Doe No. 5 v. Epstein, No. 08-cv-80381 (S.D. Fla. 2008)
Snapshot
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| Case | Jane Doe No. 5 v. Jeffrey Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80381 (S.D. Fla.) |
| Court | U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, West Palm Beach |
| Case type | Civil lawsuit for money damages, filed by a plaintiff using a pseudonym |
| Filed | Complaint dated April 14, 2008 and entered on the docket April 15, 2008 |
| Plaintiff | Jane Doe No. 5 (pseudonym), represented by Herman & Mermelstein, P.A. |
| Defendant | Jeffrey Epstein |
| Judge | U.S. District Judge Kenneth A. Marra |
| Claims | Original complaint: sexual assault and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Later complaints added a federal claim under 18 U.S.C. 2255. |
| Published ruling | Doe No. 5 v. Epstein, 611 F. Supp. 2d 1339 (S.D. Fla. Feb. 12, 2009), on Epstein’s motion to dismiss |
| Related cases | Consolidated in May 2009 with ten other Epstein cases for discovery and shared procedural motions, filed in Doe No. 2 v. Epstein, No. 08-80119 |
| Outcome | Settled. Dismissed with prejudice on June 25, 2010, with the court keeping power to enforce the settlement. No court decided whether the allegations were true. |
| Content warning | This page discusses a lawsuit about the alleged sexual abuse of a minor. It does not describe the allegations in detail. |
Introduction
Jane Doe No. 5 v. Epstein is one of the civil lawsuits that women filed against Jeffrey Epstein in federal court in Florida in 2008. It was filed in April 2008, a few months after the 2007 Non-Prosecution Agreement and before Epstein pleaded guilty to state charges in June 2008. A non-prosecution agreement is a deal in which prosecutors agree not to bring charges in exchange for certain promises.
The case matters for two reasons. First, it produced a published federal ruling in February 2009 that let the plaintiff’s claims move forward. Second, it shows how the Florida Doe cases were grouped together and then settled at the same time in June 2010. The plaintiff is known only by a pseudonym. This page does not try to identify her and does not repeat the details of her allegations. An allegation is a claim that has not been proven in court, and this case ended without a trial or a finding on the facts.
Key Takeaways
- The complaint is dated April 14, 2008 and was entered on the docket on April 15, 2008, as case No. 9:08-cv-80381.
- On February 12, 2009, Judge Kenneth A. Marra denied most of Epstein’s motion to dismiss and ordered the plaintiff to clarify one federal claim. The ruling is published at 611 F. Supp. 2d 1339.
- In May 2009 the court combined this case with ten related cases for discovery and shared procedural motions.
- Jane Does 2 through 8 settled with Epstein in June 2010. This case was dismissed with prejudice on June 25, 2010, which means it cannot be filed again.
- No court found the allegations true or false. The settlement terms for this plaintiff are not public in the records reviewed.
Parties and Claims
Parties
Plaintiff: Jane Doe No. 5, a pseudonym. Her lawyers were Herman & Mermelstein, P.A., the same firm that filed several of the other Florida Doe cases.
Defendant: Jeffrey Epstein. No other person was a defendant in this case.
Claims
The original complaint (Document 1) brought two claims under state law: sexual assault and intentional infliction of emotional distress. It sought damages of more than $50 million and asked for a jury trial. A later amended complaint added a federal claim under 18 U.S.C. 2255, a law that lets victims of certain federal sex crimes against minors sue for damages. That claim was based on the federal crime of coercion and enticement, 18 U.S.C. 2422.
The February 2009 Ruling
Epstein asked the court to dismiss parts of the amended complaint or to order a more definite statement, which is a request that the plaintiff explain a claim more clearly. In an Opinion and Order entered February 12, 2009 (Document 58), Judge Marra ruled as follows:
- Sexual assault and battery: The motion was denied. The court said federal pleading rules did not require more factual detail at this early stage and that details could come out in discovery.
- Federal coercion and enticement claim: The court refused to dismiss it but agreed that one paragraph was unclear about which crime the plaintiff relied on. It ordered her to file a new complaint that stated this claim more clearly.
- Citation error: The court corrected a typing error that cited 28 U.S.C. 2255 instead of 18 U.S.C. 2255.
- Outside letter: The court declined to consider a July 2008 letter from the U.S. Attorney’s Office because it was not part of the complaint.
The ruling was about whether the complaint was properly written. It did not decide whether the allegations were true.
Consolidation and Settlement
On April 28, 2009, the court consolidated four Doe cases for discovery and ordered the parties in this case and several others to explain why they should not be added. In an order entered May 14, 2009, Judge Marra consolidated eleven Epstein cases, including this one, “for purposes of discovery and for procedural motions that relate to multiple cases.” Filings that affected more than one case had to be made only in Jane Doe No. 2 v. Epstein, No. 08-80119, “the lowest-numbered pending case.” Consolidation means the cases shared some procedures. It did not merge the claims.
On June 11, 2010, the parties filed a joint notice in the lead case saying that Jane Does 2 through 8 had reached settlements and that stipulations of dismissal would follow. A June 18, 2010 letter from the plaintiffs’ law firm to Epstein’s lawyer enclosed seven signed settlement agreements and releases for those plaintiffs, asked for one combined wire payment of $3,250,000, and said the firm would hold the dismissal papers until the money arrived. The letter does not divide that sum among the seven women, so no amount can be assigned to Jane Doe No. 5.
On June 25, 2010, the court entered the stipulation of dismissal and a Final Order of Dismissal With Prejudice (Document 147). The order denied all pending motions as moot and said the court would keep jurisdiction “to enforce the terms of the parties’ settlement.”
Chronology
| Date | Documented Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| April 14 to 15, 2008 | Complaint signed and entered on the docket | EFTA02741488 |
| February 12, 2009 | Opinion and Order on Epstein’s motion to dismiss | EFTA02741750 |
| February 27, 2009 | Second amended complaint filed (Document 60) | EFTA02741765 |
| April 2, 2009 | Epstein files his answer and defenses (Document 71) | EFTA02742022 |
| May 14, 2009 | Eleven cases consolidated for discovery and shared motions | EFTA02741035 |
| June 11, 2010 | Joint notice that Jane Does 2 through 8 had settled | EFTA02749757 |
| June 18, 2010 | Plaintiffs’ firm sends seven signed settlement agreements and requests one combined payment | EFTA00724313 |
| June 25, 2010 | Stipulation of dismissal and Final Order of Dismissal With Prejudice entered | EFTA02742588 |
Evidence Appearances
| Record or ID | Date | What It Shows | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA02741488 | April 2008 | Original complaint with two state law claims and a jury demand | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02741750 | February 12, 2009 | Ruling that kept the claims alive and required a clearer federal claim | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02741035 | May 14, 2009 | Consolidation order listing this case among eleven related cases | Epstein Data |
| EFTA00724313 | June 18, 2010 | Settlement transmittal letter covering Jane Does 2 through 8, with one combined payment request | Epstein Data |
| EFTA02742588 | June 25, 2010 | Final order dismissing the case with prejudice after settlement | Epstein Data |
What the Record Does and Does Not Establish
Established by court records: The case was filed in April 2008, survived Epstein’s motion to dismiss in February 2009, was consolidated with related cases in May 2009, and was dismissed with prejudice after a settlement in June 2010.
Not established: Whether the plaintiff’s allegations were true. A settlement is not an admission of fault, and the court never held a trial. The records reviewed do not show the amount paid to this plaintiff. Nothing in this case makes a finding about any person other than Epstein.
Do not confuse: Several other plaintiffs used similar pseudonyms, such as Doe II in No. 09-cv-80469 and Jane Doe No. 101 in No. 09-cv-80591. Those are separate cases and separate people.
Related Cases
- Doe No. 3 v. Epstein, No. 08-cv-80232
- Doe No. 1 v. Epstein, No. 08-cv-80804
- Doe v. United States, No. 08-cv-80736, the victims’ rights case about the Non-Prosecution Agreement
Conclusion
Jane Doe No. 5 v. Epstein followed the same path as most of the 2008 Florida Doe cases: an early fight over the complaint, consolidation with related cases, and a group settlement in June 2010. Its main legal contribution is the published February 2009 ruling, which held that the claims were pleaded well enough to go forward. The case ended without a trial, so the court records show what was alleged and how the case was resolved, not whether the allegations were proven.
Questions and Answers
How did this case end?
It settled. The court dismissed it with prejudice on June 25, 2010 and kept the power to enforce the settlement.
How much did the plaintiff receive?
The records reviewed do not say. A June 2010 letter asked for one combined payment for seven plaintiffs and did not divide it among them.
Did a court decide whether the allegations were true?
No. The February 2009 ruling only decided that the complaint was properly written. The case settled before trial.
Why does this case appear in filings for other Doe cases?
In May 2009 the court consolidated eleven related cases for discovery and shared motions, so many filings list all of the case numbers in one caption.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Justice, Court Records: Doe No. 5 v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80381
- Complaint, Document 1 (EFTA02741488)
- Opinion and Order on Motion to Dismiss, Document 58, February 12, 2009 (EFTA02741750)
- Doe No. 5 v. Epstein, 611 F. Supp. 2d 1339 (S.D. Fla. 2009), Leagle
- Second Amended Complaint, Document 60 (EFTA02741765)
- Answer and Affirmative Defenses, Document 71 (EFTA02742022)
- Order Consolidating Cases, May 14, 2009 (EFTA02741035)
- Joint Notice of Settlement, June 11, 2010 (EFTA02749757)
- Settlement transmittal letter, June 18, 2010 (EFTA00724313)
- Stipulation of Dismissal With Prejudice, Document 146 (EFTA02742586)
- Final Order of Dismissal With Prejudice, Document 147 (EFTA02742588)