Skip to main content
Print

Giuffre v. Dershowitz

Snapshot

Giuffre v. Dershowitz, No. 1:19-cv-03377, was a federal civil lawsuit filed by Virginia Giuffre against attorney and former Harvard Law School professor Alan Dershowitz.

Giuffre had alleged since 2014 that Jeffrey Epstein trafficked her to Dershowitz for sexual purposes while she was a teenager. Dershowitz consistently denied meeting Giuffre or having any sexual contact with her.

The 2019 lawsuit was initially about what Dershowitz said while denying the allegation. Giuffre accused him of defamation after he publicly called her a liar, accused her of perjury, and alleged that she and her lawyers participated in an extortion scheme.

Dershowitz moved to dismiss the complaint. On October 16, 2019, Judge Loretta A. Preska denied his motion to dismiss, allowing Giuffre’s defamation claim to proceed. The court expressly stated that it was not deciding whether Giuffre’s underlying sexual abuse allegation was true.

Judge Preska also disqualified Boies Schiller Flexner from representing Giuffre because attorneys at the firm, including David Boies, had become potential witnesses.

Dershowitz filed counterclaims accusing Giuffre of defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Giuffre later added battery and federal Wiretap Act claims to her complaint. The battery claim was dismissed with prejudice by agreement in August 2021.

After more than three years of discovery, the parties dismissed all remaining claims with prejudice in November 2022. No money changed hands.

As part of the resolution, Giuffre said she continued to believe she had been trafficked to Dershowitz for many years but now recognized that she “may have made a mistake” in identifying him.

Dershowitz reiterated that he never had sex with Giuffre. He also said that he had come to believe Giuffre believed her accusation when she made it and withdrew his allegations that David Boies had participated in extortion or suborned perjury.

There was no trial and no judicial finding that Dershowitz sexually abused Giuffre. There was also no court finding that Giuffre deliberately fabricated the allegation.

The complete filing history is available through the CourtListener docket for Giuffre v. Dershowitz.


Case Information

Case: Virginia L. Giuffre v. Alan M. Dershowitz

Case number: 1:19-cv-03377

Court: United States District Court for the Southern District of New York

Judge: Loretta A. Preska

Filed: April 16, 2019

Terminated: November 10, 2022

Initial claim: Defamation

Later claims: Battery and violation of the federal Wiretap Act

Dershowitz’s counterclaims: Defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress

Disposition: All remaining claims dismissed with prejudice by agreement, without costs, legal fees, or monetary payment

Primary docket: CourtListener case record

Reported dismissal opinion: Giuffre v. Dershowitz, 410 F. Supp. 3d 564


The Parties

Virginia Giuffre was a survivor of Epstein and Maxwell’s trafficking operation and one of the most prominent advocates to speak publicly about their crimes.

Giuffre said Ghislaine Maxwell recruited her while she was working at Mar-a-Lago. She alleged that Maxwell and Epstein groomed, abused, controlled, and trafficked her to other people.

Alan Dershowitz was a prominent criminal defense attorney and Harvard Law School professor who became part of Epstein’s legal team during the Palm Beach investigation.

Dershowitz participated in the defense effort that produced Epstein’s controversial 2007 federal nonprosecution agreement. That agreement allowed Epstein to avoid federal prosecution in South Florida while pleading guilty to state offenses.

Dershowitz’s role as Epstein’s attorney is established. It does not establish that he participated in Epstein’s sexual abuse or trafficking.


The Original Allegation

Giuffre’s allegation against Dershowitz first became widely public through filings made in the Crime Victims’ Rights Act litigation against the United States.

On December 30, 2014, Giuffre and another survivor sought to join the lawsuit challenging the government’s handling of Epstein’s nonprosecution agreement.

Giuffre was identified in the filing as Jane Doe 3. The filing alleged that Epstein required her to have sexual relations with Dershowitz on multiple occasions, including in Florida, New York, New Mexico, the United States Virgin Islands, and aboard private aircraft.

The original filing is preserved in the released collection as HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014652. It establishes that the allegation was formally presented in court. It does not establish that the allegation was proven.

The Second Circuit’s later account of the litigation confirms that Giuffre was one of the women who sought to join the Crime Victims’ Rights Act case and that her filing named Dershowitz.


Judge Marra Struck the Allegations

Dershowitz moved to intervene in the Crime Victims’ Rights Act case so he could challenge the accusations and seek sanctions against the lawyers who filed them.

Judge Kenneth A. Marra struck allegations concerning Dershowitz and other third parties from the pleadings in April 2015.

The court concluded that those allegations were not necessary to resolve whether federal prosecutors had violated survivors’ rights when they negotiated Epstein’s agreement.

The striking of the allegations was procedural. Judge Marra did not conduct a trial or determine whether Giuffre’s accusation was true or false.

Because the material had already been reported publicly, removing it from the pleadings did not end the dispute.


Dershowitz’s Denials

Dershowitz denied Giuffre’s allegation immediately and consistently.

He said that he had never met Giuffre, never had sexual contact with her, and never participated in Epstein’s trafficking operation.

Dershowitz also attacked Giuffre’s credibility. He accused her of lying, committing perjury, falsely accusing prominent people, and participating with her attorneys in an effort to extort wealthy targets.

Giuffre maintained that these statements went beyond a simple denial.

A person accused of wrongdoing may publicly deny an allegation. The legal question in the defamation case was whether Dershowitz knowingly made false factual accusations about Giuffre and her attorneys while defending himself.


The 2015 Lawyer Litigation

The original allegation produced defamation litigation before Giuffre personally sued Dershowitz.

Attorneys Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell, who helped present Giuffre’s allegations, sued Dershowitz after he accused them of unethical conduct.

Dershowitz filed counterclaims.

The litigation ended in a settlement announced on April 8, 2016. In the joint statement, Edwards and Cassell acknowledged that it was a mistake to have filed the sexual misconduct accusations and withdrew them; Dershowitz withdrew his accusations that they had acted unethically.

The statement did not say Giuffre’s allegation had been proven false.

It is therefore inaccurate to treat the 2016 settlement either as proof against Dershowitz or as a judicial exoneration.


Giuffre’s 2019 Defamation Complaint

On April 16, 2019, Giuffre filed her own lawsuit against Dershowitz in the Southern District of New York.

The initial complaint contained one count of defamation.

Giuffre alleged that Dershowitz had deliberately made false and malicious statements intended to discredit and intimidate her. The challenged statements included accusations that she was a serial liar, had committed perjury, and had participated in a criminal extortion scheme.

The public federal docket contains the original complaint and its supporting exhibits.

A complaint states a plaintiff’s allegations. Its filing does not establish that the allegations are true.


Dershowitz’s Motion to Dismiss

Dershowitz moved to dismiss the defamation complaint.

He argued that Giuffre’s claim was time-barred under the single-publication rule and that his challenged statements were protected by a qualified self-defense privilege.

Giuffre argued that calling her a criminal, perjurer, extortionist, and deliberate fabricator constituted factual accusations capable of being proven true or false.

On October 16, 2019, Judge Preska denied Dershowitz’s motion to dismiss.

The court concluded that Giuffre had adequately stated a defamation claim and was entitled to proceed into discovery.


What the 2019 Ruling Did Not Decide

The October 2019 ruling did not determine whether Giuffre’s sexual abuse allegation was true.

It also did not determine that Dershowitz’s statements were defamatory.

At the motion to dismiss stage, the court was required to treat Giuffre’s properly pleaded allegations as true for the limited purpose of deciding whether she had stated a legally recognizable claim.

Judge Preska expressly explained that neither the truth of Giuffre’s underlying accusation nor Dershowitz’s denial was before the court.

The ruling established only that Giuffre’s case could proceed.


The Disqualification of Boies Schiller Flexner

Although Judge Preska refused to dismiss Giuffre’s lawsuit, she granted Dershowitz’s motion to disqualify Boies Schiller Flexner as Giuffre’s counsel.

Dershowitz alleged that Giuffre and her attorneys had constructed the accusation against him as part of an extortion effort. That defense made David Boies and other attorneys potential fact witnesses.

The court applied the advocate witness rule, which generally prevents an attorney from serving as both trial counsel and a necessary witness in the same case.

The October 2019 opinion therefore produced a divided result:

  1. Dershowitz failed to obtain dismissal of Giuffre’s claim.
  2. Dershowitz succeeded in removing Boies Schiller Flexner as her counsel.

Giuffre later retained Cooper & Kirk to continue the case.

The disqualification was not a finding that Boies participated in extortion or caused Giuffre to lie.


The Recorded Call With David Boies

A secretly recorded telephone conversation between Dershowitz and David Boies became an important part of the litigation.

Dershowitz argued that the recording supported his position that Boies had doubts about Giuffre’s identification of him.

Boies disputed Dershowitz’s interpretation. He said the conversation involved a hypothetical discussion and denied admitting that Giuffre had fabricated the accusation.

Judge Preska ordered Dershowitz to produce the microcassette so it could be examined by a digital forensic firm. The federal docket records the October and December 2019 orders governing the tape.

The recording never received a final interpretation from a jury.


The Amended Complaint

In April 2020, Giuffre filed an expanded complaint.

The amended complaint retained the defamation claim and added:

  1. A battery claim based on the alleged sexual contact.
  2. A federal Wiretap Act claim connected to the recorded conversation between Dershowitz and Boies.

The complete April 2020 amended complaint contains the expanded allegations and three legal counts.

A proposed version of the amended complaint appears in the released Epstein collection as EFTA00092647.

Giuffre alleged that the recording involved communications made by Boies on her behalf and that its interception, use, and disclosure violated federal law.

Dershowitz acknowledged recording the conversation but disputed that he had violated the Wiretap Act.


Evidence Submitted With the Amended Complaint

The expanded complaint cited records and witness accounts intended to show that Dershowitz had access to Epstein’s residences and social network.

The filing referenced accounts from Maria Farmer, Sarah Ransome, and former Epstein household employee Juan Alessi.

Those accounts were relevant to the broader question of whether Dershowitz visited Epstein’s properties and whether his description of his relationship with Epstein was accurate.

Evidence that Dershowitz visited an Epstein residence would not, by itself, prove that he had sexual contact with Giuffre.

The proposed amended complaint and its supporting records are preserved across EFTA00092647 and related pages in the Epstein Data full text corpus.


Dershowitz’s Counterclaims

Dershowitz responded with counterclaims against Giuffre.

He accused her of defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress.

Dershowitz alleged that Giuffre’s accusation was false and that she and her lawyers had used it as part of an effort to obtain money from wealthy people connected with Epstein.

He also alleged that Giuffre’s statements caused severe reputational and emotional harm.

Giuffre denied participating in an extortion scheme and continued to maintain her allegation against Dershowitz during the litigation.

The counterclaims converted the case into a dispute in which each party alleged that the other had made damaging false statements.


The Attempt to Disqualify Giuffre’s Replacement Lawyers

After Boies Schiller Flexner was removed, Cooper & Kirk became Giuffre’s counsel.

Dershowitz later asked Judge Preska to disqualify Cooper & Kirk because the firm had received confidential discovery from the separate Giuffre v. Maxwell litigation.

On January 28, 2021, Judge Preska denied the second disqualification motion.

The court found that removing Giuffre’s lawyers for a second time was not justified. Cooper & Kirk therefore remained in the case.

The opinion also documents the unusual overlap between the Dershowitz litigation and the sealed discovery generated in Giuffre’s earlier case against Maxwell.


The Maxwell Records

Dershowitz sought access to discovery from Giuffre v. Maxwell, arguing that the materials could contain evidence relevant to Giuffre’s credibility and his defense.

Much of that discovery remained protected by a confidentiality order.

Judge Preska allowed limited access to certain materials but did not authorize unrestricted use of the complete Maxwell discovery record.

The dispute mattered because Giuffre v. Maxwell contained depositions, emails, witness statements, and other records concerning Giuffre’s allegations about Epstein, Maxwell, Dershowitz, Prince Andrew, and additional people.

Dershowitz also intervened in the Maxwell litigation and supported public access to sealed records.

The CourtListener docket for Giuffre v. Maxwell preserves the extensive unsealing litigation.


Discovery Into Other Accusations

Dershowitz sought discovery concerning Giuffre’s allegations against other men associated with Epstein.

Judge Preska limited that effort.

In a November 2021 discovery order, the court described the central factual question as whether Giuffre and Dershowitz had intimate contact.

The court found that broad discovery into every other person Giuffre had accused would impose an extraordinary burden and move the litigation away from its central issue.

Judge Preska therefore granted Giuffre a protective order covering most allegations involving other people.

That order did not declare those other allegations true or false. It limited discovery to what the judge considered proportionate and relevant.


The Leslie Wexner Deposition Dispute

Dershowitz alleged that Giuffre and her lawyers had developed an extortion strategy directed at billionaire Leslie Wexner, Epstein’s former client and patron.

Wexner’s attorneys denied that Giuffre or her lawyers had made a payment demand or sought other consideration from him.

Judge Preska nevertheless allowed Dershowitz to obtain Wexner’s deposition because the alleged extortion theory had become part of the claims and defenses.

The November 2021 order granted Dershowitz’s motion to compel the deposition.

An order permitting a deposition is not a finding that an extortion scheme existed.


The Miami Herald’s Intervention

The Miami Herald sought to intervene for the limited purpose of requesting access to sealed court records.

Judge Preska allowed the newspaper to intervene and ordered several categories of documents unsealed with narrow redactions.

The affected materials included briefing concerning Giuffre’s lawyers, the Wexner deposition dispute, and a request by Dershowitz to provide information to federal prosecutors.

The court recognized a public interest in access to judicial records while preserving portions covered by the Maxwell protective order.

The ruling is another reason the case matters beyond the dispute between Giuffre and Dershowitz. It contributed to the continuing public release of Epstein related court materials.


The Battery Claim Was Dismissed

On August 16, 2021, Judge Preska approved the stipulation dismissing the battery count with prejudice.

The stipulation specified that neither side would receive costs or legal fees concerning that claim.

The partial dismissal appears in the federal docket. A copy is also available through the DocumentCloud battery claim stipulation.

A dismissal with prejudice prevents the same claim from ordinarily being filed again.

The stipulation did not contain a judicial finding about whether the alleged sexual contact occurred.

The defamation litigation and Dershowitz’s counterclaims continued.


The Case Moved Toward Depositions and Trial

By 2022, the case had produced hundreds of docket entries and years of contentious discovery.

The court addressed document production, confidential Maxwell materials, Harvard email records, recordings, attorney communications, proposed expert evidence, and depositions.

Dershowitz was scheduled for a deposition in September 2022. The court’s September 1 order permitted Giuffre’s attorneys to seek emergency assistance if disputes arose during the questioning.

The case was moving toward a trial schedule when the parties negotiated a joint resolution.


The November 2022 Resolution

In November 2022, Giuffre, Dershowitz, and David Boies agreed to end all remaining litigation.

The parties stated that the resolution involved no payment of money or other consideration.

Giuffre and Dershowitz dismissed their claims with prejudice, waived appeal rights, and agreed that neither side would recover costs or legal fees.

The final federal docket entries record the dismissal. The resolution was also documented by Reuters and Courthouse News Service.

The case terminated on November 10, 2022.


Giuffre’s Final Statement

Giuffre said that she had long believed Epstein trafficked her to Dershowitz.

She explained that she had been young and living in a stressful and traumatic environment. She then stated that she recognized she “may have made a mistake” in identifying Dershowitz.

The wording matters.

Giuffre did not say that she had knowingly lied. She did not say her account of being trafficked by Epstein was false. She acknowledged the possibility that she had misidentified Dershowitz as one of the men involved.

Her statement was not testimony produced through a verdict. It was part of a negotiated resolution ending years of litigation.


Dershowitz’s Final Statement

Dershowitz repeated his position that he had never had sex with Giuffre.

He also changed an important part of his public position.

Dershowitz said that he had come to believe Giuffre believed her accusation when she made it. He commended her for acknowledging that she may have been mistaken and recognized that she had suffered at Epstein’s hands.

Dershowitz also withdrew his allegations that David Boies had engaged in an extortion plot or suborned perjury.

Boies accepted the statements and agreed that the litigation should end.

The complete statements were published together in David Lat’s account of the resolution.


What the Resolution Meant

The resolution gave Dershowitz the public acknowledgement he had sought that Giuffre may have misidentified him.

It also removed Giuffre from years of litigation in which her trafficking history, memory, credibility, medical records, attorney communications, and allegations against other people were being examined.

No money changed hands.

Dershowitz did not obtain a trial verdict declaring Giuffre’s accusation false. Giuffre did not obtain a verdict finding that Dershowitz defamed or abused her.

Dershowitz withdrew his allegation that Giuffre’s lawyer had participated in extortion and perjury. He also said he believed Giuffre had believed her accusation.

The resolution therefore cannot accurately be reduced to either “Dershowitz was found guilty” or “Giuffre admitted she lied.”

Neither statement reflects the actual record.


The 2024 Unsealing

Additional records from Giuffre v. Maxwell were unsealed in January 2024.

Those records included older deposition testimony in which Giuffre described her allegations against Dershowitz in greater detail.

The release did not represent a new accusation. It made earlier testimony publicly accessible.

The Associated Press review of the unsealed records emphasized that much of the information had already been known for years.

The unsealing did not undo Giuffre’s 2022 statement that she may have made a mistake. It also did not transform the earlier testimony into an adjudicated finding.

Dershowitz continued to deny the allegations and said the complete record supported his innocence.


Released Epstein Records Concerning the Case

The later Epstein document releases contain copies of court filings, transcripts, and reporting connected with the Dershowitz litigation.

EFTA00092647 contains the proposed expanded complaint setting out Giuffre’s defamation, battery, and Wiretap Act theories. It documents what Giuffre sought to allege. It does not prove those allegations.

EFTA00027039 contains Giuffre’s memorandum supporting her request to amend the complaint. It explains why she sought to add the battery and recording claims.

EFTA00092688 contains a December 2019 court conference transcript discussing discovery, the recorded call, the proposed amendment, and the need to narrow the case.

EFTA00026703 contains reporting concerning the dispute over the disqualification of Boies Schiller Flexner. It is a news record inside the released corpus, not an independent judicial finding.

EFTA00030155 contains additional reporting about the disqualification and conflict arguments.

The Epstein Data search results for case number 19-cv-03377 identify additional pages from the litigation.

These materials demonstrate that the Justice Department’s released corpus contains parts of the civil case record. Their inclusion does not mean the Department endorsed either party’s allegations.


What the Evidence Establishes

The available evidence establishes that:

  1. Giuffre formally accused Dershowitz in a 2014 court filing.
  2. Giuffre alleged that Epstein trafficked her to Dershowitz on multiple occasions.
  3. Dershowitz consistently denied meeting Giuffre or having sexual contact with her.
  4. Dershowitz served on Epstein’s legal defense team.
  5. Dershowitz participated in the defense effort surrounding Epstein’s nonprosecution agreement.
  6. Judge Marra struck the allegations from the Crime Victims’ Rights Act pleadings because they were unnecessary to that case.
  7. The striking order did not determine whether the allegations were true.
  8. Giuffre sued Dershowitz for defamation in April 2019.
  9. Judge Preska denied Dershowitz’s motion to dismiss the defamation claim.
  10. The denial of dismissal was not a finding that the allegations were true.
  11. Boies Schiller Flexner was disqualified because its attorneys had become potential witnesses.
  12. Cooper & Kirk remained as Giuffre’s replacement counsel after Dershowitz’s second disqualification motion failed.
  13. Dershowitz filed counterclaims for defamation and emotional distress.
  14. Giuffre added battery and Wiretap Act claims.
  15. The battery claim was dismissed with prejudice in August 2021.
  16. The court limited discovery into Giuffre’s allegations against other men.
  17. The court allowed discovery involving Leslie Wexner.
  18. The Miami Herald successfully intervened to seek access to judicial records.
  19. All remaining litigation ended without a monetary payment.
  20. Giuffre said she may have made a mistake in identifying Dershowitz.
  21. Dershowitz withdrew his allegations that David Boies participated in extortion or suborned perjury.
  22. No court found that Giuffre knowingly lied.
  23. No court found Dershowitz liable for sexual abuse.

What the Evidence Does Not Establish

The available evidence does not establish that:

  1. Dershowitz was convicted of an Epstein related offense.
  2. A jury found that Dershowitz sexually abused Giuffre.
  3. Judge Preska’s refusal to dismiss the case was a finding against Dershowitz on the facts.
  4. Judge Marra’s striking order proved that Giuffre’s allegation was false.
  5. Giuffre admitted that she deliberately fabricated the allegation.
  6. Giuffre’s statement that she may have made a mistake was a trial verdict.
  7. The 2022 resolution involved a payment to Giuffre or Dershowitz.
  8. The disqualification of Boies Schiller established an extortion scheme.
  9. Dershowitz’s withdrawal of his allegations against Boies proved every allegation in Giuffre’s complaint.
  10. Evidence that Dershowitz visited Epstein’s properties proves sexual contact with Giuffre.
  11. Every document included in the Epstein release represents verified evidence.
  12. The 2024 unsealing created new judicial findings.

These limitations are necessary for an accurate and fair account.


Investigative Assessment

Giuffre v. Dershowitz ended with a significant change in Giuffre’s position but without a factual verdict.

Giuffre did not continue to assert an unqualified identification of Dershowitz. In her statement, she described being young and living in a stressful and traumatic environment, then acknowledged that she may have made a mistake in identifying him.

That acknowledgement is important and should be stated clearly.

It is equally important not to rewrite her statement as an admission of deliberate deception. Dershowitz ultimately said he believed Giuffre believed the allegation when she made it.

The litigation established that Dershowitz’s attacks on Giuffre were legally sufficient to support a defamation case. It did not establish that those statements were ultimately defamatory.

The court record also establishes that Dershowitz had a documented professional and personal association with Epstein. That relationship justified investigation but did not prove Giuffre’s original identification.

The most accurate classification is:

A mutually dismissed defamation dispute in which Giuffre acknowledged possible mistaken identification, Dershowitz maintained his denial, both sides withdrew claims, and no court adjudicated the underlying sexual abuse allegation.


Key Takeaways

  1. Giuffre accused Dershowitz of being one of the men to whom Epstein trafficked her.
  2. Dershowitz consistently denied ever having sex with or meeting Giuffre.
  3. Giuffre’s 2019 lawsuit focused primarily on Dershowitz’s public attacks against her.
  4. Dershowitz’s motion to dismiss the defamation claim failed.
  5. The ruling allowed discovery but did not determine who was telling the truth.
  6. Giuffre’s original lawyers were disqualified because they had become potential witnesses.
  7. Dershowitz counterclaimed and accused Giuffre and her lawyers of an extortion scheme.
  8. The litigation expanded to include battery and Wiretap Act claims.
  9. Giuffre’s battery claim was dismissed with prejudice before the final resolution.
  10. No money changed hands when the remaining cases ended.
  11. Giuffre said she may have made a mistake in identifying Dershowitz.
  12. Dershowitz said he believed Giuffre believed her accusation when she made it.
  13. Dershowitz withdrew his accusations of extortion and suborned perjury against David Boies.
  14. There was no trial, liability ruling, or judicial exoneration.
  15. The proper historical record must include both Giuffre’s possible misidentification and the absence of any finding that she deliberately lied.

Related EpsteinWiki Articles

  1. Virginia Roberts Giuffre
  2. Alan Dershowitz
  3. Jeffrey Epstein
  4. Ghislaine Maxwell
  5. Bradley Edwards v. Alan Dershowitz
  6. Giuffre v. Maxwell
  7. Giuffre v. Prince Andrew
  8. 2007 Nonprosecution Agreement
  9. Epstein v. United States Government NPA Due Process Litigation
  10. Leslie Wexner
  11. Maria Farmer
  12. Sarah Ransome
  13. How to Read an Epstein Document

Primary Court Records

  1. Complete CourtListener docket for Giuffre v. Dershowitz contains the complaint, counterclaims, discovery disputes, motions, orders, and dismissal filings.
  2. Judge Preska’s October 2019 opinion denied Dershowitz’s motion to dismiss and disqualified Boies Schiller Flexner.
  3. Giuffre’s April 2020 amended complaint contains the defamation, battery, and Wiretap Act claims.
  4. Judge Preska’s January 2021 opinion denied Dershowitz’s effort to disqualify Cooper & Kirk.
  5. Judge Preska’s November 2021 order addressed amendment, discovery into other allegations, the Wexner deposition, and the Miami Herald’s unsealing request.
  6. The battery claim dismissal stipulation documents the dismissal of Count II with prejudice.
  7. The Justia federal docket record provides a searchable chronology of major filings and orders.
  8. The Second Circuit opinion discussing the original allegations explains how the accusations entered the Crime Victims’ Rights Act litigation.
  9. CourtListener’s Giuffre v. Maxwell docket contains the related sealed record and unsealing litigation.

Epstein Data Evidence Sources

  1. HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014652 contains the Crime Victims’ Rights Act material naming Dershowitz. It documents the allegation, not its truth.
  2. EFTA00092647 contains the proposed amended complaint with Giuffre’s expanded allegations.
  3. EFTA00027039 contains Giuffre’s memorandum supporting amendment of the complaint.
  4. EFTA00092688 contains a court conference transcript concerning discovery, the recording, and the proposed expanded claims.
  5. EFTA00027034 contains the formal motion seeking leave to amend.
  6. EFTA00027037 contains the supporting declaration filed with the amendment request.
  7. EFTA00026703 preserves reporting concerning the attorney disqualification dispute.
  8. EFTA00030155 contains additional reporting on the conflict and disqualification arguments.
  9. The Epstein Data full text search for case number 19-cv-03377 identifies additional released pages connected with the litigation.
  10. The Epstein Data evidence map identifies FBI indexed evidence categories associated with Dershowitz and the November 2022 resolution.

External Sources

  1. Reuters report on the November 2022 dismissal
  2. Courthouse News report on the joint resolution
  3. Complete public statements from Giuffre, Dershowitz, and Boies
  4. Associated Press review of the 2024 unsealed records
  5. Washington Post account of the recorded Boies conversation and related litigation
  6. First Amendment Watch account of the Boies and Dershowitz litigation

Previous Flight Log FOIA Cases and Jeffrey Epstein
Next Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 15-cv-7433 (S.D.N.Y. 2015)
Table of Contents