Skip to main content
Print

EFTA00946569 to EFTA00946571: Email Correspondence About Travel, Seating, and the 2017 Gotham Awards

EFTA00946569 through EFTA00946571 is a three page copy of an email chain between Jeffrey Epstein and a correspondent whose name and address are redacted in this version. The messages discuss Epstein’s location in the Caribbean, the correspondent’s plans in East Hampton, seating for four people at the 2017 Gotham Awards, and other social plans in New York.

The requested copy does not identify the correspondent in its visible address fields. It does, however, preserve the signoff “Peg.” Other copies of the same chain, together with an earlier Gotham Awards invitation thread, identify the correspondent as entertainment publicist Peggy Siegal. Those related records provide useful context, but they must remain distinct from what is visible in this three page copy.


Snapshot

Document: EFTA00946569 through EFTA00946571

Direct evidence link: EFTA00946569, three page PDF

Individual page links: EFTA00946569, EFTA00946570, and EFTA00946571

Official DOJ file: Department of Justice Dataset 9 PDF

Dates of correspondence: November 25 and 26, 2017

Top level message date: November 26, 2017 at 16:29:29 UTC

Date released: The Department of Justice announced its large Epstein Files Transparency Act production on January 30, 2026. The release does not provide a separate public posting date for this individual PDF.

Sender: “Jeffrey E.” using jeevacation@gmail.com

Correspondent: Redacted in this copy. Related copies identify Peggy Siegal.

Custodian or producing source: United States Department of Justice, Dataset 9

Evidence type: Email chain

Length and format: Three page PDF with EFTA Bates stamps and no visible attachments

Subject: “Re: Monday night. Etc.”

People named or identifiable: Jeffrey Epstein, Peggy Siegal, Susan Gutfreund, and Annette Tapert

Organizations and events named: Gotham Awards and the Carlyle

Locations named: Caribbean, East Hampton, and New York City

Content warning: This record contains no description of sexual abuse. It comes from a larger archive concerning Jeffrey Epstein and may lead readers to sensitive material.

Key takeaway: The chain documents active planning for four seats at the November 27, 2017 Gotham Awards and places Epstein in the Caribbean on November 26. It supports a finding that Epstein and Peggy Siegal were coordinating about the event, but it does not by itself prove who ultimately attended, whether any payment was completed, or what occurred at the event.


What Is This Record?

This record is a printed or exported email chain. Its top message was sent from the account jeevacation@gmail.com under the display name “Jeffrey E.” The message is dated November 26, 2017 at 16:29:29 UTC. Earlier messages embedded below it reach back to November 25.

The requested PDF preserves the conversation in reverse email order. Its newest message says, “and im sitting next to you,” then provides a telephone number. EpsteinWiki omits the full number because reproducing personal contact information is not necessary to understand the record.

Most sender and recipient addresses in the chain are covered with black redaction boxes. The visible message text includes the signoff “Peg,” but the requested copy does not spell out a full name. A later duplicate in DOJ Dataset 11, EFTA02562289, identifies Peggy Siegal in the recipient field. An earlier November 16 invitation chain also identifies Siegal and connects her to the same four Gotham Awards seats.

The PDF contains no visible attachment. Much of pages two and three consists of a repeated confidentiality notice appended to Epstein’s messages. The notice describes the communication as the property of “JEE.” Its presence is part of the original email formatting and is not proof that the correspondence was legally privileged.


Source and Provenance

Epstein Data metadata identifies EFTA00946569 as a three page Dataset 9 file. It classifies the document as an email record, identifies Jeffrey Epstein as the sender, and assigns the date November 26, 2017. The PDF carries consecutive Bates stamps from EFTA00946569 through EFTA00946571.

The Department of Justice said on January 30, 2026 that it had published more than three million additional pages responsive to the Epstein Files Transparency Act. DOJ described the larger collection as material gathered from several investigations and prosecutions involving Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein’s death, and related matters. DOJ also warned that its library might contain sensitive information and that search results may be unreliable for some document formats.

The public record does not expose the native email file, full technical headers, message identifiers, server logs, collection path, or a file level chain of custody for this PDF. The source image is therefore stronger evidence of what appears in the released collection than of the complete technical history of each email.

Multiple overlapping copies in the same public corpus corroborate the thread’s text. EFTA00946533, EFTA00946549, EFTA00946560, and EFTA00946566 preserve earlier stages of the same exchange. Dataset 11 copies preserve fuller recipient labels. Repetition across these copies supports the documentary consistency of the chain, although it does not independently verify every statement made in it.

Primary source: EFTA00946569 through EFTA00946571

Official source: DOJ Epstein Library

Official file: DOJ Dataset 9, EFTA00946569 PDF


Evidence and Document Index

EFTA pagePDF pageContentsEvidentiary note
EFTA009465691Top level email from “Jeffrey E.” and most of the quoted November 26 chainShows seating coordination, a planned group of four, discussion of New York, and a partial location exchange
EFTA009465702Continuation of the location exchange, the initial November 25 inquiry, and repeated confidentiality noticesShows the correspondent in East Hampton and Epstein replying “Caribbean”
EFTA009465713Continuation of repeated confidentiality noticesAdds no new substantive event planning beyond the disclaimer text

What the Record Contains

The chain begins on November 25 when Epstein asks the recipient where she is. On the morning of November 26, the correspondent says she is in East Hampton and plans to attend a New York Jets game and a new Daniel Day Lewis film. She asks where Epstein is. Epstein answers that he is in the Caribbean.

Later that morning, the correspondent asks about conditions where Epstein is staying and whether he is rebuilding. The wording appears to refer to damage or disruption on an island, but the record does not name the island or explain the work. Epstein maintained property in the United States Virgin Islands, yet this chain alone does not establish which island he meant.

The correspondent then asks whether Epstein will be in New York City on Monday night for the Gotham Awards. She refers to an arrangement of three seats for Epstein and one for herself and asks whether the four people will sit together. She also says she needs to give organizers an answer quickly.

The same message mentions the correspondent’s apartment, a new decorator, Susan Gutfreund, the Carlyle, and Annette Tapert’s apartment. These references describe the correspondent’s personal lodging and decorating situation. They do not show that Gutfreund or Tapert participated in the Gotham Awards planning or communicated with Epstein in this chain.

Epstein responds that he is coming and says they have much to discuss. The correspondent then asks for clarification and writes, “Need to organize seating asap today.” Epstein gives a one word confirmation. The correspondent says she is booking four for Monday. The top level response says Epstein will sit next to her and provides a telephone number.

The thread therefore documents ongoing logistical coordination. It does not contain a guest list naming Epstein’s three proposed companions. It also does not include tickets, a receipt, a seating chart, a photograph, or a check in record.


Gotham Awards Context

The “Monday” discussed in the emails was November 27, 2017. The 27th annual Gotham Independent Film Awards took place in New York that evening. The date aligns with the chain’s repeated reference to Monday night.

An earlier email chain provides the clearest context for the four seats. In EFTA00464491, dated November 16, Epstein wrote that he was willing to purchase $10,000 in “chairs” and would need seating for himself plus three guests. Peggy Siegal then said she would sit with him and that he would have four seats with her. The invitation identified the event as the IFP Gotham Awards at Cipriani Wall Street on November 27.

EFTA00950636, dated November 21, records an event representative following up about an invoice and donation letter sent to Richard Kahn. It asks Epstein to confirm attendance and provide the names of his three guests because security required names on the list. This follow up supports the meaning of the seating discussion, but it does not show that the invoice was paid.

Records created on November 27 list the Gotham Awards on Epstein’s itinerary. EFTA00463709 schedules a cocktail reception at 6:30 p.m. and the dinner and ceremony at 7:30 p.m. at Cipriani Wall Street. EFTA02230829 records an instruction to a driver that Epstein planned to leave for the awards at 6:00 p.m. These records strengthen the evidence that attendance was planned shortly before the event. They still do not amount to an admission record, verified eyewitness account, photograph, or other conclusive proof that Epstein entered the venue and remained for the ceremony.


People and Entities Appearing in the Record

Jeffrey Epstein: The top level header identifies “Jeffrey E.” as the sender and displays jeevacation@gmail.com. Related records name Jeffrey Epstein with the same account. The chain places him in the Caribbean on November 26 and shows him participating in seating discussions for the following night.

Peggy Siegal: The recipient’s identifying fields are redacted in EFTA00946569 through EFTA00946571. The correspondent signs one message “Peg.” Dataset 11 duplicate EFTA02562289 identifies the recipient as Peggy Siegal, and the earlier invitation chain names her while discussing the same four seats. This cross document identification is stronger than an inference from the nickname alone.

Susan Gutfreund: Siegal mentions Gutfreund in a sentence about making an apartment chic. The record does not show that Gutfreund sent or received any message, arranged seats, attended the awards, or engaged in misconduct.

Annette Tapert: Siegal refers to staying between the Carlyle and Tapert’s apartment. Tapert is merely mentioned. The chain does not establish her participation in the correspondence, the event planning, or any wrongdoing.

Independent Filmmaker Project and the Gotham Awards: The requested pages name the Gotham Awards. Related invitation records identify the organizer as the Independent Filmmaker Project and the venue as Cipriani Wall Street.


Key Evidence Points

  • The top level header on EFTA00946569 identifies the sender as “Jeffrey E.” using jeevacation@gmail.com and dates the message November 26, 2017 at 16:29:29 UTC.
  • The chain records Epstein saying he was in the Caribbean on November 26.
  • The correspondent says she was in East Hampton and planned to attend a Jets game and a Daniel Day Lewis film that Sunday.
  • The correspondent asks whether Epstein will be in New York for the Gotham Awards on Monday night and refers to three seats for him and one for herself.
  • The thread ends with the correspondent saying she is booking four and Epstein saying he will sit next to her.
  • Related copies identify the correspondent as Peggy Siegal.
  • Earlier invitation records connect the four seats to a proposed $10,000 purchase of chairs, while later itinerary records show that Epstein planned to depart for the event.
  • The requested PDF contains no named guest list, payment record, seating chart, event photograph, or confirmation of entry.

What the Record Does and Does Not Prove

What it establishes:

  • A released email chain shows messages exchanged through an account identified in the documents with Jeffrey Epstein.
  • The messages discuss Epstein’s location, New York plans, and seating for four at the November 27, 2017 Gotham Awards.
  • The correspondent signs as “Peg,” and related versions of the same chain identify Peggy Siegal.
  • The requested copy is part of DOJ Dataset 9 and carries consecutive EFTA stamps.

What it does not establish:

  • It does not prove that every displayed message was read or acted upon.
  • It does not by itself prove that Epstein or any proposed guest entered the Gotham Awards venue.
  • It does not identify Epstein’s three proposed guests.
  • It does not prove that the proposed $10,000 chair purchase was paid, processed, or accepted.
  • It does not establish the nature of every relationship among the people mentioned.
  • It does not implicate Susan Gutfreund or Annette Tapert in the event planning or in misconduct.
  • It does not document sexual abuse, trafficking, or another crime.
  • The confidentiality footer does not itself establish attorney client privilege or a valid legal restriction on the released record.

Timeline Significance

This chain was created more than nine years after Epstein pleaded guilty in Florida to state charges involving a minor and was required to register as a sex offender. Its significance is social and logistical. It shows that Epstein continued to receive access to a prominent New York cultural event and was coordinating group seating shortly before the ceremony.

The record is especially useful when read with the November 16 invitation and November 21 follow up. Together, the documents show a progression from a proposed chair purchase and four seat request, to a request for guest names, to final seating coordination, and then to an itinerary and driver instruction on the event date.

That sequence documents planned access. It should not be converted into a claim about actual attendance without an admission log, final seating chart, photograph, contemporaneous eyewitness account, or another reliable confirmation.


Related Evidence

  • EFTA00946533: Earlier two page stage of the same November 26 chain. It preserves the “Peg” signoff.
  • EFTA00946549: Overlapping three page copy ending with Epstein’s one word response.
  • EFTA00946560: Overlapping two page copy containing another Epstein response in the same conversation.
  • EFTA00946566: Three page incoming message in which the correspondent says she is booking four for Monday.
  • EFTA00464491: November 16 invitation chain identifying Peggy Siegal, four seats, the proposed $10,000 chair purchase, the event date, and Cipriani Wall Street.
  • EFTA00950636: November 21 follow up discussing an invoice, donation letter, security, and the need for three guest names.
  • EFTA00463709: November 27 itinerary listing the Gotham Awards reception and ceremony.
  • EFTA02230829: Driver instruction stating that Epstein planned to depart for the awards at 6:00 p.m.
  • EFTA02562289: Dataset 11 copy of the requested chain with Peggy Siegal identified in the recipient field.

Reliability and Limitations

The PDF was reviewed page by page against its extracted text. Dates, the sender account, the subject, the seating language, the named people, and the EFTA stamps are legible in the page images. The repeated copies provide strong internal corroboration that the chain was preserved more than once in the released collection.

Several limitations remain. The recipient fields are redacted in the requested copy. The native emails and full routing headers are not included. No cryptographic signature or server side authentication record appears. The public PDF therefore supports the existence and content of the released record, while the complete technical authentication history remains unavailable.

The displayed times require caution. The top level header uses UTC, while embedded messages show local clock times without a uniform zone. Some replies appear out of order if all displayed times are treated as one time zone. This likely reflects different mail clients or locations, but the PDF does not provide enough technical metadata to normalize every timestamp safely.

OCR also introduces small errors. Extracted versions sometimes render the at sign in the Gmail address as another symbol, misspell “Sunday,” or distort words in the body. This article relies on the page image where OCR and the scan differ.

The phrase about the Caribbean may suggest Epstein was at one of his Virgin Islands properties, especially because the correspondent asks about island conditions and rebuilding. The specific island is not named, so the article does not assign a property.

Finally, an itinerary records a plan, and a driver instruction records preparation for travel. Neither alone proves that the scheduled movement or event attendance occurred.


Survivor Safety and Privacy Review

The requested record does not name a survivor or describe sexual abuse. It does include a full telephone number and redacted personal contact details. EpsteinWiki should omit the telephone number and should not attempt to reverse the source redactions.

The article names Peggy Siegal because related public records identify her directly and because her identity is necessary to explain the event planning. Susan Gutfreund and Annette Tapert are described only as people mentioned in Siegal’s message. Their appearance in this chain is not evidence of misconduct.


Why This Record Matters

The value of this email chain lies in the mundane detail of access. It records the practical work of arranging seats, confirming a group size, discussing who would sit together, and coordinating Epstein’s return to New York for a prominent event.

The record also demonstrates why evidence pages should connect incremental email copies without treating each copy as a separate event. Several EFTA files preserve successive points in the same chain. Read together, they clarify the sequence. Counted carelessly, they could exaggerate the number of distinct conversations.

Most importantly, the document helps reconstruct Epstein’s continuing social access after his Florida conviction. It does not establish criminal conduct by the correspondent or by people merely mentioned. Its historical contribution is the documented planning itself and the broader question of how established social networks continued to accommodate Epstein.


Fact Check

Checked September 10, 2026:

  • The three page DOJ Dataset 9 PDF was reviewed in full.
  • EFTA00946569, EFTA00946570, and EFTA00946571 were visually checked against the extracted text.
  • Epstein Data metadata identifies the file as Dataset 9, three pages, an email record, sent by Jeffrey Epstein on November 26, 2017.
  • The recipient remains redacted in the requested copy.
  • The “Peg” signoff was verified in overlapping Dataset 9 copies.
  • Peggy Siegal’s identity was verified through EFTA02562289 and the earlier invitation chain, not inferred solely from the nickname.
  • The 2017 Gotham Awards date was independently checked as November 27, 2017.
  • A New York Jets home game against the Carolina Panthers occurred on November 26, matching the correspondent’s stated Sunday plan. This confirms that the reference is chronologically plausible, not that the correspondent attended.
  • The Daniel Day Lewis film is not titled in the chain. It may have referred to Phantom Thread, but the article does not make that identification because the film’s public New York premiere was later and the email may refer to a private screening.
  • No relevant independent Substack investigation was found for this exact EFTA range during the review.

Verification status: Verified as a released three page email record. Recipient identity is corroborated by related copies. Payment and final attendance remain unverified.

Last checked: September 10, 2026


Questions Still Unanswered

  • Who were the three guests Epstein proposed bringing?
  • Was the proposed $10,000 chair purchase completed, and what financial record would confirm it?
  • Did Epstein enter the Gotham Awards venue and remain for the ceremony?
  • Does a final guest list, security list, seating chart, photograph, or check in record survive?
  • Which Caribbean island or property was Epstein referring to?
  • What accounts for the one hour differences among some displayed timestamps?
  • Why were multiple incremental copies of the same chain retained and released?

Related EpsteinWiki Pages


Sources

Previous EFTA00909508 — Jeffrey Epstein and Boris Nikolic Coordinate Party Access and Guest Preferences (April 2011)
Next EFTA01028064: Email Requesting Meeting With “Don Jr.”
Table of Contents