Skip to main content
Print

Judge Loretta Preska and the Epstein Records Unsealing Litigation

Snapshot

Loretta A. Preska is a senior United States district judge for the Southern District of New York.

Preska became a central judicial figure in the public release of records from Giuffre v. Maxwell, the defamation lawsuit filed by Virginia Giuffre against Ghislaine Maxwell.

After an appellate court rejected the broad sealing of the case record, Preska was assigned to review hundreds of documents and determine which materials should become public.

Her orders led to the release of depositions, emails, witness statements, motions, and documents identifying people mentioned in the litigation.

Some of her decisions preserved privacy protections for survivors and third parties. Other decisions kept records sealed and were challenged by Giuffre, journalist Julie K. Brown, and the Miami Herald.

In July 2025, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit found that Preska applied the wrong legal standard to several categories of documents. The appellate court vacated portions of her rulings and ordered additional individualized review. It affirmed her remaining decisions.

Preska is included in EpsteinWiki because of her judicial role. She was not an Epstein associate, employee, attorney, witness, or alleged participant in his crimes.


Who Is Loretta Preska?

Loretta A. Preska was born in Albany, New York, in 1949.

She earned a bachelor’s degree from the College of Saint Rose in 1970, a law degree from Fordham University School of Law in 1973, and a Master of Laws degree from New York University School of Law in 1978.

Preska worked in private practice in New York from 1973 until 1992.

President George H. W. Bush nominated her to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York on March 31, 1992. The United States Senate confirmed her on August 11, 1992.

Preska served as chief judge of the Southern District of New York from 2009 through 2016. She assumed senior status on March 1, 2017.

Read Judge Preska’s official Federal Judicial Center biography

View Judge Preska’s Southern District of New York page


The Original Giuffre v. Maxwell Case

Virginia Giuffre sued Maxwell for defamation in 2015.

The lawsuit arose after Maxwell publicly denied Giuffre’s account of being recruited and trafficked by Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein.

The case generated extensive discovery. That material included depositions, emails, witness statements, police records, photographs, and allegations involving numerous third parties.

Judge Robert W. Sweet originally presided over the case.

The parties used a broad protective order that allowed large amounts of material to be filed under seal without separate judicial findings for each document.

Giuffre and Maxwell settled the lawsuit in 2017. The settlement ended the dispute between them, but it did not end the effort to obtain public access to the court records.


Julie K. Brown and the Miami Herald Intervention

Investigative journalist Julie K. Brown and the Miami Herald moved to intervene in the case and requested access to sealed records.

Brown’s reporting exposed how federal prosecutors negotiated Epstein’s 2007 nonprosecution agreement while concealing the agreement from survivors.

The newspaper argued that documents used in federal judicial proceedings should not remain hidden merely because the parties had agreed to seal them.

The public access dispute eventually reached the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.


The First Second Circuit Decision

In 2019, the Second Circuit ruled in Brown v. Maxwell that the district court had improperly allowed the parties to seal large portions of the record without the individualized analysis required by law.

The appellate court explained that documents relevant to judicial decision making are ordinarily subject to a presumption of public access.

It criticized the earlier sealing process for effectively giving the parties control over which records the public could see.

The Second Circuit vacated the orders denying access and returned the case to the district court for an individualized review of the sealed documents.

After Judge Sweet’s death, the case was assigned to Judge Preska.

Read the 2019 Second Circuit decision in Brown v. Maxwell


Preska’s Individual Review Process

Preska inherited hundreds of sealed filings involving more than one hundred survivors, witnesses, employees, public figures, and other third parties.

The court created a review process that assigned pseudonyms to affected individuals. These people were identified as Doe 1, Doe 2, and continuing numbers.

The process allowed each Doe to receive notice and argue that particular information should remain sealed.

Preska then evaluated several competing interests:

  1. The public’s right to monitor federal courts
  2. The privacy and safety of survivors
  3. The reputational interests of third parties
  4. The status of allegations that had never been adjudicated
  5. Whether each document influenced or could have influenced a judicial decision
  6. Whether redactions could protect privacy without concealing an entire document

This review continued for several years.

Search Epstein Data for records concerning Judge Preska


Release of Maxwell’s Deposition

One of Preska’s most significant decisions concerned Maxwell’s 2016 deposition.

Maxwell argued that releasing the deposition would undermine her right to a fair criminal trial. She also asserted privacy interests and argued that confidential discovery material should remain sealed.

Preska rejected Maxwell’s attempt to prevent the deposition’s release. The court stayed the order temporarily so Maxwell could appeal.

The Second Circuit upheld the disclosure order.

The deposition became important because it preserved Maxwell’s sworn answers about Epstein, Giuffre, massages, sexual activity, employees, travel, and people within Epstein’s social circle.

Maxwell repeatedly denied Giuffre’s allegations and said she could not remember numerous events.

The release gave the public access to statements that later became relevant during Maxwell’s criminal prosecution.


The 2023 Unsealing Orders

On December 18, 2023, Preska ordered another group of documents unsealed after reviewing arguments submitted by the affected Does.

The order was temporarily stayed to allow people to appeal before their identities or information became public.

Preska concluded that many names were already publicly associated with Epstein or had appeared during Maxwell’s criminal trial. In those circumstances, she frequently found that continued anonymity was not justified.

She maintained sealing protections for some survivors, minors, medical information, and people whose privacy interests outweighed the value of disclosure.

Read the December 2023 unsealing order


The January 2024 Document Release

Documents were released in stages beginning in January 2024.

The records contained names that had already appeared publicly, as well as testimony and supporting material from the settled civil case.

The release was widely and inaccurately described as an Epstein “client list.”

It was not a client list.

The records included survivors, witnesses, employees, social contacts, attorneys, investigators, public figures, and people mentioned only during questioning.

Preska’s orders did not determine that everyone named had committed misconduct. They decided whether particular judicial records should remain sealed.

Read the Associated Press explanation of Preska’s unsealing order


The Redaction Failures

During the January 2024 release, attorneys filed some documents without fully implementing Preska’s required redactions.

The defective filings exposed names, telephone numbers, email addresses, photographs, and other identifying information that the court had ordered to remain confidential.

Some affected individuals reported fearing for their safety and the safety of family members.

Preska ordered certain documents removed or replaced. She reminded counsel that information released on a heavily monitored public docket could not realistically be recovered once copied and distributed.

The judge emphasized the human consequences of disclosing information belonging to people who should have remained protected.

Read Preska’s January 12, 2024 warning concerning the disclosure failures

The disclosure failures resulted from documents filed by counsel without the ordered redactions. They should not be inaccurately described as Preska intentionally releasing protected information.


Giuffre and the Miami Herald Appeal

Giuffre, Brown, and the Miami Herald challenged portions of Preska’s decisions that kept records sealed.

Their appeal addressed several categories of material:

  1. Motions that had not been decided before Giuffre and Maxwell settled the case
  2. Giuffre’s deposition from separate Florida litigation
  3. Portions of Maxwell’s deposition concerning relationships with consenting adults
  4. Information identifying various Does
  5. The confidential master list used to identify the Does
  6. Arguments submitted by Does seeking continued sealing

The appellants contended that Preska had given insufficient weight to the public’s right of access.

Maxwell defended the sealing decisions.


The 2025 Second Circuit Decision

On July 23, 2025, the Second Circuit affirmed Preska in part, vacated her rulings in part, and returned the case for additional review.

The appellate court identified three legal errors.

First, Preska had ruled that motions left undecided when the case settled were categorically not judicial documents. The Second Circuit held that a document’s judicial status must be determined when it is filed. A later settlement does not automatically remove the presumption of access.

Second, Preska had assigned only a minimal presumption of access to Giuffre’s Florida deposition because it appeared not to have influenced a ruling. The Second Circuit held that the weight given to a judicial document cannot depend simply on how much the judge relied upon it.

Third, Preska did not treat some submissions supporting sealing requests as judicial documents. The appellate court held that filings intended to influence a court’s sealing decision can themselves qualify as judicial documents.

The Second Circuit ordered Preska to conduct additional individualized review under the corrected standards.

However, the appellate court rejected the remaining challenges. It affirmed Preska’s decisions protecting parts of Maxwell’s deposition, certain Doe identities, and the confidential Doe list.

Read the complete 2025 Second Circuit decision


What the Appellate Reversal Means

The 2025 decision did not find misconduct by Preska.

Appellate courts routinely review and correct lower court interpretations of law.

The Second Circuit determined that Preska used an incorrect legal framework for several categories of documents. It required her to review those materials again.

The court did not order every document released.

It required individualized consideration of whether the presumption of access outweighed survivor privacy, third party interests, and other legally recognized concerns.

The appellate court affirmed substantial portions of Preska’s work.


The Separate December 2025 Criminal-Case Order

On December 9, 2025, Judge Paul Engelmayer issued an opinion in United States v. Maxwell, No. 20 Cr. 330, addressing the Justice Department’s request to release grand jury and criminal discovery materials under the Epstein Files Transparency Act. The ruling authorized disclosure subject to safeguards for victim-identifying information and modified the criminal case’s protective order.

That was not a ruling by Preska in Giuffre v. Maxwell. Footnote 14 expressly states that Engelmayer’s order does not modify protective orders entered in Preska’s civil case. The criminal-case ruling should not be treated as a decision in the civil case’s appellate-remand proceedings.


Preska and Giuffre v. Dershowitz

Preska also presided over parts of Virginia Giuffre’s litigation involving Alan Dershowitz.

In 2019, she denied Dershowitz’s request to dismiss Giuffre’s defamation case.

Preska later disqualified Boies Schiller Flexner from representing Giuffre in that lawsuit because of conflicts involving attorney David Boies and the law firm’s earlier interactions with Dershowitz.

An Epstein Data record discusses Preska’s decision allowing the disqualification motion to proceed:

Review the Epstein Data record concerning Preska and the Boies Schiller conflict

The disqualification ruling concerned legal ethics and conflicts of interest. It did not decide whether Giuffre’s or Dershowitz’s underlying allegations were true.

Giuffre and Dershowitz ultimately resolved their litigation in 2022. Giuffre stated that she recognized she might have misidentified Dershowitz. Dershowitz maintained that he had never met her.


Political and Judicial Background

Preska was appointed by Republican President George H. W. Bush.

She has generally been described as a conservative judge and has previously been associated with the Federalist Society.

President George W. Bush nominated her to the Second Circuit in 2008, but the Senate did not act on the nomination before the end of his presidency.

Political background alone does not establish bias in a particular case.

No verified evidence shows that Preska had a personal relationship with Epstein, Maxwell, or the people whose identities she reviewed.

No credible evidence establishes that she received money, gifts, travel, or favors from anyone in Epstein’s network.


Criticism of Preska’s Unsealing Decisions

Preska received criticism from transparency advocates when she declined to release certain materials.

Julie K. Brown and the Miami Herald argued that the court gave too much protection to influential third parties and documents containing allegations of public importance.

The Second Circuit agreed with some of those arguments in 2025.

Preska also received criticism from privacy advocates and affected Does who feared that unsealing untested allegations could damage reputations, expose survivors, or place individuals in danger.

The competing criticism reflects the difficulty of the assignment.

Excessive secrecy can conceal institutional failure and information about abuse.

Careless disclosure can expose survivors and transform unproven allegations into permanent public accusations.

Preska’s legal responsibility was to balance those interests document by document.


What Is Established?

The available record establishes the following facts:

  1. Preska did not preside over the original merits of Giuffre v. Maxwell.
  2. Judge Robert Sweet originally handled the case and approved the sealing system used by the parties.
  3. The Second Circuit rejected the broad sealing process in 2019.
  4. Preska received the case after the appellate remand and Judge Sweet’s death.
  5. She reviewed hundreds of documents involving more than one hundred Does.
  6. Her orders resulted in the public release of substantial Epstein related evidence.
  7. She preserved protections for survivors, minors, medical information, and some third parties.
  8. Filing errors by counsel exposed information Preska had ordered to remain confidential.
  9. The Second Circuit found legal errors in several of Preska’s sealing decisions in 2025.
  10. The appellate court affirmed her remaining decisions.
  11. Preska continued reviewing documents after the 2025 remand.
  12. No evidence identifies Preska as a member of Epstein’s personal or professional network.

Key Takeaways

Preska’s connection to Epstein is judicial, not personal.

Her most important role was deciding how much of the sealed Giuffre v. Maxwell record the public could examine.

The January 2024 documents were not an Epstein client list. They were records from a settled defamation case containing many different categories of people.

Preska released extensive material while protecting some survivors and third parties.

The Second Circuit found that she applied the wrong legal standard to several categories of documents. It ordered another individualized review rather than automatic release.

The appellate court affirmed many of her privacy determinations.

Preska’s record illustrates the tension between public accountability and survivor centered privacy in Epstein related litigation.


Epstein Data Evidence Index

  1. Complete Epstein Data search for Loretta Preska
  2. Epstein Data record concerning Preska and the Boies Schiller conflict
  3. Epstein Data legal actors and litigation index
  4. Epstein Data judicial branch report
  5. Epstein Data extraction report identifying Preska’s judicial role
  6. Epstein Data final investigation report discussing Preska’s unsealing orders

Fact Check

This article was checked against the official Federal Judicial Center biography, Southern District of New York records, district court orders, both Second Circuit opinions, Epstein Data records, and contemporaneous reporting.

Preska is correctly identified as the judge assigned to the unsealing process after the first Second Circuit remand.

She is not described as the judge who originally sealed the entire record.

The 2024 privacy failures are correctly attributed to defective filings by counsel rather than an intentional order by Preska.

The 2025 appellate decision is accurately described as affirming in part, vacating in part, and remanding.

The article does not characterize the unsealed documents as a client list.

No personal, financial, social, or criminal connection between Preska and Epstein was located as of August 20, 2026.


Sources

  1. Federal Judicial Center biography of Loretta Preska
  2. Southern District of New York page for Judge Preska
  3. 2019 Second Circuit decision in Brown v. Maxwell
  4. 2023 district court unsealing order
  5. January 2024 privacy warning
  6. 2025 Second Circuit decision in Giuffre v. Maxwell
  7. December 2025 opinion and order
  8. Associated Press report on the release of more than 150 identities
  9. Jeffrey Epstein
  10. Ghislaine Maxwell
  11. Virginia Giuffre
  12. Julie K. Brown
  13. Alan Dershowitz
Previous Joseph L. Ackerman
Next Katherine Ezell
Table of Contents