Skip to main content
Print

EFTA00020462 to EFTA00020469: FBI Intake Report Alleging Art Theft and Grooming Linked to Jeffrey Epstein

Snapshot

Document type: FBI National Threat Operations Center intake

Agency: Federal Bureau of Investigation

FBI case ID: 50D-NY-3027571

Case caption: Epstein, Jeffrey; Child Sex Trafficking

Tip submitted: August 2, 2020, at 11:54 a.m. Eastern Time

Intake dated: August 3, 2020

Classification marking: Unclassified

Page range: EFTA00020462 to EFTA00020469

Evidentiary status: An FBI record showing that a member of the public submitted allegations. It is not a sworn statement, an FBI interview report, an investigative finding, or proof that the allegations were substantiated.

This eight page record preserves an online tip about alleged art theft, art fraud, forgery, and grooming. The complainant connected those claims to Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, actor Jeffrey Matthew Settle, and several people and institutions in the art world.

The most important distinction is simple: the document proves that the FBI received and recorded the tip. It does not prove that the reported events occurred. No follow up interview, art examination, ownership ruling, charging document, or FBI conclusion appears in these pages.


Critical Reading Warning

This article describes allegations contained in an FBI intake record. Names appearing in the record are not automatically suspects, accomplices, witnesses with verified knowledge, or people whom the FBI found responsible for wrongdoing.

An intake is the beginning of a review process. The FBI describes its National Threat Operations Center as a central point for telephone and electronic tips from the public. Intake personnel evaluate incoming information and decide whether it should be sent for further action. The FBI also explains that online submissions are free form reports whose credibility and investigative merit must be assessed.

Accordingly, phrases such as the complainant alleged, the tip claimed, and the intake states are essential here. They prevent the allegations from being mistaken for established fact.

The complainant’s identity and contact information are redacted in the released pages. EpsteinWiki does not attempt to identify that person.


Document Identity and Provenance

The first page is marked Official Record, Unclassified, and Federal Bureau of Investigation, Intake. It records that an online submission was sent through tips.fbi.gov to the FBI National Threat Operations Center on August 2, 2020. The intake was dated the following day.

The header places the material under FBI case ID 50D-NY-3027571 and the caption Epstein, Jeffrey; Child Sex Trafficking. That placement shows how the tip was indexed. It does not show that every allegation in the submission was accepted as part of a proven Epstein trafficking scheme.

The record identifies North Hollywood, California, as the complainant’s location. The name, telephone number, email address, street address, and internet protocol address are redacted. Technical metadata on the final pages records a North Hollywood location, an Android browser, and a referral from a government page about the FBI New York Art Crime Team.

The document lists three violation categories selected for the submission: public corruption, white collar crime, and civil rights. When asked for the exact crime, the complainant entered art theft, art fraud, and art forgery. The complainant answered that no government official was involved.

Those form entries reflect the submitter’s characterization. They are not FBI legal conclusions.


What the Complainant Alleged

The complainant said the relevant events began in 1996, when the complainant was 19 and had completed an art portfolio for art school applications. According to the tip, former classmates and acquaintances learned about the artwork. The complainant then came to believe that several people devised a plan involving a false romantic relationship, the eventual disappearance of the portfolio, and later approaches by Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein.

The tip states that the artwork disappeared during a move into a first Los Angeles apartment in July 1997. The complainant identified actor Jeffrey Matthew Settle as a former romantic partner who helped during the move and alleged that the relationship was part of the plan.

The complainant also described an earlier encounter with Epstein at a bar near Settle’s residence. The intake does not provide the bar’s name, its address, the exact date, an independent witness statement, or any record establishing that the encounter occurred.

The complainant reported hearing a speakerphone conversation about money allegedly owed by Settle. The tip further alleged that Settle said a Serbian organized crime group might harm him if he did not pay. These assertions appear only as the complainant’s account. The released pages contain no recording, telephone record, debt instrument, police report, or corroborating statement.


Alleged Grooming Sequence

The complainant characterized several events as grooming:

  1. A romantic relationship with Settle allegedly began in July 1996 after he appeared outside an audition.
  2. The complainant said Settle later encouraged a trip to New York and arranged a stay connected to professional magician J.B. Benn.
  3. During an April 1997 dinner in New York, the complainant alleged that Maxwell was seated nearby and requested contact information so she could send modeling castings.
  4. The complainant said that, although 20 at the time, the complainant looked younger, was not pursuing modeling, and believed the approach was deceptive.
  5. The relationship with Settle allegedly ended in July 1997, shortly after the artwork disappeared.

This sequence is significant because it shows how the complainant understood the reported conduct in 2020. It does not establish coordination among the named people. The intake contains no travel record, restaurant reservation, photograph, message, diary entry, or witness interview confirming the alleged New York dinner or Maxwell’s reported approach.

The term grooming can describe conduct used to build trust, lower boundaries, or prepare a person for exploitation. In this record, however, it is the complainant’s interpretation of events reported more than two decades later. Investigators would need contemporaneous evidence and independent corroboration to determine whether the encounters occurred as described and whether they were coordinated.


Art Theft and Forgery Claims

The complainant alleged that a complete art portfolio disappeared in Los Angeles in July 1997 and that works from the portfolio later entered the commercial art market under other artists’ names.

The reported claims included:

  • A painting of Bill Clinton’s head on a woman’s body, said to have been created from November 1995 to January 1996.
  • A collage associated in the tip with the Ray Johnson estate. The complainant said it incorporated pieces of a high school calendar, a drawn fingerprint, dental impressions, traced handprints, and a fictional Ray Johnson biography.
  • A painting originally depicting Dan Quayle. The complainant alleged that someone later altered the face to resemble George W. Bush and painted over a signature.
  • A self portrait said to have been created at age 19.
  • Other works allegedly sold or displayed with false attribution through auction houses, galleries, estates, collectors, or artists named in the tip.

The complainant asserted that some works appeared in a Sotheby’s London catalogue dated June 22, 2017, that three paintings became part of Epstein’s estate, and that one work was falsely attributed to Petrina Ryan Kleid. The tip also referenced D.B. Henkel, Paul Tobeler, the Adler Beatty Ray Johnson estate, Adelson Gallery, Tony Podesta, Biljana Djurdjevic, and the Smithsonian.

The complainant reported both financial and physical losses and said a parent provided $100,000 to buy back some of the allegedly stolen works. No invoices, bank records, insurance claims, catalogue lot numbers, conservation reports, images, dimensions, bills of sale, or provenance files are attached to the intake.

Without those materials, the released record does not allow a reader to match any claimed original work to a specific object in an auction, gallery, collection, museum database, or estate inventory.


People and Organizations Named in the Tip

The following descriptions report how names appear in the intake. Inclusion does not establish misconduct.

Person or organizationHow the intake refers to the nameEvidentiary caution
Jeffrey EpsteinAllegedly encountered by the complainant and allegedly connected to three paintingsThe pages contain no independent proof of the encounter or ownership claim
Ghislaine MaxwellAllegedly approached the complainant about modeling at a New York dinnerNo reservation, communication, photograph, or witness statement is attached
Jeffrey Matthew SettleNamed as the subject and witness in form fields; accused by the complainant of participating in a false romance and art theft planThe document records one person’s accusations and no response from Settle
J.B. BennAllegedly hosted or accompanied the complainant in New YorkNo supporting travel or event record appears in the release
Mark EpsteinDescribed as Settle’s friend and incorrectly or uncertainly identified by the complainant as a Cooper Union directorThe intake provides no supporting record for the claimed 1997 role or relationship
Petrina Ryan KleidAccused by the complainant of falsely claiming artworkPublic reporting identifies Ryan Kleid as the artist of Parsing Bill, creating a material conflict if the tip refers to that work
Sotheby’s and other art market entitiesAllegedly sold, displayed, or handled misattributed worksNo lot numbers or object level comparisons are attached
SmithsonianSaid to list a disputed work onlineThe intake does not identify a stable catalogue record or accession number

One private acquaintance is identified by name in the original intake. This article does not repeat that name because the released pages offer no independent evidence of wrongdoing and the person’s identity is not needed to understand the document.


Page by Page Evidence Index

  • EFTA00020462: FBI intake header, case ID, receipt information, redacted complainant data, and the opening portion of the submitted narrative.
  • EFTA00020463: Continuation of the alleged 1997 move, reported Epstein encounter, alleged threat, descriptions of artwork, and selected violation categories.
  • EFTA00020464: Claimed financial losses, alleged auction and gallery activity, references to Epstein’s estate, and the beginning of redacted complainant information.
  • EFTA00020465: Remaining complainant location fields, subject information naming Jeffrey Matthew Settle, Smithsonian related assertions, Petrina Ryan Kleid allegations, and the altered political portrait claim.
  • EFTA00020466: Claimed signature evidence, further auction and gallery allegations, references to Tony Podesta and Biljana Djurdjevic, and a list of alleged social connections.
  • EFTA00020467: Witness fields naming Settle and the complainant’s account of the alleged New York trip, Maxwell encounter, modeling approach, and claimed art market scheme.
  • EFTA00020468: Continuation of the alleged relationship with Settle, the Cooper Union assertion, and technical submission metadata.
  • EFTA00020469: Remaining location and time zone metadata. This page adds no substantive allegation.

What the Document Actually Establishes

The released pages establish a limited set of facts about the record itself:

  • The FBI received an online tip on August 2, 2020.
  • The FBI created or preserved an intake dated August 3, 2020.
  • The record was indexed under an Epstein child sex trafficking case caption.
  • The submitter described alleged conduct involving art theft, art fraud, forgery, a false romance, and grooming.
  • The submitter named Epstein, Maxwell, Settle, and several other people and institutions.
  • The submitter claimed to possess some evidence and to know witnesses.
  • The released intake contains redactions and no attached supporting exhibits.

These are record based facts. They do not resolve whether the underlying story is accurate.


What the Document Does Not Establish

The intake does not establish:

  • That Epstein, Maxwell, Settle, or any other named person participated in stealing or forging art.
  • That Maxwell met the complainant or offered modeling castings.
  • That Epstein met the complainant at the unidentified bar.
  • That any work in Epstein’s properties or estate was created by the complainant.
  • That any Sotheby’s lot, Smithsonian listing, gallery object, or private collection contained the complainant’s work.
  • That signatures were removed, works were repainted, or provenance records were falsified.
  • That the FBI found the tip credible, opened a new investigation, referred it to an art crime team, or closed it without action.
  • That the reported physical and financial losses were documented.

No FD 302 interview report, search warrant affidavit, laboratory result, subpoena return, charging instrument, civil complaint, judgment, or agency disposition accompanies these pages.


Corroborated Background

Some contextual facts can be checked independently without validating the tip’s allegations.

The FBI states that its National Threat Operations Center receives public telephone and electronic tips, evaluates the information, and determines whether a lead should go to a field office or another law enforcement partner. The FBI’s explanation of its internet tip process says members of the public can submit information in a free form field and that analysts review submissions for believability, credibility, and investigative merit. This supports classifying the source as a public tip intake rather than an investigative finding.

Photographs in the EFTA collection show the well known portrait of Bill Clinton in a blue dress inside an Epstein property. Relevant image records include EFTA00001458, EFTA00001459, and EFTA00000856.

Public reporting identifies that portrait as Parsing Bill by Petrina Ryan Kleid. The reported provenance says Ryan Kleid made it while she was an MFA student at the New York Academy of Art and that it was offered at the Tribeca Ball in 2012. That independently reported history matters when assessing the complainant’s Clinton painting claim.

The corroborated fact that Epstein possessed a Clinton portrait does not corroborate the complainant’s authorship claim. It only shows why the claim can be compared against an identifiable object and its reported provenance.


Material Conflicts and Contradictions

The intake says the complainant painted an image of Bill Clinton’s head on a woman’s body between November 1995 and January 1996. It also accuses Petrina Ryan Kleid of claiming one of the complainant’s works.

If the complainant meant Parsing Bill, those assertions conflict with the public identification of Ryan Kleid as the artist and with the reported 2012 creation and auction history. The conflict is substantial because the dates differ by about sixteen years.

The record does not include a photograph, title, measurements, materials, or distinctive composition sufficient to prove that the complainant was referring to Parsing Bill. It is possible that the tip referred to a different Clinton image. For that reason, the accurate conclusion is not that the intake claim has been conclusively disproved. The accurate conclusion is that its apparent match to Parsing Bill conflicts with documented public provenance and cannot be resolved from the released pages.

The complainant also described Mark Epstein as the director of Cooper Union in 1997. The intake contains no record supporting that description. Public accounts more commonly identify him as a Cooper Union graduate and later board leader, not as the school’s director in 1997. This weakens the precision of that portion of the narrative, although it does not by itself resolve the other allegations.

The Smithsonian reference is also too vague to test. The tip does not provide an object title, creator record, accession number, archive box, catalogue URL, or screenshot. An institution holding archival material about an artist or critic is not the same as an institution authenticating or owning a disputed artwork.


Evidence Needed to Test the Claims

A meaningful investigation would require object level evidence and contemporaneous records. Useful materials would include:

  • Photographs of the portfolio before July 1997.
  • School applications, assignments, exhibition records, dated sketches, or testimony from teachers and classmates who saw the works.
  • Moving contracts, inventories, loss reports, insurance claims, and communications from the July 1997 move.
  • Police reports or other complaints made near the time of the alleged disappearance.
  • Images and measurements of each disputed work, including the reverse, frame, labels, signatures, repairs, and surface layers.
  • Scientific analysis of ink, paint, canvas, paper, adhesives, fingerprints, dental imagery, and any alleged overpainting.
  • Complete provenance histories, bills of sale, consignment agreements, auction lot files, and payment records.
  • The exact Sotheby’s catalogue and lot numbers referenced by the complainant.
  • A stable Smithsonian catalogue entry or archival citation for the claimed Ray Johnson related work.
  • Travel records, restaurant records, messages, calendars, and independent witnesses for the alleged 1997 New York encounter.
  • Documentation of the reported $100,000 used to recover art, including recipients and objects purchased.
  • FBI routing, assessment, interview, referral, or closure records created after the intake.

Without this evidence, the claims remain a narrative submitted to law enforcement rather than a demonstrable chain of events.


Privacy and Survivor Centered Handling

The complainant described being targeted as a young adult who looked younger, experiencing a false romance, losing personally meaningful artwork, and suffering financial and physical harm. Those statements should be handled without ridicule or sensationalism.

Survivor centered reporting does not require accepting every claim as verified. It requires preserving the person’s account accurately, protecting private identifying information, avoiding unnecessary repetition of intimate details, and being honest about what the evidence can and cannot show.

It is equally important not to convert an untested tip into accusations against every person named in it. Neutral evidentiary language protects both the integrity of the archive and the possibility of later verification.


Investigative Significance

The intake has archival value because it shows the range of reports that reached the FBI after Epstein’s 2019 arrest and death and Maxwell’s 2020 arrest. It also documents how one complainant connected an older personal account to the public Epstein and Maxwell narrative.

Its significance is procedural and lead based. The report could have supplied investigators with names, possible locations, claimed witnesses, and categories of records to examine. Yet the released pages do not show that any such examination occurred.

The document should therefore be used as a lead index, not as proof of an art theft network. Its strongest research function is to identify follow up questions and missing records.


Fact Check

Reviewed September 10, 2026.

ClaimAssessmentBasis
The FBI received an online tip about Epstein and MaxwellVerifiedThe official intake records the submission date, time, channel, case ID, and narrative
The tip alleged art theft, fraud, forgery, and groomingVerified as a description of the tipThese allegations appear throughout EFTA00020462 to EFTA00020468
The FBI substantiated the allegationsNot establishedNo investigative finding or disposition appears in the eight pages
Epstein possessed a portrait of Bill Clinton in a blue dressCorroboratedEFTA photographs show the work inside an Epstein property
The complainant created that well known portraitMaterially disputedPublic provenance identifies Parsing Bill as Petrina Ryan Kleid’s work and places it in a 2012 auction context
The complainant’s portfolio was stolen during a July 1997 moveUnverifiedNo moving record, contemporaneous complaint, inventory, or attached witness statement appears
Maxwell approached the complainant about modeling in April 1997UnverifiedThe released record contains only the complainant’s later account
Settle coordinated a false romance and theft planUnverifiedThe intake provides the allegation but no independent evidence or response
Three disputed paintings were in Epstein’s estateUnverifiedNo inventory entry, photograph match, or chain of title is attached
The FBI referred the claim for further investigationUnknownThe intake contains no routing or disposition page

Questions Still Unanswered

  1. Did the FBI contact the complainant after receiving the online tip?
  2. Did investigators obtain the evidence and witness information the complainant said existed?
  3. Was the tip referred to the FBI New York Art Crime Team, another field office, or another agency?
  4. Is there a contemporaneous report from 1997 documenting the missing portfolio?
  5. Which exact Sotheby’s lots, gallery records, Smithsonian entries, and estate inventory items did the complainant mean?
  6. Are there dated photographs, school records, sketches, or witnesses capable of establishing authorship before the alleged theft?
  7. Did any conservator or forensic laboratory examine the disputed works for hidden signatures, overpainting, or material dates?
  8. Which Clinton painting did the complainant mean, and was it the work publicly known as Parsing Bill?
  9. Can travel, restaurant, telephone, or calendar records test the alleged 1997 encounters?
  10. Does the FBI hold later assessment, referral, interview, or closure records connected to case ID 50D-NY-3027571?

Limitations

This article is limited to the eight released EFTA pages and the public sources listed below. The intake’s narrative contains spelling errors, broken lines, redactions, uncertain name spellings, and broad claims covering more than two decades.

No attachments identified by the complainant are included. No response from the named people or institutions appears in the record. No later FBI action is visible in this page range.

Targeted searches did not identify a reliable independent source corroborating the alleged grooming sequence or the claimed art theft network. Absence of a located source is not proof that no such evidence exists. It means the present article cannot responsibly treat the claims as confirmed.


Related EpsteinWiki Pages


Sources

Previous Zoning & Property Use Cases
Next EFTA00020517: FBI Intake Call Report
Table of Contents