Skip to main content
Print

Helm v. Indyke, No. 1:19-cv-10476 (S.D.N.Y. 2019)

Case Snapshot

FieldDetails
Full caseHelm v. Indyke et al.
DocketNo. 1:19-cv-10476-PGG-DCF
CourtUnited States District Court for the Southern District of New York
FiledNovember 12, 2019
PlaintiffTeresa Helm. Her surname is redacted from the released caption, while the complaint repeatedly identifies her by the first name Teresa.
DefendantsDarren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn, solely in their capacities as co-executors of the Estate of Jeffrey Edward Epstein
Assigned judgesDistrict Judge Paul G. Gardephe and Magistrate Judge Debra C. Freeman
ClaimsBattery and intentional infliction of emotional distress
Alleged conductRecruitment through a supposed traveling masseuse position followed by nonconsensual sexual touching and sexual assault at Epstein’s Manhattan residence in 2002
Central disputesStatutes of limitation, equitable estoppel, equitable tolling, and the availability of punitive damages against Epstein’s estate
OutcomeDismissed with prejudice by joint stipulation on October 15, 2020, after Helm accepted an offer from the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program
Merits rulingNone. The court did not decide the truth of the allegations or rule on the pending motion to dismiss.

Key Takeaways

Helm v. Indyke was Teresa Helm’s civil lawsuit against the co-executors of Jeffrey Epstein’s estate. Helm alleged that she was recruited in California in 2002 for what appeared to be a traveling masseuse job, flown to New York, introduced to Ghislaine Maxwell, and then sexually assaulted by Epstein at his Manhattan mansion.

Helm was 22 years old and studying massage therapy when the alleged conduct occurred. Her complaint did not rely on a claim that she was a minor. Instead, it alleged that Epstein and associates used a deceptive employment opportunity, travel, wealth, status, and intimidation to place her in a vulnerable setting.

The estate moved to dismiss the lawsuit as untimely. The co-executors argued that New York limitation periods expired by 2005. Helm argued that New York Civil Practice Law and Rules section 215(8)(a) gave her one year after the August 29, 2019 termination of Epstein’s federal criminal case and that equitable estoppel or tolling independently preserved her claims.

The court never resolved those competing positions. Litigation and the pending motion were stayed while Helm participated in the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program. The parties later stipulated that Helm had accepted a compensation offer and that the action would be dismissed with prejudice.

The public docket does not identify the compensation amount, disclose the full terms of the resolution, or establish findings about the allegations.


Survivor Reading Note

This article discusses alleged sexual assault, nonconsensual sexual touching, deceptive recruitment, intimidation, fear, and lasting emotional harm.

The released EFTA complaint removes the plaintiff’s surname from the caption and several identifying details, but uses the first name Teresa throughout its factual allegations. The case is publicly indexed as Teresa Helm’s action. This article uses her public name while preserving redactions that could identify other private individuals.

The allegations are labeled as allegations because the lawsuit ended without a trial or merits ruling. That legal distinction does not erase Helm’s account or the documented fact that she accepted an offer from the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program.


Overview

Teresa Helm filed the action on November 12, 2019, approximately three months after Jeffrey Epstein died in federal custody. Because Epstein was deceased, Helm named Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn in their representative capacities as co-executors of his estate. The complaint did not accuse Indyke or Kahn of personally participating in the alleged 2002 assault.

Helm alleged that she was living in Santa Monica, California, and attending the California Healing Arts College when a fellow massage therapy student told her about a traveling masseuse position. The proposed job allegedly involved traveling on a private aircraft with a wealthy New York couple. It was described as an opportunity to attend lavish parties, receive expensive clothing, travel internationally, and continue her education.

According to the complaint, a fellow student arranged for Helm to meet a woman identified in the pleading as an Epstein employee, recruiter, and alleged co-conspirator. That woman’s name is redacted in the released copy. About two weeks later, Helm was told that the couple wanted to fly her to New York for a further interview. The couple allegedly purchased her airline ticket.

Upon reaching New York, Helm was driven to an apartment building on 66th Street. She alleged that she was instructed to visit Ghislaine Maxwell’s home the next day. Helm said she gave Maxwell a professional massage and was paid $100. The complaint alleges that Maxwell then told Helm she would massage and interview with Epstein, instructed her to give him “whatever he wants,” and said that Epstein “always gets what he wants.”

Helm alleged that she later received instructions to go to Epstein’s Manhattan mansion. She described its opulence and displays of photographs with political figures as communicating Epstein’s wealth, power, and connections. In his office, Epstein allegedly requested a foot massage and repeatedly pressed his foot against intimate areas of Helm’s body after she tried to reposition herself.

The complaint then alleged that Epstein grabbed Helm, sexually assaulted her against her will, and grabbed her buttocks as she left. Helm returned to the 66th Street apartment and eventually went home to California. She did not respond when an alleged Epstein associate later emailed to say that the group would decide whether to hire her.

Helm alleged that the experience interfered with her massage therapy education, prompted her to leave California and return to Ohio, and caused severe emotional distress that continued into adulthood.


Parties

Teresa Helm was the plaintiff. The complaint states that she was an Ohio citizen and resident when the case was filed. It describes her as a 22 year old massage therapy student living in Santa Monica at the time of the alleged 2002 recruitment and assault.

Darren K. Indyke was sued solely as an appointed executor of the Estate of Jeffrey Edward Epstein. The complaint relied on his representative role as a basis for pursuing claims based on Epstein’s alleged conduct.

Richard D. Kahn was also sued solely as an appointed executor. Neither executor was named as a personal participant in the alleged assault.

Jeffrey Epstein was the deceased person whose alleged conduct formed the basis of both claims. The complaint alleged that his estate remained liable for damages resulting from that conduct.

Ghislaine Maxwell was not a defendant in this case. The complaint nevertheless alleged that she interviewed Helm, accepted a massage from her, paid her $100, and directed her to give Epstein what he wanted. Those allegations were not adjudicated in this action.

Helm was represented by Boies Schiller Flexner LLP. The complaint was signed by Joshua I. Schiller and listed David Boies and Sigrid McCawley. The co-executors were represented by Troutman Sanders LLP, later known as Troutman Pepper.


Allegations in the Complaint

The following points summarize allegations from the complaint. They are not judicial findings.

  • In September 2002, Helm was 22 and studying massage therapy at the California Healing Arts College.
  • A fellow student asked whether she was interested in working as a traveling masseuse for a wealthy couple with a private aircraft.
  • A woman described as an Epstein employee and recruiter interviewed Helm at Santa Monica beach and portrayed the position as an unusual opportunity for travel, education, luxury, and professional work.
  • Approximately two weeks later, Helm was flown from California to New York for another interview.
  • A driver took her to an apartment building on 66th Street, where she stayed during the trip.
  • Helm was instructed to visit Maxwell’s home. She alleged that Maxwell wore a bathrobe, received a massage from her, paid her $100, and then instructed her to give Epstein whatever he wanted.
  • At Epstein’s residence, Helm was taken to a private office and asked personal questions before he requested a foot massage.
  • Epstein allegedly pressed his foot against intimate areas of Helm’s body. She tried to reposition him and continue professionally, but the touching allegedly continued.
  • Helm alleged that Epstein grabbed her chin, turned her face toward him, and made a remark about trusting a woman who showed her gums when she smiled. She described the interaction as terrifying.
  • As Helm tried to leave, Epstein allegedly grabbed and sexually assaulted her more than once. The complaint also alleges that he grabbed her buttocks near the front door and made a remark that she understood as intimidating.
  • After Helm returned to California, an alleged Epstein associate emailed to thank her for the visit and say that Epstein and associates would decide whether to hire her. Helm did not respond.
  • Helm alleged that she did not complete the massage therapy certification she had originally planned to earn. She moved back to Ohio within months.
  • She alleged severe and continuing emotional distress, humiliation, fear, psychological trauma, loss of dignity, loss of self esteem, and invasion of privacy.

The complaint placed Helm’s account within a broader alleged recruitment system. It asserted that Epstein and associates offered modeling, employment, education, travel, or financial opportunities based on a young woman’s circumstances, then used wealth, status, sexualized surroundings, money, and threats to normalize abuse and discourage disclosure.

Those broader assertions were part of Helm’s pleading and her legal theories. This case did not produce findings establishing the responsibility of every person mentioned in the complaint.


Claims and Requested Relief

The first cause of action was battery. Helm alleged that Epstein intentionally made offensive and sexual contact with intimate parts of her body without consent. She claimed past and continuing emotional distress, humiliation, fear, psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self esteem, and invasion of privacy.

The second cause of action was intentional infliction of emotional distress. Helm alleged that the recruitment, enticement, touching, assault, and intimidation were extreme and outrageous and that Epstein knew or disregarded the substantial likelihood of severe emotional harm.

The complaint sought compensatory, consequential, exemplary, and punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. It also requested costs, attorneys’ fees, other appropriate relief, and a jury trial.

No court awarded damages in this action. The compensation program resolution was not a trial verdict or judicial assessment of damages.


Timeliness Dispute

The co-executors argued that Helm’s claims were untimely because the alleged conduct occurred in New York in 2002. Their January 24, 2020 pre-motion letter stated that a New York battery claim ordinarily had to be filed within one year and a personal injury claim within three years. On that reasoning, they contended that Helm’s claims had expired by 2005 at the latest.

Helm relied primarily on New York Civil Practice Law and Rules section 215(8)(a). That provision may allow at least one year after termination of a criminal case to commence a related civil action arising from the same event or occurrence. Epstein’s 2019 federal prosecution ended on August 29, 2019, after his death, and Helm filed her complaint less than three months later.

Helm argued that the relevant event or occurrence was Epstein’s broader sex trafficking operation. Her opposition compared her account with the 2019 indictment, noting the shared period, New York location, massage based recruitment, escalating sexual contact, and payments associated with massages. She maintained that section 215(8)(a) did not require her to be named in the indictment or to have been a minor.

The estate disputed that interpretation. Its lawyers argued that the indictment concerned the trafficking of minors, while Helm alleged an assault when she was 22. They contended that the criminal charges and her civil claims did not concern the same event or occurrence.

The parties also disputed equitable estoppel and equitable tolling. Helm alleged that Epstein and associates used wealth, political connections, threats, and continued contact to intimidate victims and deter legal action. She argued that her fear of retaliation and the alleged effort to normalize or conceal the conduct justified equitable relief from the limitation period.

The co-executors responded that the complaint did not identify sufficiently particular conduct that prevented Helm from filing during the ordinary period. They also argued that Helm had not pleaded the diligence or extraordinary circumstances required for tolling.

The court did not decide any of these questions. It did not rule that Helm’s claims were timely, and it did not rule that they were time barred.


Punitive Damages Dispute

The executors sought dismissal of Helm’s request for punitive damages. They argued that New York law governed because the alleged tort occurred in New York and that New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law section 11-3.2(a)(1) prohibited punitive damages in a personal injury action against a deceased wrongdoer’s representative.

Helm argued that a request for punitive damages was a remedy rather than a separate cause of action and should not be dismissed at the pleading stage. She also argued that Virgin Islands law should govern because the estate was being administered there and because the Virgin Islands had the greater interest in regulating the estate.

Her opposition contended that Virgin Islands law had not adopted a categorical rule barring punitive damages against a deceased tortfeasor’s estate. She argued that deterrence supported allowing such damages under the circumstances alleged and asked the federal court to certify the issue to the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands if necessary.

The executors replied that New York choice of law principles pointed to the place of the alleged tort and that both New York law and the best reading of Virgin Islands common law barred the requested remedy.

This dispute was never adjudicated. The public docket therefore supports reporting the parties’ positions, but not declaring either position the holding of the court.


Discovery Dispute

The case advanced into discovery while the motion to dismiss remained pending. On May 7, 2020, Helm asked Magistrate Judge Freeman for a conference concerning the executors’ discovery responses. Her counsel said the estate had produced no documents at that point, had largely objected to her interrogatories, and wanted to restrict discovery to a narrow period in 2002.

Helm sought records from January 1, 2002 through the time of the requests. Her lawyers argued that evidence concerning Epstein’s later conduct, alleged recruitment system, communications, employees, and treatment of other women could corroborate her account and support her equitable estoppel theory. They also sought information about Epstein’s email accounts, telephone numbers, possible witnesses, travel records, and communications with alleged associates.

The executors opposed the request. They argued that discovery about other people and distant periods was disproportionate to Helm’s two pleaded tort claims. Their May 13 letter stated that they had assembled a database containing more than 730,000 documents and were searching it, but that collection and review were complicated by the size of the estate and the COVID-19 pandemic. They also disputed Helm’s characterization of their responses and accused her counsel of failing to narrow the requests through a meaningful conference.

Helm replied that the estate’s burden assertions were insufficiently specific and that its supplemental interrogatory responses remained too narrow. The papers show sharp disagreement over both the relevance of the larger alleged trafficking operation and the practical scope of electronic discovery.

At a May 22, 2020 joint conference covering Helm and three related estate actions, Magistrate Judge Freeman declined to impose a single global period for every discovery request. She directed counsel to confer request by request, extended discovery deadlines by 30 days, and required a status report. The transcript shows that the judge wanted discovery tailored to the claims while avoiding unnecessary cost. The court did not issue a merits finding about Epstein’s alleged conduct at that conference.


Procedural History

November 12, 2019: Helm filed the complaint in the Southern District of New York. The case was assigned to District Judge Paul G. Gardephe.

November 21, 2019: Judge Gardephe referred the action to Magistrate Judge Debra C. Freeman for general pretrial supervision, settlement, and reports and recommendations on dispositive motions.

January 14, 2020: Magistrate Judge Freeman entered a coordinated case management order covering this and several other Epstein estate cases. The order expressly stated that the actions were not consolidated and had not been formally designated as related.

January 24, 2020: The co-executors requested a pre-motion conference concerning their proposed motion to dismiss the complaint as time barred and to dismiss the punitive damages demand.

January 29, 2020: Helm opposed the proposed motion, arguing that section 215(8)(a), equitable estoppel, and equitable tolling allowed her claims to proceed.

February 11, 2020: The court issued a coordinated scheduling order for initial disclosures, written discovery, amendments, fact discovery, and expert discovery.

March 20, 2020: The docket recorded the executors’ motion to dismiss, Helm’s opposition, and the executors’ reply. The briefing addressed timeliness and punitive damages. Helm’s opposition was dated March 9, 2020, but its docket stamp is March 20.

May 7 through May 14, 2020: The parties submitted letters and exhibits concerning the scope and pace of discovery.

May 21 and May 22, 2020: A confidentiality agreement and protective order governed sensitive discovery, including information identifying alleged victims or minors, medical records, financial information, and other confidential material.

May 22, 2020: Magistrate Judge Freeman held a joint teleconference concerning discovery in Helm and three other estate cases. She directed further good faith discussions and extended deadlines.

June 12 through June 15, 2020: The parties stipulated to a 60 day stay of discovery and resolution of pending motions while Helm sought to participate in the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program.

June 26, 2020: According to the August status report, Helm submitted her claim to the compensation program on this date.

August 14, 2020: The parties reported that Helm remained active in the program and expected an eligibility or compensation determination. They requested an additional 45 day stay.

October 1, 2020: The parties reported that Helm’s program participation continued and was expected to conclude in the coming weeks.

October 15, 2020: Helm and the co-executors signed a joint stipulation stating that she had accepted an offer of compensation from the program. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), the action was dismissed with prejudice, with each party bearing its own attorneys’ fees and costs.

Because the parties ended the case by signed stipulation, the pending motion to dismiss did not produce a decision on timeliness, punitive damages, or the truth of the allegations.


Evidence and Filing Index

The links below open the released EFTA document sets on Epstein Data.

DateFilingEvidence linkWhy it matters
November 12, 2019Complaint, Document 1EFTA02819086Primary source for Helm’s allegations, claims, requested relief, and attached 2019 Epstein indictment
November 21, 2019Magistrate judge referral, Document 6EFTA02819122Identifies the roles assigned to Magistrate Judge Freeman
January 10, 2020Joint case management letter, Document 10EFTA02819132Addresses discovery planning in the estate litigation
January 14, 2020Coordinated case management order, Document 11EFTA02819134Confirms coordination without consolidation
January 24, 2020Defense pre-motion letter, Document 12EFTA02819136Summarizes the executors’ limitation and punitive damages defenses
January 29, 2020Plaintiff’s response, Document 13EFTA02819140Presents Helm’s section 215(8)(a), estoppel, tolling, and remedy arguments
February 6, 2020Joint discovery plan, Document 15EFTA02819144Records the parties’ proposed discovery subjects and competing positions
February 11, 2020Coordinated scheduling order, Document 16EFTA02819149Sets discovery and case management deadlines
March 20, 2020Defendants’ motion to dismiss memorandum, Document 27EFTA02819169Full defense argument seeking dismissal
March 20, 2020Plaintiff’s opposition, Document 29EFTA02819189Full opposition comparing Helm’s allegations with the 2019 indictment
March 20, 2020Defendants’ reply, Document 31EFTA02819221Final briefing supporting dismissal
May 7, 2020Plaintiff’s discovery letter and exhibits, Document 37EFTA02819265Documents Helm’s request for broader discovery and includes party correspondence and requests
May 13, 2020Defendants’ discovery response, Document 43EFTA02819350Presents the estate’s proportionality, burden, and production arguments
May 14, 2020Plaintiff’s discovery reply and exhibits, Document 44EFTA02819354Challenges the estate’s search period and supplemental responses
May 21, 2020Confidentiality agreement and protective order, Document 45EFTA02819375Establishes protections for sensitive discovery
June 3, 2020Official transcript of May 22 conference, Document 48EFTA02819401Records the court’s discovery directions and discussion of the proposed claims program
June 12, 2020Joint stipulation seeking stay, Document 51EFTA02819463Connects the litigation stay to Helm’s intended compensation program participation
August 14, 2020Joint status report, Document 59EFTA02819473Reports that Helm submitted her program claim on June 26
October 1, 2020Joint status report, Document 62EFTA02819476Confirms continuing program participation
October 15, 2020Joint stipulation for dismissal, Document 63EFTA02819477Confirms acceptance of compensation and dismissal with prejudice

Legal Significance

The case is important because it documents an alleged recruitment method directed at an adult vocational student. The promise was not simply money for a massage. According to Helm, it was a professional opportunity involving travel, education, prestigious employers, and a possible career. Her allegations illustrate how a legitimate field and an apparently credible job interview could be used to create access and vulnerability.

The lawsuit also shows the difference between a procedural defense and a factual determination. The estate challenged the filing date and the remedies available against an estate. Those arguments did not produce a finding that Helm’s account was false. Conversely, the unresolved motion means the case did not establish liability through a judgment.

The discovery filings are significant because they expose a conflict over how much of the alleged Epstein operation was relevant to one survivor’s individual tort claims. Helm sought evidence about the wider pattern, later communications, other alleged victims, employees, travel, and electronic accounts. The estate attempted to confine discovery more closely to Helm and the alleged 2002 encounter. Magistrate Judge Freeman required a more tailored, request specific process instead of adopting either side’s broadest position.

The resolution further shows how the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program intersected with federal civil litigation. Helm suspended active litigation, submitted a claim, accepted an offer, and dismissed her federal case with prejudice. The result was final as to the claims in the lawsuit, but it did not create public findings or a public damages figure.


Fact Check

Fact check date: September 10, 2026

StatementStatusBasis
Teresa Helm filed the action on November 12, 2019VerifiedComplaint docket stamp
Helm was 22 at the time of the alleged assaultVerified as an allegationComplaint paragraphs 11 and 36
Helm alleged that she was recruited while studying massage therapyVerified as an allegationComplaint paragraph 36
The alleged assault occurred at Epstein’s Manhattan residenceVerified as an allegationComplaint paragraphs 20, 24, and 44 through 50
Maxwell was a defendant in this caseFalseOnly Indyke and Kahn, in representative capacities, were named as defendants
Helm alleged that Maxwell participated in the recruitment processVerified as an allegationComplaint paragraphs 41 through 43
Indyke and Kahn were accused of personally assaulting HelmFalseThey were sued solely as estate co-executors
The court found Helm’s claims timelyNot establishedThe motion to dismiss was never decided
The court found the claims untimelyNot establishedThe motion to dismiss was never decided
The court awarded punitive damagesFalseNo damages judgment was entered
Helm submitted a compensation program claim on June 26, 2020VerifiedAugust 14, 2020 joint status report
Helm accepted a compensation offerVerifiedOctober 15, 2020 joint stipulation
The public docket discloses the offer amountFalseThe stipulation gives no amount or detailed terms
The dismissal was with prejudiceVerifiedJoint stipulation under Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(ii)
The coordinated estate cases were consolidatedFalseThe January 14 order expressly said they were not consolidated or formally designated as related

Questions Still Unanswered

  • Who was the fellow massage therapy student who first presented the traveling masseuse opportunity?
  • What is the identity of the recruiter whose name is redacted in the released complaint?
  • What records exist concerning the purchase of Helm’s airline ticket, her driver, the 66th Street apartment, and her movement in New York?
  • Does the estate retain emails or telephone records that corroborate the alleged recruitment, instructions, interview, or later follow up?
  • Which people were working at Epstein’s Manhattan property during Helm’s visit, and what did they observe?
  • What evidence was produced before the litigation was stayed?
  • What evidence did Helm submit to the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program?
  • What compensation amount and release terms did the program offer?
  • How would the court have interpreted section 215(8)(a) in relation to an adult survivor whose allegations resembled the recruitment pattern in the 2019 indictment?
  • Would discovery have supported equitable estoppel or equitable tolling?
  • Which jurisdiction’s law would the court have applied to punitive damages?

Limitations

This page relies primarily on the released EFTA copies of the federal docket. The complaint and later filings contain redactions that obscure the plaintiff’s surname in the caption and the names of certain private individuals. The first name Teresa appears throughout the factual allegations, and the docket is publicly indexed as Helm’s case.

The complaint is a statement of allegations. The estate’s briefs and discovery letters are statements of defense positions. Neither category should be treated as a judicial finding.

The action ended before the motion to dismiss was decided and before a public trial record developed. The public docket does not reveal the compensation amount, the full program submission, witness testimony, or the complete evidence reviewed by the claims administrator.

The May 22 transcript covers four estate cases and also discusses issues unique to a separate case in which Maxwell was a defendant. This article uses only the portions relevant to Helm’s case and the shared discovery administration.

No docket specific report from the established EpsteinWiki sleuth Substack sources was located during preparation of this page. A general sleuth article was not added simply to fill a source category.


Related EpsteinWiki Pages


Sources

Previous Government of the United States Virgin Islands v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.: 2022 Complaint
Next Housekeeper and Employee Wage, Confidentiality, and NDA Litigation Involving Jeffrey Epstein
Table of Contents