Skip to main content
Print

EFTA00067066: Extortion Email Referencing Alleged Epstein Video Evidence

Snapshot

FieldDetails
Document identifierEFTA00067066
Bates rangeEFTA00067066 through EFTA00067067
Document typeForwarded anonymous email offering alleged evidence for payment
Original email dateNovember 21, 2019, at 5:59:13 a.m. Mountain Standard Time
Forwarding dateNovember 25, 2019
Original senderRedacted ProtonMail account
Original recipientEddy Aragon, addressed as Edward
Forwarding senderEddy Aragon
Subject“Fwd: CONFIDENTIAL: Jeffrey Epstein”
Property referencedZorro Ranch, New Mexico
Material allegedly offeredSix video recordings and one audio recording
Payment demandedOne Bitcoin
Delivery promisedUSB drive sent anonymously by overnight courier
Principal allegationsRecordings of Epstein sexually abusing minors, an alleged recording associated with Matthew Mellon, an alleged confession involving “Madam G,” and two unidentified foreign girls allegedly buried near Zorro Ranch
Evidentiary statusAuthentic record of an anonymous allegation and payment demand, not proof that the recordings, USB drive, deaths, or burial sites existed
Direct evidenceEFTA00067066 at Epstein Data
Related FBI recordEFTA00067072 at Epstein Data
Duplicate email copyEFTA01250229 at Epstein Data

EFTA00067066 is a two page record containing an anonymous ProtonMail message sent to New Mexico radio host Eddy Aragon approximately three months after Jeffrey Epstein’s death. The sender claimed to be a former Zorro Ranch employee and offered purported recordings and information about alleged deaths in exchange for one Bitcoin.

The email describes six alleged video recordings and one alleged audio recording. Several descriptions claim that the recordings showed Epstein engaging in sexual activity with minors. One item is labeled as a “Matthew Mellon video.” Another allegedly contained a suicide attempt confession by a woman from the San Francisco Bay Area to someone identified only as “Madam G.”

The sender also alleged that two unidentified foreign girls died during violent sexual activity and were buried in the hills outside Zorro Ranch on the orders of Epstein and “Madam G.”

None of those allegations are proven by the email. The released pages contain no recordings, screenshots, file metadata, USB drive, courier receipt, identity verification, forensic report, or evidence that the Bitcoin demand was paid.

The email is nevertheless significant because Aragon reported it to the Federal Bureau of Investigation on November 25, 2019. The FBI created a complaint record documenting the allegations and identifying the email as information offered for sale about Zorro Ranch.


What Is This Record?

EFTA00067066 is a forwarded copy of an email originally sent from a redacted ProtonMail address.

The original sender claimed to have worked at Zorro Ranch and to have removed material from an Epstein residence as protection against possible litigation. The sender refused questions and offered to send a USB drive only after receiving one Bitcoin.

The message uses several forms of pressure commonly seen in questionable evidence sales:

Pressure methodAppearance in the email
SecrecyThe sender described the communication as sensitive and potentially the final email
UrgencyA short payment deadline was imposed
CryptocurrencyPayment was requested through a Bitcoin wallet
No verificationThe sender refused to provide samples
No legal reviewThe sender instructed the recipient not to involve attorneys
No questionsThe sender refused follow up questions
ExclusivityThe material was described as never previously shared
Anonymous deliveryA USB drive was promised through an overnight courier
Anonymous accountThe original message came from ProtonMail

The record is commonly described as an extortion email because it demanded cryptocurrency in connection with highly damaging allegations. However, the document does not contain a legal finding of extortion.

The sender appears to have been attempting to sell purported evidence. Whether that conduct met the elements of extortion, fraud, attempted fraud, evidence trafficking, or another offense was not determined in the released pages.


Source and Provenance

The primary released copy consists of EFTA00067066 and EFTA00067067.

The record was released by the United States Department of Justice through its Epstein Files Transparency Act disclosures. The official production can be accessed through the Department of Justice Epstein disclosures portal.

The document can be reviewed directly through Epstein Data.

A duplicate copy appears at EFTA01250229 and EFTA01250230. That version carries earlier evidence numbering and markings stating that it was subject to specified paragraphs of a protective order. It also preserves information redacted from other public copies, including the digital wallet address.

The wallet address should not be repeated outside an evidentiary need. Its presence proves that a specific payment destination was supplied. It does not identify the wallet owner or prove that any funds were transferred.

A related FBI Guardian Complaint Form appears at EFTA00067072 and EFTA00067073. The FBI titled the matter “Email regarding information for sale about the Epstein Zorro Ranch.”

The FBI form was created on October 8, 2021, but records that Aragon personally reported the email to the FBI’s Albuquerque office on November 25, 2019.


What the Record Contains

The Anonymous Sender’s Claimed Identity

The sender claimed to be a former Zorro Ranch staff member who had been present at the property and had witnessed significant events.

No name, employment dates, job title, supervisor, payroll record, photograph, signature, or identifying detail appears in the public copy.

The sender’s employment claim therefore remains unverified.

The Claimed Source of the Material

The sender stated that the material had been taken from an Epstein home as protection against possible future litigation.

The email does not identify:

  • Which Epstein residence allegedly contained the material
  • When the material was taken
  • Who created the recordings
  • What device stored the original files
  • Whether the sender copied or removed the originals
  • How the sender maintained custody of the material
  • Whether anyone else possessed copies
  • Why the sender waited until after Epstein’s death to offer the material

The email was sent after Epstein died on August 10, 2019. Its reference to future litigation “against Epstein” is therefore chronologically unusual unless the sender meant litigation against his estate or had drafted the language earlier.

The Alleged Recordings

The sender listed seven items.

ItemAlleged formatStated durationSender’s descriptionVerification status
1Video13 minutes 57 secondsAlleged sexual recording involving Epstein and a minorNo recording included
2Video27 minutes 3 secondsAlleged threesomeNo recording included
3Video12 minutes 54 secondsAlleged threesomeNo recording included
4Video19 minutes 22 secondsAlleged sexual recording involving an underage girlNo recording included
5Video7 minutes 31 secondsAlleged underage girl and a parenthetical reference to Matthew MellonNo recording included
6Video23 minutes 48 secondsAlleged underage girl and a rape fantasyNo recording included
7Audio15 minutes 19 secondsAlleged suicide attempt confession by a woman from the Bay Area to “Madam G”No audio included

The six alleged videos total approximately one hour, forty four minutes, and thirty five seconds. The alleged audio adds another fifteen minutes and nineteen seconds. The complete list therefore describes approximately one hour, fifty nine minutes, and fifty four seconds of purported material.

These precise durations may have been intended to make the offer appear credible. Precision is not authentication. Without the files, metadata, hashes, screenshots, or independent witnesses, the descriptions remain unsupported claims.

The Alleged Burial Claim

The sender alleged that two foreign girls were buried somewhere in the hills outside Zorro Ranch after dying from strangulation during violent sexual activity.

The message attributed the burial orders to Epstein and “Madam G.”

The email does not provide:

  • The victims’ names
  • Their ages
  • Their countries of origin
  • The dates of their alleged deaths
  • The location of the alleged burial site
  • A map or geographic coordinates
  • Photographs
  • Witness names
  • Travel records
  • Missing person reports
  • Death certificates
  • Forensic evidence
  • An explanation of the sender’s personal knowledge

The claim was serious enough to warrant investigation. It was not independently established by the email.

The Bitcoin Demand

The sender demanded one Bitcoin by a stated deadline and promised to send the USB drive after receiving payment.

The duplicate copy at EFTA01250229 preserves a wallet address. The 2021 FBI record describes it as a valid wallet address.

A technically valid wallet can receive cryptocurrency. That fact does not establish who controlled it, whether it belonged to the sender, or whether any transaction occurred.


Key Evidence

Aragon Reported the Email to the FBI

The strongest corroborated fact is that Eddy Aragon reported the communication to the FBI’s Albuquerque office on November 25, 2019.

The related FBI complaint record states that Aragon came to the office to report an email offering alleged sexual abuse recordings and the location of two foreign girls supposedly buried at Zorro Ranch.

This means the email was not merely preserved in a private inbox. It became part of the FBI’s Epstein child sex trafficking case records.

The FBI Catalogued the Matter

The FBI assigned the record to case number 50D NY 3027571, the Jeffrey Epstein child sex trafficking investigation.

The FBI title described the information as being offered for sale. The record also states that the current assessment information was maintained elsewhere in the Guardian system.

The released complaint does not disclose the FBI’s final assessment, if one was made.

Multiple Copies Preserve the Same Message

The existence of multiple copies supports the authenticity of the email as a received communication.

It does not authenticate the sender’s identity or the allegations.

RecordEvidentiary contribution
EFTA00067066Redacted forwarded email
EFTA00067067Second page and ProtonMail footer
EFTA01250229Duplicate copy with earlier evidence markings
EFTA01250230Second page of the duplicate
EFTA00067072FBI Guardian Complaint Form
EFTA00067073Enclosure listing and continuation page
EFTA01684466FBI serial and evidence index referencing the Zorro Ranch email

Aragon Did Not Pay

In 2026, Aragon told Reuters that he did not make the requested payment and had no further contact with the sender. He said he believed the message might be legitimate and immediately reported it.

This account is consistent with the FBI form documenting his November 25, 2019 visit.

The Sender Provided No Sample

The sender expressly refused to provide samples. This prevented the recipient from verifying whether the claimed recordings existed before making payment.

That refusal substantially limits the credibility of the offer.


What It Proves

EFTA00067066 proves that:

  • An anonymous ProtonMail user sent a message to Eddy Aragon on November 21, 2019.
  • The sender claimed to be a former Zorro Ranch employee.
  • The sender offered purported Epstein related recordings in exchange for one Bitcoin.
  • The email listed six alleged videos and one alleged audio recording.
  • Several descriptions alleged sexual activity involving minors.
  • One description included the name Matthew Mellon.
  • One description referred to a Bay Area woman, a suicide attempt confession, and “Madam G.”
  • The sender alleged that two unidentified foreign girls were buried near Zorro Ranch.
  • The sender demanded secrecy, refused questions, refused samples, discouraged attorneys, and promised anonymous delivery.
  • Aragon forwarded and reported the email on November 25, 2019.
  • The FBI documented the report within its Epstein child sex trafficking case.
  • The FBI retained at least one copy of the email as an enclosure.
  • The allegations later became relevant to renewed investigations of Zorro Ranch.

What It Does Not Prove

The document does not prove that:

  • The anonymous sender worked at Zorro Ranch.
  • The sender witnessed any crime.
  • The alleged recordings existed.
  • The listed links contained authentic files.
  • The sender possessed a USB drive.
  • Epstein appeared in the alleged recordings.
  • Any recording involved a minor.
  • Matthew Mellon appeared in a recording.
  • “Madam G” meant Ghislaine Maxwell.
  • Maxwell received a confession from the person described.
  • Two foreign girls died at Zorro Ranch.
  • Human remains were buried near the ranch.
  • Epstein or Maxwell ordered a burial.
  • The Bitcoin wallet belonged to a former employee.
  • The sender received payment.
  • The FBI authenticated the recordings.
  • The FBI located or interviewed the sender.
  • The FBI obtained the alleged USB drive.
  • The allegations resulted in a criminal charge.
  • The email was legally determined to constitute extortion.

People and Entities

Person or entityRole in the recordEvidentiary caution
Eddy AragonRecipient who reported the email to the FBIReceipt of the message does not mean he endorsed every allegation
Anonymous ProtonMail userClaimed former Zorro Ranch employeeIdentity and employment remain unverified
Jeffrey EpsteinSubject of the alleged recordings and burial accusationThe email was sent after his death
“Madam G”Person accused by the anonymous senderThe email does not provide a complete name
Ghislaine MaxwellLikely intended identity of “Madam G”This remains an inference from wording and context
Matthew MellonName included in the description of alleged item fiveThe label does not prove his presence or conduct
Two unidentified foreign girlsAlleged victims in the burial claimNo names or identifying information are provided
Unidentified Bay Area womanSubject of the alleged audio recordingHer identity and the existence of the recording are unverified
Federal Bureau of InvestigationAgency that received and catalogued the reportThe released documents do not reveal a final assessment
Zorro RanchLocation referenced by the anonymous senderDocumented site of survivor allegations, but the burial claim remains unverified
ProtonMailEmail service used by the senderUse of encrypted email does not establish truth or falsity
Bitcoin walletRequested payment destinationA valid address does not identify its controller

Timeline

DateEvent
1993Epstein acquired the New Mexico property that became known as Zorro Ranch
August 10, 2019Epstein died in federal custody
November 21, 2019, 5:59:13 a.m. MSTAnonymous ProtonMail message was sent to Aragon
November 22, 2019Stated payment deadline, although the wording contains a calendar inconsistency
November 25, 2019Aragon forwarded the email and reported it to the FBI’s Albuquerque office
October 8, 2021FBI Guardian Complaint Form was created from the earlier report
2023Epstein’s estate sold the former Zorro Ranch
Early 2026Public release of EFTA records brought renewed attention to the anonymous email
February 2026New Mexico officials announced renewed investigation of the ranch allegations
March 9, 2026New Mexico authorities began searching the former ranch
July 2026New Mexico and federal authorities disputed access to unredacted Epstein records
August 5, 2026New Mexico Survivors’ Truth Commission issued an interim report discussing EFTA00067066
August 2026The interim report stated that the claim’s source and validity remained unknown and that no human remains had been confirmed by the March search

Related Evidence

EFTA00067072: FBI Guardian Complaint Form

EFTA00067072 documents Aragon’s report to the FBI.

The form states that Aragon appeared at the Albuquerque office on November 25, 2019. It summarizes the offer as seven recordings of alleged sexual abuse and information about two foreign girls supposedly buried at Zorro Ranch.

The primary email is more precise. It lists six videos and one audio recording, not seven videos.

The FBI record says the wallet address was valid. It does not say that funds were transferred or that investigators identified its owner.

EFTA01250229: Duplicate Email Copy

EFTA01250229 contains a duplicate version of the same email. It preserves evidence number 3501.517 001 and protective order markings.

The duplicate confirms the substance of the message and preserves information redacted from EFTA00067066.

FBI Evidence and Serial Indexes

EFTA01684466 is part of an FBI serial listing that includes the entry “Email regarding information for sale about the Epstein Zorro Ranch.”

The index confirms that the matter was catalogued within the broader Epstein case. An index entry does not reveal what investigative steps were taken.

Narativ Investigation

Investigative journalist Zev Shalev examined EFTA00067066 and the unresolved Zorro Ranch allegations in “The Bodies ‘Buried’ at Zorro”.

The investigation helped draw public attention to the record and asked whether authorities attempted to identify the sender or search the alleged location.

Shalev correctly treated the burial story as an allegation requiring investigation rather than an established fact.

Reuters Reporting

Reuters reported in February 2026 that the New Mexico Department of Justice was actively investigating the allegation and had requested an unredacted copy of the email.

Reuters also reported that Aragon did not pay the Bitcoin demand and did not have further contact with the sender.

The FBI declined to comment on what investigators determined.

New Mexico Search

New Mexico authorities searched the former Zorro Ranch in March 2026. The search involved investigative personnel and was conducted with cooperation from the property’s current owners.

The New Mexico Survivors’ Truth Commission Interim Report states that cadaver dogs and ground penetrating radar had not confirmed the presence of human remains.

This does not prove that the anonymous email was false. It means the burial allegation remained unverified as of the interim report.

New Mexico Survivors’ Truth Commission

The August 2026 interim report cites EFTA00067066 directly.

The commission reported that testimony from former New Mexico Attorney General Hector Balderas indicated that the 2019 tip was not provided to his office when it was originally given to the FBI.

The commission stated that the source and validity of the claim remained unknown. It also reported that documentation showing whether the FBI investigated the underlying allegations was not available to the commission.


Reliability

ComponentReliability assessment
Existence of the emailHigh
Original date and ProtonMail originHigh
Aragon’s receipt of the messageHigh
Aragon’s report to the FBIHigh
FBI cataloguing of the reportHigh
Payment demand for one BitcoinHigh
Existence of a syntactically valid wallet addressSupported by the FBI record
Sender’s claim of former employmentUnverified
Existence of the alleged recordingsUnverified
Accuracy of the recording descriptionsUnverified
Matthew Mellon referenceUnverified label within the email
Identity of “Madam G”Strong contextual inference, not explicit identification
Existence of two deceased foreign girlsUnverified
Burial near Zorro RanchUnverified
Sender’s chain of custodyNot established
FBI authentication of the materialNot shown
Payment or USB deliveryNo evidence found
Legal classification as extortionNot adjudicated

The document has high reliability as evidence that the communication occurred. It has low reliability as proof of the anonymous sender’s claims.


Credibility Indicators and Warning Signs

Potential credibility indicatorMajor warning sign
Specific recording durationsNo recordings or samples were supplied
Claimed firsthand employmentNo identity or employment evidence was provided
Named propertyZorro Ranch was already publicly connected to Epstein
Reference to a specific payment walletWallet ownership was not established
Detailed recording descriptionsDetail can be fabricated
Use of the recipient’s full first nameThat information may have been publicly available
Claim of physical possessionNo photograph of the USB or files was included
Promise of courier deliveryNo tracking information or delivery record exists
Claim of litigation insuranceEpstein was already dead when the email was sent
Urgent deadlineThe date and weekday in the demand do not align
Claimed exclusivityThe sender refused verification
Use of encrypted emailAnonymous email protects both legitimate sources and fraudsters

The payment line reportedly refers to “Thursday 11.22.19.” November 22, 2019, was a Friday. November 21 was Thursday. This inconsistency is a meaningful credibility concern.

It could reflect a typographical error, a reused draft, confusion about the date, or fabrication. It does not by itself resolve whether any underlying information was genuine.


Survivor Safety and Privacy

This record contains allegations of child sexual abuse, rape, strangulation, suicide, and possible homicide.

The purported recordings have not been publicly authenticated. Researchers should not search for, download, share, or redistribute material that may depict child sexual abuse. Possession and distribution of child sexual abuse material are serious crimes and cause continuing harm to victims.

The anonymous sender’s descriptions should not be used to identify possible victims through speculation. The two alleged foreign girls and the woman described as being from the Bay Area remain unidentified.

The email’s reference to Matthew Mellon must also be handled carefully. His name appears only inside the anonymous sender’s description of an alleged file. The released evidence does not establish his presence in a recording or participation in a crime.

“Madam G” should not automatically be converted into a definitive identification. Context suggests Ghislaine Maxwell, but the email does not spell out the name.

The responsible approach is to preserve the document, document the allegations accurately, and distinguish every allegation from independently established evidence.


Why This Matters

EFTA00067066 matters for two separate reasons.

First, it contains an extraordinarily serious allegation involving possible recordings of child sexual abuse and unidentified victims. Even an anonymous and potentially fraudulent report of this nature should be evaluated through lawful investigative methods.

Second, the record raises questions about institutional follow through. Aragon reported the email to the FBI within days. The matter was entered into the Epstein child sex trafficking case, and the email was preserved as an enclosure. The public records do not show whether agents traced the wallet, subpoenaed ProtonMail records, attempted to identify the sender, examined courier activity, searched the claimed locations, or determined that the message was fraudulent.

The New Mexico Survivors’ Truth Commission reported in August 2026 that the state attorney general’s office did not receive the tip when it was originally supplied to the FBI. The commission also reported that it did not have documentation showing what investigation, if any, followed.

The absence of a publicly released investigative result does not validate the anonymous claims. It does create a legitimate accountability question about how a report involving possible child sexual abuse evidence and alleged burial locations was assessed.


Fact Check

ClaimAssessmentExplanation
EFTA00067066 is a two page email recordConfirmedThe Bates range is EFTA00067066 through EFTA00067067
The original email was sent on November 21, 2019ConfirmedThe timestamp appears in the forwarded message
Eddy Aragon received the emailConfirmedThe email and FBI form identify him as the recipient
The sender claimed to be former Zorro Ranch staffConfirmed as a claimNo employment evidence verifies it
The sender offered seven videosIncorrect descriptionThe email lists six videos and one audio recording
The sender requested one BitcoinConfirmedThe payment demand appears in the email
The supplied wallet was validSupported by FBI recordValidity does not identify the owner
The sender possessed a USB driveUnverifiedNo USB drive or photograph was supplied
The recordings existedUnverifiedNo media files were included in the release
The links were functionalNot establishedThe released record truncates the links
Epstein appeared in the alleged recordingsUnverifiedThe descriptions were written by an anonymous sender
Matthew Mellon appeared in a recordingUnverifiedHis name appears only in a parenthetical file description
“Madam G” was Ghislaine MaxwellProbable inferenceThe email does not provide the full name
Two girls were buried near Zorro RanchUnverifiedNo remains or burial site had been confirmed by the August 2026 report
Aragon paid the demandFalse according to AragonHe told Reuters that he did not pay
Aragon reported the message to the FBIConfirmedThe FBI complaint records his November 25 visit
The FBI investigated the sender fullyUnknownNo public final assessment has been located
New Mexico investigators searched the ranchConfirmedA state search began in March 2026
The search confirmed human remainsNot confirmedThe interim report said no remains had been confirmed
The email was legally proven to be extortionNot establishedNo charge or adjudication appears in the released record
The tip was shared with New Mexico officials in 2019Apparently notThe interim report says the state attorney general’s office did not receive it at that time

Questions Still Unanswered

  1. Who controlled the ProtonMail account?
  2. Did the FBI seek subscriber, login, recovery, or network records connected to the account?
  3. Who controlled the Bitcoin wallet?
  4. Did the wallet receive any payment near the stated deadline?
  5. Did investigators perform blockchain tracing?
  6. Were the truncated links ever opened or preserved by the FBI?
  7. Did the links point to actual media files?
  8. Did investigators conduct forensic analysis of any downloaded material?
  9. Did the sender ever contact Aragon again?
  10. Did the sender contact other journalists, attorneys, law enforcement agencies, or members of Epstein’s network?
  11. Was the sender ever employed at Zorro Ranch?
  12. Which Epstein residence allegedly contained the material?
  13. Why did the sender describe the material as insurance against litigation after Epstein’s death?
  14. Why does the payment deadline contain an incorrect weekday and date combination?
  15. Did a USB drive ever exist?
  16. Was any overnight courier shipment prepared?
  17. What did the label “Matthew Mellon video” mean?
  18. Who was the woman described as being from the Bay Area?
  19. Who did the sender mean by “Madam G”?
  20. Were any missing foreign nationals compared with visitor, employment, immigration, or flight records connected to Zorro Ranch?
  21. Did the FBI share the tip with federal prosecutors in New York?
  22. Why was the tip not provided to the New Mexico Attorney General’s Office in 2019?
  23. What assessment is stored under the Guardian reference cited in the 2021 FBI form?
  24. Did the March 2026 search cover the specific areas contemplated by the anonymous allegation?
  25. Did investigators recover any electronic evidence, soil anomalies, or other information requiring additional examination?

Related EpsteinWiki Pages


Source List

Primary Evidence

Official New Mexico Sources

Investigative Reporting

Previous EFTA00013785: Stephanie D. Thacker Letter Opposing Federal Prosecution of Jeffrey Epstein
Next EFTA00101259: Scarola Memorandum Relaying Witness Account of Additional Victims
Table of Contents