Skip to main content
Search
< All Topics
Print

EFTA02329528: 2016 Email to Jeffrey Epstein and Karyna Shuliak Referencing Dr. Rosenwaks and Blood Samples

Updated
ByEpsteinWiki
Views72

Snapshot

EFTA02329528 is a March 8, 2016 email sent by an unidentified person to Jeffrey Epstein and Karyna Shuliak. The sender writes, “All mine!! Dr Rosenwaks this am,” and lists an image attachment named IMG_8896.JPG.

The image is missing from EFTA02329528. However, a duplicate copy preserved as EFTA01184863 includes the photograph. It shows numerous filled blood collection tubes and medical supplies on a countertop.

A third copy appears as EFTA02703724.

The email does not say that Epstein or Shuliak attended the appointment. It only establishes that the sender reported the apparent medical visit or testing to both recipients.

The reference may concern Dr. Zev Rosenwaks, a prominent reproductive endocrinologist and fertility specialist. However, the email identifies the physician only as “Dr Rosenwaks.” The record does not establish the purpose of the testing, the identity of the sender, a diagnosis, fertility treatment, pregnancy, egg retrieval, embryo creation, or participation by Epstein or Shuliak in the appointment.

Document Details

Primary evidence: EFTA02329528

Duplicate with photograph: EFTA01184863

Additional duplicate: EFTA02703724

Date: March 8, 2016

Time: Approximately 5:40 p.m. UTC

Sender: Redacted

Recipients: Jeffrey Epstein and Karyna Shuliak

Message: “All mine!! Dr Rosenwaks this am”

Named attachment: IMG_8896.JPG

Additional listed attachment: Untitled attachment 00139.txt

Collection: Department of Justice Epstein Files

Primary data set: Data Set 11

Duplicate data sets: Data Set 9 and Data Set 11

The Email

The complete visible message in EFTA02329528 reads:

All mine!! Dr Rosenwaks this am

The email was sent to “jeffrey E.” and Karyna Shuliak. The sender’s name and email address are redacted.

The record lists two attachments:

  • IMG_8896.JPG
  • Untitled attachment 00139.txt

The Data Set 11 copy does not display the photograph. As a result, EFTA02329528 alone does not show what the sender meant by “All mine.”

The email does not contain a subject line, explanation, medical result, diagnosis, treatment plan, or response from either recipient.

Duplicate Copy Preserves the Photograph

A duplicate version of the email appears in Department of Justice Data Set 9 as EFTA01184863.

This copy identifies the inline image as IMG_8896.JPG and displays the photograph beneath the email. The image shows multiple filled blood collection tubes with several different cap colors, medical packaging, gauze, and other clinical supplies on a countertop.

The phrase “All mine!!” appears directly above the photograph. It may mean that the blood samples belonged to the sender. That interpretation is plausible, but it remains an inference because the sender does not explicitly explain the photograph.

No laboratory results are included. The visible record does not establish:

  • What tests were ordered.
  • Who ordered the tests.
  • Why the blood was collected.
  • Whether every tube belonged to the sender.
  • Whether the testing concerned fertility.
  • Whether genetic testing was performed.
  • Whether any reproductive procedure occurred.
  • Whether Epstein or Shuliak was present.

The photograph provides important context that is absent from EFTA02329528, but it does not establish the medical purpose of the samples.

Additional Duplicate Record

The same short message also appears as EFTA02703724.

That version is another one page email record dated March 8, 2016. It lists the same image filename and repeats the statement about Dr. Rosenwaks.

The presence of at least three copies suggests that the same email was preserved through different production paths or collections. The records carry different EFTA identifiers and should be cross referenced rather than treated as three separate communications.

The duplicate records are:

Who Was Dr. Rosenwaks?

The email identifies the physician only as “Dr Rosenwaks.”

A likely identification is Dr. Zev Rosenwaks, a reproductive endocrinologist associated with Weill Cornell Medicine and the Ronald O. Perelman and Claudia Cohen Center for Reproductive Medicine. His official Weill Cornell profile identifies his specialties as reproductive endocrinology, infertility, assisted reproduction, and reproductive medicine.

The surrounding context makes Dr. Zev Rosenwaks a reasonable possibility. However, the released email does not provide a first name, medical office, institution, appointment confirmation, or patient record conclusively identifying him.

The article therefore should not state as proven that:

  • The physician was Zev Rosenwaks.
  • The appointment concerned fertility treatment.
  • The sender was undergoing in vitro fertilization.
  • Eggs or embryos were retrieved.
  • Epstein arranged the appointment.
  • Shuliak attended the appointment.

Further corroboration would require appointment records, medical correspondence, calendar entries, invoices, or related emails naming the physician more completely.

What the Record Establishes About Epstein

The email establishes that Jeffrey Epstein was one of the recipients of a message concerning an apparent medical encounter with someone identified as Dr. Rosenwaks.

The sender chose to report the encounter and share a photograph of blood samples with Epstein and Shuliak. This indicates that both recipients were included in a private medical communication.

The record does not explain why Epstein received the message. It does not establish that he:

  • Scheduled the appointment.
  • Paid for medical services.
  • Attended the appointment.
  • Selected the physician.
  • Directed the blood testing.
  • Received laboratory results.
  • Participated in fertility treatment.
  • Had a biological connection to any reproductive procedure.

The email demonstrates communication and knowledge, not the scope or purpose of Epstein’s involvement.

What the Record Establishes About Karyna Shuliak

Karyna Shuliak appears as a direct recipient of the email.

The communication shows that the unidentified sender included Shuliak in the same medical update sent to Epstein. It does not establish whether Shuliak was acting as a friend, assistant, coordinator, medical contact, or participant in any treatment.

The record does not show Shuliak replying to the message. It also does not establish that she attended the appointment, handled the blood samples, arranged medical care, or had access to the sender’s laboratory results.

Additional context regarding Shuliak’s documented position within Epstein’s later life appears in the EpsteinWiki Karyna Shuliak article and the Sleuth Report on Karyna Shuliak’s expanded role.

Medical Privacy and Survivor Centered Review

The sender’s identity is redacted, and the message concerns private medical activity. Researchers should not attempt to identify the sender from the photograph, the number of collection tubes, speculation about Epstein’s relationships, or other unsupported assumptions.

The image does not prove pregnancy, infertility, egg retrieval, sexually transmitted infection testing, genetic screening, hormone testing, or any specific medical condition.

The sender’s wording and decision to share the photograph may indicate familiarity with Epstein and Shuliak. It does not establish exploitation, coercion, or criminal conduct.

Survivor centered documentation requires preserving the evidence without converting an unidentified person’s medical information into speculation about their sexual or reproductive history.

Relationship to Other Reproductive Records

EFTA02329528 should be examined alongside other records concerning Epstein’s interest in fertility, reproductive medicine, biological material, and genetic testing. Those records provide broader context, but they do not determine what happened in this specific email.

Relevant EpsteinWiki records include:

These records should be compared carefully. Similar subject matter does not prove that every reproductive or medical communication involved the same person, purpose, or plan.

Why This Record Matters

EFTA02329528 matters because it documents an unidentified person sending Epstein and Shuliak a private update after apparently seeing a physician identified as Dr. Rosenwaks.

The duplicate record EFTA01184863 adds important visual context by preserving the photograph of numerous blood collection tubes. That photograph was missing from the primary Data Set 11 copy.

The evidence demonstrates:

  • A direct medical update sent to Epstein and Shuliak.
  • An apparent same day encounter with Dr. Rosenwaks.
  • A photograph showing numerous blood collection tubes.
  • At least three released copies of the same communication.
  • A missing image in one production copy that survives in another data set.

The record is useful for mapping communications and locating missing attachments. It does not establish the purpose of the testing or prove that Epstein participated in a fertility procedure.

Evidence Appearances

  • EFTA02329528: Data Set 11 copy naming Jeffrey Epstein and Karyna Shuliak as recipients and listing IMG_8896.JPG, but not displaying the photograph.
  • EFTA01184863: Data Set 9 duplicate preserving the inline photograph of multiple filled blood collection tubes and medical supplies.
  • EFTA02703724: Additional Data Set 11 copy of the same March 8, 2016 communication.

Questions Still Unanswered

  1. Who sent the email?
  2. Did all the blood collection tubes belong to the sender?
  3. What tests were performed?
  4. Why were so many collection tubes used?
  5. Which physician was identified as Dr. Rosenwaks?
  6. Was the physician Dr. Zev Rosenwaks?
  7. Where did the appointment or blood collection occur?
  8. Did the appointment concern fertility or reproductive medicine?
  9. Did it involve hormone testing, genetic screening, egg retrieval preparation, or another medical purpose?
  10. Why were Epstein and Shuliak included in the update?
  11. Did either recipient arrange or pay for the appointment?
  12. Did Epstein or Shuliak attend the appointment?
  13. Did either recipient respond?
  14. Are laboratory results preserved elsewhere in the released records?
  15. Is the listed text attachment available in another evidence file?
  16. Why is the photograph absent from EFTA02329528 but present in EFTA01184863?
  17. Which source account or device produced each duplicate?
  18. Are there calendar entries, invoices, or emails that provide additional context?
  19. Does the image contain identifying information that was redacted in other versions?
  20. Were additional medical attachments withheld to protect personal information?

Fact Check

Confirmed by the evidence: The email was sent on March 8, 2016.

Confirmed by the evidence: Jeffrey Epstein and Karyna Shuliak were recipients.

Confirmed by the evidence: The sender wrote, “All mine!! Dr Rosenwaks this am.”

Confirmed by the evidence: EFTA02329528 lists IMG_8896.JPG as an attachment.

Confirmed by the evidence: EFTA01184863 displays the inline photograph.

Confirmed by the evidence: The photograph shows numerous filled blood collection tubes and medical supplies.

Confirmed by the evidence: At least three EFTA records preserve versions of the same email.

Not established by the evidence: The sender’s identity.

Not established by the evidence: That Epstein or Shuliak attended the appointment.

Not established by the evidence: That Epstein arranged or paid for the appointment.

Not established by the evidence: That the physician was definitively Dr. Zev Rosenwaks.

Not established by the evidence: That the blood testing concerned fertility.

Not established by the evidence: That the sender underwent in vitro fertilization, egg retrieval, pregnancy testing, or genetic screening.

Not established by the evidence: That any crime or exploitation occurred in connection with this communication.

Source List

EFTA02329528Download
Posted
ByEpsteinWiki
Tags:
Previous EFTA02319891: Gena Dale Email (“This Is Stunning”) (December 5, 2012)
Next EFTA02334777: Ghislaine Maxwell Email About Palm Beach Household Manual (2001)
Table of Contents