United States v. Noel, No. 1:19-cr-00830 (S.D.N.Y. 2019)
Snapshot
United States v. Noel was the federal criminal case brought against two Metropolitan Correctional Center employees who were assigned to the Special Housing Unit during the final night of Jeffrey Epstein’s life. Correctional Officer Tova Noel and Material Handler Michael Thomas were accused of failing to perform mandatory inmate counts and 30 minute rounds and then signing official Bureau of Prisons records that falsely represented that the work had been completed.
A federal grand jury returned a six count indictment on November 19, 2019. Count One charged both defendants with conspiracy under 18 U.S.C. § 371. The remaining counts charged falsification of federal records under 18 U.S.C. §§ 1001(a)(3) and 2. Noel faced five substantive falsification counts. Thomas faced three. Both pleaded not guilty.
The case did not proceed to trial. On May 25, 2021, each defendant entered a six month deferred prosecution agreement. The agreements included admissions that the defendants falsely certified that required counts and rounds had been conducted. Each defendant also agreed to provide truthful and complete information, submit to interviews, complete 100 hours of community service, obey the law, and comply with supervision and good behavior conditions.
On January 3, 2022, after prosecutors determined that Noel and Thomas had fulfilled the agreements, the court entered a nolle prosequi order and dismissed all charges. Neither defendant was convicted or sentenced.
This case is directly relevant to the institutional failures surrounding Epstein’s death in federal custody. It is not a homicide prosecution, and it did not adjudicate how Epstein died. The New York City medical examiner determined that Epstein died by suicide by hanging. The FBI found no criminality concerning how he died. The Department of Justice Office of Inspector General later found serious staff misconduct and systemic failures but no evidence contradicting the FBI’s conclusion.
Key Takeaways
- The formal caption includes both Tova Noel and Michael Thomas, although public indexes often shorten the case name to United States v. Noel.
- The indictment concerned false federal records and an alleged conspiracy to conceal missed correctional duties.
- Prosecutors alleged that no officer conducted a required count or round in the Special Housing Unit from approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 until approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10, 2019.
- Noel and Thomas initially pleaded not guilty.
- Their later deferred prosecution agreements contained factual admissions. Those agreements were not guilty pleas.
- Both defendants completed 100 hours of community service and other conditions.
- The court dismissed every charge on January 3, 2022.
- No trial verdict, criminal conviction, or sentence resulted from the case.
- The prosecution documented serious correctional failures. It did not establish that either defendant caused Epstein’s death.
- Later disclosures and congressional testimony raise additional questions about the final night, but unanswered questions are not proof of homicide, bribery, or a coverup.
Why This Case Matters
Epstein died before the 2019 sex trafficking prosecution against him could reach trial. His death deprived survivors of the opportunity to see that case tested before a jury and intensified public scrutiny of the federal institutions responsible for his custody.
United States v. Noel was the only public federal criminal prosecution directed at the conduct of the two employees assigned to the Special Housing Unit when Epstein was found. The case therefore occupies a narrow but important place in the record. It documents alleged failures in inmate supervision, the creation of false correctional records, and the government’s decision to resolve the charges through diversion rather than trial.
The case must also be read in proportion. The indictment did not charge murder, manslaughter, assistance in a suicide, obstruction of an Epstein sex trafficking investigation, or destruction of camera evidence. It charged a conspiracy to defraud the United States and false writings within federal jurisdiction. The later dismissal did not erase the admissions in the deferred prosecution agreements, but it left no conviction.
For survivors and researchers, the most important institutional question is not limited to a single night’s misconduct. The broader record shows staffing shortages, overtime practices, supervision failures, an unfilled cellmate directive, excess linens, deficient searches, and malfunctioning recording equipment. Focusing only on Noel and Thomas can obscure the management failures documented by the Inspector General.
The Defendants
Tova Noel was a federal correctional officer assigned to the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan. According to the Inspector General, she worked her regular Special Housing Unit shift from 4:00 p.m. to midnight on August 9, 2019, followed by an overtime shift from midnight to 8:00 a.m. on August 10.
Michael Thomas was employed as a material handler. He had previously worked as a correctional officer and was assigned on overtime to the Special Housing Unit from midnight to 8:00 a.m. on August 10. The Inspector General described Noel and Thomas as the only two staff members on duty in the unit after midnight.
The public CourtListener parties page identifies Montell Figgins of the Law Offices of Montell Figgins as counsel for Thomas. It identifies Assistant United States Attorneys Nicolas Roos, Rebekah Donaleski, and Jessica Lonergan for the government. The publicly indexed parties information used for this page does not provide a complete defense appearance history for Noel, so no unsupported counsel attribution is added here.
Background at MCC New York
Epstein was detained at the Metropolitan Correctional Center after his July 2019 arrest on federal sex trafficking charges. He was housed in the Special Housing Unit, where Bureau of Prisons policy required staff to observe inmates at least twice each hour. Institutional counts were also required at specified times.
After a July 23 incident in which Epstein was found with a cloth around his neck, he was placed on suicide watch and later psychological observation. When he returned to the Special Housing Unit, Psychology Department personnel directed that he be housed with an appropriate cellmate. More than 70 MCC employees received notice of that requirement.
Epstein’s cellmate was transferred on August 9. The Inspector General found that staff did not assign a replacement. Epstein was therefore locked alone in his cell that evening. A later search found excess blankets, linens, and clothing in the cell, some of which had been torn into nooses.
The available recording system was also impaired. A digital video recorder failure meant that only about half of the institution’s cameras were recording. One functioning camera captured a large portion of the Special Housing Unit common area and the approaches to the tiers, but not the door of Epstein’s cell itself.
These conditions form the institutional setting for the records charged in United States v. Noel.
Events of August 9 and 10, 2019
The indictment and Inspector General report describe the following sequence:
| Time | Event documented or alleged |
|---|---|
| 4:00 p.m., August 9 | Noel began her regular shift. The indictment alleged that the mandatory 4:00 p.m. count was not properly performed. |
| Approximately 8:00 p.m. | Special Housing Unit inmates were locked in their cells for the night. Epstein was alone. |
| 10:00 p.m. | The indictment alleged that the mandatory count was not properly completed. Noel later maintained that she counted inmates alone, which would not satisfy the required two person procedure. |
| Approximately 10:40 p.m. | The last approach to Epstein’s tier visible on the available video occurred. |
| Midnight | Thomas began his overtime assignment. Noel and Thomas became the two staff members on duty in the unit. |
| Midnight, 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. | The required institutional counts were not performed, according to the indictment, later admissions, video review, and the Inspector General. Count slips were completed as if the counts had occurred. |
| Overnight | Required 30 minute rounds were not performed. Noel completed and signed more than 75 round sheet entries stating that she and Thomas had conducted rounds. |
| Approximately 1:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m. | Available video showed both employees seated at the officers’ station for an extended period. The indictment alleged that they appeared to be asleep. |
| Approximately 6:30 a.m. | Noel and Thomas began breakfast delivery. Thomas entered Epstein’s cell after Epstein did not respond and found him hanged. Thomas called for help and began an emergency response. |
The available camera did not show Epstein’s cell door. The Inspector General nevertheless found that anyone entering his tier from the common area would have appeared on the recording. Its review found no one entering the tier from approximately 10:40 p.m. until Noel and Thomas approached at approximately 6:30 a.m.
The Six Count Indictment
The grand jury returned the indictment on November 19, 2019. The charging document is available as EFTA00010968.
Count One charged Noel and Thomas with conspiracy to defraud the United States under 18 U.S.C. § 371. The theory was that they agreed to impair the lawful functions of the Bureau of Prisons by obstructing required inmate monitoring and creating false records that concealed the failure.
Counts Two through Six charged false writings or documents within the jurisdiction of the executive branch under 18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3), together with aiding and abetting liability under 18 U.S.C. § 2 where applicable. The substantive counts concerned official count slips and round sheets.
The charging allocation was not identical for both defendants. Noel was charged in all five substantive falsification counts. Thomas was charged in three of them. With Count One included, Noel faced six counts and Thomas faced four.
An indictment is an accusation, not evidence of guilt. At the time it was returned, both defendants retained the presumption of innocence. They pleaded not guilty and did not later enter guilty pleas.
Government Allegations
Prosecutors alleged that Noel and Thomas repeatedly failed to perform mandatory counts and rounds, spent substantial portions of the shift at the officers’ desk, browsed the internet, and appeared to sleep for a period. They allegedly signed official forms representing that required monitoring had occurred.
The government treated the entries as material because MCC personnel relied on them to determine that institutional counts had cleared and that inmates were being monitored. False entries did not merely record an internal scheduling error. They created an official representation that safety procedures had been completed.
The indictment also described statements allegedly made soon after Epstein was found. It attributed to Noel an admission that the 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. rounds had not been completed. It attributed to Thomas statements including that the employees had made a serious mistake and had not done the rounds. These were allegations in the charging document at the start of the case. Later admissions in the deferred prosecution agreements supplied a separate basis for stating that false certifications occurred.
Defense Position and Presumption of Innocence
Noel and Thomas pleaded not guilty at their initial appearances. Public reporting described their lawyers as arguing that the two employees were being singled out for broader institutional failures, including severe staffing shortages and repeated overtime demands.
That context is supported in part by the Inspector General’s later findings. MCC New York suffered chronic staffing problems, and the report documented management and supervisory failures extending well beyond the two defendants. The report also found that other employees created false count and round documentation. Prosecutors declined charges against those other employees.
Institutional context does not by itself determine individual criminal liability. It does matter when evaluating charging discretion, culpability, and why a case might be resolved through a deferred prosecution agreement rather than a trial.
Because the charges were dismissed, no jury made findings on the indictment and no court entered a judgment of guilt.
Deferred Prosecution Agreements
On May 25, 2021, the United States Attorney’s Office entered separate six month deferred prosecution agreements with Noel and Thomas. A released agreement is available as EFTA00023087.
The Department of Justice Inspector General summarized the material conditions. Each defendant:
- Admitted falsely certifying that required inmate counts and rounds had been conducted.
- Agreed to disclose truthfully and completely all information concerning the defendant’s activities and Bureau of Prisons employment.
- Agreed to interviews by the United States Attorney’s Office, FBI, and Inspector General.
- Agreed to complete 100 hours of community service.
- Agreed not to violate federal, state, or local law.
- Agreed to comply with pretrial supervision and other good behavior conditions.
The agreements deferred prosecution while the conditions were performed. This procedure allowed the charges to remain pending without a trial during the agreement period. If the defendants complied, the government would seek dismissal.
The factual admissions matter. They mean it would be inaccurate to write that the government simply withdrew unsupported allegations. The legal result matters equally. A deferred prosecution agreement is not a guilty plea and is not a criminal conviction.
Dismissal and Final Disposition
In a recommendation dated December 13, 2021, prosecutors represented that Noel and Thomas had successfully fulfilled the deferred prosecution agreements. The District Court signed and filed the nolle prosequi order dismissing all pending charges on January 3, 2022.
Nolle prosequi means that the government discontinued the prosecution. Here, dismissal followed the negotiated diversion period and completion of the agreed conditions. It did not follow an acquittal, a jury verdict, or a judicial finding that no false records had been made.
The accurate disposition is therefore:
- Charges filed and contested.
- Deferred prosecution agreements accepted.
- Admissions made within those agreements.
- Conditions completed.
- All charges dismissed.
- No convictions and no criminal sentences.
Reports stating that Noel or Thomas pleaded guilty, were convicted, or received a sentence of community service are incorrect. The 100 hours were conditions of the deferred prosecution agreements.
Relationship to the DOJ Inspector General Investigation
The criminal case and the Inspector General investigation overlapped but were not the same proceeding. The prosecution addressed federal criminal statutes and required proof beyond a reasonable doubt if taken to trial. The Inspector General applied an administrative misconduct framework and generally used a preponderance of the evidence standard.
The Inspector General’s June 2023 report, EFTA01656708, found that Noel and Thomas did not perform the midnight, 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. counts, and that they falsified the associated count slips. It found that the required rounds were not conducted and that Noel completed more than 75 false round entries. The report also found that Noel lacked candor concerning the 10:00 p.m. count.
The report found misconduct by additional MCC personnel. It concluded that the evening watch officer in charge and another material handler also prepared or signed false documentation. The United States Attorney’s Office declined to prosecute those employees.
The Inspector General concluded that negligence, misconduct, and performance failures created an environment in which Epstein was left alone and unmonitored with excess linens. It issued eight recommendations involving cellmate assignments, suicide risk controls, counts and rounds, cell searches, staffing, supervision, and camera systems.
Relationship to Epstein’s Death
The prosecution arose from conduct on the night Epstein died, but it did not charge Noel or Thomas with causing his death.
The Office of Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York determined that the cause of death was hanging and the manner of death was suicide. The FBI investigated the cause of death and found no criminality concerning how Epstein died. The Inspector General stated that it found no evidence contradicting that conclusion.
The Inspector General also found that the available video did not show anyone entering Epstein’s tier from approximately 10:40 p.m. to 6:30 a.m. It reported that the reactions of Noel and Thomas when Epstein was discovered were consistent with their being unaware of harm to him before the cell was opened.
These findings do not excuse the missed monitoring or false records. They distinguish documented custodial misconduct from unsupported claims that the prosecution proved a homicide or conspiracy to kill Epstein.
Later Released Evidence
The Epstein Files Transparency Act releases add investigative records that can be read beside the court docket.
The preliminary FBI situational report, EFTA01659612, records early information that two guards had falsified logs and supplies a preliminary emergency timeline.
Emails concerning subpoenas and interviews of MCC personnel appear at EFTA01659570 and EFTA01659578. An internal exchange about likely criminal charges appears at EFTA01660852. These records help document the transition from the death investigation to the falsified records case.
An FBI briefing concerning the final approach to the tier is available at EFTA01656152. A later FBI timeline and investigative summary is available at EFTA01656198. The more detailed video timeline is available at EFTA01656209.
Additional released records include computer forensic material at EFTA00062276, bank material at EFTA00124206, a witness proffer at EFTA00126075, and a subpoena record at EFTA00075342. These materials have prompted renewed public questions. They must be evaluated separately for provenance, scope, and what they actually establish. A search, deposit, image interpretation, or third party statement is not by itself proof of bribery, homicide, or participation in a coverup.
In a voluntary transcribed interview before the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform on May 18, 2026, Noel discussed her employment, the counts and rounds, conditions in the Special Housing Unit, the discovery of Epstein, the prosecution, and later questions about released records. Her testimony is a later witness account, not a modification of the 2021 criminal disposition.
Procedural Timeline
| Date | Proceeding |
|---|---|
| August 10, 2019 | Epstein was found hanged in his MCC cell at approximately 6:30 a.m. |
| August 12, 2019 | FBI and Inspector General interview and subpoena activity concerning MCC staff was underway. |
| August 13, 2019 | Internal communications reflected that criminal charges concerning staff conduct were being considered. |
| November 19, 2019 | Grand jury returned the six count indictment against Noel and Thomas. Both pleaded not guilty. |
| 2020 | The case proceeded through discovery and pretrial scheduling. A trial date was set but did not result in a trial. |
| May 25, 2021 | Noel and Thomas entered separate six month deferred prosecution agreements. |
| January 3, 2022 | The court entered nolle prosequi and dismissed every charge after successful completion of the agreements. |
| June 27, 2023 | DOJ Inspector General released Report 23-085 detailing the broader custody, supervision, and institutional failures. |
| May 18, 2026 | Noel appeared voluntarily for a transcribed House Oversight interview concerning the final night and later released records. |
Evidence and Court Document Index
| Record | Date | Relevance | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grand jury indictment | November 19, 2019 | Six count charging instrument | EFTA00010968 |
| Federal docket | 2019 to 2021 | Procedural history, parties, filings, and termination | CourtListener docket |
| Parties and attorneys | 2019 to 2021 | Public appearance index | CourtListener parties page |
| Deferred prosecution agreement | May 25, 2021 | Admissions and diversion conditions | EFTA00023087 |
| DOJ OIG Report 23-085 | June 27, 2023 | Official findings concerning MCC custody and personnel conduct | EFTA01656708 |
| DOJ OIG official report page | June 27, 2023 | Government publication page and recommendations | DOJ OIG |
| Preliminary FBI situational report | August 10 to 12, 2019 | Early investigative timeline and log falsification information | EFTA01659612 |
| MCC officer subpoena email | August 2019 | Names Noel and Thomas among interview and subpoena targets | EFTA01659570 |
| Interview and subpoena material | August 12, 2019 | Early investigative activity concerning duty officers | EFTA01659578 |
| Internal criminal charge discussion | August 2019 | Documents early prosecutorial assessment | EFTA01660852 |
| FBI final approach briefing | Later investigative record | Analysis of movement toward the tier | EFTA01656152 |
| FBI investigation timeline | Later investigative record | Summary of the death investigation and related matters | EFTA01656198 |
| FBI video timeline | Later investigative record | Chronology derived from available Special Housing Unit video | EFTA01656209 |
| Computer forensic record | Later released evidence | Internet activity attributed to the officers’ station | EFTA00062276 |
| Bank records | Later released evidence | Financial records that generated later public questions | EFTA00124206 |
| Witness proffer | Later released evidence | Third party account requiring credibility assessment | EFTA00126075 |
| Forthwith subpoena record | August 2019 | Investigative demand concerning a device | EFTA00075342 |
The index prioritizes records that bear directly on the charged conduct, the diversion agreements, and the investigation of Epstein’s custody. Inclusion does not mean that every statement within a record has been independently proven.
What the Case Establishes
The public record establishes that:
- Noel and Thomas were the two employees assigned to the Special Housing Unit after midnight on August 10, 2019.
- Required counts and rounds were not performed.
- Official documentation represented that required work had been completed.
- A federal grand jury indicted both employees.
- Both initially pleaded not guilty.
- Both later admitted false certifications as part of deferred prosecution agreements.
- Both completed the agreement conditions, including 100 hours of community service.
- The government discontinued the prosecution and the court dismissed all charges.
- No conviction resulted.
What the Case Does Not Establish
The case does not establish that:
- Noel or Thomas killed Epstein.
- Either defendant assisted Epstein in taking his life.
- Either defendant was bribed.
- The camera failures were caused by either defendant.
- The defendants destroyed evidence.
- The dismissal was an acquittal.
- The dismissal erased the admissions made in the deferred prosecution agreements.
- Every later allegation in an investigative file is true.
- Institutional failure and the official suicide finding are mutually exclusive. The official investigations found both serious institutional failure and no evidence of criminality in how Epstein died.
Legal and Historical Significance
United States v. Noel is significant because it placed official recordkeeping at the center of accountability for a death in federal custody. Counts and rounds are basic safety mechanisms. When records falsely show that they occurred, supervisors and control personnel cannot reliably know whether detained people are alive, present, and secure.
The disposition also illustrates the difference between criminal adjudication and negotiated diversion. The defendants accepted responsibility for specified false certifications and performed conditions, while avoiding convictions. The result may be criticized or defended as an exercise of prosecutorial discretion, but it should be described accurately.
The Inspector General’s later findings broaden the frame. They show that the failures were not confined to two overnight employees. Management decisions, staffing shortages, overtime use, cell assignment practices, searches, supervision, and camera maintenance all contributed to the conditions at MCC New York.
For Epstein’s survivors, these failures had a direct consequence: the pending sex trafficking case ended without trial when Epstein died. The accountability question is therefore larger than whether two correctional employees completed their rounds. It includes whether federal institutions used the safeguards necessary to preserve a prosecution of extraordinary public importance.
Fact Check
Reviewed: September 10, 2026
Claim: Noel and Thomas were convicted. False. They entered deferred prosecution agreements, completed the conditions, and had all charges dismissed.
Claim: They pleaded guilty. False. Their initial pleas were not guilty. The deferred prosecution agreements included admissions but were not guilty pleas.
Claim: They were sentenced to community service. Misleading. The 100 hours of community service were conditions of diversion, not a criminal sentence following conviction.
Claim: The indictment charged six counts against each defendant. False. The indictment contained six counts total. Noel faced Count One and all five substantive counts. Thomas faced Count One and three substantive counts.
Claim: The charges were dismissed in November 2021. Incorrect. The deferral period expired on November 20, 2021, but the court dismissed the charges on January 3, 2022. The Inspector General report gives December 13, 2021; the signed court order identifies that as the prosecutors’ date, not the judge’s order date.
Claim: The prosecution proved that Epstein was murdered. False. The case did not charge or adjudicate homicide. The medical examiner ruled suicide, and the FBI and Inspector General reported no evidence of criminality concerning how Epstein died.
Claim: The official investigations found no wrongdoing at MCC. False. The Inspector General documented numerous serious failures, false records, misconduct, poor judgment, and management deficiencies.
Claim: No other employees falsified records. False. The Inspector General found that other staff also created false documentation. The United States Attorney’s Office declined to prosecute them.
Claim: The available video showed Epstein’s cell door. False. The functioning camera showed common areas and approaches to the tiers, not the cell door itself.
Claim: Dismissal makes the indictment’s allegations established facts. False. Allegations remain allegations unless supported by admissions or other evidence. This article identifies the separate factual admissions and Inspector General findings.
Questions Still Unanswered
- Why did prosecutors select deferred prosecution rather than taking the case to trial, and what considerations beyond the public agreement terms influenced that decision?
- Why were Noel and Thomas charged while prosecutors declined charges against other employees whom the Inspector General found had also prepared false records?
- What is the complete public docket record for the separate deferred prosecution agreements, interview certifications, and dismissal submissions?
- Which defendant is represented by the released agreement at EFTA00023087, and is the other defendant’s complete agreement separately available in the released corpus?
- How did supervisors evaluate and clear institutional counts based on forms that did not reflect direct observation?
- Why was the directive that Epstein have a cellmate not carried out after his prior cellmate was transferred?
- When was Epstein’s cell last searched before his death, and how did excess linens remain in it?
- What explains the complete sequence of movements visible near the tier at approximately 10:40 p.m.?
- What is the full context for later released computer, banking, subpoena, and witness records, and what corroboration exists for claims drawn from them?
- Which portions of the May 18, 2026 House interview materially clarify or conflict with Noel’s earlier accounts to investigators?
- What administrative discipline was imposed on each employee identified by the Inspector General, including personnel who were not criminally charged?
Limitations
This article distinguishes the indictment, negotiated admissions, Inspector General findings, witness accounts, and unresolved allegations. Those categories carry different evidentiary weight.
The CourtListener docket supplies a useful public index but is not PACER and may not contain every filing. Some Epstein Files Transparency Act records are redacted, extracted from larger files, or presented without the complete context available to investigators. EFTA numbering identifies released documents, not a judicial finding that every statement in them is true.
The May 18, 2026 House transcript is a later congressional interview. Statements in it should be attributed to the witness or questioner and checked against contemporaneous records. This page does not adopt insinuations in questions as facts.
No directly relevant article was found in searches of the key Epstein focused Substack publications reviewed for this page. None is included merely to fill a source category.
Related EpsteinWiki Pages
- United States v. Epstein, No. 1:19-cr-00490
- Death of Jeffrey Epstein
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Ghislaine Maxwell
- United States Department of Justice
- Federal Bureau of Prisons
- House Oversight Committee Evidence Files
Sources
- United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, United States v. Noel public docket.
- United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, parties and attorneys index.
- Grand jury indictment, United States v. Noel, No. 1:19-cr-00830, EFTA00010968.
- Deferred prosecution agreement, EFTA00023087.
- U.S. Department of Justice Office of Inspector General, Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons’ Custody, Care, and Supervision of Jeffrey Epstein at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York, New York, Report 23-085, June 27, 2023.
- U.S. Department of Justice Office of Inspector General, full released report, EFTA01656708.
- FBI preliminary situational report, EFTA01659612.
- FBI and SDNY communications concerning MCC personnel subpoenas and interviews, EFTA01659570, EFTA01659578, and EFTA01660852.
- FBI briefings and timelines concerning the Special Housing Unit, EFTA01656152, EFTA01656198, and EFTA01656209.
- Later released investigative records, EFTA00062276, EFTA00124206, EFTA00126075, and EFTA00075342.
- House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, transcribed interview of Tova Noel, May 18, 2026.