Epstein Mystery Senders Tracker
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| What this tracks | Emails in the Epstein files where the DOJ hid the sender or recipient, and what is publicly known about who they are |
| Identified so far | Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem (torture video email), plus names that sleuths matched to visible copies, including Leon Black, Peter Mandelson, David Stern and Tom Pritzker |
| Survivor protected | Emails where the DOJ told a federal judge the hidden name belongs to a survivor. EpsteinWiki will never try to identify these people. |
| Under court review | Emails in Katie Phang’s lawsuit, Phang v. Blanche, that Judge Emmet Sullivan is still reviewing |
| Search the emails | Our Epstein Email Inbox shows these labels on each email |
| Last updated | November 19, 2026 |
Introduction
The Epstein files are full of emails where the Justice Department blacked out the sender or the recipient. Sleuths call them the question mark emails. Some hide survivors, which the law requires. Others hide powerful men, which the law does not allow. The Epstein Files Transparency Act bars redactions for reputational harm or political sensitivity, yet reporters found many cases where prominent names were hidden while survivors’ names were not.
This tracker lists the most important question mark emails and what is publicly known about each one. We only name a sender when an official, a court record or a well sourced sleuth investigation backs it up. We never try to identify anyone the DOJ has told a court is a survivor.
Key Takeaways
- The torture video email was sent by Epstein to Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem, the Dubai ports tycoon, according to Rep. Thomas Massie and the DOJ’s own response.
- Katie Phang’s lawsuit forced the DOJ to explain eight hidden senders and recipients to a federal judge. The DOJ says six hide survivors and two hide only email addresses.
- The viral “9yo” email is a scan error. Other copies of the same January 17, 2013 email read “19yo.”
- Our resident expert Katie Chenoweth of American Freakshow pushed us to track down who sent these mystery emails. Her team’s Unmasking the Redacts matched several hidden names, including Leon Black, Peter Mandelson, David Stern and Tom Pritzker, by comparing records the DOJ redacted inconsistently.
- Appearing in an email does not mean someone committed a crime. None of the people named here has been charged in connection with Epstein.
Identified Senders and Recipients
These hidden names have been identified by members of Congress, the DOJ itself or sleuths comparing the released records.
| Record | Date | What it shows | Who | How we know |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA00749245 and 8 copies | April 24, 2009 | Epstein writes to a hidden recipient: “where are you? are you ok, I loved the torture video.” The reply says the writer is in China. | Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem, recipient | Rep. Thomas Massie named the Sultan after viewing the unredacted file. Todd Blanche answered that only an email address was hidden and pointed to EFTA00666117, where the Sultan writes to Epstein under his own name. In court, the government told Judge Sullivan that the hidden text in EFTA00749245 is only email addresses. |
| EFTA01043364 | See record | A farewell gift that Irina Chernova said she received | Leon Black, as matched by sleuths | American Freakshow matched the hidden name using surrounding records and other unredacted emails. Details are in our Sleuth Report. |
| EFTA00771896 | See record | A sender asks Epstein to find someone for the sender to be nice to in Dubai | Attributed to Peter Mandelson | American Freakshow attributed it using the sender information and related copies. The meaning of the line cannot be settled from that sentence alone. |
| EFTA00660713, EFTA02706579, EFTA02410911, EFTA02547484 | Various | A series of sexually crude messages | David Stern, as matched by sleuths | American Freakshow matched him through visible copies and recurring context. |
| EFTA00581770 | See record | A routine message | Tom Pritzker | His name is hidden here but appears openly elsewhere in the files, which suggests an inconsistent redaction. |
| EFTA00172119 and EFTA01649149 | 2024 FBI summary | A case summary that hides names in one version and shows them in the matching version | Names including Les Wexner and Jean Luc Brunel | The two versions of the same FBI document were redacted differently. CNN reported that the DOJ later unredacted Wexner, Lesley Groff and Brunel as people the document lists as co-conspirators. None were charged. |
The Phang v. Blanche Emails
In Phang v. Blanche, Judge Emmet Sullivan ordered the DOJ to justify hiding the names in eight emails. The government’s answers and the judge’s rulings set the status of each one below. On November 19, 2026, Judge Sullivan ordered the DOJ to publish redacted documents in the Epstein Library within 14 days.
| Record | Date | What it says | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA00628112 | February 2, 2015 | The hidden sender complains about hate mail after a Reuters story and an upcoming Guardian piece | Unknown. The government says the hidden text is only personal contact information, not a survivor’s name. No official or reliable source has identified the sender. | Government notice of compliance, July 30, 2026 |
| EFTA01187999 and copies EFTA00659212, EFTA00952636, EFTA02706746 | January 17, 2013 | “New Brazilian just arrived, sexy and cute, 19yo.” The viral “9yo” version is a scan misread of the same email. Its copies carry the signature block of Mademoiselle Agency in Paris. | Under court review. The DOJ says the hidden name is a survivor’s. The judge ordered proof. | Order of September 16, 2026 |
| EFTA02504630 | March 19, 2018 | “I found at least 3 very good young poor but we was so tired.” | Under court review. The DOJ says the hidden name is a survivor’s. The judge ordered proof. | Order of September 16, 2026 |
| EFTA01022356 | September 21, 2018 | Epstein replies “full name instagram?” to a message about “My favorite from Lithuania, 19.” | Under court review. The DOJ says the recipient and the person mentioned may be survivors. | Order of September 16, 2026 |
| EFTA01930501 and copies | March 11, 2014 | “Thank you for a fun night… Your littlest girl was a little naughty.” | Survivor protected. The DOJ told the court the hidden name is a survivor’s, and the court accepted it. | Order of September 16, 2026 |
| EFTA01928255 | April 21, 2014 | The hidden sender writes about seeing “the most beautiful little girl on Madison.” | Survivor protected. The DOJ says the hidden names are survivors’, and the court accepted it. | Order of September 16, 2026 |
| EFTA02648868 | May 23, 2017 | “She is like Lolita from Nabokov, femme miniature 🙂 So now I should send you her type of candidates only?” | Survivor protected. The DOJ says the hidden name is a survivor’s, and the court accepted it. | Order of September 16, 2026 |
Names Unredacted After the Congress Review
After reviewing unredacted files at the DOJ, Rep. Ro Khanna read six names on the House floor: Salvatore Nuara, Zurab Mikeladze, Leonic Leonov, Nicola Caputo, Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem and Leslie Wexner. CBS News reported that the files do not appear to directly implicate the six men in any crimes, and the DOJ said some of them had no ties to Epstein.
How We Decide
- Identified means an official, a court record or a sourced sleuth comparison of released records names the person.
- Under court review means a judge has not yet ruled on the DOJ’s reason for the redaction.
- Survivor protected means the DOJ told a court the hidden name belongs to a survivor. We will not guess, hint or help anyone else guess.
- Unknown means no reliable source has named the person. We do not publish guesses based on writing style or content alone.
Conclusion
The question mark emails are where the files are most frustrating and most important. Some of the hidden names are survivors who deserve protection. Others are powerful men who were hidden for no lawful reason, and Congress, Katie Phang and independent sleuths have pried several of those names loose. This tracker will keep growing as the court rules and as sleuths match more records.
Questions and Answers
Who sent the torture video?
The email itself was written by Epstein to Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem. Rep. Massie said the Sultan appears to have sent Epstein the video. What the video showed is still not public.
Was the “New Brazilian” email about a 9 year old?
No. That reading comes from a scan error. Other released copies of the same email say “19yo.” The hidden name in that email is still under court review.
Why won’t EpsteinWiki identify every hidden sender?
Because many of them are survivors. The DOJ told a federal judge that six of the eight emails in Katie Phang’s case hide survivors’ names. Protecting survivors comes first.
How can I help?
If you match a hidden name to a visible copy in the released files, send us the record numbers. We fact check every lead before it goes on this page.
Sources
- Phang v. Blanche, Memorandum Opinion and Order, September 16, 2026
- Phang v. Blanche, Government Notice of Compliance, July 30, 2026
- The New Republic: DOJ identifies UAE Sultan behind torture video email
- The Daily Beast: Massie and Blanche on the redactions
- CBS News: Khanna names six men
- CNN: Justice Department unredacts more names
- CBS News: What’s missing from the Epstein files
- American Freakshow: Unmasking the Redacts
- EpsteinWiki Sleuth Report: Unmasking the Redacts