EFTA02731082: The SDNY Memo on Jeffrey Epstein’s Potential Co-Conspirators (December 2019)
Snapshot
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| Record | EFTA02731082 through EFTA02731167 (DOJ stamps EFTA_00022461 through EFTA_00022546) |
| Title on the memo | Investigation into Potential Co-Conspirators of Jeffrey Epstein |
| Date | December 19, 2019 |
| From and to | Assistant U.S. Attorneys (names redacted) to Geoffrey S. Berman, U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York |
| Length | 86 pages. The analysis section (pages 75 to 86) is almost entirely redacted. |
| Markings | Privileged, attorney work product and deliberative process; confidential, subject to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e) |
| People the memo analyzes | Ghislaine Maxwell, Lesley Groff (spelled Leslie in the memo) and other associates and employees whose names are redacted |
| Charges considered | Sex trafficking of minors (18 U.S.C. 1591), transportation of minors (18 U.S.C. 2423) and enticement of minors (18 U.S.C. 2422(b)) |
| What it does not show | The released version does not show the prosecutors’ conclusions about any person except one: it says a separate memo would seek charges against Maxwell. |
| Content warning | The memo summarizes survivor accounts of child sexual abuse and rape. This article describes them only in general terms. |
Introduction
Four months after Jeffrey Epstein died in federal custody, federal prosecutors in Manhattan wrote an internal memo to their boss about the people around him. The memo, dated December 19, 2019, explains what the investigation had done since Epstein’s July 2019 indictment and asks whether any of his associates or employees could be charged with federal crimes.
The memo matters for two reasons. First, it shows that the investigation did not end when Epstein died. Prosecutors kept interviewing survivors, witnesses and subjects, searched his homes and reviewed his bank records. Second, it records what dozens of people told federal investigators in 2019, including accounts that name Maxwell, Groff, an assistant whose name is redacted, and other men in Epstein’s world.
The memo also has clear limits. It is a prosecutor’s working document, not a court finding. Most of what it reports are statements people made in interviews, which are allegations (claims) unless a court later tested them. And the most important part, the analysis of whether each person should be charged, is almost completely blacked out in the released copy.
Key Takeaways
- Federal prosecutors kept investigating Epstein’s network after his death. The memo says the investigation focused on Ghislaine Maxwell, Lesley Groff and at least one other person whose name is redacted.
- The memo says prosecutors and the FBI conducted dozens of interviews and proffers (meetings where a person shares information with prosecutors under set terms). The released text numbers 24 accounts from people abused as minors and 14 from people abused as adults.
- A footnote says prosecutors expected to recommend transportation of minors charges against Maxwell in a separate memo. Maxwell was charged in 2020 and convicted in 2021.
- The memo reports that Groff’s lawyer said she would not proffer and had been advised to invoke her Fifth Amendment right not to testify if subpoenaed, and that Jean-Luc Brunel’s lawyer said Brunel would invoke it. Groff has not been charged.
- It records Leslie Wexner’s lawyers saying Epstein stole or misappropriated several hundred million dollars from Wexner and returned $100 million in January 2008. That is Wexner’s side, as his lawyers told it.
- One adult survivor told prosecutors that Epstein sent her to massage Leon Black and Jes Staley, and she described sexual misconduct by both. Neither man has been criminally charged over Epstein, and the memo does not say what prosecutors made of the account.
- The memo says searches of Epstein’s homes found no cameras in bedrooms or massage rooms, contrary to some news reports, and that early bank reviews found no accounts consistent with Epstein managing other people’s money.
- Pages 75 to 86, where prosecutors weighed the evidence against each person, are almost entirely redacted.
What the Memo Is
The memo was written by Assistant U.S. Attorneys in the Southern District of New York (SDNY), the federal prosecutors’ office in Manhattan. It is addressed to Geoffrey S. Berman, who led that office. Its stated purpose is to detail the investigative steps taken since the July 2, 2019 indictment and to analyze whether certain associates and employees may be criminally liable.
It is a follow up to an earlier memo. The June 2019 prosecution memo made the case for charging Epstein. This one asks who else could be charged.
Every page is stamped as attorney work product (material lawyers prepare for a case, normally kept private) and as subject to Rule 6(e), the federal rule that keeps grand jury material secret. The copy reviewed here is the one released in the Justice Department’s Epstein file disclosures, with redactions.
How the memo is organized
- I. Background: the charges against Epstein and how he recruited and paid girls in New York and Palm Beach.
- II. Investigative Steps Taken: interviews of people abused as minors, people abused as adults, witnesses who were not abused, and subjects of the investigation, followed by meetings with lawyers, search warrants, financial records and document review.
- III. Legal Landscape: the three federal crimes prosecutors considered and the statute of limitations (the deadline for bringing charges).
- IV. Analysis: whether there was enough evidence to charge Groff, Maxwell and others. This section is almost entirely redacted.
The Investigation After Epstein’s Death
The memo says the office held a press conference the day the indictment was unsealed and asked victims and witnesses to come forward. The FBI screened people who called its tip line, and prosecutors then held follow up interviews. The memo says some people declined to talk, but the team conducted dozens of interviews and proffers, executed search warrants, reviewed financial records and met with lawyers for subjects of the investigation.
It states that Epstein died in custody at the Metropolitan Correctional Center on or about August 10, 2019, and that the investigation into potential co-conspirators continued after his death.
Survivor accounts
Most of the memo summarizes what survivors told investigators. Their names are redacted, and EpsteinWiki does not try to identify them. In general terms, the accounts describe girls being recruited for paid “massages” that became sexual, being paid in cash, and being paid to bring other girls. Several accounts describe abuse in New York, Palm Beach, New Mexico, the Virgin Islands, Paris and London.
Many accounts describe who scheduled the appointments and arranged travel. Groff, Maxwell and an assistant whose name is redacted appear repeatedly in that role. Some survivors said they did not discuss their ages with the people who scheduled them. Those gaps matter, because federal trafficking law turns on what each person knew.
Allegations involving Leon Black and Jes Staley
In an October 24, 2019 interview (EFTA02731112 to EFTA02731114), an adult survivor told prosecutors that around 2011 or 2012, Epstein directed her to massage Leon Black and Jes Staley at his New York home. She said Black began initiating sexual contact and she ran out of the room. She said Staley forced sexual contact and raped her. She said Epstein laughed off her complaint about Black.
These are allegations recorded in a prosecutor’s summary of an interview. The released memo does not say whether prosecutors found the account credible or investigated it further. Neither man has been criminally charged in connection with Epstein. A footnote says the office was receiving documents from JPMorgan that included messages between Staley and Epstein around the period the survivor described (EFTA02731149).
Witnesses who were not abused
- Juan Alessi, the Palm Beach house manager into 2002, was interviewed July 13, 2019. He said Maxwell took charge of Epstein’s homes around 1993, that he saw younger girls near the end of his job, and that Maxwell told him not to ask their ages. He said Epstein told him, “I hope you keep your mouth shut.”
- Maria Alessi, who also worked at the Palm Beach house, was interviewed the same day. She mostly worked outside the house and recalled Maxwell visiting often.
- Dr. Gregory Bledsoe, a doctor hired by the Secret Service for Bill Clinton’s 2002 Africa trip on Epstein’s plane, was interviewed July 22, 2019. He said there were no minors on the flight. The memo says flight logs confirm who was aboard.
- Richard Barnett, chief engineer and property manager of the New York house from about 1995 to 2014, was interviewed September 16, 2019. He said he was hired by Maxwell and told not to speak with guests.
Subjects and their lawyers
The memo summarizes proffers from former assistants whose names are redacted. Their accounts describe how, in 2005 while Epstein was under investigation in Florida, computers and contact books were collected from the Palm Beach house and handed to a man, and contact books from the Virgin Islands were to be shredded (EFTA02731122, EFTA02731123). Former assistants also described being sexually abused by Epstein themselves.
- Maxwell: her lawyers met prosecutors on October 8, 2019. They described her relationship with Epstein, said she hired only adult massage therapists and believed the massages were not sexual, and challenged the credibility of three accusers. The memo says Maxwell denies one accuser’s allegations.
- Groff: prosecutors gave her a “reverse proffer” on July 18, 2019, explaining what victims had said about her scheduling role. On August 7, 2019, her lawyer said she would not proffer and had been advised to invoke the Fifth Amendment if subpoenaed. The memo says her lawyer was considering whether to bring her in.
- Jean-Luc Brunel: after calls in August and September 2019, his lawyer said Brunel would not proffer and would invoke the Fifth Amendment before a grand jury.
- Leslie Wexner: his lawyers met prosecutors on July 25, 2019. They said Wexner knew nothing of Epstein’s abuse, that Epstein misappropriated several hundred million dollars from him, and that Epstein returned $100 million in January 2008 after a private settlement. These are statements by Wexner’s lawyers, not findings by prosecutors.
Searches and financial records
The memo says the FBI searched Epstein’s homes in New York and the Virgin Islands in July and August 2019, then obtained warrants for the devices seized there. Prosecutors also reviewed what the Palm Beach Police Department seized in its October 2005 search. They identified some victims in photographs kept in Epstein’s homes. The memo adds that, contrary to some news reports, the searches did not reveal cameras in bedrooms or massage rooms.
On money, the memo says Epstein banked mainly at JPMorgan until 2013, then at Deutsche Bank until 2019. His accounts included ones for Southern Trust Company, his charities and several trusts. Prosecutors said they had not found accounts consistent with Epstein handling other people’s money, and that a Deutsche Bank presentation on September 12, 2019 showed no immediate sign of financial crime. These were early findings; the memo says the review was continuing.
The Legal Landscape
Prosecutors considered three federal crimes:
- Sex trafficking of minors (18 U.S.C. 1591): the charge brought against Epstein. It requires proof that the person knew the victim was under 18 and would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act.
- Transportation of minors (18 U.S.C. 2423): knowingly moving a minor across state lines intending that the minor engage in illegal sexual activity.
- Enticement of minors (18 U.S.C. 2422(b)): using phone, mail or similar means to persuade a minor to engage in illegal sexual activity.
The memo says the conduct revealed by the investigation spanned roughly 1994 through 2005, which made the statute of limitations an important question. A footnote on that page says prosecutors anticipated recommending transportation of minors charges against Maxwell in a separate prosecution memo (EFTA02731154).
What Is Redacted
Section IV, “Analysis,” begins on EFTA02731156. It says prosecutors would evaluate whether there was enough evidence to charge a redacted person, Groff and/or Maxwell and whether charges would be in the interests of justice. After that, the released pages show only headings such as “Knowledge of Sex Acts,” “Knowledge of Age,” “Leslie Groff” and “Ghislaine Maxwell.” The text under them is blacked out.
That means the public copy does not tell us what prosecutors concluded about Groff or anyone else besides Maxwell. Claims that this memo shows prosecutors decided to charge, or not charge, any other named person go beyond what the released record shows.
What Happened Next
The SDNY charged Maxwell in July 2020. A jury convicted her in December 2021 of sex trafficking and related charges, and she was sentenced to 20 years in prison. See the United States v. Maxwell docket for the full record.
Groff has not been charged. Brunel was placed under formal investigation in France in December 2020 and died in a Paris jail in February 2022 before any trial. The released record does not show charges against the other people analyzed in this memo.
Chronology
| Date | Documented Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| July 2, 2019 | Grand jury returns sealed indictment charging Epstein | EFTA02731082 |
| July 13, 2019 | Juan and Maria Alessi interviewed in Florida | EFTA02731118, EFTA02731119 |
| July 18, 2019 | Prosecutors give Groff a reverse proffer | EFTA02731146 |
| July 25, 2019 | Wexner’s lawyers give an attorney proffer | EFTA02731146 |
| July and August 2019 | FBI searches Epstein’s New York and Virgin Islands homes | EFTA02731147 |
| August 7, 2019 | Groff’s lawyer says she will not proffer | EFTA02731146 |
| On or about August 10, 2019 | Epstein dies in custody | EFTA02731083 |
| September 12, 2019 | Deutsche Bank lawyers present their review of Epstein’s accounts | EFTA02731148 |
| October 8, 2019 | Maxwell’s lawyers give an attorney proffer | EFTA02731143 |
| December 19, 2019 | Memo sent to U.S. Attorney Berman | EFTA02731082 |
Evidence Appearances
| Record or ID | Date | What It Shows | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA02731082 (memo page 1) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Header, markings, purpose and background on Epstein’s indictment | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731083 (page 2) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Investigation continued after Epstein’s death; focus on Maxwell, Groff and a redacted person; separate Maxwell memo expected | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731112 to EFTA02731114 (pages 31 to 33) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Adult survivor’s October 24, 2019 interview, including allegations involving Leon Black and Jes Staley | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731118 to EFTA02731120 (pages 37 to 39) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Interviews of Juan Alessi, Maria Alessi, Dr. Gregory Bledsoe and Richard Barnett | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731122 to EFTA02731123 (pages 41 to 42) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Former assistants’ accounts of computers and contact books removed in 2005 | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731143 to EFTA02731146 (pages 62 to 65) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Meetings with lawyers for Maxwell, Groff, Brunel and Wexner | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731147 to EFTA02731149 (pages 66 to 68) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Wexner settlement claim, search warrants, no cameras found, bank account review, footnote on Staley messages | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731154 (page 73) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Enticement statute, 1994 to 2005 conduct period, footnote on planned Maxwell charges | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02731156 to EFTA02731167 (pages 75 to 86) | Dec. 19, 2019 | Analysis section; almost entirely redacted | Epstein Data |
Page numbers are the memo’s own. Each page carries its own EFTA number, so a page can be opened directly on Epstein Data. You can also download the full PDF from Epstein Data, or read the copy hosted on EpsteinWiki below.
What the Memo Does and Does Not Establish
It establishes that SDNY prosecutors were actively investigating Epstein’s associates in late 2019, whom they focused on, what steps they took, which charges they considered, and that they planned to seek charges against Maxwell.
It records, but does not prove, what survivors, witnesses and lawyers told prosecutors. An account in this memo is an allegation unless a court later tested it. Lawyers’ statements, such as those from Maxwell’s and Wexner’s lawyers, are advocacy for their clients.
It does not show prosecutors’ conclusions about any person other than Maxwell, because the analysis is redacted. It does not show why Groff or others were not charged.
Unresolved Questions
- What did the redacted analysis conclude about Groff and the other redacted subject?
- Did Groff ever proffer after December 2019?
- Did prosecutors follow up on the allegations involving Black and Staley?
- What did the FBI’s review of the seized devices ultimately find?
Conclusion
The December 2019 memo is one of the clearest windows into what federal prosecutors did after Epstein died. It shows a team still interviewing survivors, pressing his assistants and reviewing his money, and preparing to charge Maxwell. It also shows exactly where the public record stops. The pages that would tell us why other people around Epstein were not charged remain blacked out. Until they are released, readers should treat this memo as a record of what investigators heard and planned, not as a verdict on anyone.
Questions and Answers
Does this memo show prosecutors wanted to charge Lesley Groff?
No. It shows they investigated her and asked her to proffer. The section analyzing whether to charge her is redacted, and she has not been charged.
Did the investigation stop when Epstein died?
No. The memo says the investigation into potential co-conspirators continued, and it led to Maxwell’s 2020 indictment.
Does the memo accuse Leon Black or Jes Staley of a crime?
It records one survivor’s allegations against both men. That is a summary of what she told prosecutors, not a charge or a finding. Neither man has been criminally charged in connection with Epstein.
Did investigators find hidden cameras in Epstein’s homes?
According to this memo, the 2019 searches did not reveal cameras in bedrooms or massage rooms.
Sources
- U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, “Investigation into Potential Co-Conspirators of Jeffrey Epstein,” memorandum, December 19, 2019, EFTA02731082 through EFTA02731167 (Epstein Data)
- Full PDF of the memorandum (Epstein Data)
- EFTA02731039: The June 2019 Prosecution Memorandum Against Jeffrey Epstein (EpsteinWiki)
- United States v. Maxwell Docket (EpsteinWiki)