Skip to main content
Print

EFTA01248315: The FBI’s 85 Person Photo Book, Faces Matched to Names

Field Details
Record EFTA01248315 (also stamped EFTA_00073011 through EFTA_00073098)
What it is An 88 page FBI photo index and photo book: a 3 page numbered name list followed by 85 numbered photo pages
Control marking 3501.191-006, marked UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO and CONFIDENTIAL
Related record EFTA01248313, an FBI interview report (FD-302) marked 3501.191-003, in which witness Steve Scully was shown a photo book of 85 persons
Names left visible 16 of the first 24 index rows; all rows from 25 to 90 are blacked out
Photos left visible 13 of 85 (one of them with the face partly blacked out)
Photos fully blacked out 51
Empty photo pages 21 (the person was listed but no photo was included)
Case file FBI New York Epstein investigation, file 50D-NY-3027571 (from the related FD-302)
Research cutoff November 17, 2026

Introduction

This record looks like nothing at first. It is mostly black boxes. But EFTA01248315 is one of the clearest windows we have into how the FBI organized the people around Jeffrey Epstein in 2019. It is a numbered photo book. The first three pages are an index with a number, a name, a date of birth column, a source column and a column marked P. The next 85 pages each carry one number and, in some cases, one photograph.

When you line up the index numbers with the photo page numbers, you can see which face the FBI placed next to which name. That is what this article does, using only the document’s own numbering. We did not use facial recognition, and we did not try to identify anyone whose name or photo was blacked out.

Why it matters: the same control series, 3501.191, appears on an FBI interview report from August 13, 2019. In that interview, agents in St. Thomas showed a man named Steve Scully a photo book of 85 persons associated with the investigation and wrote down what he said about certain pages. This document has exactly 85 photo pages. That strongly suggests it is that photo book, or a version of it. The document itself does not say so, so we treat that link as an inference, not a proven fact.

A word of caution. Being in this photo book does not mean a person did anything wrong. Investigators include staff, witnesses, victims and suspects in books like this so that witnesses can tell them who they saw. The book mixes all of those groups together, and the redactions hide most of them.


Key Takeaways

  • The record is an FBI photo index plus 85 numbered photo pages, marked 3501.191-006.
  • Sixteen names survive in the index, including Ghislaine Maxwell, Jean Luc Brunel, Leslie Wexner and Leslie Groff (spelled that way in the record).
  • Thirteen photos survive. By the document’s own numbering they sit beside the names of Groff, Maxwell, Brunel, Wexner, Merwin Delacruz, Peter Listerman, Juan Alessi, Maria Alessi, Richard Barnett, Rinaldo Rizzo, David Rodgers, Larry Visoski and Karyna Shuliak.
  • Shuliak’s photo is the only visible one with part of the face blacked out. The record does not explain why.
  • Four of the first 24 people have empty photo pages: Daniel Siad, Natividad Ruperez and David Richard Mullen, whose names are printed in red, and the person at row 19, whose name is blacked out.
  • A 2019 FBI interview report in the same 3501.191 series says a witness was shown a photo book of 85 persons. This record has 85 photo pages.
  • The witness, Steve Scully, said photo 12 (Listerman’s number) looked like a man who lived below Miles Alexander’s cottage on the island, and photo 22 (Rodgers’ number) looked like a man who stayed in the guest room. He was not sure in either case.
  • Appearing in this book is not evidence of a crime. Only Maxwell among the visible names has been convicted.

What the Document Is

The index pages

The first index page lists rows 1 through 33. The second and third pages continue to row 90. Every date of birth and every source entry is blacked out. The last column, marked P, has an x on most rows. The rows with no x line up with photo pages that are empty, so P most likely means photo on file. That reading is ours; the record has no legend.

Some row numbers and names are printed in red. In the visible part of the index, the red rows are 13, 17, 21 and several rows from 26 onward. Each red row we could check has an empty photo page. The record does not explain the color.

The photo pages

Pages 4 through 88 each show one number, from 1 to 85, with a photo above it. Our page by page review found 13 visible photos, 51 photos completely blacked out, and 21 pages with a number but no photo. Every page carries the same banner, the marking 3501.191-006, a page count, and two serial numbers (EFTA_000730xx and EFTA0124xxxx), which shows this record was released twice under different numbering.

The 3501.191 series and the Scully interview

The related FBI interview report, EFTA01248313, is marked 3501.191-003. It records that on August 13, 2019, at the FBI resident agency in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, Steve Scully was shown a photo book containing 85 persons associated with this investigation. A second copy of the same report sits at EFTA00091916. The report then lists what he said while viewing certain pages. The page numbers he commented on run as high as 76, which fits an 85 page book.

The two records share a series number and a photo count, but no page in this photo book names Scully or gives a date. So the link is strong but not proven.


Matching Faces to Names

Each photo below is shown exactly as released, with its number. The name beside it comes from the matching row of the FBI index. We did not compare faces or judge whether the FBI chose the right photo for each person. Click any photo number to open that page on Epstein Data.

Number Photo as released Name in FBI index Who they are
Photo 2 FBI photo book page 2 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Leslie Groff Leslie Groff Epstein’s longtime executive assistant (usually spelled Lesley). Named among possible co conspirators in Epstein’s 2008 Florida non prosecution agreement and listed as a co conspirator in an August 2019 FBI document released in 2026. She has never been charged.
Photo 5 FBI photo book page 5 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell Epstein’s longtime companion. Convicted in December 2021 of sex trafficking and related charges and serving a 20 year sentence.
Photo 6 FBI photo book page 6 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Jean Luc Brunel Jean Luc Brunel French modeling agent. Charged in France with rape of minors and found dead in a Paris jail cell in February 2022 before trial.
Photo 10 FBI photo book page 10 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Leslie Wexner Leslie Wexner Founder of L Brands and Victoria’s Secret and Epstein’s biggest known client (see our Wexner arrangement records). Listed as a co conspirator in the August 2019 FBI document; his representative says prosecutors told him in 2019 he was neither a co conspirator nor a target. Never charged.
Photo 11 FBI photo book page 11 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Merwin Delacruz Merwin Delacruz Property manager at Epstein’s Manhattan house at 9 East 71st Street. Told investigators in 2019 he had worked for Epstein about five years.
Photo 12 FBI photo book page 12 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Peter Listerman Peter Listerman A 2016 draft news item that Epstein forwarded calls him a matchmaker and claims he was photographed entering Epstein’s mansion. Named on witness lists in civil cases against Maxwell.
Photo 15 FBI photo book page 15 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Juan Alessi Juan Alessi House manager of Epstein’s Palm Beach home from about 1990 to 2002. Testified for the government at Maxwell’s 2021 trial.
Photo 16 FBI photo book page 16 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Maria Alessi Maria Alessi Juan Alessi’s wife. Listed as a potential witness in Giuffre v. Maxwell.
Photo 18 FBI photo book page 18 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Richard Barnett Richard Barnett Household staff member whose emails from 2011 to 2013 deal with scheduling and logistics at Epstein’s homes.
Photo 20 FBI photo book page 20 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Rinaldo Rizzo Rinaldo Rizzo House manager for Glenn and Eva Dubin. Gave a 2016 deposition in Giuffre v. Maxwell.
Photo 22 FBI photo book page 22 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as David Rodgers David Rodgers Epstein pilot listed as captain on Epstein aircraft and as pilot in flight records.
Photo 23 FBI photo book page 23 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Larry Visoski Larry Visoski Epstein’s chief pilot for decades. Interviewed by the FBI in 2020 and testified at Maxwell’s 2021 trial.
Photo 24 FBI photo book page 24 from EFTA01248315, listed in the index as Shuliak, Karyna Shuliak, Karyna Widely reported as Epstein’s girlfriend in his final years; emails show her working with his household staff. Her photo is the only visible one with the face partly blacked out.

For photo 24 the index writes the name last name first, as Shuliak, Karyna. That formatting is different from every other visible row and may mean the row was added by a different person or at a different time. The record does not say.


The Names With No Photo

Three visible names have empty photo pages, along with the blacked out name at row 19.

Daniel Siad (row 13)

Records in the corpus show a man using the name Daniel Siad writing to Epstein’s jeevacation account by Skype, email and voicemail from 2009 to 2018. In an email from 2011 he describes himself as someone who makes his living scouting and complains about a person named Jean luc. In a 2014 Skype message he tells Jeffrey that a woman is downstairs waiting. These records show contact, not a crime, and Siad has not been charged.

Natividad Ruperez (row 17)

An FBI record says investigators wanted to speak with Natividad Ruperez, who worked as a house maid for Epstein for about 15 years, and that a subpoena for her was not served. A federal grand jury subpoena naming her also appears in the files. A grand jury subpoena is an order to give testimony or records; it is not an accusation.

David Richard Mullen (row 21)

The files include an FBI interview record of a David Mullen described as a chef at the Ritz Carlton in Manalapan, Florida, and 2005 Palm Beach passenger lists that put a David Mullen on flights with Epstein. We have not confirmed that these records refer to the same David Richard Mullen named in the index, so we do not merge them.


What the Witness Said About the Photo Book

The Scully interview report records comments he made while flipping through the 85 person book. The report says he recognized the following persons by making these statements, but most of his comments are about resemblance, not firm identifications. Below are the comments that the report ties directly to a page number, next to the name the index gives for that number.

Page Name in index What Scully said (paraphrased) How solid
2 Leslie Groff Looks like an older version of one of the girls in photos on the wall Page label printed on the same line
12 Peter Listerman Looks like a man who had an apartment below Miles Alexander‘s cottage, which would make him an employee Page label printed on the same line
22 David Rodgers Looks like a man who stayed in the guest room, but not sure it is him Page label printed on the same line
34 Redacted Thinks it is one of the pictures in Epstein’s bedroom Page label printed on the same line
67 Redacted Looks like a brunette on the boat that took him back to St. Thomas Page label printed on the same line
76 Redacted Looks familiar Page label printed on the same line

The report also lists six page numbers (5, 9, 18, 30, 52 and 62) with no comment beside them in the text layer, and six comments with no page number. Those comments include looks like Ghislaine Maxwell, looks like a younger Miles Alexander, and three remarks about women he thought he saw on the island. If the labels and comments line up in order, the Maxwell remark would belong to page 5, which is Maxwell’s number in the index. That fit is suggestive, but we have not confirmed the pairing against the original scan, so we label it unproven.

Two cautions apply. First, a remark that someone looks like a person is not an identification. Second, Scully’s comments about Groff’s and Listerman’s numbers describe resemblance only and do not accuse either of anything.


How This Fits the FBI’s Use of Photo Books

Photo books were a routine tool in the federal Epstein and Maxwell investigation. Interview notes, including one dated August 17, 2021, show agents showing witnesses a smaller, 20 photo book, with answers recorded page by page (see EFTA00159206 and EFTA00157999). One of those books was shown to a witness identified as LV in EFTA00159731.

How these arrays were built became a fight at Maxwell’s trial. Her lawyers asked the judge to bar one accuser from identifying Maxwell, arguing the government used unduly suggestive photo array procedures. A photo array is a set of photos shown to a witness to see whether they pick out a suspect; it is unduly suggestive if it nudges the witness toward one face. The court said it was prepared to deny the motion, finding neither the photos nor the procedure unduly suggestive.

This 85 page book is not the trial array; it covers a much wider circle of staff, associates and others, and it appears to date from August 2019, two years before trial.


Documented Chronology

Date Documented Event Source
About 1990 to 2002 Juan Alessi manages Epstein’s Palm Beach home UPI trial coverage
2002 Email lists David Rodgers as captain of Epstein’s 727 with Larry Visoski EFTA00582017
2009 to 2018 Daniel Siad corresponds with Epstein’s jeevacation account EFTA01217941
2011 to 2013 Richard Barnett handles staff logistics at Epstein’s homes EFTA02136704
June 10, 2016 Rinaldo Rizzo is deposed in Giuffre v. Maxwell EFTA02788171
July 2019 Epstein is arrested; Merwin Delacruz is interviewed as property manager EFTA01245765
August 13, 2019 Steve Scully is shown an 85 person photo book in St. Thomas EFTA01248313
August 15, 2019 FBI document lists Wexner, Groff, Brunel and Maxwell among co conspirators NBC News via Yahoo
November 17, 2020 FBI interviews Larry Visoski by video EFTA00159720
November and December 2021 Visoski and Juan Alessi testify at Maxwell’s trial NBC News
February 2022 Jean Luc Brunel dies in a Paris jail before trial NBC News via Yahoo

Evidence Appearances

Record or ID Date What It Shows Source
EFTA01248315 Not dated (likely 2019) FBI photo index and 85 page photo book, marking 3501.191-006 Epstein Data
EFTA01248313 Interview August 13, 2019 FD-302 of Steve Scully viewing an 85 person photo book, marking 3501.191-003 Epstein Data
EFTA00091916 Same interview Second copy of the Scully FD-302 Epstein Data
EFTA01245765 July 2019 Delacruz interviewed as property manager, about five years with Epstein Epstein Data
EFTA00157603 Not clear in OCR FD-302 of Juan Alessi: Epstein learned of him through Leslie Wexner, a customer of his repair work Epstein Data
EFTA00147254 Not dated Investigators sought Natividad Ruperez, a housemaid for about 15 years; subpoena not served Epstein Data
EFTA00152159 Not dated Grand jury subpoena naming Natividad Ruperez Epstein Data
EFTA00832412 March 7, 2016 Epstein forwards a draft news item describing Peter Listerman as a matchmaker Epstein Data
EFTA02780718 Not dated Civil witness list naming Peter Listerman Epstein Data
EFTA02169576 May 2, 2012 Richard Barnett sends Lesley a photo of a masquerade mask found in a pantry Epstein Data
EFTA00539812 May 28, 2013 Barnett tells Karyna he will be at the house until evening Epstein Data
EFTA02789405 Not dated Court filing describing Rinaldo Rizzo’s deposition testimony about Maxwell Epstein Data
EFTA00582017 February 7, 2002 Pilot details email naming David Rodgers as captain Epstein Data
EFTA00159720 November 17, 2020 FD-302 of Larry Visoski Epstein Data
EFTA00090466 2021 Maxwell defense motion attacking photo array procedures Epstein Data
EFTA02834890 Filed November 15, 2021 Court transcript finding the array not unduly suggestive Epstein Data

Limits, Responses and Open Questions

What the evidence establishes

  • The FBI built a numbered photo book of 85 people tied to its Epstein investigation, with an index of up to 90 rows.
  • By the book’s own numbering, the 13 visible photos sit beside the 13 names listed above.
  • A witness in the same 3501.191 series was shown an 85 person book in August 2019.

What it does not establish

  • It does not show that anyone in the book committed a crime. The book mixes staff, witnesses and others.
  • It does not prove each photo is the right person. We relied on the FBI’s numbering and did not run facial comparison.
  • It does not prove this exact file is the book shown to Scully, though the match in series and count is strong.

Responses

A representative for Leslie Wexner has said an assistant U.S. attorney told his lawyers in 2019 that he was neither a co conspirator nor a target, and that he cooperated with investigators, as NBC News reported. At Maxwell’s trial, Visoski and Juan Alessi said they never saw Epstein or Maxwell act inappropriately with underage girls. Maxwell has maintained her innocence.

Unresolved questions

  • Who are the many people whose names or photos were blacked out, and how many are survivors whose privacy the redactions protect?
  • Why was only Karyna Shuliak’s visible photo partly blacked out?
  • What do the red names and the 3501.191 numbering mean?
  • Which page numbers do Scully’s six unlabeled comments belong to?
  • Were other witnesses shown this same 85 person book?

Conclusion

This photo book is a map of the FBI’s view of Epstein’s world in the weeks after his arrest. The surviving names cut across every part of his life: the woman later convicted with him, a modeling agent charged abroad, his biggest client, his pilots, his house staff in Florida and New York, his assistant and his girlfriend. Most of the book is still hidden, and much of that hiding likely protects survivors, which is right.

What remains is enough to show how wide the circle was and how investigators worked it, one face at a time, in front of witnesses who had been on the island. It is also a reminder that a face in an FBI book is a question, not an answer. The answers are in the interview reports, testimony and records linked above, and in the files still waiting for release.


Questions and Answers

What is EFTA01248315?

It is an 88 page FBI record: a numbered index of names followed by 85 numbered photo pages, marked 3501.191-006. It was released with the Epstein files.

How did you match faces to names?

We matched each photo page number to the same number in the FBI’s own index. We did not use facial recognition.

Does being in the photo book mean someone is guilty?

No. Photo books include witnesses, staff and others so that witnesses can say who they recognize. Only Ghislaine Maxwell among the visible names has been convicted.

Why are so many photos blacked out?

The record does not say. Redactions in the Epstein files often protect survivors and private people. We do not try to identify anyone behind a redaction.

Who is Steve Scully?

He is the witness in an August 13, 2019 FBI interview in St. Thomas who was shown a photo book of 85 persons. The report suggests he spent time on Epstein’s island.

Is Karyna Shuliak’s photo really partly redacted?

Yes. In the released file, a black box covers the middle of the face on photo 24. No other visible photo has this.


Sources

Previous EFTA01246381: James Hatt’s FBI Interview on Epstein, the Maxwells and Telecommunications Dealings
Next EFTA01248577: A Former Maxwell Employee’s FBI Interview About Epstein, Sexual Coercion, and Life Inside the Network
Table of Contents