“Re: Federal Sex Trafficking and States With Lower Ages of Consent”: August 23, 2006 Email Between Jeffrey Epstein and Harvard Law Correspondent
Snapshot
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| Record type | Email reply containing a quoted legal analysis |
| Date | August 23, 2006 |
| Time | 2:56 PM |
| Sender | J. Epstein, using jeeproject@yahoo.com |
| Recipient | Mitch Webber, using mwebber@law.harvard.edu |
| Subject | “Re: federal sex trafficking and states with lower ages of consent” |
| Central issue | Federal law governing interstate travel, transportation of minors, age of consent differences, and sexual activity |
| Additional request | Epstein asked Webber to examine sex tourism laws |
| Referenced statute | 18 U.S.C. § 2423 |
| Referenced legislation | Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 |
| Referenced case | United States v. Sims, 428 F.3d 945 |
| Related missing record | An August 11, 2006 memorandum referenced in Webber’s message |
| Archive identifier | 4552fe1aacb8e8743d0db763825882e6 |
| Primary source | Archived PDF of the email |
| Evidentiary status | Direct correspondence, with important legal and contextual limitations |
An August 23, 2006 email documents Jeffrey Epstein requesting additional legal research about sex tourism laws after receiving an analysis of federal statutes governing interstate travel and the transportation of minors for sexual activity.
The quoted message, sent by Mitchell “Mitch” Webber from a Harvard Law School email address, discusses a hypothetical involving travel to a state where a person under eighteen was above that state’s age of consent. Webber told Epstein that his “intuition was right” and concluded that the specific hypothetical would not violate the federal transportation provision being examined.
Epstein responded by asking Webber to examine sex tourism laws and travel undertaken with the specific intent to have sex with an underage person.
The record is significant because it shows Epstein personally participating in detailed legal discussions about minors, interstate travel, age of consent differences, and foreign sex laws while he was under investigation in Florida. It does not, standing alone, prove that Epstein planned a particular trip or committed a particular interstate offense.
What Is This Record?
This record is an email reply sent by Jeffrey Epstein to Mitch Webber on August 23, 2006.
Epstein’s reply contains Webber’s earlier message, which appears to follow a telephone conversation. Webber attempted to restate the question that Epstein had presented during that call and then supplied a legal analysis involving federal transportation law, state age of consent rules, and criminal intent.
The exchange concerns two related scenarios:
- Transporting a minor across state lines for sexual activity.
- Traveling across state lines with the intent to engage in sexual activity with a minor.
Webber used Alabama as a hypothetical example because the state’s age of consent was identified as sixteen. His example involved a person in New York arranging to meet a seventeen year old in Alabama and then traveling there for noncommercial sexual activity.
Webber concluded that the described facts would not satisfy the particular federal offense he was analyzing because the proposed sexual activity would not itself be criminal under the cited Alabama statute.
Epstein then expanded the inquiry by asking for research into sex tourism laws and travel with the specific intent to engage in underage sex.
Source and Provenance
The preserved record identifies the sender, recipient, subject, date, and quoted message history.
| Provenance element | Recorded information |
|---|---|
| Sender display name | J. Epstein |
| Sender address | jeeproject@yahoo.com |
| Recipient | Mitch Webber |
| Recipient address | mwebber@law.harvard.edu |
| Date | August 23, 2006 |
| Time | 2:56 PM |
| Format | Reply email with quoted prior correspondence |
| Archive hash | 4552fe1aacb8e8743d0db763825882e6 |
| Preserved copy | EpsteinWiki PDF archive |
| Email database locator | Jmail EML viewer |
The available copy does not display an EFTA or House Oversight catalog number. The archive hash should therefore be retained as the record’s primary technical identifier unless a numbered release copy is located.
The email has also been described by independent reporting. The Forward reported that Webber was working as a research assistant for Alan Dershowitz during Epstein’s defense effort. Webber told the publication that he relayed Dershowitz’s legal analysis and did not provide Epstein with his own independent advice.
Dershowitz similarly told the publication that Webber’s messages represented research and analysis conducted under Dershowitz’s direction. He maintained that the work concerned allegations about Epstein’s past conduct and was not advice about future conduct.
Those later explanations provide context, but they do not change the words recorded in the email itself.
What the Record Contains
Webber’s Restatement of the Question
Webber began by referring to an earlier telephone conversation. He said that he had initially misunderstood Epstein’s question but now understood it to concern what would happen if someone transported a minor, or traveled personally, for sex in a state where the person was above the local age of consent but still under eighteen.
This establishes that the email was not an isolated, unsolicited legal memorandum. It followed an earlier oral discussion whose complete contents are not preserved in this record.
Federal Transportation Statute
Webber quoted language from the federal transportation statute now codified at 18 U.S.C. § 2423.
The quoted provision concerned knowingly transporting a person under eighteen in interstate or foreign commerce with the intent that the person engage in prostitution or other criminal sexual activity.
Webber interpreted the phrase concerning chargeable criminal activity as requiring an underlying criminal offense. He therefore reasoned that state law could determine whether the sexual activity in his hypothetical satisfied that element.
Alabama Hypothetical
Webber constructed an example involving:
| Element | Hypothetical fact |
|---|---|
| Starting location | New York |
| Destination | Alabama |
| Age of younger person | Seventeen |
| Stated Alabama age of consent | Sixteen |
| Communication | A call arranging a meeting |
| Travel | The adult travels to Alabama |
| Conduct described | Noncommercial sexual activity |
| Webber’s conclusion | An element of the examined transportation offense would be absent |
The example was narrowly framed. It did not address payment, prostitution, coercion, force, enticement, exploitation, pornography, trafficking for commercial sex, or a younger child below the applicable age of consent.
Case Specific Statement About Epstein
Webber then referred directly to Epstein’s circumstances and an earlier August 11 memorandum. He asserted that the transportation provision was inapplicable because Epstein had not transported a girl across state lines and had not traveled with the intent to solicit prostitution from underage girls.
That assertion is presented in the email as part of the defense analysis. The August 23 record does not supply the complete factual basis for it, and the referenced August 11 memorandum is not attached.
Epstein’s Sex Tourism Request
Epstein’s reply asked Webber to expand the research to sex tourism laws. Epstein specifically referred to traveling somewhere with the intent to have underage sex.
This response is among the most important parts of the record. Epstein did not merely acknowledge receipt of a legal memorandum. He proposed an additional research question involving purposeful travel for sexual activity with an underage person.
Key Evidence
| Evidence | Evidentiary significance |
|---|---|
| Reference to a telephone call | Establishes an earlier conversation about the legal question |
| Webber’s statement that Epstein’s intuition was correct | Indicates that Epstein had already advanced or anticipated a legal interpretation |
| Discussion of a minor above a state’s age of consent | Shows attention to the difference between being under eighteen and being below a state’s consent threshold |
| New York to Alabama hypothetical | Demonstrates how geographic differences in criminal law were being analyzed |
| Reference to Epstein’s own case | Connects the legal discussion to the defense of Epstein, rather than leaving it as a purely academic exercise |
| Reference to an August 11 memorandum | Establishes the existence of related legal research not contained in this email |
| Epstein’s request concerning sex tourism laws | Shows Epstein seeking an expansion of the research into foreign travel and underage sex |
| Harvard Law email address | Shows that Webber communicated through a Harvard institutional address |
| Later statements by Webber and Dershowitz | Provide their explanation that Webber was relaying work performed for Epstein’s legal defense |
The email’s most consequential language is the combination of Webber’s conclusion that “there is no violation of law” under his stated hypothetical and Epstein’s request to “look at sex tourism laws.”
Those passages must be read in context. The first was a legal conclusion about a limited hypothetical. The second was a request for additional research. Neither sentence independently proves that Epstein undertook a particular trip or acted upon the analysis.
What It Proves
The record directly establishes that:
- Epstein communicated with Mitch Webber on August 23, 2006.
- Webber used a Harvard Law School email address.
- The two had previously discussed a legal question by telephone.
- The legal question involved minors, interstate travel, state age of consent rules, and federal criminal liability.
- Webber supplied a case specific analysis concerning Epstein.
- Webber referred to an earlier memorandum dated August 11, 2006.
- Epstein personally requested additional research concerning sex tourism laws.
- Epstein framed that additional question around travel undertaken with the intent to have underage sex.
- The communication occurred while Epstein’s attorneys were responding to the Palm Beach criminal investigation.
The record also supports the conclusion that legal research about age of consent differences and federal jurisdiction formed part of Epstein’s defense related communications.
What It Does Not Prove
The email does not, by itself, prove that:
- Epstein planned a specific interstate or international trip.
- Epstein transported a particular minor across state lines.
- Epstein traveled on a particular occasion with the criminal intent required by 18 U.S.C. § 2423.
- Webber’s legal conclusion was complete or correct under every potentially applicable statute.
- State age of consent rules automatically eliminated federal criminal liability.
- Commercial sexual activity involving a minor would have been lawful.
- Coercion, payment, prostitution, enticement, pornography, or trafficking were present in Webber’s Alabama hypothetical.
- Harvard Law School authorized, supervised, or approved the correspondence merely because Webber used a Harvard email address.
- Webber was acting as a Harvard professor.
- Alan Dershowitz personally wrote the specific email, although Webber and Dershowitz later said the analysis was relayed under Dershowitz’s direction.
- The referenced August 11 memorandum accurately described all available evidence concerning Epstein’s conduct.
The distinction between what the email records and what later evidence might establish is essential. This document is evidence of legal inquiry and defense preparation. It is not a self contained record of a completed offense.
Legal Context
18 U.S.C. § 2423(a)
The transportation provision concerns knowingly transporting a person under eighteen across state or international boundaries with the intent that the person engage in prostitution or other sexual activity for which someone can be criminally charged.
Webber focused on whether the contemplated sexual activity would constitute an underlying offense in the destination state.
His conclusion should not be interpreted as a general rule that interstate sexual activity with anyone above a state’s age of consent is lawful. The federal statute separately addresses prostitution, while other federal and state laws may apply depending on the facts.
18 U.S.C. § 2423(b)
The travel provision concerns a person who travels with the required intent to engage in illicit sexual conduct.
Webber cited United States v. Sims for the importance of specific intent. The precise timing and purpose of travel can therefore become central questions in a prosecution under this subsection.
Foreign Travel and Sex Tourism
Epstein’s request concerning sex tourism potentially implicated provisions governing:
- Foreign travel undertaken with the required criminal purpose.
- Illicit sexual conduct in foreign places.
- Commercial sex involving a person under eighteen.
- Arranging or facilitating qualifying travel.
The exact scope of those provisions depends on the statutory language in effect at the time of the conduct, the age of the younger person, the character of the sexual activity, the existence of payment or commercial exchange, and the traveler’s intent.
Adam Walsh Act
Webber noted that penalties had recently been increased by the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act, signed on July 27, 2006.
The email was sent less than one month after that law was enacted. The historical amendment notes for 18 U.S.C. § 2423 confirm that the 2006 legislation increased the minimum penalty under subsection (a).
Other Potential Federal Provisions
The email concentrates on § 2423, but that statute did not represent the entire field of possible federal liability.
Depending on the facts, communications or arrangements involving minors could also require analysis under statutes addressing coercion, enticement, commercial sex, prostitution, child sexual abuse material, conspiracy, or attempt. For example, 18 U.S.C. § 2422 separately addresses certain forms of persuasion, inducement, enticement, or coercion involving interstate commerce.
Webber’s statement should therefore be understood as a conclusion about the particular hypothetical and statutory theory he selected, not as a comprehensive declaration that all described or related conduct would be lawful.
People and Entities
| Person or entity | Role in the record |
|---|---|
| Jeffrey Epstein | Sender of the reply and requester of additional sex tourism research |
| Mitchell “Mitch” Webber | Sender of the quoted legal analysis |
| Alan Dershowitz | Epstein defense attorney for whom Webber said he was conducting and relaying research |
| Harvard Law School | Institution associated with Webber’s email address |
| Palm Beach Police Department | Agency whose investigation formed part of the surrounding criminal context |
| United States Department of Justice | Federal department later involved in the Epstein investigation and document releases |
| State of Alabama | Jurisdiction used in Webber’s hypothetical |
| State of New York | Starting location used in Webber’s hypothetical |
| United States Congress | Enacted the federal statutes and 2006 penalty amendments discussed in the email |
| Yahoo | Provider of the email account used by Epstein |
Use of a Harvard email address establishes an institutional connection to the account. It does not establish that Harvard Law School endorsed the analysis or participated in Epstein’s defense as an institution.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| March 2005 | Palm Beach police began investigating Epstein following a complaint involving a fourteen year old girl |
| 2005 | Investigators developed evidence concerning additional girls and massage related payments |
| July 27, 2006 | The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act was signed into law |
| August 11, 2006 | Date of the earlier memorandum referenced by Webber |
| Before August 23, 2006 | Epstein and Webber discussed the legal question by telephone |
| August 23, 2006 | Epstein received Webber’s analysis and requested research into sex tourism laws |
| 2006 and 2007 | Epstein’s defense team continued negotiations with state and federal prosecutors |
| September 24, 2007 | Epstein entered into a federal nonprosecution agreement |
| June 30, 2008 | Epstein pleaded guilty in Florida state court to prostitution related offenses |
| September 2025 | Bloomberg reporting brought public attention to Webber’s correspondence with Epstein |
| December 2025 | Independent reporting further examined the legal memoranda and Epstein’s concern about potential federal exposure |
| February 4, 2026 | The Forward published additional reporting and statements from Webber and Dershowitz |
Related Evidence
August 11, 2006 Memorandum
Webber quoted a conclusion from an August 11 memorandum concerning possible application of § 2423 to Epstein.
That memorandum is essential related evidence because it may contain:
- The factual assumptions used by the defense.
- The evidence reviewed by Webber or Dershowitz.
- The complete statutory analysis.
- Qualifications omitted from the August 23 email.
- Discussion of other possible federal offenses.
Until the memorandum is located and authenticated, the quotation in this email should not be treated as a complete representation of its contents.
Earlier Telephone Conversation
The email confirms that Epstein and Webber had discussed the issue by telephone. No transcript or recording of that call accompanies the preserved message.
The missing call record matters because it could clarify:
- How Epstein originally phrased his question.
- Whether Epstein described actual conduct or a hypothetical.
- Whether a particular person, destination, or trip was discussed.
- Why Webber initially misunderstood the question.
Other Webber Correspondence
The Forward’s investigation describes other Webber communications concerning the defense effort. One November 2006 message reportedly argued that the return of girls to Epstein’s properties weighed against a finding of pressure.
That later statement concerns a different legal issue and should not be merged with the August 23 email. Together, however, the records help document Webber’s role in legal research and communications during Epstein’s defense.
An independent Just da Facts Substack archive review also flagged Webber’s communications while cataloging notable Epstein email exchanges. Such investigative indexes can assist discovery, but conclusions should remain anchored to the underlying records.
Federal Nonprosecution Agreement
The legal research preceded the controversial Jeffrey Epstein federal nonprosecution agreement.
That agreement resolved potential federal exposure through a negotiated arrangement tied to Epstein’s Florida state plea. It is a separate document and does not establish that prosecutors accepted every legal position advanced in the Webber correspondence.
Palm Beach Investigation Records
The email should also be reviewed alongside:
- The Palm Beach Police Department probable cause affidavit.
- The February 18, 2006 communication concerning possible charges, commonly identified as the Krischer email.
- The Department of Justice review of the Epstein nonprosecution agreement.
These records provide factual and prosecutorial context not contained in the August 23 email.
Reliability
| Reliability factor | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Visible sender and recipient fields | Strong |
| Exact timestamp and subject | Strong |
| Quoted message history | Strong |
| Preservation as a PDF | Strong, subject to ordinary archive verification |
| Archive hash | Useful for identifying the electronic record |
| Independent reporting quoting the same exchange | Strong corroboration |
| Complete email chain | Incomplete |
| Earlier telephone conversation | Not preserved |
| August 11 memorandum | Referenced but not attached |
| Legal accuracy | Requires independent analysis |
| Proof of actual conduct | Limited |
The record is highly reliable for establishing that the written exchange occurred in the form displayed. It is less complete as evidence of the entire legal discussion because the earlier call and memorandum are absent.
The legal statements in the email should be treated as advocacy or defense analysis, not as a judicial ruling.
Survivor Safety and Privacy
The record discusses minors and sexual activity in abstract legal language. No survivor is identified by name in the email.
Responsible use of the document requires avoiding speculation about which survivor, if any, may have been connected to the questions. The hypothetical involving a seventeen year old in Alabama should not be attributed to a real person without additional evidence.
The phrase “age of consent” must also not be used to minimize exploitation, commercial sexual activity, grooming, coercion, or disparities in power. Conduct can be exploitative even when a narrowly selected criminal statute does not apply to a hypothetical set of facts.
Descriptions of survivors should remain factual, necessary, and respectful.
Why This Matters
This email is significant because it places Epstein directly inside a legal research process concerning the boundary between state consent laws and federal offenses involving minors.
The record is not merely a lawyer circulating a general summary of criminal law. Webber referred to Epstein’s earlier telephone question, addressed Epstein’s intuition, connected the analysis to Epstein’s case, and cited an earlier case specific memorandum.
Epstein then requested additional research involving sex tourism and intentional travel for underage sex.
The exchange therefore provides evidence about the subjects Epstein considered important during his defense:
| Subject | Importance |
|---|---|
| State age of consent differences | Potential effect on whether sexual activity constituted an underlying state offense |
| Interstate transportation | Possible basis for federal jurisdiction |
| Personal travel | Possible exposure under the federal travel provision |
| Specific intent | Required mental state for certain federal offenses |
| Sex tourism laws | Possible application to foreign travel |
| Recent penalty amendments | Increased consequences under federal law |
| Case specific factual assumptions | Defense claim that Epstein had not transported girls or traveled with the required intent |
The email also illustrates why document based analysis must separate a lawyer’s interpretation from an authoritative legal determination. Webber’s conclusion was not a court ruling, and the selected hypothetical did not address every federal statute or every factual variation.
Fact Check
| Claim | Finding |
|---|---|
| Epstein sent the reply on August 23, 2006 | Confirmed by the preserved email |
| The recipient was Mitch Webber | Confirmed |
| Webber used a Harvard Law email address | Confirmed |
| The exchange followed a telephone call | Confirmed by Webber’s message |
| The analysis involved a minor above the destination state’s age of consent | Confirmed |
| Alabama was used as the hypothetical destination | Confirmed |
| Webber cited 18 U.S.C. § 2423 | Confirmed |
| Webber referenced the Adam Walsh Act | Confirmed |
| The Adam Walsh Act was signed shortly before the email | Confirmed, July 27, 2006 |
| Webber cited United States v. Sims | Confirmed |
| Epstein requested research into sex tourism laws | Confirmed |
| The email proves Epstein planned foreign travel for illegal sex | Not established |
| The email proves all sex with a minor above a state’s age of consent was federally lawful | False as a general proposition |
| Webber was a Harvard professor | Not supported |
| Harvard Law School approved the advice | Not established |
| Webber said he was relaying Dershowitz’s analysis | Confirmed through later reporting |
| Dershowitz said the work concerned Epstein’s past conduct | Confirmed as Dershowitz’s reported position |
| The August 11 memorandum is attached | False |
| A numbered EFTA identifier is visible on the available copy | Not confirmed |
Questions Still Unanswered
- Where is the complete August 11, 2006 memorandum?
- Is there a numbered EFTA, Department of Justice, or House Oversight version of this email?
- What exactly did Epstein ask during the preceding telephone conversation?
- Why did Webber initially misunderstand Epstein’s question?
- What facts concerning Epstein’s conduct were supplied to Webber and Dershowitz?
- What evidence supported the assertion that Epstein had never transported a girl across state lines?
- What evidence supported the assertion that Epstein had never traveled with the relevant criminal intent?
- Did Webber complete the additional sex tourism research Epstein requested?
- Are there later emails, memoranda, billing entries, or research notes documenting that work?
- Were other members of Epstein’s defense team copied on related correspondence?
- Did prosecutors receive or respond to any version of the legal argument?
- Did the defense analyze other statutes addressing enticement, commercial sex, attempt, or foreign illicit sexual conduct?
- Was Epstein’s question based on a purely hypothetical scenario, prior conduct, contemplated conduct, or a combination of concerns?
- What records establish the complete chain of custody for the archived email?
Related EpsteinWiki Pages
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Alan Dershowitz
- Harvard University
- Jeffrey Epstein Nonprosecution Agreement
- Palm Beach Police Department Probable Cause Affidavit
- Krischer Email Concerning Charges Against Jeffrey Epstein
- Epstein Email Communications Index
- Communication Records
Source List
- Archived PDF: “Re: federal sex trafficking and states with lower ages of consent”
- Jmail EML record, archive identifier 4552fe1aacb8e8743d0db763825882e6
- The Forward: “Antisemitism group keeps board member who emailed Epstein on the legality of transporting minors for sex”
- 18 U.S.C. § 2423, Transportation of Minors
- Official United States Code text and amendment history for 18 U.S.C. § 2423
- 18 U.S.C. § 2422, Coercion and Enticement
- Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006
- United States v. Sims, 428 F.3d 945
- Department of Justice Office of Professional Responsibility review of the Epstein nonprosecution agreement
- Just da Facts Substack archive