Skip to main content
Print

Sex Toys and Sexual Reading Materials in the Epstein Files: Inventory, Purchases and Evidence Limits

Overview

The Epstein files contain a much more specific record of sexual objects and reading material than the generic phrase “sex toys” suggests. A private investigator’s inventory names individual products removed from Epstein’s Palm Beach home in October 2005. A separate FBI log records devices, restraints, costumes, and other objects collected in New York in July 2019. An Amazon invoice identifies three books shipped to Epstein, while released photographs show additional items and readable titles.

The most revealing distinction is how these objects entered the record. A product removed by a privately retained investigator, an object collected by the FBI, and an image transmitted by email are different forms of evidence. This report preserves those distinctions and links individual findings to document identifiers, pages, dates, and locations wherever the records supply them.

The photographic evidence also fills gaps left by text searches. It identifies Erotica Universalis and Complete Shibari, Volume 1: Land, confirms several packaged products, and shows a New York evidence display with a harness-mounted dildo, restraints, condoms, and medical costume accessories. Other photographs depict retail displays or commercial product images whose presence in the files does not establish purchase or possession.

These materials matter where they corroborate witness accounts, household routines, collection records, or the chronology of the investigation. Consensual adult sexual products and literature are not inherently evidence of abuse. A title, object, or photograph cannot by itself establish who used it, whether a particular act occurred, or the age of anyone depicted in commercial media.

Documented finding Scope
11 named boxed-product entries October 2005 private inventory; not eleven shipping or storage cartons.
3 Brookstone massagers Explicit quantity in that same inventory.
4 butt plugs Combined count across receipts 10 and 11 in the July 2019 New York log.
8 distinct book or guide titles Titles supported by a purchase record, private inventory, or reviewed photograph; excludes magazines, excerpts, and recommendations.
No defensible global object total Packages, components, repeat photographs, and duplicate productions overlap.

Audit scope: 17,288 matching text pages, 763 image-description entries, and 106 finding rows in the master ledger. Rows may group objects, transactions, titles or references and are not a physical-object total. The method below describes the complete matched-source register embedded in the supplied research PDF. The CSV itself is not embedded in this web draft.

Master Inventory

This ledger groups the strongest located evidence for each item or record category. Quantities refer to the cited event. Similar names or appearances are not treated as proof that two records show the same physical object.

Finding Item or title Event / location Strongest record Evidence status Related evidence / duplicate caution
F001 SuperStrap
Box label; described as an alternative to bed posts.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F002 Furry Cuffs
Box with fur-covered handcuffs.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F003 Twin Torpedos
Box with separate vibrating controls. Inventory spelling retained.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory Twin Torpedos packaging EFTA00003948 · page 2; police narrative EFTA00028568 · page 2. Same physical set not established.
F004 Cyber Suck
Box label describing an oral stimulator.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F005 Mini Lovers Kit
Box listing a mini vibrator and four accessory sleeves; component names are preserved in the source inventory.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F006 Lacey Double Trouble
Box identified as a masturbator.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F007 The Vibrating Facilitator
Box label; no verified model specifications in this record.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F008 Eroscillator 2
Box label.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F009 Pocket Rocket
Box identified as a mini massager.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory “Rock Pocket” gift description in EFTA00162520 · page 9 is a separate reported identification.
F010 Japanese Culture Pearl Tickler Ring
Name preserved as written in the inventory; brand spelling is unconfirmed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F011 The Ladybug
Box identified as a personal vibrator.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F012 Brookstone massagers
Three listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F013 Purple rubber/silicone dildo
One listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F014 Rubber/silicone artificial vagina
One listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F015 Red leather strap/whip
One listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F016 Pewter-colored electric dildo with attachments
One listed; number of attachments unspecified.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F017 Silver-colored chain with clip
One listed; precise use not established.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F018 Black silk thongs
Two listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F019 White silk thong
One listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F020 Woman’s black hose
One listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F021 Black underwear
One listed.
Palm Beach; removed October 7, 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 4 Private removal inventory No additional match established
F022 SM 101: A Realistic Introduction Palm Beach; 2005 EFTA00007606 · page 2 Invoice or private inventory Jay Wiseman; September 4, 2005 Amazon order.
F023 SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for Erotic Servitude Palm Beach; 2005 EFTA00007606 · page 2 Invoice or private inventory Guy Baldwin; same Amazon order.
F024 Training With Miss Abernathy Palm Beach; 2005 EFTA00007606 · page 2 Invoice or private inventory Christina Abernathy; also inventoried in EFTA01733753 · page 2. Copy count unresolved.
F025 The Compleat Slave Palm Beach; 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Invoice or private inventory Jack Rinella; bibliographic author corroborated by publisher.
F026 Sexy New York City 2000 Palm Beach; 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Invoice or private inventory Annual erotica guide; author not established.
F027 Purely 18; Only 18; Barely Legal Palm Beach; 2005 EFTA01733753 · page 2 Invoice or private inventory Three magazine entries; issue details below.
F028 Green massage table
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room P, middle of room
EFTA01301570 · page 3 FBI collection log Receipt 7
F029 Copper handcuffs and whip
1 set; component count not expanded
New York; July 7, 2019
Room P, display-case shelf
EFTA01301570 · page 3 FBI collection log Receipt 8
F030 Framed nude photographs
4
New York; July 7, 2019
Room P, massage-room walls
EFTA01301570 · page 3 FBI collection log Receipt 9
F031 Butt plug
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, third drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 3 FBI collection log Receipt 10
F032 Vibrator
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F033 Butt plugs
3
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F034 Cuffs
1 set
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F035 Dildo
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F036 Leash
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F037 Condoms
1 box; unit count unknown
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F038 Nurse cap and stethoscope
1 each
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 11 / evidence 1B15: EFTA00173107; display photograph EFTA01648794
F039 Costumes and wig
5 costumes; 1 wig
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Q, fifth drawer left of sink
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 12
F040 Photos of female buttocks
2
New York; July 7, 2019
Room V, nightstand drawer
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 13
F041 Blue female-torso bust
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room V, floor left of glass table
EFTA01301570 · page 4 FBI collection log Receipt 14
F042 Brown breast sculpture
1
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Z, shelf above bathtub
EFTA01301570 · page 6 FBI collection log Receipt 20
F043 White female-torso busts
2
New York; July 7, 2019
Room Z, closet top shelf
EFTA01301570 · page 6 FBI collection log Receipt 21
F044 Harness-mounted pink/purple dildo Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA00000508 Reviewed residence photograph Evidence display EFTA01648794 shows a similar harness/device; continuity is not independently proven.
F045 Lather-Up Pussy novelty soap Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA00003858 · page 4 Reviewed packaging photograph Anatomical soap also described in police narrative EFTA00028568 · page 2
F046 Sexy Loving Soap: anatomical novelty pair Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA00004049 · page 2 Reviewed packaging photograph Packaging photograph overlaps the item-23 product description in EFTA02728436, page 39. Do not count as an additional soap lot.
F047 Erotica Universalis Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA00000518 Reviewed book-cover photograph Gilles Néret; exhibit notes EFTA00159145
F048 Complete Shibari, Volume 1: Land Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Douglas Kent; author/title checked against author’s catalog.
F049 Extreme Restraints Catalog Sampler Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Readable catalog title; no transaction inferred.
F050 Packaged Pussy Pump, tubing, and gauge Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Size Matters branding visible. Exact purchased configuration unknown.
F051 Coiled black rope Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Length/material unknown.
F052 Metal screw-adjusted U-shaped accessory Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Exact model and function not established.
F053 Chain-linked metal clip/clamp-like accessories Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Precise component count and intended placement not independently identified.
F054 Pink linked bulb-shaped accessory Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 Reviewed estate photograph Exact model/function not established.
F055 Textured black glove Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037638 Reviewed estate photograph Material cannot be confirmed from appearance alone.
F056 Jawbreaker Gag instruction sheet and black strap Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037629 Reviewed estate photograph Incoming email image EFTA01145320 dated February 10, 2013; likely related image/text, not a second proven object.
F057 Trump-themed novelty condom packets Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_083462 Reviewed estate photograph A photographed retail display; no purchase or ownership inferred.
F058 Metal plug with green jewel-like base Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA01610483 Reviewed product photograph Commercial-looking image; provenance does not establish seizure or ownership.
F059 Blue two-armed handheld sexual device Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA01599714 Reviewed photograph Anatomical diagram nearby; exact model and purchaser unknown.
F060 Retail display of black sexual devices and packaged sheath Photographic record; date/location unspecified unless separately documented EFTA01600213 Reviewed shop photograph No purchase or household possession established.
F061 The Joy of Sex Textual or testimonial record EFTA00981369; EFTA01789697 Reported, recommended, or digitally present January 2014 recommendation/download instruction.
F062 The S&M Feminist: Best of Clarisse Thorn Textual or testimonial record HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018438 Reported, recommended, or digitally present Digital text in release; original custodian unresolved.
F063 Massage For Dummies: The Lover’s Touch chapter Textual or testimonial record EFTA00008320 · page 12 Reported, recommended, or digitally present Scanned chapter of Massage For Dummies; title confirmed on page 55 and authors on page 88.
F064 Lolita Textual or testimonial record EFTA01618557 · page 3 Reported, recommended, or digitally present Title discussed in message export; physical copy not established.
F065 Hidden Flower Bondage Gear Ribbon Textual or testimonial record EFTA02315560; EFTA02316425 Reported, recommended, or digitally present October 2012 product link/reply.
F066 Wet for Her finger-extender product Textual or testimonial record EFTA01014643 Reported, recommended, or digitally present December 2018 incoming product recommendation.
F067 Shibari webpage Textual or testimonial record EFTA00571251 Reported, recommended, or digitally present January 2017 outgoing link; distinct from the photographed book.
F068 Vibrator review article Textual or testimonial record EFTA02585185 Reported, recommended, or digitally present October 2017 link; no product purchase established.
F069 More vibrators Textual or testimonial record EFTA00510490 · page 1 Reported, recommended, or digitally present Household task in calendar export; completion and quantity unknown.
F070 Black vinyl costume and adult videos Textual or testimonial record EFTA00157613 · page 7 Reported, recommended, or digitally present Witness description of Maxwell’s bathroom basket; no new seizure inferred.
F071 Rock Pocket vibrator birthday gift Textual or testimonial record EFTA00162520 · page 9 Reported, recommended, or digitally present FBI interview description; name/model not normalized to Pocket Rocket.
F072 Twin Torpedos: four invoiced units March 3, 2005; Palm Beach shipping address EFTA00068131, page 2 Merchant invoice: 4 × $24.95 One transaction; duplicates EFTA01246899 and EFTA01719824. Not four additional recovered sets.
F073 BARE lubricant: free gift March 3, 2005; same shipment EFTA00068131, page 2 Invoice: one free gift Invoice does not establish subsequent use or recovery.
F074 Twin Torpedos: two boxed sets Palm Beach police evidence, item 24 EFTA00244471, page 1; EFTA02728436, page 39 Photograph and collection description Distinct evidence event from the four-unit invoice and the privately removed box.
F075 Mini Peni-Soaps Palm Beach; item 23 EFTA02728436, page 39 Opened novelty-soap package California Exotic Novelties; one of two soaps described as missing.
F076 Sexy Loving Soap Palm Beach; item 23 EFTA02728436, page 39 Unopened novelty-soap package Pipedream Products. This resolves the function of the packaged product shown elsewhere.
F077 Soap on a Rope Lather-Up Pussy Palm Beach; item 23 EFTA02728436, page 39 Unopened novelty-soap package California Exotic Novelties; overlaps earlier photographed packaging.
F078 Two penis-shaped soaps Palm Beach; item 25 EFTA02728436, page 39 One small and one large soap with rope Collection lots and packages cannot be converted into a single five-bar total.
F079 Peach lubricant, 4 oz Palm Beach; item 28 EFTA02728436, page 39; EFTA00244476, page 1 Unopened bottle and evidence photograph Inventory calls it JOY JELLY; photographed label reads Joy Elly / Juicy Peach. One evidence item.
F080 Ten NOVELTY line items Adult Video Warehouse; July 23, 2005 EFTA01332988, page 1 Receipt: $200.90 subtotal; $213.96 total Generic descriptions do not identify ten specific models or prove ten additional items.
F081 Strap-on dildo receipt described by counsel February 17, 2006 letter; Guys and Dolls EFTA01246275, page 1 Counsel says enclosed receipt belonged to an adult using their own card Counsel assertion; purchaser identity withheld here; not a judicial finding or Epstein purchase finding.
F082 Massage For Dummies FBI item 1B10; acquired August 7, 2007 EFTA01657859, page 10; EFTA01699302, page 26 Physical book in evidence General massage guide with sensual content; interview record separately describes a gifted copy. Identity of copies not established.
F083 Healing Love through the Tao: Cultivating Female Sexual Energy Kindle order, July 20, 2012 EFTA00529239, page 1 Order addressed to Karina; billing names Karyna Shuliak; $9.99 Do not attribute the purchase to Epstein. Digital order is not a recovered physical book.
F084 Rationale of the Dirty Joke: An Analysis of Sexual Humor Kindle gift notice, May 22, 2015 EFTA00687957, page 1 Gift from Jackie Martling to Jeffrey Epstein Notice permits claiming or exchanging; redemption and reading are unproved.
F085 Two Gershon Legman books, second title unspecified May 22, 2015 correspondence EFTA02500664, page 1 Martling says he mailed two hard copies Delivery unproved. Do not manufacture a second title or add a second copy from the Kindle notice.
F086 Story of O; The Second Sex; Lolita February 27, 2012 correspondence EFTA01842864, page 1 Recommendations and reported reading First two recommended by Epstein; correspondent reports reading Story of O and Lolita. No physical recovery established.
F087 “shades of grey” series August 2012 correspondence EFTA01885007, page 1 First and second books recommended; third reportedly being read No completed order or physical recovery in this thread.
F088 Urban Tantra: Sacred Sex for the Twenty-First Century Incoming recommendation, December 8, 2017 EFTA02551241, page 1 Barbara Carrellas title and workshop reference Recommendation is not purchase or ownership.
F089 “dr. tatyana’s sex advice for all creation” November 2013 book-list correspondence EFTA00529347, page 1 Source wording for Dr. Tatiana’s Sex Advice to All Creation Karyna says she managed to get the first list item; no edition or invoice supplied.
F090 Evolution and Human Sexual Behavior Academic introduction, December 7, 2012 EFTA00949840, page 1 Coauthored book mentioned by Justin Garcia Academic reference; no purchase, possession, abuse, or author involvement established.
F091 In The Garden: The Memoirs of the Garden Keeper Vendor literature accompanying Eve’s Garden records EFTA01719824, page 4; EFTA01719824, page 5 Promotional chapter; Dell Williams and Lynn Vannucci An excerpt in the records does not prove ownership of the completed book.
F092 Hot Surrender, Charlotte Lamb Commercial cover image EFTA01240502, page 1 Reviewed Harlequin Treasury cover No physical recovery, purchase, or reader established.
F093 Untitled “Dubai book” Joi Ito correspondence, October 2013 EFTA01956909, page 1 Book thanked for; described as having “lots of sex” Title not supplied; no speculative identification.
F094 Black plug with blue gem-like base Commercial-style product photograph EFTA01611163, page 1 Original image reviewed No established purchase or household provenance; overlap with other product images possible.
F095 Metal plug with striped tail-like attachment Commercial-style product photograph EFTA01611512, page 1 Original image reviewed Material of the tail cannot be established from appearance.
F096 Jeweled plugs, tail attachments and elongated black device Composite product image EFTA01611574, page 1 Original image reviewed A composite image is not a count of recovered objects.
F097 Broken purple object; tentative Cyclone / jelly anal-wand identification April 1, 2005; Palm Beach trash collection EFTA00022654, page 7; EFTA00022654, page 8; EFTA01333510, page 1 Police narrative reports recovery, photograph, packaging and retention One fragment. Shop owner supplied a qualified opinion from photographs; Cyclone webpage was comparison material. No forensic confirmation, proven use or exact model established.
F098 Magic Wand Personal Massager, white, 110V Order placed August 24, 2013; shipment notice August 27; St. Thomas destination EFTA02298809, page 7; EFTA02298809, page 8; EFTA02298809, page 9; EFTA02331062, page 2 Amazon order and shipping notice addressed to Karyna Shuliak One $57.99 device; $11.17 shipping; $69.16 total. Same order identifier in both records. No delivery to Little Saint James or Epstein purchaser established.
F099 Magic Wand, beginner butt plug, and lubricant June 15–17, 2019 message exports EFTA01620616, page 1; EFTA01620616, page 3; EFTA01620628, page 2; EFTA01620628, page 3 Instructions and correspondent’s reported purchase Not a merchant receipt, seizure, established location, or additional unit count. Forensic export also labels a corresponding message as Self: EFTA01214099, page 14.
F100 Justine and other de Sade reading references August 29, 2011 email and January 20, 2017 Skype export EFTA01857287, page 1; EFTA01622719, page 1; EFTA01622719, page 2; EFTA01622719, page 3 Recommendations and discussion of Story of O / Fifty Shades The phrase “justine in the bedroom” is ambiguous. It is not silently corrected to another de Sade title or counted as a recovered book.
F101 Sex Movies magazine Undated released photograph EFTA01230671, page 1 Readable cover title in an original image Issue/date, ownership and circumstances unestablished. No identification of the person or inference about their age or conduct.
F102 Xcitement magazine material Scanned adult-industry publication pages EFTA01720322, page 5; EFTA01720322, page 69; EFTA01720503, page 6 Publication scans in the released records Masthead, listings and advertisements establish publication content; physical recovery, reader, issue count and acquisition remain unestablished.
F103 Playboy USA June 3, 2015 incoming email EFTA02380505, page 1 Request to buy the magazine Not proof Epstein bought, subscribed to or possessed a particular issue.
F104 Fab Pleasure Shop product advertising March 30, 2013 incoming marketing email EFTA02679300, page 1; EFTA02679300, page 2; EFTA02679300, page 3 Advertisement naming sexual-product brands and lingerie Includes Jimmyjane, Liberator, OhMiBod, Aneros, Good Vibes, Crave, Kama Sutra, Lelo and Museum of Sex; no purchase established.
F105 Sexual technique / anatomy reading and video references June 2019 message exports EFTA01214149, page 3; EFTA01620628, page 4; EFTA01620628, page 5 An anatomy-guide URL and discussion of technique viewing A reading link or reported viewing is not an independently recovered book or video file.
F106 LS-titled online magazines FBI intake, July 12, 2019 EFTA01249229, page 1; EFTA01249229, page 2 Unverified caller report of potentially abusive material Caller speculated about an Epstein connection. This record establishes the tip, not authorship, distribution, ownership, seizure or FBI corroboration. No underlying imagery reproduced or sought.

Reading Materials

Eight distinct book or guide titles have support in a purchase record, private inventory, physical evidence log, or reviewed photograph: SM 101, SlaveCraft, Training With Miss Abernathy, The Compleat Slave, Sexy New York City 2000, Erotica Universalis, Complete Shibari, Volume 1: Land, and Massage For Dummies. This count includes a general massage guide with sensual content. It counts titles across specified evidence categories, not physical copies. Digital purchases, gifts, recommendations, excerpts, and unnamed references are listed separately below.

The publisher’s catalog identifies Jack Rinella as the author of The Compleat Slave. The author’s catalog confirms Douglas Kent’s Complete Shibari, Volume 1: Land. Bibliographic confirmation identifies a title; it does not connect an author or publisher to Epstein’s conduct.

Books and Magazines in the 2005 Inventory

Original 2005 title descriptions
Title or label Evidence Status
Compleat Slave: creating and living an erotic dominant/submissive lifestyle EFTA01733753 · p. 2 One book recorded in private-removal inventory. The title corresponds to Jack Rinella’s book; the recovered copy’s printing is not established.
Training with Miss Abernathy: a workbook for erotic slaves and their owners EFTA01733753 · p. 2 One book recorded. Also appears in the Amazon transaction below; not automatically a separate copy.
Sexy New York City 2000 EFTA01733753 · p. 2 Listed as annual guide to NYC erotica.
Purely 18 EFTA01733753 · p. 2 One magazine, year 2000.
Only 18 EFTA01733753 · p. 2 One magazine; issue not supplied.
Barely Legal EFTA01733753 · p. 2 One magazine, identified as Hustlers, January 2000. Marketing title does not establish performer ages.

The Three-Book Amazon Shipment

The invoice identifies Jeffrey Epstein as customer and recipient at his Palm Beach address and records an order dated September 4, 2005. The clearest text copy reviewed is EFTA00007606 · p. 2; the same transaction also appears in EFTA00007600 · p. 3. It lists one copy of each title. Item prices total $44.37, with $24.46 shipping and handling, yielding $68.83 paid by Amex and a zero balance. OCR varies on digits in the order identifier, so the transaction is identified here by its date, titles, prices, and recipient rather than uncertain digits.

Book Author listed ISBN shown Price
SM 101: A Realistic Introduction Jay Wiseman 0963976389 $16.47
SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for Erotic Servitude: Principles, Skills and Tools Guy Baldwin 1881943143 $15.95
Training With Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for Erotic Slaves and Their Owners Christina Abernathy 1890159077 $11.95

The invoice supports a purchase/shipment finding. It does not prove that Epstein read every book or used its contents against a particular person. Litigation exhibit lists and deposition questions about these books are corroborating references to the records, not additional purchases. The later invocations of the Fifth Amendment are not admissions of the questions’ factual premises.

Photographed Books and Scanned Reading

Erotica Universalis is directly visible in EFTA00000518. The cover reads Gilles Néret, From Pompeii to Picasso, and TASCHEN. This is a verified photographed book, not merely an OCR keyword. Handwritten exhibit-selection notes in EFTA00159145 also identify the title, a third-floor blue bedroom, and photograph CDG0520. Those notes identify a separate photograph of lubricants on a massage-room shelf, CDG0489. The notes’ handwriting transcript is an interpretive layer; the notes alone do not prove that the cited image and CDG0520 are identical.

The released scan EFTA00008320 · p. 12 contains chapter 19, “The Lover’s Touch: Massage and Intimacy.” It discusses sensual touch, setting a mood, Tantra, and vibrating devices. The book excerpt refers to the Kama Sutra and books by Mantak Chia. Those references do not establish possession of separate Kama Sutra or Mantak Chia volumes. The surrounding general massage text also covers nonsexual topics. The running header on page 55 identifies Massage For Dummies; the back-cover text on page 88 names Steve Capellini and Michel Van Welden. The exact printing remains unconfirmed.

A House Oversight text result identifies The S&M Feminist: Best of Clarisse Thorn in HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018438 and HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018439. The text is present in the release, but its original custodian and acquisition context are unresolved. It is therefore not included among the eight physically inventoried, photographed, or purchased titles.

The title Erotica Universalis is readable in the EFTA00000518 photograph cited here. Its cover and the publisher’s catalog identify Gilles Néret and TASCHEN. The precise printing is not established from this photograph.

A further reading reference appears in EFTA01618557 · page 3: participants in a message export debate whether Lolita is a romance. This establishes discussion of the title, not a recovered physical copy. Ordinary literary titles elsewhere in the discussion are not classified as sexual material merely because they share the thread.

Additional Reading and Digital Records

The broader reading search recovered digital transactions, gift notices, recommendations, promotional excerpts, and academic references. Their inclusion records what the evidence actually says. It does not convert correspondence into a bookshelf inventory or imply misconduct by authors.

Title / reference Record and evidence status
Healing Love through the Tao: Cultivating Female Sexual Energy EFTA00529239, page 1. Order addressed to Karina; billing names Karyna Shuliak; $9.99. Do not attribute the purchase to Epstein. Digital order is not a recovered physical book.
Rationale of the Dirty Joke: An Analysis of Sexual Humor EFTA00687957, page 1. Gift from Jackie Martling to Jeffrey Epstein. Notice permits claiming or exchanging; redemption and reading are unproved.
Two Gershon Legman books, second title unspecified EFTA02500664, page 1. Martling says he mailed two hard copies. Delivery unproved. Do not manufacture a second title or add a second copy from the Kindle notice.
Story of O; The Second Sex; Lolita EFTA01842864, page 1. Recommendations and reported reading. First two recommended by Epstein; correspondent reports reading Story of O and Lolita. No physical recovery established.
“shades of grey” series EFTA01885007, page 1. First and second books recommended; third reportedly being read. No completed order or physical recovery in this thread.
Urban Tantra: Sacred Sex for the Twenty-First Century EFTA02551241, page 1. Barbara Carrellas title and workshop reference. Recommendation is not purchase or ownership.
“dr. tatyana’s sex advice for all creation” EFTA00529347, page 1. Source wording for Dr. Tatiana’s Sex Advice to All Creation. Karyna says she managed to get the first list item; no edition or invoice supplied.
Evolution and Human Sexual Behavior EFTA00949840, page 1. Coauthored book mentioned by Justin Garcia. Academic reference; no purchase, possession, abuse, or author involvement established.
In The Garden: The Memoirs of the Garden Keeper EFTA01719824, page 4; EFTA01719824, page 5. Promotional chapter; Dell Williams and Lynn Vannucci. An excerpt in the records does not prove ownership of the completed book.
Hot Surrender, Charlotte Lamb EFTA01240502, page 1. Reviewed Harlequin Treasury cover. No physical recovery, purchase, or reader established.
Untitled “Dubai book” EFTA01956909, page 1. Book thanked for; described as having “lots of sex”. Title not supplied; no speculative identification.

The approximate phrase “enhancing female sexual energy” in EFTA00929334, page 1 and EFTA00947554, page 1 is retained as an approximate recommendation, rather than silently equated with the separately invoiced Tao title. EFTA02526046, page 1 also records an earlier recommendation of The Second Sex in July 2009.

The released text of The S&M Feminist contains nested references to books such as My Secret Garden, Our Bodies, Ourselves, Best Sex Writing 2010, Nine and a Half Weeks, and The Wisdom of Whores. These are references inside a published text, not independent evidence that Epstein owned those books. See HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018438, page 1. General genetics books, political books, unrelated case reporting, and bibliographies are excluded from the sexual-products inventory unless a specific relevant transaction, object, or reading reference is established.

The Recovered Trash Fragment

A Palm Beach police supplement places the collection on April 1, 2005. The officer describes a purple, finger-sized fragment about three inches long with a broken end. The account says it was photographed, packaged in a biohazard evidence bag because of possible bodily fluids, and secured as investigative evidence. The supplied report records a check of the original scanned pages: EFTA00022654, page 7 and EFTA00022654, page 8. This is a reported physical recovery, not merely an email reference to a product.

The model identification is less certain than the recovery. In an April 1 email, a SpicyGear contact offered a photographic opinion that the fragment resembled a jelly anal wand, while explaining that many similar products existed. A Cyclone product webpage appears with that correspondence. The webpage is comparison literature; it is not an Epstein purchase receipt. See EFTA01333510, page 1 and EFTA01333510, page 2. A separate investigative note records the same inquiry in EFTA01334217, page 1. The officer’s suggested use and packaging precaution are not laboratory findings. The report does not establish DNA results, actual use, an exact model, or a link to a particular survivor.

Further titles and publication evidence

Material What is documented Evidence boundary
Justine and other de Sade reading references EFTA01857287, page 1; EFTA01622719, page 1; EFTA01622719, page 2; EFTA01622719, page 3. Recommendations and discussion of Story of O / Fifty Shades The phrase “justine in the bedroom” is ambiguous. It is not silently corrected to another de Sade title or counted as a recovered book.
Sex Movies magazine EFTA01230671, page 1. Readable cover title in an original image Issue/date, ownership and circumstances unestablished. No identification of the person or inference about their age or conduct.
Xcitement magazine material EFTA01720322, page 5; EFTA01720322, page 69; EFTA01720503, page 6. Publication scans in the released records Masthead, listings and advertisements establish publication content; physical recovery, reader, issue count and acquisition remain unestablished.
Playboy USA EFTA02380505, page 1. Request to buy the magazine Not proof Epstein bought, subscribed to or possessed a particular issue.
Fab Pleasure Shop product advertising EFTA02679300, page 1; EFTA02679300, page 2; EFTA02679300, page 3. Advertisement naming sexual-product brands and lingerie Includes Jimmyjane, Liberator, OhMiBod, Aneros, Good Vibes, Crave, Kama Sutra, Lelo and Museum of Sex; no purchase established.
Sexual technique / anatomy reading and video references EFTA01214149, page 3; EFTA01620628, page 4; EFTA01620628, page 5. An anatomy-guide URL and discussion of technique viewing A reading link or reported viewing is not an independently recovered book or video file.

In the January 2017 Skype exchange, the account labeled jeevacation discusses Story of O as political satire and recommends de Sade. That characterization is the speaker’s interpretation, not this report’s literary conclusion. The ambiguous phrase “justine in the bedroom” remains an unresolved title reference. Source: EFTA01622719, page 2 and EFTA01622719, page 3.

The Xcitement scans contain adult-video listings, venue advertisements, and sexual-product promotion. References inside those pages, including Penthouse-branded video releases, are publication content rather than separate evidence that the listed videos or advertised products were owned. A source file containing many pages also does not establish how many physical issues were collected.

Palm Beach Purchases and Police Evidence

The Eve’s Garden invoice dated March 3, 2005 lists four Twin Torpedos units at $24.95 each, a free BARE lubricant gift, $16 shipping, $8.68 tax, and a $124.48 total. The invoice ships to the Palm Beach residence; the buyer field is redacted. The source is EFTA00068131, page 2, with a receipt photograph in EFTA00244470, page 1. Duplicates in EFTA01246899, page 1 and EFTA01719824, page 1 represent the same transaction.

The Adult Video Warehouse receipt, invoice 679654, dated July 23, 2005, lists ten generic NOVELTY purchases at $12.99, $12.99, $19.99, $69.99, $7.99, $6.99, $19.99, $5.99, $21.99, and $21.99. They total $200.90 before $13.06 tax, or $213.96. The supplied report records an original receipt-image check in EFTA01332988, page 1. Reproductions in EFTA00006072, page 3, EFTA01700746, page 3 and EFTA01702869, page 55 must not be counted as additional purchases. Generic receipt descriptions cannot be assigned to particular models without a further link.

Palm Beach product-lot cross-check
Evidence lot Description and source
Twin Torpedos: two boxed sets EFTA00244471, page 1; EFTA02728436, page 39. Photograph and collection description. Distinct evidence event from the four-unit invoice and the privately removed box.
Mini Peni-Soaps EFTA02728436, page 39. Opened novelty-soap package. California Exotic Novelties; one of two soaps described as missing.
Sexy Loving Soap EFTA02728436, page 39. Unopened novelty-soap package. Pipedream Products. This resolves the function of the packaged product shown elsewhere.
Soap on a Rope Lather-Up Pussy EFTA02728436, page 39. Unopened novelty-soap package. California Exotic Novelties; overlaps earlier photographed packaging.
Two penis-shaped soaps EFTA02728436, page 39. One small and one large soap with rope. Collection lots and packages cannot be converted into a single five-bar total.
Peach lubricant, 4 oz EFTA02728436, page 39; EFTA00244476, page 1. Unopened bottle and evidence photograph. Inventory calls it JOY JELLY; photographed label reads Joy Elly / Juicy Peach. One evidence item.

The detailed schedule also records three VHS tapes: a partly obscured I Love Lesbians Four label, an incompletely readable “Eatin’” label, and a tape labeled “Zorro Ranch Main House 3/17/00” with “SEX IN CITY” overlaid. These are labels, not verified content descriptions. The ranch wording does not establish that this tape was seized in New Mexico. Source: EFTA02728436, page 39.

Transfer and custody records

The FBI collected-items print lists an acquisition date of August 28, 2006 for the transferred Palm Beach property, including two massage tables, soap lots, two Twin Torpedo vibrators, lubricant, and three tapes. That is the FBI acquisition date, not a new finding that police first seized the property in 2006. See EFTA00082615, page 2. The June 2021 inventory of item 1B1 links original property 05-1024 to four boxes and records later splits, including the brown table as 1B131 and beige table as 1B132. See EFTA00173109, page 1. These are custody cross-references, not additional tables or devices.

The separate Massage For Dummies item is logged as 1B10, acquired August 7, 2007, in EFTA01657859, page 10. A later migration record gives the same acquisition date in EFTA01699302, page 26. Interview records describe a gifted book and other items voluntarily supplied to investigators: EFTA00157640, page 3. The record for 1B9 lists An Invitation to Poetry and Victoria’s Secret underwear; its “red rope” describes evidence packaging and is not proof of a sexual restraint: EFTA01699302, page 23.

Merchant records and attributed claims

Grand jury testimony states that Adult Video Warehouse subpoenas were served April 24, 2007 and complied with April 30: EFTA00009440, page 6. The investigation chronology separately lists subpoena issue dates and an Eve’s Garden return: EFTA00224943, page 5. These dates describe investigative steps. A February 17, 2006 defense letter says an enclosed Guys and Dolls strap-on purchase receipt belonged to an adult using their own card. This remains counsel’s assertion, rather than a court finding or an established Epstein purchase: EFTA01246275, page 1.

The October 2005 Private Removal

The memorandum from William Riley to Roy Black is dated October 9, 2005. It states that investigator Paul Lavery visited Epstein’s Palm Beach residence on October 7 and, pursuant to Black’s instructions, removed items of potential evidentiary value. The memorandum says they were turned over to Riley for inventory and safekeeping. The released copy carries privilege markings. Source: EFTA01733753. This provenance is material: the list records private removal, not police seizure. The document does not itself identify a storage unit or establish that investigators subsequently recovered every item.

Original private-inventory wording
Product or item Inventory detail Source
SuperStrap Box label; described as an alternative to bed posts. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Furry Cuffs Box with fur-covered handcuffs. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Twin Torpedos Box with separate vibrating controls. Inventory spelling retained. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Cyber Suck Box label describing an oral stimulator. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Mini Lovers Kit Box listing a mini vibrator and four accessory sleeves; component names are preserved in the source inventory. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Lacey Double Trouble Box identified as a masturbator. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
The Vibrating Facilitator Box label; no verified model specifications in this record. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Eroscillator 2 Box label. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Pocket Rocket Box identified as a mini massager. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Japanese Culture Pearl Tickler Ring Name preserved as written in the inventory; brand spelling is unconfirmed. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
The Ladybug Box identified as a personal vibrator. EFTA01733753 · p. 2
Brookstone massagers Three listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Purple rubber/silicone dildo One listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Rubber/silicone artificial vagina One listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Red leather strap/whip One listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Pewter-colored electric dildo with attachments One listed; number of attachments unspecified. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Silver-colored chain with clip One listed; precise use not established. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Black silk thongs Two listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
White silk thong One listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Woman’s black hose One listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Black underwear One listed. EFTA01733753 · p. 4

Eleven box-labeled product entries appear on page 2. That wording does not establish eleven shipping cartons or eleven storage boxes. A box may contain several pieces; an empty package may not establish that every marketed component was present. The list does not establish a deduplicated count of individual devices.

The July 2019 FBI Collection

The FBI log dated July 8 describes execution of a July 6 warrant and additional measures early July 7. The operative item entries are in EFTA01301570 · p. 3 and EFTA01301570 · p. 4. The rows below preserve receipt groupings and locations because one receipt is not one object.

Receipt-by-receipt New York detail
Receipt Items Recorded location Source
7 One green massage table Room P, middle of room EFTA01301570 · p. 3
8 One set of copper handcuffs and whip Room P, bottom shelf of display case EFTA01301570 · p. 3
9 Four framed photos of naked females Room P, walls of massage room EFTA01301570 · p. 3
10 One butt plug Room Q, third drawer left of sink; location continues onto next page EFTA01301570 · p. 3
11 One vibrator; three butt plugs; one set of cuffs; one dildo; one leash; one box of condoms; one nurse cap; one stethoscope Room Q, fourth drawer left of sink EFTA01301570 · p. 4
12 Five costumes and one wig Room Q, fifth drawer left of sink EFTA01301570 · p. 4
13 Two photos of female buttocks Room V, nightstand drawer to right of bed EFTA01301570 · p. 4
14 One blue bust of a female torso Room V, floor left of blue glass table EFTA01301570 · p. 4
20 One brown bust sculpture of female breasts Room Z, shelf above bathtub EFTA01301570 · p. 6
21 Two white busts of female torsos Room Z, right-hand closet, top shelf EFTA01301570 · p. 6

The log records at least four butt plugs across receipts 10 and 11. It does not give a count of individual condoms, identify every costume, or establish that every costume was used sexually. Nurse cap and stethoscope are included because they were collected in the same bundle, not because either is inherently a sexual object.

The subsequent evidence detail EFTA00173107 identifies 1B15 and receipt item 11, with the July 7 collection time and the fourth-drawer location. Its description is garbled by OCR. The log and photograph clarify the bundle; garbled OCR does not establish an additional object. Another log copy is EFTA00153844.

The EFTA01648794 display photograph is labeled 1B15. It provides a visual cross-check for the receipt-11 bundle rather than evidence of another acquisition.

Estate Photographs: Identified Objects and Titles

The December 12, 2025 committee release announced a 19-photo selection from a production exceeding 95,000 photographs. A later committee statement explained that the estate supplied no context for the images. This matters for photographs that look like product shots or retail displays: inclusion in the estate production is not proof that the object was owned or used by Epstein.

The object-only reproductions examined here carry visible House Oversight identifiers and appear in the PBS reproduction of the release. The supplied report describes each finding below as checked against the photograph rather than adopted from an AI description; those checks have not all been independently repeated for this draft.

Image Direct observation Evidence boundary
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037702 A readable Complete Shibari cover, Extreme Restraints Catalog Sampler, pink Size Matters pump box, clear suction component, tubing and gauge, coiled black rope, metal U-shaped accessory, chain-linked clip/clamp-like objects, and a pink linked accessory. Exact photo date, location, purchaser, and use are not supplied. Several accessory functions remain unidentified.
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037638 Black glove with pronounced textures on its fingers. Appearance does not prove latex composition or use in any particular encounter.
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_037629 Jawbreaker Gag instruction/warning sheet and a black buckled strap. The visible text warns of serious risk. It does not document an injury or a particular use.
HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_083462 Novelty condom packets with Trump caricature and a retail sign priced $4.50. The image shows a retail display. It does not establish purchase, ownership, endorsement, or involvement by the person depicted in the branding.

The EFTA01145320 email dated February 10, 2013 is addressed to Jeff Epstein and includes an inline image containing Jawbreaker Gag warning text. That is an additional documentary connection to the product literature. It does not establish that the email image and estate photograph show two separate gags.

Other Reviewed Object Photographs

Record Visible finding Interpretation
EFTA01648794 An evidence display labeled 1B15: pink phallic device with black harness; clear and black plug-shaped objects; purple object; a corded white device; SKYN condom box; nurse cap; stethoscope; pink leash/collar and cuff-like accessories; black drawstring bag. Reviewed in the supplied report. The display corroborates the collected bundle; avoid counting it again as another set. Precise brand/model identification remains limited.
EFTA00000506 Open drawer containing a nurse cap, stethoscope, black bag, white mesh pouch, two oval packaged objects, and a FUN-branded box. Reviewed in the supplied report. Context photograph; exact identities of packaged oval objects are not established here.
EFTA00000508 Harness-mounted pink/purple dildo with black straps and a pink buckled accessory at the edge of the frame. Reviewed in the supplied report. Residence photograph; exact model not established.
EFTA00003948 · p. 2 Twin Torpedos retail packaging with separate vibrating controls. Reviewed in the supplied report. Product name and controls readable; same physical set as another inventory is not established.
EFTA00004049 · p. 2 Two anatomically shaped novelty objects in a package reading Sexy Loving, priced $7.99, with redactions. Reviewed in the supplied report. The AI description calls this a sex toy, but the image alone does not establish function. The collection description in EFTA02728436, page 39 identifies Sexy Loving Soap; the image alone would not establish its function.
EFTA00003858 · p. 4 Lather-Up Pussy, Soap on a Rope packaging; California Exotic Novelties; code SE-2482-04-2. Reviewed in the supplied report. Novelty soap packaging, not a confirmed penetrative device.
EFTA01610483 Metallic plug-shaped product with green jewel-like base on a plain white background. Reviewed in the supplied report. Looks like a commercial product image; seizure, purchase, and ownership are not established by this page.
EFTA01599714 Blue two-armed handheld device with gold-colored center, beside anatomical diagrams and chocolate packaging. Reviewed in the supplied report. Exact model, owner, and purchase history are not established.
EFTA01600213 Shop display of black sexual devices and packaged sheath products. Reviewed in the supplied report. Commercial context; no purchase or household possession established.

Additional image checks

Original photographs confirm a black plug with a blue gem-like base in EFTA01611163, page 1, a metal plug with a striped tail-like attachment in EFTA01611512, page 1, and a composite of devices in EFTA01611574, page 1. Their commercial presentation does not establish purchase or custody. A photographed accessory in EFTA01146318, page 1 resembles metal cuffs; no use or provenance is established.

Image descriptions were also rejected when the source failed to support them. The purported wall handcuffs in EFTA00245258, page 1 and the tiny-room device identifications in EFTA01148685, page 1 could not be verified. A description calling Twin Torpedos boxes “staplers” is contradicted by readable product packaging in EFTA00244541, page 1 and EFTA00244471, page 1. Ordinary shirt collars, dog and surfboard leashes, table-tennis paddles, prison restraints, cactus references, and aviation lubricants are excluded from sexual-item findings.

Emails, Product Links, and Household Tasks

Earlier correspondence references
Material or item Record and date What the record supports
The Joy of Sex EFTA00981369 · January 18, 2014; EFTA01789697 · January 19, 2014 Epstein recommends the title and a subsequent email says to download it. Recommendation/instruction, not a verified purchase or recovered physical copy.
Hidden Flower Bondage Gear Ribbon EFTA02315560; EFTA02316425; duplicate lead EFTA00556157 · October 2012 A product link sent from a header naming Nadia to Sarah K, and a reply saying Perfect. Link circulation and response do not establish completed purchase or use.
Shibari webpage EFTA00571251 · January 24, 2017 Email from Jeffrey E. to Karyna Shuliak containing a shibari link. Not proof of a photographed instructional book or a particular session. Duplicate search lead: EFTA02328696.
Wet for Her two-finger extender product EFTA01014643 · December 2, 2018 Incoming recommendation to JEE with a product URL. No completed purchase established. Duplicate lead EFTA02611842.
Vibrator review article EFTA02585185 · October 10, 2017 Communication contains a Marie Claire vibrator-review URL. Does not document buying every reviewed product.
More vibrators task EFTA00510490 · p. 1 A forensic calendar-items export contains that entry among household tasks. The visible page does not establish quantity, fulfillment, assignee, or date for that particular task.
Purchasing toys from a New York store EFTA00090773 · p. 10 FBI interview account says the witness was instructed to buy sex toys, thought they were vibrators, and could not recall who gave the instruction. The witness’s uncertainty limits attribution.
Good vibrations and bathing suits EFTA00838532 · April 8, 2018 Short phrase in an email. Exact vendor, purchase, or sexual meaning cannot be assumed from the phrase alone.

Coverage by Property and Aircraft

Location Located evidence What it establishes
Palm Beach EFTA01733753, page 2; EFTA02728436, page 39 Private removal inventory, police evidence descriptions, merchant receipts, object photographs, and later federal custody records. These are separate events.
New York EFTA01301570, page 3; EFTA01648794, page 1 July 2019 collection records and evidence-display photograph. Use the receipt-specific ledger above for quantities.
Little Saint James EFTA01205884, page 3; EFTA00020141, page 1 A released news article reports a household worker describing a box of sex toys. The search affidavit also discusses New York evidence. Neither supplies a complete final island seizure inventory.
Zorro Ranch / New Mexico EFTA00019101, page 4; EFTA02728436, page 39 A civil complaint alleges vibrator abuse across several locations, including New Mexico. A ranch-labeled VHS appears in Palm Beach material. Allegation and tape label do not establish a New Mexico recovered-device count.
Paris EFTA02023984, page 1; EFTA02731082, page 10 September 2011 correspondence jokes about bringing “sextoys”; the sender expressly says she is joking. Interview summaries describe travel and sexual activity. No completed toy shipment or itemized Paris seizure is established.
Aircraft EFTA00087610, page 2 Pilot David Rogers said in an August 2006 interview that he had never observed sex toys aboard either plane. This is a witness’s negative observation, not proof that none were ever aboard.

The island news account is secondary reporting preserved in the files. The civil complaint is an allegation. The interview summary is an attributed account. They remain useful leads without being presented as equivalent to photographed police exhibits.

Later Purchases and Instructions

The August 2013 Amazon confirmation lists a white 110V Magic Wand Personal Massager sold by Top Novelty for $57.99, with $11.17 shipping and a $69.16 total. The order was placed August 24, and the August 27 shipping notice names Karyna Shuliak as recipient in St. Thomas. The shared order identifier establishes that the confirmation and notice describe one transaction. It does not establish Epstein as the buyer, actual delivery, or onward movement to Little Saint James. See EFTA02298809, page 7, EFTA02298809, page 8, EFTA02298809, page 9 and EFTA02331062, page 1.

June 2019 exports separately contain instructions to obtain a Magic Wand and beginner butt plug, questions about lubricant, and a correspondent’s statement that a toy had been bought. See EFTA01620616, page 1, EFTA01620616, page 3, EFTA01620628, page 2 and EFTA01620628, page 3. The corresponding forensic export labels the June 15 instruction as sent by the account listed as Self, jeeitunes, in EFTA01214099, page 14. These records document communication and a reported purchase, with no merchant receipt or recovered-device identity. Their context does not supply an age finding or justify identifying a redacted participant.

A February 2013 email proposes a ball gag in response to a question about requests for an island visit: EFTA00875535, page 1. The February 10 incoming Jawbreaker Gag image provides a dated product-literature connection: EFTA01145320, page 1. A proposed item and an attached image still do not establish completed transport, use or two separate gags.

Police Descriptions and Witness Accounts

A police search narrative in EFTA00028568 · p. 2 describes Twin Torpedoes in a northeast bedroom closet and anatomically shaped soap in upstairs bedrooms. The image-description catalog also locates the narrative in EFTA00007157 · p. 46. These may be duplicate reports of the same discovery, not additional sets of products.

The April 1, 2005 identification correspondence in EFTA00260432 · p. 3 asks for an opinion about a broken object shown in photographs. A respondent characterizes it as a jelly anal wand and qualifies the identification. Page 5 contains a Cyclone retail product printout. Neither an opinion nor a comparison advertisement establishes purchase of a Cyclone or an exact forensic match. The related police summary EFTA01334217 records an identification that must be evaluated alongside the original pictures and the disputed fork-handle interpretation.

An FBI interview record in EFTA00162520 · p. 9 describes a birthday gift called a “Rock Pocket” vibrator, beige with gold bumps and a twist-open battery compartment. The reported “Rock Pocket” wording remains separate from the inventory’s Pocket Rocket name because resemblance alone does not establish a product match. A duplicate lead is EFTA01248877 · p. 3.

Juan Alessi’s trial testimony in EFTA02840124 · p. 217 describes cleaning a dildo and putting it in a basket in Maxwell’s closet; surrounding pages describe where objects were found. The testimony is evidence of what the witness recalled, not proof of which individual used each item. Other deposition and interview copies repeat household-cleaning descriptions; they require witness and date matching before deduplication.

Grand-jury material in EFTA00008631 · p. 65 and EFTA00008744 · p. 68 describes a New York massage room, oils, massager, cuffs, whip, and a schoolgirl outfit nearby. These accounts can corroborate the 2019 collection, but they do not document separate recoveries of each object. Trial filings also disputed whether photographed vibrators were the exact devices used on a witness. That distinction prevents overstatement.

The interview notes in EFTA00157613 · page 7 record Alessi describing both phallic devices and neck/back-style massagers, cleaning them, and returning them to a basket in Maxwell’s bathroom. The same passage identifies a black vinyl costume and adult videos. The descriptions do not establish that all the devices were the same model. Alessi’s account also distinguishes what he saw during cleanup from conduct he did not witness behind closed doors.

In EFTA02809392 · page 14, a civil filing quotes a JPMorgan human-trafficking paper discussing sex toys among expenses in trafficking operations generally. That passage is not a specific Epstein purchase receipt. Its proximity to allegations about Epstein’s payments does not turn every generic expense example into an individually documented purchase.

What the Trial Record Establishes

Photographs in a released case file are not necessarily exhibits admitted at trial. The December 6, 2021 transcript in EFTA02840590 · page 11 records the court excluding proposed photographs 918 and 921, described as back massagers and a bathroom drawer. The government offered them to corroborate Jane’s account. The court explained that the objects were movable, the photographs were taken decades after the alleged abuse, and no testimony established a match to the massagers Jane described. The next page records the court’s conclusion that the photos had little relevance and risked confusing the jury. That ruling concerns the proposed photographs, not a finding that no device was ever used.

This is also why a photograph of a similar massager does not identify the exact device used against a named survivor without an evidentiary link. The inventory establishes collection; testimony establishes a reported experience; the identity of a particular object requires the connection between them.

Adult Media and Instructional Video Labels

The following labels appear in the same private-removal inventory. They are label transcriptions, not verification of recording contents, legality, performer ages, or a connection to any victim. Several are ambiguous without viewing the case or recording. Nonsexual entertainment also appears in the inventory and is omitted from this subject list.

Label as recorded or lightly normalized Page
Lipstick Lesbians #7 EFTA01733753 · p. 2
I Love Lesbians (DVD listed empty) EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Lipstick Lesbian #7 EFTA01733753 · p. 3
XX EFTA01733753 · p. 3
House of Dreams EFTA01733753 · p. 3
How to Give Pleasure to a Woman by a Woman EFTA01733753 · p. 3
No Man’s Land #5 EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Cherry Poppers Crash Course Volume 9 EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Sharon Kane Loves Women EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Cherry Poppers #15 Mischievous Maidens EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Over Forty EFTA01733753 · p. 3
No Dicks Allowed EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Happy Lesbians EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Ace in the Hole EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Where the Boys Aren’t #5 EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Lickety Slit EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Pussy Woman 2 EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Girls of Milan Volume 12 EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Nightmare on Lesbian Street EFTA01733753 · p. 3
Orgy Girls #1 EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Gary W. Blakes Girls EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Bizarre Desires EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Tiffany & DJ: Wild Girls EFTA01733753 · p. 4
All Little Women #4 EFTA01733753 · p. 4
No Dicks Allowed Volume #39 EFTA01733753 · p. 4
New Faces, Hot Bodies Volume 15 EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Lesbos in Dildo Land EFTA01733753 · p. 4
No Man’s Land #16 EFTA01733753 · p. 4
Strap on Sally #9 EFTA01733753 · p. 4

The repeated Lipstick Lesbian(s) #7 entries may represent duplicate listing or more than one tape; the inventory alone cannot resolve that. An 8mm tape on page 1 has a label mentioning exercise, dancing, shower, and lingerie. It belongs in the media follow-up queue, but the label does not establish sexual content. The Sea Gate Kids Reunion label is not classified as sexual material merely because it shares this inventory.

Chronology of the Main Records

Date Record event Why it matters
April 1, 2005 Police identification correspondence about a broken object, EFTA00260432 · page 3 An opinion and a retail comparison, not an exact forensic identification.
September 4, 2005 Three-book Amazon order, EFTA00007606 · page 2 Documents one transaction, even though copies recur in the release.
October 7–9, 2005 Removal and inventory described by private investigators, EFTA01733753 Separates private custody from later police collection.
October 2005 Palm Beach police-search findings, EFTA00028568 · page 2 Documents Twin Torpedoes and anatomical soap in bedrooms.
February 10, 2013 Jawbreaker instruction image emailed to Epstein, EFTA01145320 Connects product literature to a dated communication.
January 2014 The Joy of Sex recommendations, EFTA00981369; EFTA01789697 Recommendations rather than a recovered physical copy.
July 6–8, 2019 New York warrant execution and collected-item log, EFTA01301570 Receipt groups supply collection locations and quantities.
December 6, 2021 Trial ruling on massager photographs, EFTA02840590 · page 11 Distinguishes case-file content from admitted trial evidence.
December 12, 2025 Estate-photo public release Adds image-based findings with a different provenance.

Unverified Leads and Negative Controls

The July 12, 2019 FBI intake records William Blackwood’s recollection of LS-titled online magazines and his suggested Epstein connection. The source supplies no corroborating ownership, authorship or distribution finding. It is included as an unverified lead because it names potentially relevant publications, not as a recovered magazine holding. Only the intake metadata and attributed claim are described here: EFTA01249229, page 1 and EFTA01249229, page 2.

Negative wording matters. A January 20, 2019 birthday email explicitly says the sender did not obtain a sex doll. It cannot support adding a doll to the physical inventory: EFTA01027413, page 1. Similarly, “magic wand” in unrelated wishes or missile-system reports, Hitachi hard drives and construction tools, Penthouse apartments, Hustler legal citations, and Playboy business proposals are not sexual-product holdings.

Additional original-image checks confirm the Joy Elly label in EFTA00244875, page 1 and two Twin Torpedos packages in EFTA00244577, page 1. These reinforce earlier evidence groups rather than add new recovered units. The cover title Sex Movies is readable in EFTA01230671, page 1. Generic shelving in EFTA01610337, page 1 and the unrelated books in EFTA01624753, page 1 do not establish additional sexual-reading titles.

Questions That Remain

What happened to the objects removed in 2005? The Riley memorandum identifies removal, transfer, and safekeeping, but does not supply a complete subsequent custody history. Storage contracts, handover receipts, return records, and any later law-enforcement acquisition could establish what remained available and when.

Which photographs and witnesses refer to the same device? Similar shapes, colors, or product names can suggest a match but cannot establish continuity across different properties and years. The “Rock Pocket” gift description and the inventory’s Pocket Rocket label therefore remain separate descriptions.

How complete are the location-specific inventories? The strongest itemized lists recovered here concern Palm Beach and New York. The Little Saint James search-warrant affidavit EFTA00020141 discusses relevant objects and reasons for the search; it is not itself a final inventory of everything collected on the island. The located records do not support an equally complete ledger for New Mexico or Paris.

How much material is visible only in photographs or handwriting? A readable book cover or package may have almost no searchable OCR. Conversely, an AI description can mistake a scanned document for a photograph of an actual object. These limits prevent a certified all-files total even when the principal documented categories are carefully inventoried.

How to Read the Evidence Status

Source class What can be concluded What requires another record
Collection or recovery record The record describes an object being acquired, collected or retained at a stated event. Identity across later records, actual use, complete custody and forensic conclusions.
Private inventory A privately retained investigator reported removal and safekeeping. Police acquisition or a complete later chain of custody.
Order or shipment record A named recipient, product, date or dispatch is documented. Purchaser where unstated, actual delivery, end user and destination beyond the stated address.
Photograph or commercial image Visible packaging, text or object form, with qualified identification. Ownership, acquisition date, use, age of depicted persons or guilt by association.
Correspondence, testimony or tip An attributed statement, recommendation or allegation was made. Independent confirmation of the claimed event or physical possession.

Dates are labeled by their meaning: a retail order date, a seizure or transfer date, a memorandum date, an interview date, or a later publication/release date. An author’s or retailer’s appearance here does not establish knowledge of or involvement in abuse. No single grand total is offered because invoices, packages, fragments, sets, photographs, duplicate productions and witness descriptions measure different things.

Search Coverage and Counting Rules

The final supplementary pass completed three further paginated families: extra_devices (220 pages), extra_gear (334), and extra_reading (4,042). After overlap with the earlier queries, the combined register contains 17,288 distinct text pages. The new terms recovered the Cyclone comparison record, Magic Wand transaction, Justine recommendation and publication scans. A result in the register is a search match, not a verified physical item.

The supplied report states that its expanded search retrieved and programmatically screened 17,288 distinct matching text pages across 8,630 document identifiers and 763 image-description entries. Findings were checked against substantive source passages, and object/title claims from images were checked against selected originals. The search register exposes every retrieved match, including irrelevant matches. Retrieval, screening, source-text review and original-image review are distinct operations; the report does not label all matching pages as manually reviewed.

According to the supplied report, full-text retrieval used the read-only SQL FTS endpoint with stable ordering and successive 500-row pages until each stated query was exhausted. This avoids the 50-result cap of the earlier search interface; that interface’s offset did not produce a dependable continuation. The live image index contained 92,249 rows at the time of the search. The earlier downloaded 38,955-row catalog was supplemented by the live database queries.

Search family Matching text pages
core 4639
reading 594
gear 3299
ocr 5
product_more 467
supplement 210
broad_reading 5688
extra_devices 220
extra_gear 334
extra_reading 4042

Families overlap; their counts must not be added to obtain a unique-page total. Core terms covered sex toy(s), vibrator and dildo variants, butt plugs, shibari, SlaveCraft and Abernathy. Reading terms covered erotica, sex books/manuals/positions, named titles and magazine labels. Gear terms covered condoms, lubricant, bondage, clamps, beads, gags, adult shops/videos and sexual devices. Additional screens covered named merchants and brands, massage/poetry/vendor titles, and broad sexual-language intersections with book, reading, magazine and catalog terms.

The OCR screen included the exact phrases ex toy and ex toys, sextoy variants, “s ex toy” and “sex tovs.” A final SQL phrase-count check returned zero for “ex toy” and zero for “ex toys” in each of the full-text and image-description indexes. The broader OCR family returned five text pages, including duplicate Paris sextoys correspondence, a URL containing sex-tovs-in-the-attic, and a defensive memorandum using adult sextoys. These are phrase-index results. They do not establish zero substring occurrences in unindexed, handwritten or withheld material.

Image searches included core device terms, erotic/bondage language, condoms and lubricant, restraints and accessories, named products, and book/magazine/catalog objects combined with sexual language. Image descriptions were discovery aids. Claims in the findings retain uncertainty where source packaging or context does not establish identity.

Duplicate productions of an invoice count as one transaction. A purchase, later seizure, private removal, photograph and custody transfer cannot be added as independent objects without a demonstrated identity link. A source-register match is not a confirmed holding. Unrelated litigation, quoted news, biological terms and references inside other books were screened separately.

The supplied report describes exhaustive retrieval for the documented search families in the accessible indexes on November 9, 2026. It is not a certified census of every released or withheld object. Unindexed handwriting, unreadable spines, incomplete property inventories and missing custody links prevent a defensible all-files physical-object total.

Exact expanded search expressions

reading

erotica OR “sex book” OR “sex books” OR “sexual positions” OR “sex positions” OR “sex manual” OR “SM 101” OR “Compleat Slave” OR “Joy of Sex” OR “Kama Sutra” OR “S&M Feminist” OR “Barely Legal” OR “Purely 18” OR “Only 18”

gear

condom* OR lubrican* OR bondage OR “nipple clamp” OR “anal beads” OR gag OR “sex shop” OR “adult store” OR “adult video” OR “pornographic soap” OR “genital soap” OR masturbator* OR “strap on” OR “sex device” OR “sexual device”

ocr

“ex toy” OR “ex toys” OR sextoy* OR “s ex toy” OR “sex tovs” OR “sex tovs”

images

“sex toy” OR “sex toys” OR vibrator* OR dildo* OR buttplug* OR “butt plug” OR shibari OR slavecraft OR abernathy OR erotic* OR bondage OR condom* OR lubrican* OR “nipple clamp” OR “sex book” OR “sex manual” OR “sex positions” OR “Kama Sutra” OR “anal beads” OR “Jawbreaker” OR “Pocket Rocket” OR “Torpedos” OR “Torpedoes”

core

“sex toy” OR “sex toys” OR vibrator* OR dildo* OR buttplug* OR “butt plug” OR shibari OR slavecraft OR abernathy

broad_reading

(erotic* OR sexual* OR sex) AND (book OR books OR reading OR magazine OR magazines OR catalog OR catalogue)

supplement

“massage for dummies” OR “invitation to poetry” OR “Hot Surrender” OR “Eve s Garden” OR “Eves Garden”

accessory

handcuff* OR whip OR collar OR cuffs OR leash OR “anal beads” OR “nipple clamps” OR “sex swing” OR “sexual device” OR gag OR paddle OR “sex book” OR “sex magazine”

product_more

“sex swing” OR “nipple clamps” OR “cock ring” OR “anal beads” OR “Love Shop” OR “Adult Video Warehouse” OR “peach flavored” OR “Joy Jelly” OR “SuperStrap” OR “Cyber Suck” OR “Eroscillator” OR “sexual magic” OR “vibrating egg” OR “sexology” OR “Fleshlight” OR “Tenga” OR “masturbator”

Additional loose image screen: book, magazine or catalog objects intersecting sex or erotic language in the analysis text; 38 returned rows. Results overlap the other image screens.

extra_devices

cyclone OR “sexual aid” OR “sex aid” OR “sex machine” OR “cock sheath” OR “cocksheath” OR “finger extender” OR “nipple clamp” OR “nipple clamps” OR “penis pump” OR “pussy pump” OR “anal wand” OR “dental dam” OR “rabbit vibrator” OR “magic wand” OR “massage wand” OR “love doll” OR “sex doll” OR “electro sex” OR “prostate massager”

extra_gear

“ball gag” OR “Jawbreaker” OR “nipple rings” OR “nipple ring” OR “anal plug” OR “cock ring” OR “flesh light” OR “Fleshlight” OR “Hitachi” OR “Wand Essentials” OR “Sybian” OR “We Vibe” OR “Lelo” OR “love eggs” OR “vibrating egg” OR “vibrating panties” OR “vibrating ring” OR “strapon” OR “strap-on” OR “restraint kit”

extra_reading

“The Ethical Slut” OR “The New Topping Book” OR “The New Bottoming Book” OR “Screw the Roses” OR “Sleeping Beauty” OR “Penthouse” OR “Hustler” OR “Playboy” OR “Sex for Dummies” OR “sexual magic” OR “kamasutra” OR “kama-sutra” OR “Sade” OR “ReStorying Your Life” OR “Erotic Mind” OR “Sex at Dawn” OR “Art of Seduction” OR “She Comes First” OR “Tantric Sex” OR “Ovid” OR “Intercourse”

The supplied PDF embeds the full source register as EpsteinWiki_Matched_Source_Register.csv. The register is a retrieval appendix rather than an inventory of confirmed objects.

Source Records and Further Reading

The principal records are linked beside each finding. The official DOJ disclosures provide the release source, while the research-data repository provides the searchable image-description catalog. The estate-photo release is documented by the committee statements linked above. Publisher and author catalogs are used only to confirm bibliographic details, not provenance or criminal conduct.

Conclusion

The documented record includes a recovered fragment from the 2005 trash investigation, named products privately removed from Palm Beach, merchant purchases, police and FBI evidence groups, the three-book Amazon shipment, later digital reading and device transactions, and readable product and publication photographs. The dated records reveal several different routes into the evidence. They do not justify treating every photographed or recommended item as a recovered possession.

The master ledger preserves those distinctions, while the search register makes the retrieval scope inspectable. The most consequential unresolved questions concern the exact identity and testing of the trash fragment, the later custody of privately removed objects, and the completeness of final inventories for properties beyond Palm Beach and New York. Those are gaps in what the located records establish, rather than grounds to invent a physical-object total.

Editorial review and unresolved source checks

  • The embedded CSV contains 18,051 rows, but many search-family labels are malformed character-separated strings or mixed fragments. The row and document totals are reproducible; reliable family-level attribution requires regeneration from the original search output. No attempt has been made to guess damaged labels.
  • A stale reference to seven physically supported titles has been corrected to eight, consistent with the report’s list including Massage For Dummies. The earlier unresolved description of Sexy Loving packaging is reconciled with the later soap identification.
  • The EFTA02331062 page-reference question was resolved by inspecting the three-page mirror PDF on November 10, 2026. PDF page 1 (Bates EFTA02331062) contains the August 27, 2013 shipping-confirmation header; page 2 (EFTA02331063) contains the product description and $57.99 price; page 3 (EFTA02331064) continues the total. The ledger’s page-2 product citation is correct. These are different parts of one notice, not conflicting records. Personal address, order and tracking identifiers are not reproduced here.
  • Direct DOJ PDF requests encountered an age-verification page. No age assertion was submitted. Public third-party text copies were used for the limited checks described above; original-image verification remains necessary for exact disputed wording.
  • Epstein Forums was checked on November 9, 2026. Its public index returned “This board has no forums”; targeted indexed searches for the principal inventory identifiers and subject returned no matching transcription. No forum transcription is represented as reviewed or credited without a verified match.

Independent cross-checks

Related EpsteinWiki coverage

Previous How the Epstein Files Numbering System Works
Next Sleuth Report: A Galaxy of Horror, What 1.3 Million Epstein Files Reveal About the Scale of the Investigation
Table of Contents