EFTA02351775: Email Referencing Hormone Treatment and Menstrual Cycle (2016)
This September 2016 email records an unidentified sender telling a recipient listed as “Jeffrey E.” that her menstrual period had returned for the first time since an unspecified hormone treatment. She describes her immediate physical condition as severe, but the email does not identify the hormones, their purpose, the sender, a physician, or any medical diagnosis.
Evidence Snapshot
Document ID: EFTA02351775
Document type: Email with embedded Apple device metadata
Date: September 6, 2016
Time: 9:04 PM
Sender: Redacted
Recipient: “Jeffrey E.” as displayed in the released header
Apparent recipient: Jeffrey Epstein
Subject: No visible subject line
Source collection: United States Department of Justice Epstein Library, Data Set 11
Document length: One page
Internal Bates number: EFTA_R1_01330385
Primary subjects: Hormone treatment, menstrual cycle, and acute physical distress
People referenced: An unidentified sender and a recipient displayed as “Jeffrey E.”
Evidence status: Verified primary source document
Content warning: Private reproductive health information and description of physical distress
Key finding: The unidentified sender told the recipient that her period had returned for the first time since undergoing an unspecified hormone treatment. She described the experience as “unbelievable” and said she could barely move from the toilet.
Why This Document Matters
EFTA02351775 documents an unidentified person sharing intimate reproductive health information with a recipient displayed as “Jeffrey E.”
The email is relevant because the sender assumes the recipient will understand what she means by “the hormones.” She does not identify the medication, treatment, clinic, or purpose. The lack of explanation may suggest that the recipient already knew about the treatment, but the document does not establish that conclusion.
The sender reports that her period returned for the first time after the hormone treatment. This shows that she associated the treatment with a period during which she did not menstruate. It does not establish whether the hormones caused the interruption, whether the interruption was expected, or whether a physician had discussed it with her.
The message also conveys immediate physical distress. The sender says she can barely move from the toilet. The document does not identify whether she was experiencing bleeding, cramping, gastrointestinal symptoms, weakness, pain, or another condition.
This email appears within a broader collection containing communications about fertility appointments, egg freezing, egg retrieval, in vitro fertilization, and sperm banking. That surrounding collection makes the reference to hormones worthy of further review.
However, EFTA02351775 never mentions fertility treatment, egg freezing, in vitro fertilization, pregnancy, or egg retrieval. Connecting this particular message to any specific reproductive procedure requires additional evidence.
The sender’s identity is redacted. Her private medical information should not be used to identify her through speculation or comparison with unrelated women appearing in Epstein records.
What the Document Shows
The email confirms that an unidentified sender wrote to a recipient displayed as “Jeffrey E.” on September 6, 2016, at 9:04 PM.
The sender wrote that her period had returned.
She described it as her first period since an unspecified course or period of hormone treatment.
She characterized the experience as “unbelievable.”
She said she could barely move from the toilet.
The message includes the signature “Sent from my iPhone.”
The released page also contains embedded Apple property list data. That data includes a date received value, message flags, Gmail label identifiers, and a remote identifier.
The embedded date received value corresponds with September 6, 2016, at approximately 9:04 PM UTC. This is consistent with the date and time displayed in the email header.
The document therefore confirms:
- The sender had previously undergone or used some form of hormone treatment.
- The sender associated the treatment with an interval during which she did not have a menstrual period.
- Her period had returned by September 6, 2016.
- She described the immediate experience as physically severe.
- She communicated this private information directly to a recipient displayed as “Jeffrey E.”
- The released record contains no visible reply.
- The email does not identify the hormones or their purpose.
- The email does not identify a doctor, clinic, prescription, or diagnosis.
The wording suggests that the recipient may already have known about the sender’s hormone treatment. The sender refers to “the hormones” without explanation. That is a reasonable inference, but it is not direct proof of prior knowledge.
The email also suggests a sufficiently personal relationship for the sender to share intimate menstrual information. It does not establish whether the relationship was romantic, sexual, medical, professional, financial, or social.
The recipient is displayed only as “Jeffrey E.” The document’s placement in the Epstein collection and the existing classification of the record support identifying Jeffrey Epstein as the apparent recipient. The released header does not display his complete surname or email address.
What the Document Does Not Show
EFTA02351775 does not identify the sender.
It does not provide the sender’s age.
It does not establish whether she was an adult or a minor.
It does not identify her nationality, residence, occupation, or relationship with Epstein.
It does not display the sender’s email address.
It does not display the recipient’s complete name or email address.
It does not identify the hormones.
It does not identify the dosage, duration, method of administration, or prescribing physician.
It does not state why the sender used hormones.
It does not mention egg freezing.
It does not mention egg retrieval.
It does not mention in vitro fertilization.
It does not mention pregnancy.
It does not mention contraception.
It does not mention gender affirming treatment.
It does not mention treatment for a menstrual disorder.
It does not mention cancer treatment or fertility preservation associated with another medical condition.
It does not establish that the hormones were prescribed.
It does not establish that the treatment was medically supervised.
It does not prove that Epstein arranged the treatment.
It does not prove that Epstein recommended the treatment.
It does not prove that Epstein selected a doctor or clinic.
It does not show that Epstein purchased or supplied medication.
It does not show that Epstein paid any medical expenses.
It does not establish that Epstein controlled the sender’s reproductive decisions.
It does not prove that the sender’s absent period was caused by the hormones.
It does not establish how long the sender went without a period.
It does not identify the symptoms that left her near the toilet.
It does not provide a medical diagnosis.
It does not establish whether she required emergency or follow up medical care.
It does not show whether Epstein responded.
It does not establish that the sender was a victim or survivor.
It does not show coercion, abuse, trafficking, or criminal conduct.
It does not establish that the sender knowingly participated in wrongdoing.
The phrase “since the hormones” is too broad to support a definitive medical interpretation. Hormones may be used for many purposes, and the email provides no clinical details.
The phrase “can barely move from toilet” conveys distress but does not establish a particular symptom. It should not be rewritten as proof of heavy bleeding, severe cramps, vomiting, diarrhea, ovarian hyperstimulation, or another medical condition.
The appearance of this email alongside fertility related records does not prove that the hormones were part of fertility treatment. Document proximity and thematic similarity may support further research, but they do not establish identity or causation.
Document Context
The released record is a single page email identified as EFTA02351775.
The internal Bates number is EFTA_R1_01330385.
The visible header shows a sent date of Tuesday, September 6, 2016, at 9:04 PM.
The sender field is blank in the released version.
The recipient field reads “Jeffrey E.”
No subject line appears in the visible header.
The body consists of a short message followed by an iPhone signature and embedded technical metadata.
The document contains visible encoding errors. The word “barely” is interrupted by an equals sign, and the embedded Apple property list contains several damaged markup characters.
The readable message states that the sender’s period had returned for the first time since “the hormones.” It then describes her immediate physical condition.
The technical metadata includes:
- A date received value of 1473195853.
- A date last viewed value of zero.
- A flags value.
- Gmail label identifiers.
- A remote message identifier of 642268.
The date received value converts to September 6, 2016, at approximately 9:04 PM UTC. This supports the visible date and time.
The remaining technical values may help investigators locate the native message in a larger email archive. They do not identify the sender or explain the hormone treatment.
The “Sent from my iPhone” signature suggests that the message was sent through an Apple mobile mail interface. It does not establish ownership of the device or prove that the sender personally controlled it at every relevant moment.
The Department of Justice warns that portions of the Epstein Library may contain sensitive personal information and that some materials may be difficult to search because of their format. Those limitations are relevant here because the sender is redacted and the page includes corrupted text and embedded device metadata.
The EpsteinWiki Evidence Framework requires separating what the sender wrote from interpretations about why she received hormones or why she reported the information to the recipient.
People and Entities Named
Jeffrey E.: The visible recipient field identifies the recipient only as “Jeffrey E.” The document is preserved in the Epstein files and has been classified as an email to Jeffrey Epstein. The incomplete display should remain noted when describing the record. See the EpsteinWiki profile of Jeffrey Epstein.
Unidentified sender: The sender reports the return of her menstrual period following an unspecified hormone treatment. Her name, email address, age, medical provider, and relationship with the recipient are not visible.
Apple: The email contains an iPhone signature and Apple property list data. These details concern the format and handling of the message. They do not identify the sender.
Gmail: The embedded metadata contains Gmail label identifiers. No complete Gmail account address is shown.
United States Department of Justice: The Department released the record through the DOJ Epstein Library.
No physician, clinic, fertility practice, pharmacy, medication manufacturer, or additional person is named in the document.
Chronology
Before September 6, 2016: The sender underwent or used an unspecified hormone treatment.
During an unknown interval: According to the sender, she did not have a menstrual period after the hormone treatment. The duration of that interval is not stated.
September 6, 2016, at 9:04 PM: The sender emails “Jeffrey E.” and reports that her period has returned for the first time since the hormones.
At the time of the email: The sender describes the experience as “unbelievable” and says she can barely move from the toilet.
September 6, 2016, at approximately 9:04 PM UTC: The embedded date received value records receipt of the message.
After the email: No response, medical evaluation, follow up message, diagnosis, or treatment outcome appears in EFTA02351775.
The document does not provide the date when the hormone treatment began or ended.
It does not establish when the sender’s previous menstrual period occurred.
It does not provide a timeline connecting the hormone treatment to any specific fertility procedure.
Key Excerpts
The short substantive message reads:
- “My period came for first time since the hormones.”
- “It’s unbelievable!!”
- “Can barely move from toilet.”
- “Sent from my iPhone.”
The released text contains an encoding error inside the word “barely.” The normalization above preserves the apparent intended word.
The phrase “the hormones” is not explained anywhere else on the page.
The sender does not ask a direct question or request medical help. She reports what is happening to her.
No response from the recipient appears in the released record.
Related Evidence
Several other released records concern hormones, fertility treatment, reproductive planning, or preserved reproductive material. They may provide investigative context, but they do not automatically identify the sender of EFTA02351775.
- EFTA02329528 concerns a 2016 email referencing a fertility specialist, blood samples, Jeffrey Epstein, and Karyna Shuliak.
- EFTA02496527 is a 2018 email in which an unidentified sender tells Epstein that she will begin egg freezing and refers to hormones.
- EFTA00841630 concerns a 2018 exchange discussing egg freezing hormones and immigration assistance with Epstein.
- EFTA00835392 concerns a 2018 email about an egg retrieval procedure communicated to Epstein.
- EFTA00940204 contains an August 2012 email in which Epstein discusses in vitro fertilization.
- EFTA00552910 contains a reply discussing an in vitro fertilization appointment following Epstein’s fertility message.
- EFTA00827984 concerns a 2016 email from Epstein asking about sperm banking.
- EFTA00313838 contains a California Cryobank specimen storage agreement signed by Epstein.
- EFTA00313848 contains California Cryobank liability and specimen control terms signed by Epstein.
The fact that EFTA02351775 and EFTA02329528 both date from 2016 does not establish that they concern the same person or treatment.
The phrase “the hormones” may become more meaningful if native emails immediately before or after this message are located. Until then, the specific treatment remains unknown.
The Jeffrey Epstein profile provides background concerning the apparent recipient.
The Epstein List explains why an appearance in an Epstein related record does not independently establish criminal conduct, complicity, or victim status.
The EpsteinWiki Evidence Framework provides the standards used to distinguish direct evidence from inference.
Questions for Investigators
- Who sent the email?
- Is the recipient definitively Jeffrey Epstein?
- What complete email addresses appeared in the native message?
- What was the sender’s relationship with Epstein?
- Why did the sender report this information to him?
- Did Epstein already know that she had undergone hormone treatment?
- What did the sender mean by “the hormones”?
- Which hormones had she used?
- Were the hormones prescribed?
- Who prescribed them?
- What was the dosage and treatment schedule?
- When did the treatment begin?
- When did the treatment end?
- What was the medical purpose of the treatment?
- Was the treatment connected with egg freezing?
- Was it connected with egg retrieval or in vitro fertilization?
- Was it connected with contraception or another gynecological treatment?
- Was the sender being treated for a medical condition unrelated to fertility?
- How long had the sender gone without a menstrual period?
- Had a medical provider told her that menstrual interruption was expected?
- What symptoms was she experiencing when she wrote the email?
- Did she seek medical attention?
- Did the symptoms require emergency treatment?
- Did Epstein respond?
- Did Epstein offer medical, financial, or logistical assistance?
- Did Epstein arrange or recommend the hormone treatment?
- Did Epstein pay for medication, testing, or medical appointments?
- Did an Epstein employee coordinate the treatment?
- Are there invoices, prescriptions, laboratory reports, or calendar entries connected with the email?
- Are there messages immediately before or after EFTA02351775 that explain the context?
- Can the remote identifier 642268 locate the native message or surrounding conversation?
- Can the Gmail label identifiers identify the folder or account from which the record was collected?
- Are there deleted messages associated with the same conversation?
- Did investigators identify and interview the sender?
- Is the sender connected to any other fertility related record?
- Does EFTA02329528 concern the same treatment or a different person entirely?
- Is there evidence connecting the hormone treatment to any reproductive material stored under Epstein’s name or control?
- Were the sender’s medical decisions voluntary and independently supervised?
- Was any private medical information removed from the release through redaction?
- Does the native message contain a subject line that was omitted from the printed page?
Sources
- EFTA02351775 direct evidence record
- United States Department of Justice copy of EFTA02351775
- United States Department of Justice Data Set 11
- United States Department of Justice Epstein Library
- EpsteinWiki article for EFTA02351775
- EpsteinWiki article concerning EFTA02329528
- EFTA02329528 direct evidence record
- EFTA02496527 direct evidence record
- EFTA00841630 direct evidence record
- EFTA00835392 direct evidence record
- EFTA00940204 direct evidence record
- EFTA00552910 direct evidence record
- EFTA00827984 direct evidence record
- EFTA00313838 direct evidence record
- EFTA00313848 direct evidence record
- EpsteinWiki Jeffrey Epstein profile
- EpsteinWiki Evidence Framework
- EpsteinWiki explanation of the Epstein List