Skip to main content
Print

Missing Evidence Chain of Custody

Snapshot

Question Record and limit
What is being traced? Separate episodes involving Palm Beach computer equipment in 2005 and Manhattan safe contents in July 2019.
Who is Riley Kiraly? A private investigations firm, not one person. William Riley and Stephen Kiraly are separate individuals.
Were the Manhattan items permanently missing? The reviewed FBI record and trial testimony document two suitcases being delivered to agents on July 11, 2019.
What remains to be reconciled? Original inventories, later corrections, device identifiers, transfer receipts and forensic examinations.

Two Episodes That Must Not Be Collapsed

The storage and movement research guide covers the broader history. This page focuses on what the source records establish about possession and recovery. A period outside government custody can create an evidentiary question. It does not, by itself, establish alteration, destruction, an unlawful act or permanent loss.


Palm Beach: The 2005 Removal and the 2026 Inquiry

William Riley’s memorandum dated October 9, 2005, page 1, states that Paul Lavery removed property from Epstein’s Palm Beach residence on October 7 under attorney Roy Black’s instructions, then transferred it to Riley for inventory and safekeeping. It lists three computers: a Dell Precision 650, Dell Dimension 4100 and HP Pavilion 752n. The memorandum supplies a custody starting point, not a complete later disposition.

Ranking Member Robert Garcia’s March 26, 2026 letter to Riley, pages 1 and 2, sought an interview and preservation of materials. It described Darren Indyke’s March 19 deposition as suggesting that drives had not been turned over to law enforcement. That is the letter’s attributed account, not a finding that every original or copy remained unrecovered in 2026.

The separate letter to Stephen Kiraly identifies Riley Kiraly as the firm. The letter to Paul Lavery makes a parallel request. These are investigative requests, not criminal judgments against the recipients.


Manhattan: Missing From the Safe, Then Received by Agents

FBI record EFTA01301594, pages 1 and 2, describes the July 11, 2019 search. It records Kahn’s account that house manager Merwin Dela Cruz packed safe belongings on July 7 and took them to Kahn’s residence. Kahn said he had not opened the suitcases or known their contents. These statements should remain attributed to Kahn, not presented as an independently witnessed account of every transfer.

The same FBI inventory records receipt of two suitcases, including two black hard drives, CDs and valuables, followed by transport and secure FBI storage. Page 2 expressly refers readers to an updated inventory and correction in Serial 243. The report was drafted July 17 and entered August 20; those are documentation dates, not the seizure date.

Kelly Maguire’s December 6, 2021 trial testimony, transcript pages 1382 to 1384, describes the limits of the first search authority, the July 11 warrant, the missing items and Kahn’s return with two suitcases about 20 to 30 minutes after a telephone call. She said their contents appeared to be the items previously in the safe. At page 1395 she distinguishes CDs seized July 6 and 7 from CDs returned July 11. Her recognition of physical items is not a forensic finding that their data had remained unchanged.


What the Records Do Not Yet Establish

  • An exact five-day period of removal or exclusive private possession. Search dates alone cannot fix the time each object moved.
  • That the 2005 computers and the 2019 hard drives were the same objects.
  • That an inventory correction proves deliberate deletion or concealment.
  • A complete reconciliation of serial numbers, forensic images, hashes, amended inventories and final dispositions.

These are specific research tasks. They should not be converted into claims that evidence was destroyed or that a named person committed obstruction.


Sources and Evidence Appearances

  • EFTA01733753: memorandum page 1 inspected as a scan on an independent mirror; removal date and three-computer inventory.
  • Garcia to Riley, March 26, 2026: pages 1 to 3; request, deposition attribution and preservation notice. The underlying deposition was not independently reviewed here.
  • EFTA01301594: both pages inspected as mirrored scans; underlying identifiers SDNY_GM_00166094 and 00166095, EFTA_00189699 and 00189700. Serial 243 remains a follow-up record, not an inspected source in this review.
  • United States v. Maxwell, docket 751: December 6, 2021 transcript, pages 1382 to 1384 and 1395; court-filed transcript accessed through a third-party PDF mirror.

Related Research

Previous Epstein Island Mask Auction: The eBay Listing and Its Unverified Provenance
Next Al Catto in the Epstein Flight Database: An Unverified Passenger Identification
Table of Contents