnight, 3 a.m. and 5 a.m. counts generally occurred during periods he observed, sometimes late. His account should not be flattened into a claim that no count ever happened.

Reyes said he had not seen Noel sleeping and described her as serious. He nevertheless recalled limited observation checks on an overnight shift she worked with another employee.

He was absent on the fatal night. These statements concern earlier conditions and cannot establish what Noel or Thomas did after he left. Their later admissions and the investigation supply the evidence about that shift.


Extortion concerns and suspected payments

The handwritten notes on PDF pages 5 and 6 record discussion of protection money and Reyes’s belief that Epstein might have been paying guards.

The belief is not accompanied by a documented transfer to an identified officer. It should be reported as suspicion, rather than proof of a bribery arrangement.

Reyes also attributed demands for money to people Epstein encountered elsewhere in the prison. Those conversations may be relevant to fear and vulnerability, but they do not establish every alleged demand as independently verified.


The final evening together

PDF page 5 describes Thursday evening, August 8, as relatively relaxed. Reyes recalled sharing kosher meals, joking with Epstein and staying awake until approximately 1 a.m.

This observation matters because it complicates any account of unbroken visible despair. It does not erase the earlier warning signs or prove that Epstein remained safe after Reyes left.

The interview contains both ordinary companionship and concern about self harm. An accurate account includes both.


Advance notice of the August 9 transfer

The first Marshals Service email was sent on August 8 at 10:33:54 a.m. It named Reyes and another prisoner, requested transfer from MCC to GEO on Friday, August 9, and asked that medical summaries and seven days of medication accompany them.

The second email and prisoner schedule were sent at 3:36:30 p.m. The schedule identified Reyes, his register number and the transfer destination. The OIG identified recipients across receiving and discharge and supervisory roles.

One field used the word Court. Other fields specified transfer information and departure with belongings. The OIG examined that apparent inconsistency rather than treating the single word as conclusive.

These records establish advance notice. They do not establish that every recipient actually read the email or that every employee knew its contents.


What WAB and PRE REMOVE meant

The August 9 transfer receipt identifies Reyes among three prisoners and marks his status PRE REMOVE. It is a transfer document, not a release certificate for freedom outside custody.

A supplemental receiving and discharge interview addresses the paperwork and the distinction between a court trip and an institutional transfer.

The OIG reported that WAB meant with all belongings and signaled that Reyes would not return to MCC. PRE REMOVE also indicated institutional departure. A temporary court movement ordinarily used a different notation.

The records therefore support describing August 9 as a planned transfer to another detention facility, even though some early prison summaries incorrectly characterized it as a court trip.


The departure and missing replacement

The final OIG chronology places Reyes’s recorded removal at approximately 8:38 a.m. on August 9. Staff escorted Reyes toward receiving and discharge while Epstein went to meet his lawyers.

Reyes recalled that Epstein appeared sad as he left. Reyes reassured him that another suitable cellmate would be assigned and asked staff to ensure he was not left alone.

The OIG also examined a staff memorandum describing a warning to the incoming shift around 1:50 p.m. that Epstein would need a new cellmate. Other witnesses did not confirm all the claimed notifications.

By the evening, staff recognized that the cell was missing a second inmate. The report describes another claimed telephone notification that investigators could not corroborate. No replacement was assigned.


What senior officials said they knew

The OIG report documents a consequential contradiction: several supervisory employees said they thought Reyes had gone to court, although they were recipients of transfer information.

The day watch officer in charge said he knew Reyes was leaving with belongings and notified other staff. The evening officer in charge did not remember receiving the warning. Senior officials described a notification chain that did not result in action.

The report identifies failures across shifts and supervisory levels. It does not reduce the replacement failure to the two employees working when Epstein was discovered.

The advance paperwork makes this a failure with time to respond. It does not, by itself, establish that officials deliberately arranged Epstein’s death.


Reyes was not present when Epstein died

The FBI inmate interview index identifies Reyes’s interview as Serial 67 and states that he had left on August 9 without another inmate replacing him in Epstein’s cell.

Epstein was discovered around 6:30 to 6:33 a.m. on August 10. Reyes therefore could not directly describe the overnight rounds, sounds from the cell, the discovery or the resuscitation.

Claims that he saw Epstein’s fatal hanging, saw a killer enter the cell or witnessed the guards finding the body require evidence beyond his documented account. None of those observations appears in his August 16 notes.


The August 16 interview and its evidentiary limits

The nine page interview package contains a typed FBI summary followed by eight handwritten pages. The interview occurred at SDNY, 500 Pearl Street, on August 16. The summary was drafted on August 28 and entered on August 29.

It states that Reyes was interviewed under a proffer agreement with federal prosecutors, FBI personnel and OIG participation. The typed page refers readers to the attached prosecutor notes for the substance.

This is not a nine page verbatim sworn deposition. The handwritten pages use abbreviations, redactions and incomplete sentences. They preserve an investigator’s notes of the interview rather than an audio transcript.

The interview date and filing dates must remain separate. August 29 is not evidence that investigators waited until then to obtain Reyes’s account.


The plea, sentencing and public access dispute

The August 26 plea transcript independently identifies Reyes as Epstein’s last cellmate. His attorney told Judge Failla that investigators had already spoken with him.

Reporter Stephen Rex Brown’s December 29, 2020 letter sought public access to the plea and sentencing materials. It identified the sentencing proceeding as April 13, 2020 and raised concerns about sealed transcripts and missing public submissions.

Judge Failla directed the letter to be docketed and gave the parties until January 22, 2021 to respond. The redacted plea transcript was filed publicly as docket document 326 on January 27.

The initially sealed status documents a transparency issue and a stated safety rationale. It does not prove that the plea or cooperation agreement was fabricated. The reviewed material does not justify attaching an unverified final prison term to Reyes.


Reports that William Barr questioned Reyes

Los Angeles magazine’s March 2026 reporting discusses an account that Reyes told other detainees he had been questioned by Attorney General William Barr. Earlier reporting also circulated the claim.

Barr’s involvement in the death investigation makes the claim relevant. However, Reyes’s August 16 FBI cover sheet does not identify Barr as an attendee.

The documents reviewed here do not independently establish the date, participants or contents of a separate Barr interview. A reported encounter should not be silently merged into the documented August 16 proffer.


Reyes’s death in November 2020

Prison Legal News’s May 2021 account reported that Reyes died at his mother’s Bronx apartment on November 27, 2020, aged 51. Reporting said he had contracted COVID while detained in Queens and had been released in April.

Those reports establish the public account of his illness and death. They should not be described as a reviewed medical examiner certificate.

The November 30 prosecutor email confirms that an AUSA had learned of Reyes’s death from Probation. The writer said it sounded as though he died in his sleep and speculated that it might be drug related, while expressly acknowledging uncertainty.

The medical cause remains unresolved in the primary records reviewed for this article. COVID reporting and tentative prosecutor speculation are different forms of evidence. Neither supports a verified claim of homicide.


The email about not needing his testimony

The same email chain asks whether Reyes was still needed for anything related to Epstein or MCC. The reply confirms that his testimony was not expected to be needed.

A separate November 30 exchange expresses sadness about the death. It adds no medical explanation.

The testimony remark concerns anticipated future use of a witness. It does not establish that Reyes had never been interviewed, that his information was discarded or that his death served an investigative objective.

His August 16 account survived in the case records. The OIG’s later report incorporated information from the inmate identified as Inmate 3.


Recent sleuth reporting and questions worth preserving

Please Fact Check’s September 13, 2026 investigation emphasizes advance transfer notice and conflicts between paperwork and staff recollections. The transfer emails, receipt and OIG findings support the central point that notice existed before Reyes left.

The article also identifies discrepancies between earlier investigator notes and later staff interviews. Those discrepancies warrant document comparison. They do not automatically resolve whether a witness forgot, misunderstood paperwork or gave an inaccurate account.

Please Fact Check’s examination of inmate interviews highlights Reyes’s relationship with Epstein and the need to distinguish inmate identities across different indexes.

R Howard Stone’s published research collection offers an interview inventory and transcription leads. Its report is explicitly labeled as generated with AI and subject to errors. The underlying documents remain the authority.

These contributions help locate evidence. They should not replace the original handwritten pages, transfer records or court transcript.


What the official investigation concluded

The June 2023 OIG report found serious staff misconduct and institutional failures, including leaving Epstein without a cellmate, missing required checks, falsifying records, inadequate searches and recording equipment failures.

The medical examiner ruled Epstein’s death suicide by hanging. The OIG reported that it found no evidence contradicting the FBI’s determination that there was no criminality in how he died.

Reyes’s account contributes evidence of warning signs and prison conditions. It does not resolve every medical or surveillance question. He was absent during the fatal night.

The institutional consequences remain central for survivors: Epstein died before trial, preventing a verdict in the pending federal trafficking prosecution.


Common claims and the evidence

Claim Documented position
Reyes was the July 23 cellmate. Incorrect. Tartaglione was the earlier cellmate.
Reyes went home on August 9. Incorrect. He was transferred to another detention facility.
His transfer had no advance notice. Incorrect. Two August 8 emails supplied advance information.
He witnessed Epstein’s death. Incorrect. He had already left MCC.
He died before investigators interviewed him. Incorrect. His August 16, 2019 account survives.
COVID is medically confirmed by the released emails. Incorrect. News reports attributed the death to COVID; the emails express uncertainty.
A prosecutor confirmed a fatal overdose. Incorrect. The writer offered a tentative possibility.
His death proves witness silencing. Unsupported by the reviewed primary records.

Chronology

Date Event
2018 Named in the Bronx narcotics prosecution.
July 30, 2019 Assigned to share Epstein’s cell after psychological observation.
August 8, 2019 Marshals Service sent transfer notices. Reyes later described a final evening of shared meals and joking.
August 9, 2019 Transferred from MCC to Queens. No replacement cellmate assigned.
August 10, 2019 Epstein discovered unresponsive during breakfast delivery.
August 16, 2019 Reyes interviewed at SDNY under a proffer agreement.
August 26, 2019 Guilty plea hearing before Judge Failla.
April 13, 2020 Sentencing date identified in the reporter’s later court request.
November 27, 2020 Reported death in the Bronx.
November 30, 2020 Prosecutor emails discussed his death and anticipated witness needs.
December 29, 2020 Reporter requested access to sealed court materials.
January 27, 2021 Redacted plea transcript filed publicly.
June 2023 Final OIG report published.
September 13, 2026 Please Fact Check published a detailed transfer documentation review.

Evidence appearances and file guide

  • EFTA00126106: Nine page interview package. Page 1 establishes the interview date and cell assignment. Pages 2 through 9 contain handwritten notes.
  • EFTA00161492: Inmate interview index identifying Reyes as Serial 67 and noting the missing replacement.
  • EFTA00036106: August 8 morning email requesting the next day’s transfer to GEO.
  • EFTA00061353: Afternoon production email and prisoner schedule containing transfer information.
  • EFTA00120458: August 9 transfer receipt naming Reyes and recording PRE REMOVE.
  • EFTA00117078: Supplemental OIG interview concerning transfer paperwork.
  • EFTA00035116: Inventory listing Reyes’s court documentation, SHU file, rosters and TRUSCOPE records among materials collected for review.
  • EFTA00033799: Early prison timeline. It describes Reyes as departing for court, a characterization requiring correction against the transfer documents.
  • EFTA00036082: Earlier review materials concerning housing, the cellmate requirement and failures. Early terminology should be compared with the final OIG findings.
  • EFTA00102054: Reporter’s request for access to plea and sentencing materials, with Judge Failla’s endorsement.
  • EFTA00019925: November 30 death notification and exchange about anticipated testimony.
  • EFTA00017827: Separate email reaction to Reyes’s death.
  • EFTA00039025: Final OIG report, including cellmate selection, living arrangements, transfer notice and failure to replace him.

Reading the evidence accurately

  • Read the original handwritten pages. Ordinary text extraction misses or garbles much of Reyes’s interview.
  • Distinguish Reyes’s own observations from what Epstein or another inmate reportedly told him.
  • Keep the August 16 interview date separate from the August 28 drafting and August 29 entry dates.
  • Use Inmate 3 only within the OIG report’s numbering system. Other indexes use different numbers.
  • Separate a file’s first EFTA identifier from identifiers printed on individual pages.
  • Do not interpret an early Court label without reading the transfer destination and belongings notation.
  • Do not infer a medical cause of death from a prosecutor’s tentative email.
  • Do not assume that every document mentioning Efrain Reyes concerns this inmate.

What remains unresolved

  • The complete medical determination concerning Reyes’s death, supported by an authenticated death certificate or medical examiner record.
  • The full public sentencing record and final judgment in his own criminal case.
  • The complete scope of his cooperation and any protected information still withheld.
  • Whether a separate interview involving William Barr occurred, and its date and participants.
  • The precise timing and independent corroboration of the clothesline incident.
  • Which staff received each warning Reyes described and what they did afterward.
  • The explanation for conflicts between advance transfer paperwork and later claims that Reyes was expected back from court.
  • Original account records supporting the reported commissary payment.

The available evidence is substantial but does not amount to the complete investigative file. Reyes’s role is firmly established as a cellmate and witness. His absence during the fatal night sets a clear boundary around what he could personally know.


Related EpsteinWiki articles


Sources

Previous Simon Andriesz: Financial Whistleblowing, Howard Lutnick’s Epstein Connections and the Documentary Record
Next Ben Forester
Table of Contents