Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 15-cv-7433 (S.D.N.Y. 2015)
Snapshot
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| Case | Virginia L. Giuffre v. Ghislaine Maxwell, No. 1:15-cv-07433 (S.D.N.Y.) |
| Court | U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York |
| Case type | Civil defamation lawsuit |
| Filed | September 21, 2015 |
| Plaintiff | Virginia L. Giuffre (formerly Virginia Roberts) |
| Defendant | Ghislaine Maxwell |
| Judges | Robert W. Sweet, then Loretta A. Preska for the unsealing proceedings |
| Outcome | Settled in May 2017 for undisclosed terms and dismissed with prejudice. No court decided whether either side’s statements were true. |
| Why it matters | Sealed depositions and exhibits were later released in stages from 2019 to 2024 and are widely used in Epstein research |
| Appeals | Brown v. Maxwell, No. 18-2868 (2d Cir. 2019); Giuffre v. Maxwell, Nos. 24-182 and 24-203 (2d Cir. 2025) |
| Content warning | This page discusses the alleged sexual abuse of minors and legal disputes over secrecy and public access. |
Introduction
In September 2015, Virginia Giuffre sued Ghislaine Maxwell for defamation in federal court in Manhattan. Defamation means harming someone’s reputation with a false statement of fact. Giuffre said Maxwell defamed her by publicly calling her account of abuse by Jeffrey Epstein and Maxwell untrue. The case settled in May 2017, before trial.
The lawsuit is best known for what happened after it ended. The parties had filed depositions, which are sworn interviews taken before trial, along with exhibits and motions, and many were sealed, meaning hidden from the public. Journalists and others went to court to open them. The records came out in stages from 2019 through 2024, and the fight over the rest continued into 2025. This page explains the lawsuit and the unsealing fight. It does not decide whether the allegations were true, because no court made that finding.
Key Takeaways
- This was a civil defamation case, not a criminal case. No court ruled on whether Giuffre’s or Maxwell’s statements were true.
- It settled in May 2017 for terms that were not disclosed, and it was dismissed with prejudice, which means it cannot be refiled.
- In July 2019 the Second Circuit ordered the summary judgment papers unsealed and sent the rest back for review. Releases followed in 2019, 2020 and January 2024.
- In July 2025 the Second Circuit affirmed most of the later sealing decisions but ordered a fresh, document by document review of some materials.
- A name in an unsealed document shows only that the document mentions that person. It does not establish wrongdoing.
Parties
Plaintiff: Virginia Giuffre
Giuffre publicly alleged that Epstein and Maxwell sexually abused her when she was a minor. She died in April 2025. Her background is covered on the Virginia Roberts Giuffre page.
Defendant: Ghislaine Maxwell
Maxwell denied Giuffre’s allegations in this case. In a separate federal criminal case, a jury convicted her in December 2021 of sex trafficking and related crimes. That conviction came from a different case with its own record.
Intervenors seeking access
An intervenor is an outsider allowed to join a case for a limited purpose. Reporter Julie K. Brown and the Miami Herald asked the court to unseal the records. Alan Dershowitz also asked for some records to be unsealed.
The Defamation Claim
Giuffre brought one defamation claim under state law. Courthouse News reported that the claim was based on statements to the press in which Maxwell’s side said Giuffre’s claims were “shown to be untrue” and “obvious lies.” Maxwell’s lawyer argued that these were “plain vanilla” denials, not defamation.
Procedural History
Discovery and summary judgment
Both sides took depositions in 2016. Maxwell was deposed in April 2016. Business Insider reported that 167 documents containing thousands of pages were filed under seal. Maxwell moved for summary judgment in January 2017. Summary judgment is a request to win without a trial because the key facts are not in dispute. The court denied it about two months later in a largely redacted 76 page opinion. That ruling sent the claim toward trial. It was not a finding that Giuffre’s account was true.
Settlement
In May 2017 the parties filed a joint stipulation dismissing the case with prejudice, with each side paying its own costs. Courthouse News reported that the filing gave no details of the settlement terms.
The first unsealing fight
After the settlement, the Miami Herald and Julie K. Brown, Alan Dershowitz and others asked Judge Sweet to unseal records. He denied the requests, and they appealed. In Brown v. Maxwell, decided July 3, 2019, the Second Circuit vacated the denial. It found no privacy interest strong enough to keep the summary judgment papers sealed, ordered them unsealed, and sent the remaining documents back for review under the correct legal standards. The summary judgment papers were made public in August 2019.
Release of Maxwell’s deposition
Judge Loretta A. Preska took over the unsealing work after Judge Sweet. She ordered Maxwell’s 2016 deposition released. On October 19, 2020, the Second Circuit held that she did not abuse her discretion in rejecting what it called Maxwell’s “meritless arguments,” according to Reuters reporting carried by Al Jazeera. The transcripts were posted on October 22, 2020. Associated Press reporting said Maxwell repeatedly denied hiring anyone under 18 for Epstein and that over 2,000 pages had been released since the unsealing began.
January 2024 releases
In December 2023, Judge Preska ordered more documents unsealed after reviewing them one at a time. Bloomberg reported that the first of these were released on January 3, 2024. She kept the names of several victims sealed because their privacy outweighed the public’s interest, while releasing names of some people who had already identified themselves publicly.
The 2025 appeal
Giuffre, Julie K. Brown and the Miami Herald appealed several sealing rulings. In a per curiam opinion decided July 23, 2025 (an opinion issued by the panel as a whole), the Second Circuit affirmed most of the rulings. It vacated orders from December 2019 and January 2020 and a November 18, 2022 ruling that had kept parts of Giuffre’s Florida deposition transcript sealed. It sent those materials back for individual review. The court also held that whether a filing is a “judicial document” open to the public is decided as of the time it was filed.
Chronology
| Date | Documented Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| September 21, 2015 | Giuffre files the defamation suit | Court docket, No. 15-cv-07433 |
| April 2016 | Maxwell is deposed | Reuters via Al Jazeera |
| January to March 2017 | Maxwell’s summary judgment motion is filed and denied | Business Insider |
| May 2017 | Case settled and dismissed with prejudice | Courthouse News |
| July 3, 2019 | Second Circuit orders summary judgment papers unsealed | Brown v. Maxwell |
| October 19 to 22, 2020 | Appeals court rejects Maxwell’s appeal; her deposition is released | Associated Press |
| January 3, 2024 | First release under Judge Preska’s December 2023 order | Bloomberg via Fortune |
| July 23, 2025 | Second Circuit affirms in part, vacates in part and remands | Second Circuit opinion |
Evidence Appearances
Filings from this case also appear in the federal Epstein files. One example is listed below. More can be found by searching the case number on Epstein Data.
| Record or ID | Date | What It Shows | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA02796838 (Document 153-2) | Filed May 11, 2016 | Flight summary charts filed in this case, covering flights from 1998 to 2002. A chart is a summary prepared for litigation, not the original log. | Epstein Data |
What the Case Does and Does Not Establish
Established: Giuffre sued Maxwell for defamation in September 2015. The case settled in May 2017. Appeals courts ordered sealed records reviewed and released in stages, and further review was ordered in July 2025.
Allegations, not findings: Giuffre’s accounts of abuse are allegations in this case. Maxwell denied them here. Denying summary judgment only meant a jury could have heard the claim.
Not established: This lawsuit produced no court finding on whether the allegations were true. It also did not establish wrongdoing by anyone mentioned in the unsealed records. Survivor names that remain sealed should not be sought or published.
Relationship to the Wider Epstein Record
Giuffre later sued Prince Andrew in a separate case that settled in 2022. Maxwell’s criminal conviction came from a separate prosecution. Each matter has its own court record. See Giuffre v. Prince Andrew and Maxwell appeal proceedings.
Conclusion
Giuffre v. Maxwell was a defamation lawsuit that settled without any court finding on the underlying allegations. Its lasting importance is the unsealing fight, which put sworn testimony and exhibits into the public record over five years. Readers should treat those records as evidence of what was said and filed, not as proof of any person’s guilt.
Questions and Answers
What was the outcome of this case?
It settled in May 2017, before trial, and was dismissed with prejudice. The settlement terms were not disclosed.
Did the court decide whether Giuffre’s allegations were true?
No. The case ended in a settlement, and no court made a finding on whether the statements at issue were true.
Why were the records sealed and then released?
Many filings were sealed during the case. In 2019 the Second Circuit held that the court had not properly reviewed the sealing and ordered the summary judgment papers released. Other records came out after document by document review in 2020 and 2024.
Is the unsealing finished?
Not entirely. In July 2025 the Second Circuit sent some materials, including parts of Giuffre’s Florida deposition, back to the district court for another review.
Sources
- Brown v. Maxwell; Dershowitz v. Giuffre, No. 18-2868 (2d Cir. July 3, 2019), FindLaw summary
- Giuffre v. Maxwell, Nos. 24-182 and 24-203 (2d Cir. July 23, 2025)
- Courthouse News on the 2025 Second Circuit decision
- Courthouse News on the 2017 settlement
- Business Insider on the sealed filings and summary judgment ruling
- Al Jazeera (Reuters) on the October 2020 appeals ruling
- Associated Press on the October 2020 release of Maxwell’s deposition
- Bloomberg via Fortune on the January 2024 unsealing
- EFTA02796838, Document 153-2 in No. 15-cv-07433