Skip to main content
Print

Jeffrey Epstein’s 854 Fifth Avenue Tour and the Paris “Batman” House

Field Details
SubjectJeffrey Epstein’s look at two grand homes in 2016 and 2017
Main property854 Fifth Avenue, a Gilded Age mansion facing Central Park in Manhattan
Owners in 2017Five former Yugoslav republics; used as Serbia’s Permanent Mission to the United Nations
Asking terms$50 million net to the seller, plus a 5% broker fee and closing costs paid by the buyer
Listing brokerTristan Harper, Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Epstein’s go betweenDavid Mitchell, Mitchell Holdings LLC
Tour dateWednesday, October 25, 2017, 4 p.m.
Named attendeesJeffrey Epstein, Ariane de Rothschild, David Mitchell and Karyna Shuliak
OutcomeNo offer by Epstein found in the records reviewed; the house sold to another buyer in 2022
Second propertyAn unnamed Paris home called “batman’s house,” photographed for Epstein in January 2016
Key recordsEFTA00796216, EFTA00461488, EFTA02228119, EFTA00974546, EFTA00959005, EFTA02611976, EFTA01621855

Introduction

In October 2017, Jeffrey Epstein walked through one of the last intact Gilded Age mansions in New York. The house at 854 Fifth Avenue was on the market for $50 million. It was also a working diplomatic office, so every visitor had to send photo ID before stepping inside.

The Epstein files hold the full listing package, the email chain that set up the tour and months of follow up from his real estate contact. A separate set of iMessages shows that, almost two years earlier, a contact photographed a lavish Paris home for him and he asked for its price.

These records matter because they show how Epstein shopped for property late in his life, who he brought along and how much access he could arrange. They also have limits. They show interest and planning. They do not show that Epstein made an offer on either home.


Key Takeaways

  • Epstein toured 854 Fifth Avenue on October 25, 2017, with Ariane de Rothschild, David Mitchell and Karyna Shuliak.
  • The seller required photo ID for every visitor because the house was an active foreign government office.
  • The broker later wrote that Rothschild’s file held only an expired 2013 Mozambique visa, not a passport, and that security “didn’t notice.”
  • Mitchell sent Epstein an air rights report and a plan to build the house out “all the way up.”
  • After a fire at the mansion in December 2018, Mitchell told Epstein it might be a “good time to make an offer.”
  • In January 2016, a contact sent Epstein photos from “batman’s house in Paris,” and Epstein asked for the price with furniture.
  • No record reviewed shows Epstein made an offer on either home.

854 Fifth Avenue: The House

854 Fifth Avenue sits between East 66th and 67th Streets, directly across from Central Park. The architects Warren and Wetmore, who also designed Grand Central Terminal, built it for R. Livingston Beeckman. It was finished in 1905. American Aristocracy’s history of the Beeckman House notes that its last private owner was Emily Vanderbilt White, a granddaughter of Cornelius Vanderbilt.

In 1946, the government of Yugoslavia bought the house for its mission to the new United Nations. The 2017 New York Post article included in the listing package puts the price at $300,000. After Yugoslavia broke apart, five countries inherited the house: Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, North Macedonia, Serbia and Slovenia. All five had to agree before it could be sold. Serbia kept using it as its UN mission.


The Listing Package in the Epstein Files

The 33 page listing package, EFTA00796216, is a sales brochure for the house. It includes:

  • Professional photos of the grand staircase, salons, ballroom and Central Park views
  • Historic black and white photos of the house
  • Floor plans for every level, from the garden level to the roof
  • A copy of an April 15, 2017 New York Post article calling the house Manhattan’s last intact Gilded Age mansion
  • A term sheet setting the price at $50 million net to the seller

The term sheet put almost every cost on the buyer. The buyer would pay transfer taxes, the New York mansion tax and a 5% broker fee on top of the price. The house would be sold “as is,” with most furnishings and artwork included.

On October 10, 2017, broker Tristan Harper emailed David Mitchell two attachments named “854 5th Avenue.pdf” and “854 Offer Form 4-17.pdf.” Mitchell forwarded that chain to Epstein on October 24. The brochure in the files appears to be that attachment, though the released copy carries no file name or metadata to confirm it.

Open the 854 Fifth Avenue listing package (EFTA00796216)

The 854 Fifth Avenue listing package found in the Epstein files (EFTA00796216).

The October 2017 Tour

Setting Up the Visit

The planning started on the morning of October 24, 2017. Mitchell asked Harper what times were open. Epstein wrote to Mitchell, “i would like to see 854 fifth tomorw?”

Harper’s reply set the visit for 4 p.m. on Wednesday and listed the seller’s rules. Every visitor had to send photo ID in advance. The buyer had to be present. Cameras were banned, and phones had to be checked at reception. Only the main rooms, lower levels and roof could be shown until an offer was accepted. Harper explained the rules were needed to protect “this working foreign government diplomatic office.”

Epstein forwarded the chain to Karyna Shuliak and his assistant Lesley Groff. Groff then sent Mitchell Epstein’s driver’s license for the showing.

The ID Problem

The full email thread with Harper shows the guest list: Jeffrey Epstein, Ariane de Rothschild, David Mitchell and Karyna Shuliak.

Groff sent IDs for Epstein and Shuliak. For Rothschild, she sent only “the wiki page.” On the morning of the tour, Groff wrote that she had no photo ID for Rothschild. A follow up from Epstein’s side added that “Jeffrey will speak with her.” Harper pushed back. He said there was “really nothing we can do to by-pass this requirement” because they were dealing with a foreign government. At 3:41 p.m., he warned that only three people whose IDs were on file would be let in.

At 3:58 p.m., a reply from Epstein’s side said Rothschild had “JUST arrived” and had sent her passport. That same afternoon, Epstein emailed Rothschild: “looking at a house at 854 fifth 4 o’clock. Meet there?”

After the Tour

Shortly after the tour, Harper wrote back to Epstein’s office, with Mitchell copied. He said they never actually sent Rothschild’s passport page, only “her Mozambique visa, expired in 2013!” He added, “Fortunately the security didn’t notice.” He also wrote that “she seemed very impressed with the building” and asked for feedback.

The records do not say why Rothschild came or whether she had any interest in buying the house.


Follow Up: Air Rights, Status Checks and a Fire

On October 30, 2017, Epstein sent Mitchell a list of open deals that ended with “854 ?” Mitchell answered, “854 what do you want to do there.”

On November 9, 2017, Mitchell forwarded Epstein an air rights report. It said none of the property’s air rights had been sold and about 18,888 square feet remained. Air rights are the legal right to build higher on a lot. Mitchell pitched a plan to “fill in the courtyard above stair skylight and buildout back full all the way up.”

On the night of December 9, 2018, a fire broke out on the third floor of the mansion. CBS New York reported that more than 100 firefighters responded and that no one was injured. The next morning, Mitchell emailed Epstein: “Large fire at that building we looked the Serbian Mission 854 Fifth Avenue Maybe good time to make an offer if interested.”

No reply from Epstein to that email was found in the records reviewed.


The Paris “Batman” House

Almost two years before the Fifth Avenue tour, Epstein was looking at photos of another grand home. On January 8, 2016, a contact whose name is redacted texted Epstein: “Going to batman’s house in Paris tmrw. I can take pictures for u if you want…” Epstein answered, “Yes.”

Over the next two days, the contact sent a long run of photos. They show red silk salons, gilded clocks, oil paintings, a formal dining room, a stair hall and a cluttered desk. One shot shows a courtyard with a round glass skylight set into the pavement.

On January 10, Epstein asked, “is that batmans? house.” The contact said yes. Epstein then wrote, “get a price was is with furniture.” The contact replied, “I think it was 60M with furniture but I need to check. There are a lot of great paintings from famous artists.” The message does not say which currency.

The same exchange appears in a second copy of the message log and in a phone extraction report.

The records do not say who “batman” is, where the house is in Paris or whether it was for sale. No follow up about this house was found in the records reviewed.


Chronology

Date Documented Event Source
Jan. 8 to 10, 2016Contact photographs “batman’s house in Paris” for Epstein; he asks for the price with furnitureEFTA01621855
Apr. 15, 2017New York Post reports 854 Fifth Avenue is for sale at $50 millionEFTA00796216
Oct. 10, 2017Broker sends Mitchell the property PDF and offer formEFTA00461488
Oct. 24, 2017Epstein asks to see the house; Groff sends his driver’s licenseEFTA00972422, EFTA00461511
Oct. 25, 20174 p.m. tour; Epstein invites Rothschild to meet him thereEFTA02228119, EFTA00974546
Oct. 26, 2017Broker notes Rothschild’s ID was an expired visa and asks for feedbackEFTA02228119
Oct. 30, 2017Epstein asks Mitchell for a status on “854”EFTA02575480
Nov. 9, 2017Mitchell sends an air rights report and a buildout ideaEFTA00959005
Dec. 9, 2018Fire breaks out on the mansion’s third floorCBS New York
Dec. 10, 2018Mitchell suggests it may be a good time to make an offerEFTA01013957
Sept. 27, 2022The five countries sell 854 Fifth Avenue for $50 million to another buyerPincusCo

Evidence Appearances

Record or ID Date What It Shows Source
EFTA00796216Undated (2017)33 page listing package: photos, floor plans, Post article and $50 million term sheetEpstein Data
EFTA00461488Oct. 10 to 24, 2017Broker sends the PDF and offer form; tour set for 4 p.m.; seller’s ID and no camera rulesEpstein Data
EFTA00972422Oct. 24, 2017Epstein: “i would like to see 854 fifth tomorw?”Epstein Data
EFTA00461511Oct. 24, 2017Groff sends Mitchell Epstein’s driver’s license for the showingEpstein Data
EFTA02228119Oct. 24 to 26, 2017Guest list, the ID dispute and the broker’s note about the expired Mozambique visaEpstein Data
EFTA00974546Oct. 25, 2017Epstein to “A. de Rothschild”: “looking at a house at 854 fifth 4 o’clock. Meet there?”Epstein Data
EFTA02575480Oct. 30, 2017Epstein asks for a status on “854”; Mitchell asks what he wants to doEpstein Data
EFTA00959005Nov. 9, 2017Air rights report showing about 18,888 square feet unused; buildout ideaEpstein Data
EFTA01013957 and EFTA02611976Dec. 10, 2018Two copies of Mitchell’s email about the fire and a possible offerEpstein Data
EFTA01621855Jan. 8 to 10, 2016iMessage photos of “batman’s house in Paris” and the “60M with furniture” replyEpstein Data
EFTA01624264 and EFTA01067377Jan. 8, 2016Duplicate copies of the Paris message in a message log and a phone extraction reportEpstein Data

What the Evidence Does and Does Not Show

What It Shows

  • Epstein personally asked to see 854 Fifth Avenue and attended the October 25, 2017 tour.
  • His staff handled the paperwork, and his real estate contact kept pitching the property for more than a year.
  • Rothschild was on the guest list and was invited by Epstein to meet him there.
  • Epstein asked for the price of the Paris home after seeing photos of it.

What It Does Not Show

  • No record reviewed shows Epstein made an offer on either home.
  • The records do not explain why Rothschild came or whether she was a possible buyer or partner.
  • The records do not identify “batman” or the Paris address.
  • Appearing in these records does not show wrongdoing by the broker, the sellers or anyone on the guest list.

Open Questions

  • Did Epstein ever reply to Mitchell’s December 2018 suggestion to make an offer?
  • Who is “batman,” and was the Paris house ever on the market?
  • Was Rothschild’s admission on an expired visa ever raised with the mission’s security staff?

Conclusion

The 854 Fifth Avenue records show Epstein, less than two years before his 2019 arrest, touring a $50 million mansion that doubled as a foreign government office. His team worked around strict security rules, and one guest got in on an expired visa. His real estate contact kept the idea alive with air rights math and a pitch to buy after a fire.

The Paris messages show the same habit in 2016: a contact sent photos from inside a lavish home, and Epstein’s first question was the price. Together, the records show steady interest in trophy properties. They do not show that he bought, or even bid on, either one.


Questions and Answers

Did Jeffrey Epstein buy 854 Fifth Avenue?

No. The five former Yugoslav republics sold it in September 2022 to an entity called 854 Fifth Acquisition LLC. No record reviewed shows Epstein made an offer.

Who went with Epstein to see the house?

The broker’s guest list named Ariane de Rothschild, David Mitchell and Karyna Shuliak. Epstein also emailed Rothschild directly to meet him there.

Why did visitors need photo ID?

The house was Serbia’s working mission to the United Nations. The seller required ID for every visitor, banned cameras and made people check their phones.

What is “batman’s house in Paris”?

It is a nickname used in a January 2016 text to Epstein. The records do not say who “batman” is or where the house is. The contact said the price was about 60M with furniture but needed to check.

Why is a real estate brochure in the Epstein files?

The brochure appears to be the listing PDF that the broker sent to Mitchell, who forwarded it to Epstein before the tour.


Sources

Previous Jeffrey Epstein Yahoo Emails and the DDoSecrets Collection
Next Jeffrey Epstein’s May 1, 2011 Dinner: Guests, Flight Arrangements and Evidence
Table of Contents