Skip to main content
Print

EFTA01164770 and EFTA01164772: May 2011 Photo Correspondence and an Unverified Companion Image

Snapshot

Evidence snapshot: EFTA01164770
Field Details
DocumentEFTA01164770 to EFTA01164771; EFTA01164772
Evidence typeEmail chain and separate image record
Length and format2-page email PDF; separate 1-page image PDF
Date informationEmail: May 14, 2011; photograph date unverified
Direct evidence linkEFTA01164770 and EFTA01164772 on epstein-data.com (the image is not reproduced here)
Source and provenanceReleased under the Epstein Files Transparency Act (EFTA). No native mailbox, attachment manifest or chain-of-custody record accompanies the pages.
Content warning and privacyAge-related discussion of photographs; the separate image is withheld.

What Is This Record?

EFTA01164770 is a two-page email record dated May 14, 2011, containing correspondence between Jeffrey Epstein and a person whose name and email address are redacted. The exchange concerns photographs and the age at which they were taken. EFTA01164772 is a separate one-page image record whose only extracted text is its stamp. The records are considered together here, but their consecutive document numbers do not by themselves establish that the image is an attachment to this email.

The email documents what its correspondents wrote. It does not establish the unnamed person’s age, the age of anyone shown in a photograph, or the photographs’ creation dates. The image is not reproduced here.


Key Takeaways

  • The email discusses photographs and age-related restrictions expressed by Epstein. It lists two JPEG filenames. [1, p. 1]
  • Epstein wrote “do not send me photos unless they are when you are over 18.. DO NOT send” and later “It is ILLEGAL to send picture of girls under 18.. sometimes.. BE SAFE.” [1, p. 1]
  • The correspondent said the pictures were not nude and had no dates. Those are the correspondent’s claims, not verified facts. [1, p. 1]
  • Consecutive numbering does not establish that EFTA01164772 is either attachment. Age, creation date, identity and consent cannot be inferred from appearance.

Document Identification

  • Email: EFTA01164770, two pages, stamped EFTA01164770 and EFTA01164771.
  • Header: “Re: good morning!”, addressed to Jeffrey Epstein at jeevacation@gmail.com, dated Saturday, May 14, 2011, 17:00:48 +0000.
  • Attachment list: two JPEG files, e71cf878.jpg (the extracted text reads the prefix as z_; it may be x_ on the page image) and x_a65f3e55.jpg. The attachment list establishes filenames, not a match to the separately numbered image.
  • Separate image: EFTA01164772, one page, stamped EFTA01164772.
  • Source scope: Epstein Files Transparency Act release. No original mailbox, attachment manifest or independent forensic authentication accompanies the pages.

What the Email Records

The substantive exchange is on the first page. In a quoted message attributed to “Jeffrey Epstein <jeevacation@gmail.com>,” he writes: “do not send me photos unless they are when you are over 18.. DO NOT send”. The redacted correspondent responds by disputing his concern and describing the pictures as not nude. A subsequent quoted message attributed to Epstein states: “It is ILLEGAL to send picture of girls under 18.. sometimes.. BE SAFE”. These are his words, not a legal conclusion adopted by this article. [1, p. 1]

In the latest visible reply, the correspondent says the photographs are available on a Russian website and uses relative time references for two different sets of pictures, one involving a two-year period and another described as taken ten months earlier. The correspondent also says the pictures have no dates and that only the correspondent knows when they were made. These statements are claims within the email, not verified metadata. [1, p. 1]

The chain is displayed in reverse chronological order, with earlier replies nested below the latest message. Its quoted timestamps should not be treated as a uniform, independently verified time series. The header supplies a UTC offset, while quoted messages use differing timestamp presentations.


The Separate Image Record

EFTA01164772 is an image record with a face obscured in the released copy. Its proximity to the email’s stamped pages is relevant to checking a possible attachment relationship, but it does not prove one. The email lists two image attachments; the release has only one separately numbered image record next to it. No visible filename mapping establishes which attachment, if either, the image represents. [2, p. 1]

Physical appearance cannot establish age, identity or consent. This article does not identify the photographed person or infer any of those facts from the image.


What the Record Does and Does Not Prove

  • The record supports a finding that the visible email chain discusses photographs and an age-related restriction expressed by Epstein.
  • It does not establish that any released image depicts a minor, constitutes unlawful material, or was created on the dates claimed in the correspondence.
  • It does not independently establish that Epstein opened, retained or viewed either listed attachment.
  • The correspondent’s statement that the photographs were not nude is attributed to the correspondent, not independently verified for both listed files.
  • No intent, motive, relationship or criminal conclusion can be established from this exchange alone.

Privacy and Editorial Handling

The redacted correspondent remains anonymous. Unnecessary intimate health information, identifying travel details and the image itself are excluded. The second email page principally continues a confidentiality notice; that notice adds no substantive event to the exchange. [1, p. 2]


What Would Resolve the Remaining Questions?

An original attachment manifest or another authenticated record linking filenames to the image would help establish the document relationship. Reliable creation metadata or independently corroborated dates would be needed to evaluate the photographs’ timing. None is supplied by the visible record.


Page Inventory and Message Sequence

The three released pages have different functions. Email page 1, stamped EFTA01164770, contains the header, attachment filenames and the substantive nested exchange. Email page 2, stamped EFTA01164771, finishes one confidentiality notice and repeats another. It contains no further substantive reply, photograph or attachment manifest. The separate EFTA01164772 PDF consists of a single image page with its own stamp. Counting those three stamped pages does not convert them into three independent accounts. [1, pp. 1 and 2; 2, p. 1]

The nested chain can be read from the oldest visible message upward:

  1. An initial message is quoted as sent on May 14 at 8:39 a.m. It opens with a greeting and other private content. The quoted line does not state a timezone.
  2. A reply attributed to Epstein gives the restriction about sending photographs taken after age 18. Its quoted heading supplies the date but no visible time.
  3. A response from the redacted correspondent is quoted as sent at 6:31 p.m. It describes the images as not nude and asks why Epstein objects. That quoted line also supplies no timezone.
  4. A further reply attributed to Epstein contains his statement about legality. Its heading again supplies the date without a visible time.
  5. The topmost reply bears the full header timestamp 17:00:48 +0000. It discusses the pictures’ asserted relative ages and lack of dates.

This is a sequence conveyed by the nesting, not a corrected chronology based on inferred clock settings. In particular, the visible 6:31 p.m. quotation and 17:00:48 +0000 header should not be labeled contradictory without knowing the former’s timezone. The document gives insufficient information to calculate elapsed time between every reply. [1, p. 1]


Provenance and Document Comparison

The stamped identifiers provide locators for the released copies. They do not themselves establish when the underlying messages were acquired, who exported them, whether the chain is complete, or how an attachment was separated during processing. No chain-of-custody statement, native email headers, message identifiers or original image metadata is included in these pages. The email header and quoted sender lines are the basis for attributing the visible statements; this is not an independent forensic authentication.

The image record and the email should therefore remain distinct sources in the bibliography. A reliable comparison would require the native email’s attachment names and payloads, or a release index explicitly mapping them. Consecutive numbering supports an archival question worth checking, not a resolved identification. Even a proven attachment match would not establish the photographed person’s age or the legality of the image.


Open Questions

  • Does an official release manifest identify EFTA01164772 as an attachment to this exact email, and does it map the image to one of the two named JPEGs?
  • Where is the second listed attachment, and can its relationship to the email be established without assuming that the next numbered document is that attachment?
  • Does a native message or overlapping copy preserve a complete header and timezone information for the quoted replies?
  • Do authenticated original files contain reliable creation metadata? A filename, an appearance-based age estimate or a correspondent’s relative date is not a substitute.

Those are evidence gaps, not invitations to identify an anonymous person. Further reporting should prioritize document relationships and authenticated metadata, while withholding unnecessary private details.


Evidence Appearances

Record or IDDateWhat It ShowsSource
EFTA01164770 to EFTA01164771May 14, 2011Email chain “Re: good morning!” with Epstein’s age warnings and two listed JPEG attachmentsepstein-data.com/EFTA01164770
EFTA01164772Not statedSeparate one-page image; link to the email not establishedepstein-data.com/EFTA01164772

Conclusion

EFTA01164770 shows that on May 14, 2011, Jeffrey Epstein, writing from the jeevacation@gmail.com account, told a redacted correspondent not to send photos unless they were taken when the correspondent was over 18, and later wrote that it is “ILLEGAL to send picture of girls under 18.. sometimes.. BE SAFE.” The correspondent replied that the pictures were not nude and that they carry no dates. The email lists two JPEG files, but nothing in the record links them to the separately numbered image EFTA01164772. The record documents what was written. It does not establish anyone’s age, the content of the attachments, or that Epstein opened them, and the correspondent should remain anonymous. [1, p. 1]


Questions and Answers

What does this record actually establish?

The email discusses photographs and age-related restrictions expressed by Epstein. It lists two JPEG filenames. [1, p. 1]

Where did the record come from?

Released under the Epstein Files Transparency Act (EFTA). No native mailbox, attachment manifest or chain-of-custody record accompanies the pages.

What did Epstein write about age?

He told the correspondent not to send photos unless they were taken when the correspondent was over 18, and later wrote that sending pictures of girls under 18 is illegal “sometimes” and to “BE SAFE.” These are his words in the email, not a legal finding.

What remains uncertain?

Consecutive numbering does not establish that EFTA01164772 is either attachment. Age, creation date, identity and consent cannot be inferred from appearance.


Sources

  1. EFTA01164770, email chain “Re: good morning!”, May 14, 2011, two pages, EFTA01164770 to EFTA01164771, Epstein Files Transparency Act release, epstein-data.com.
  2. EFTA01164772, image record, one page, epstein-data.com.
Previous EFTA00734795: Human Skull Photograph in a Likely Belize Maya Cave Sequence
Next EFTA01169553: The Animal Head Photograph Emailed to Jeffrey Epstein
Table of Contents