Giuffre v. Prince Andrew
This page is the case overview: the allegations, response, procedural outcome and limits of the evidence. For the detailed docket and legal chronology, see the federal lawsuit and settlement record. For payment, donation, funding and confidentiality questions, see the civil settlement guide.
Start with the primary records: complaint, January 12 opinion, public settlement statement and signed dismissal order. The source register below explains what each does and does not establish.
Snapshot
Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, No. 1:21-cv-06702, was a federal civil lawsuit brought by Virginia Giuffre against Prince Andrew, Duke of York, now known as Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor.
Giuffre alleged that Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell trafficked her to Andrew for sexual purposes on three occasions while she was seventeen. She alleged encounters at Maxwell’s London residence, Epstein’s Manhattan townhouse, and Little St. James.
Andrew denied the allegations and said that he had no recollection of meeting Giuffre.
Giuffre filed the case on August 9, 2021, in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. She asserted New York common law claims for battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress under the revival provisions of the New York Child Victims Act.
Andrew moved to dismiss the lawsuit. His principal argument was that a confidential 2009 settlement between Giuffre and Epstein released other potential defendants from liability. On January 12, 2022, Judge Lewis A. Kaplan denied Andrew’s motion in all respects.
That ruling did not find Andrew liable. It determined that Giuffre’s allegations were legally sufficient for litigation and discovery to continue, with a possible trial.
The parties reached a confidential settlement in February 2022. The public settlement statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse, but it recognized Giuffre as an established victim of abuse, expressed regret for Andrew’s association with Epstein, and stated Andrew’s intention to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity.
The case was dismissed with prejudice on March 8, 2022. There was no trial, no jury verdict, no judicial determination that Giuffre’s allegations were true, and no ruling authenticating the well known photograph of Giuffre, Andrew, and Maxwell.
The public filing history can be consulted through the CourtListener docket for Giuffre v. Prince Andrew.
Case Information
Case: Virginia L. Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, Duke of York, also known as Andrew Albert Christian Edward, in his personal capacity
Case number: 1:21-cv-06702
Court: United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Judge: Lewis A. Kaplan
Filed: August 9, 2021
Dismissed: March 8, 2022
Claims: Battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress
Disposition: Dismissed with prejudice following a confidential settlement
Primary docket: CourtListener case record
Complaint: Giuffre’s federal civil complaint
Controlling dismissal opinion: Giuffre v. Andrew, 579 F. Supp. 3d 429
The Parties
Virginia Giuffre was one of the most prominent survivors to speak publicly about Epstein and Maxwell.
Giuffre said Maxwell recruited her in 2000 while she was working at Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort. She alleged that Maxwell presented the work as an opportunity to become a professional massage therapist, after which Epstein and Maxwell subjected her to sexual abuse and trafficking.
Andrew was the second son of Queen Elizabeth II. He had a documented personal relationship with Epstein and Maxwell that included social events, private residences, travel arrangements, telephone calls, and continued communications after Epstein’s 2008 Florida conviction.
Andrew was sued in his personal capacity. The Royal Family, Buckingham Palace, and the British government were not defendants.
Giuffre’s Three Alleged Encounters With Andrew
The complaint alleged three encounters involving Andrew.
Giuffre alleged that the first occurred at Maxwell’s London residence in 2001, when Giuffre was seventeen. She claimed that Epstein, Maxwell, and Andrew compelled her to engage in sexual activity with Andrew.
The second alleged encounter occurred at Epstein’s Manhattan townhouse. Giuffre claimed that Andrew again engaged in sexual activity with her under circumstances controlled by Epstein and Maxwell.
The third alleged encounter occurred on Little St. James, Epstein’s private island in the United States Virgin Islands.
Giuffre alleged that she did not consent and that she feared consequences if she disobeyed Epstein, Maxwell, or the powerful men to whom she said she was directed.
Andrew denied that any of the encounters occurred.
These allegations appeared in Giuffre’s civil complaint and other sworn records. They were never tested at trial.
The complaint’s paragraphs 36-47 set out the three alleged locations and assert that Andrew knew Giuffre was under 18 and was being trafficked. The Manhattan address was 9 East 71st Street. These are allegations in a pleading, not facts found after trial.
Giuffre’s public account also described a visit to the Tramp nightclub before the alleged London encounter. That nightclub sequence is not stated in the 2021 complaint and should not be attributed to it. Andrew’s 2019 Newsnight interview addressed the nightclub account and acknowledged visiting Epstein’s island while denying Giuffre’s allegations. Acknowledged presence at an Epstein property does not prove the alleged abuse.
In the January 2015 declaration included in EFTA00098456, paragraphs 34-35 describe Andrew arriving at Maxwell’s home before dinner and Tramp. That account should not be rewritten as a first meeting at the nightclub. It is a sworn allegation, not a finding made in this lawsuit.
The London Photograph
A photograph shows Andrew with his arm around Giuffre’s waist while Maxwell stands behind them.
Giuffre said the photograph was taken inside Maxwell’s London residence on the night of the first alleged encounter. The image became one of the most recognizable pieces of visual evidence associated with the Epstein scandal.
Andrew questioned the photograph during his 2019 BBC Newsnight interview. He raised doubts about elements of the image and said he did not recall the photograph being taken.
No public court ruling found that the photograph was fabricated. At the same time, the photograph was never formally authenticated through a trial because the case settled before evidence was presented to a jury.
Released records show that Palace press officials were involved when news organizations sought a response concerning the photograph.
EFTA02020640 contains communications involving Palace press official Ed Perkins about forwarding the photograph to Andrew and preparing a response. It proves that Palace staff participated in handling the media inquiry. It does not prove who took the photograph or independently establish every event Giuffre said followed it.
EFTA02687581 contains an overlapping copy of communications about sending the photograph to Andrew. It corroborates the institutional response process but is not a separate authentication of the image.
EFTA02017536 records internal discussion about the material supplied to the press. It documents press management, not a judicial finding concerning the photograph.
Later released communications have added support to the account that Giuffre was photographed with Andrew, but no later document can retroactively create the trial ruling that never occurred.
Investigative Records Containing Giuffre’s Allegations
Released investigative files preserve accounts concerning Giuffre’s alleged introduction to Andrew and the encounters she described.
EFTA00269896 records an account of a young woman being introduced to Andrew in the presence of Epstein and Maxwell. The record establishes that investigators formally documented the allegation. It does not independently prove the encounter.
EFTA00269967 contains an overlapping version of that same interview account concerning Andrew. It preserves an investigative account but is not a criminal judgment or civil verdict.
The distinction is important. An authentic investigative record proves that information was reported and preserved. Its authenticity as a government document does not automatically establish the truth of every statement recorded inside it.
EFTA00269896 and EFTA00269967 are substantially overlapping twelve-page productions of the same March 17, 2011 FBI interview, recorded in July 2013. They are not two independent witness accounts or sworn transcripts. Redactions and chronology differences must be preserved, not resolved by guessing identities or silently substituting a later account.
Andrew’s Denials
Andrew has consistently denied Giuffre’s allegations.
During his November 2019 BBC Newsnight interview, Andrew said that he had no recollection of meeting Giuffre. He cited a visit to PizzaExpress in Woking as part of his account of the day of the alleged London encounter.
He also challenged Giuffre’s description of him sweating, saying that a medical condition made it difficult for him to sweat at the time.
Andrew acknowledged that he had stayed at Epstein’s Manhattan residence in December 2010, after Epstein’s Florida conviction. He said he travelled to New York to end the friendship and described staying in Epstein’s house as convenient.
The Newsnight interview was not testimony in this lawsuit. The case ended without a trial at which Giuffre’s lawyers could cross-examine Andrew about his answers. Discovery had begun before settlement.
Following intense criticism of the interview, Andrew withdrew from public royal duties.
The Relationship Between Andrew and Epstein
Giuffre’s case did not arise from a chance encounter between strangers. Andrew and Epstein had a documented social relationship.
EFTA00559801 concerns arrangements to adjust a flight so Andrew could be collected at John F. Kennedy International Airport. It documents travel coordination involving Andrew and Epstein’s network. It does not establish what occurred during the visit.
EFTA02415487 records Andrew returning Epstein’s telephone call in October 2010.
EFTA01990003 contains a December 2010 communication between Andrew and Epstein concerning a telephone conversation.
EFTA01798176 contains a message attributed to Andrew in which he expressed concern for Epstein, said they appeared to be in the situation together, and proposed remaining in close contact. Duplicate copies appear as EFTA01836403 and EFTA02038795. Those copies corroborate the document’s preservation but do not represent three separate communications.
These records establish continued association and communication. They do not, by themselves, establish that Andrew participated in Epstein’s trafficking operation or committed the acts alleged by Giuffre.
The supportive message in EFTA01798176 is Andrew’s February 28, 2011 message within the correspondence thread. The direction and date matter: it is not an Epstein-to-Andrew assurance and the overlapping copies are not additional incidents. The arrangement-records guide preserves the fuller chain-level analysis.
Why Giuffre Filed in New York
Giuffre filed in federal court in Manhattan asserting diversity jurisdiction based on her alleged Colorado citizenship and Andrew’s United Kingdom citizenship, and alleging that part of the conduct occurred in New York. Andrew disputed Giuffre’s domicile; the court’s December 31, 2021 discovery order did not finally decide that jurisdictional issue.
Her claims arose under New York common law rather than a federal criminal statute.
The lawsuit also relied on New York’s Child Victims Act. The legislation created a temporary revival period allowing survivors to bring certain civil claims that otherwise would have been barred because too much time had passed.
Giuffre filed on August 9, 2021, five days before the legislatively extended statutory revival deadline of August 14, 2021. Later New York decisions recognized additional pandemic-related tolling of that deadline.
The Child Victims Act did not guarantee that her allegations would be accepted as true. It gave her an opportunity to present claims that otherwise could have been dismissed solely because of their age.
The Two Civil Claims
Giuffre’s first claim was battery.
Under New York law, battery generally concerns intentional and nonconsensual physical contact. Giuffre alleged that Andrew intentionally engaged in sexual contact with her without her consent.
Her second claim was intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Giuffre alleged that Andrew’s conduct was extreme and outrageous, that it was intended to cause or recklessly disregarded the likelihood of causing emotional harm, and that she suffered severe and lasting distress.
The complaint sought compensatory and punitive damages. It did not specify a final dollar amount.
The case was civil, not criminal. Andrew was not prosecuted through this lawsuit and did not face imprisonment as a possible outcome.
The complaint also requested litigation costs and other relief. Andrew disputed the adequacy of both claims and argued that the emotional-distress count duplicated the battery theory. The January 12 opinion rejected dismissal at that stage, not after deciding whether the alleged acts occurred.
The Dispute Over Service
Because Andrew lived in Britain, formally delivering the American lawsuit became an early procedural dispute.
Giuffre’s representatives initially attempted to serve documents at Royal Lodge. Andrew’s legal team disputed whether service had been completed properly.
Judge Kaplan later authorized service through Andrew’s United States counsel. The service dispute was resolved, and Andrew appeared through attorneys to contest the lawsuit.
The procedural fight did not decide whether Giuffre’s allegations were true. It determined whether the court had properly notified Andrew and could require him to respond.
The filings concerning service and all later case events are preserved in the public federal docket.
The 2009 Epstein Settlement Agreement
Andrew’s principal dismissal argument relied on a confidential settlement Giuffre had reached with Epstein in 2009.
Under that agreement, Epstein paid Giuffre $500,000. In return, the agreement released Epstein and used broad language concerning other people or entities who could have been included as potential defendants.
The unsealed 2009 agreement did not name Andrew.
Andrew argued that the broad release protected him because he qualified as a potential defendant and intended third party beneficiary.
Giuffre argued that the agreement did not release Andrew and that its language could not reasonably be interpreted as giving him enforceable rights.
The agreement’s drafting became the central issue in Andrew’s attempt to end the lawsuit at the pleading stage.
The filed 2009 agreement specified $500,000, excluding attorneys’ fees and costs. That known figure belongs to the Epstein agreement, not the undisclosed 2022 Andrew settlement.
Andrew’s Motion to Dismiss
Andrew moved to dismiss the complaint or, alternatively, require Giuffre to provide a more definite statement.
His arguments included:
- The 2009 Epstein settlement released him from liability.
- Giuffre had not pleaded sufficient facts showing a violation of the New York Penal Law for purposes of the Child Victims Act.
- The intentional infliction of emotional distress claim was legally insufficient or duplicative.
- The Child Victims Act revival provision was unconstitutional as applied to him.
- The complaint lacked sufficient details about the alleged encounters.
A motion to dismiss tests the legal sufficiency of a complaint. At that stage, a judge generally assumes properly pleaded factual allegations are true for the limited purpose of deciding whether the case may continue.
That assumption is not a factual judgment and does not prevent the defendant from disputing the allegations later.
Judge Kaplan’s January 2022 Ruling
On January 12, 2022, Judge Kaplan issued a detailed 46 page opinion denying Andrew’s motion.
The court found that the phrase “potential defendant” in the 2009 agreement was ambiguous. Because the agreement could support more than one reasonable interpretation, the court could not conclude at the dismissal stage that it protected Andrew.
The court also found that Giuffre had sufficiently pleaded claims for battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Judge Kaplan rejected Andrew’s constitutional challenge to the Child Victims Act and determined that the complaint provided enough information for the case to proceed.
Andrew’s request for a more definite statement was also rejected. The court explained that additional details could be obtained through discovery.
The motion was denied in all respects.
What the Dismissal Ruling Did Not Decide
Judge Kaplan expressly limited the meaning of his ruling.
The decision did not determine:
- Whether Giuffre’s allegations were true.
- Whether Andrew had sexual contact with Giuffre.
- Whether the London photograph was authentic.
- Whether Andrew knew Giuffre was being trafficked.
- Whether the 2009 agreement ultimately released Andrew after a full factual record.
- Whether Giuffre would prevail at trial.
- Whether Andrew had committed a criminal offense.
The ruling established that Andrew had not shown a legal basis for ending the case at the pleading stage.
A concise legal summary and the complete opinion are available through Cornell Law School’s case resource.
Discovery Began but Was Not Completed
Discovery was already under way before January 12. In the December 31, 2021 order (Document 61), Judge Kaplan recorded that Andrew had served extensive discovery, including requests concerning Giuffre’s domicile. The court denied his requested additional two-hour deposition and stay without prejudice to a later jurisdictional defense. Settlement interrupted an existing process; it did not prevent every discovery step from occurring.
Potential evidence included sworn testimony from the parties and relevant witnesses; travel, calendar, telephone, email and financial records; the London photograph; and evidence concerning the negotiation and intended reach of the 2009 release. The existence of a possible witness or record does not show that a deposition occurred or that material was admitted into evidence.
The public docket does not show a completed deposition of Andrew in this action. The case ended without a trial, cross-examination before a jury or a final judicial determination of the disputed allegations. That is narrower and more accurate than saying that no discovery occurred.
Federal Investigators Also Sought Andrew’s Cooperation
Separate from Giuffre’s civil case, United States prosecutors sought to interview Andrew about Epstein and his associates.
EFTA00022062 identifies subjects investigators wanted to discuss with Andrew, including his relationship with Epstein, travel, visits to Epstein’s properties, and knowledge of other people in Epstein’s circle.
Overlapping copies appear as EFTA00099391 and EFTA00087994. They are copies of related investigative material, not three independent interview requests.
In June 2020, United States Attorney Geoffrey Berman stated that Andrew had not submitted to an interview and had repeatedly declined requests to schedule one. Andrew’s legal team disputed the government’s characterization of his cooperation.
The prosecution’s position is preserved in the official Southern District of New York statement.
The request for an interview established that investigators considered Andrew’s information relevant. It did not mean that he had been charged with an offense.
The February 2022 Settlement
On February 15, 2022, the parties informed Judge Kaplan that they had reached a settlement in principle.
The settlement amount was not disclosed. Published estimates varied considerably and should not be treated as confirmed.
The public statement said Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity in support of victims’ rights.
The public settlement statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse.
The statement nevertheless contained several acknowledgements that were substantially different from his earlier public attacks on Giuffre’s credibility. It said Andrew accepted that Giuffre had suffered as an established victim of abuse and had been subjected to unfair public attacks.
It also said Andrew regretted his association with Epstein and commended Giuffre and other survivors for standing up for themselves and others.
The settlement and its public statement are recorded in the February 15, 2022 docket entry. Contemporary accounts by Reuters and PBS preserve the announced terms.
Document 78 is counsel’s settlement-in-principle letter; Document 78-1 is the attached public statement. Document 79 then suspended deadlines through March 17, 2022. That suspension was not the final dismissal, and neither filed settlement document publishes the full private agreement.
The March 2022 Dismissal
After the settlement was completed, the parties asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit.
On March 8, 2022, Judge Kaplan dismissed the case with prejudice. Each side agreed to bear its own legal costs and fees.
A dismissal with prejudice means the same claims cannot ordinarily be filed again. It does not mean that the court found the allegations false.
The formal dismissal ended the civil action without a trial, verdict, or judicial finding of liability.
The termination is documented in the CourtListener docket and in Reuters’ report on the final dismissal.
The parties’ stipulation, Document 82, identifies a settlement agreement dated February 12, 2022 and invokes Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(ii). Document 83 is the signed March 8 dismissal order. The February 15 statement had made filing dismissal contingent on Giuffre’s receipt of the settlement; the later dismissal does not disclose the payment amount or provide a banking record.
What the Settlement Meant
The settlement established that Giuffre received an agreed resolution of her civil claims and that the case ended before completion of discovery, Andrew’s anticipated deposition and trial.
It also produced a public statement recognizing Giuffre as an established victim of abuse and acknowledging Epstein’s trafficking of numerous young women and girls.
The settlement did not establish Andrew’s liability. The public statement contains no admission of the alleged abuse, but it also contains no express no-liability clause; the full private agreement is not reproduced in the public filing.
It also did not exonerate Andrew. The court never rejected Giuffre’s allegations, and the case did not end through a ruling in Andrew’s favor.
A settlement is a negotiated resolution. It is neither a criminal conviction nor a declaration that the defendant did nothing wrong.
The Royal Consequences
Andrew stepped back from public duties in November 2019 following the Newsnight interview.
One day after Judge Kaplan refused to dismiss Giuffre’s lawsuit, Buckingham Palace announced that Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages had been returned to Queen Elizabeth II.
The January 13, 2022 Palace statement said Andrew would continue not to undertake public duties and would defend the case as a private citizen.
In October 2025, Andrew announced that he would no longer use his title or honours, while continuing to deny the allegations. His words are preserved in his official October 2025 statement.
Later that month, Buckingham Palace announced that King Charles III had initiated a formal process to remove Andrew’s styles, titles, and honours. The Palace said he would be known as Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor and would leave Royal Lodge.
The Buckingham Palace statement said the measures were necessary despite Andrew’s continued denial and expressed sympathy for victims and survivors of abuse.
These were institutional consequences. They were not criminal penalties or judicial findings in Giuffre’s case.
The subsequent legal mechanisms and financial arrangements are explained in Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein and Charles III and the Epstein Record. Removal from the Roll of the Peerage, changes to style and honours, property arrangements and succession are distinct matters. None should be retroactively described as a term of the 2022 civil settlement.
The Separate 2026 Investigation
ITV reported on February 19, 2026 that Andrew was arrested on suspicion of misconduct in public office and released under investigation. The inquiry concerns allegations that sensitive information was shared with Epstein while Andrew served as the United Kingdom’s trade representative. Arrest and investigation do not establish that the alleged conduct occurred.
The 2022 civil action is closed. The later British investigation concerning suspected misconduct in public office is a separate matter involving Andrew’s former trade role, not a reopening of Giuffre’s lawsuit or a criminal determination of her allegations.
Thames Valley Police’s October 2026 update states that the investigation remains ongoing. The October 8, 2026 High Court order concerns the challenge to search warrants and the treatment of seized material. The warrant issue and the pending retention proceedings do not decide Andrew’s guilt or resolve Giuffre’s civil allegations.
For the dated investigative sequence and its legal limits, see Andrew’s main profile. Arrest, investigation and a search-warrant ruling must not be described as a conviction or an acquittal.
Virginia Giuffre’s Death and Legacy
Virginia Giuffre died by suicide in Western Australia on April 25, 2025. She was forty one.
Her death did not alter the procedural history of the lawsuit. The case had been permanently dismissed three years earlier under the settlement.
Giuffre’s wider legacy extends beyond her claim against Andrew. She helped expose Epstein and Maxwell’s treatment of vulnerable girls and young women, participated in litigation that opened previously sealed records, and became a prominent advocate for survivors.
The Associated Press account of Giuffre’s life and death described her role in bringing public attention to Epstein’s trafficking network.
Her posthumously published memoir, Nobody’s Girl, repeated her allegations against Andrew. A memoir is an important survivor account, but it is not a substitute for the trial that never occurred.
What the Evidence Establishes
The available evidence establishes that:
- Giuffre filed a federal civil lawsuit against Andrew on August 9, 2021.
- She alleged three sexual encounters arranged by Epstein and Maxwell while she was seventeen.
- Andrew denied the allegations and said he did not recall meeting Giuffre.
- Andrew had a documented personal relationship with Epstein and Maxwell.
- Andrew communicated with Epstein after Epstein’s 2008 conviction.
- Released investigative records preserve Giuffre’s allegations involving Andrew.
- Palace officials participated in responding to media inquiries about the London photograph.
- Andrew relied on Giuffre’s 2009 settlement with Epstein in seeking dismissal.
- Judge Kaplan found the release language ambiguous at the dismissal stage.
- Andrew’s motion to dismiss was denied in all respects.
- The court found Giuffre’s battery and emotional distress claims legally sufficient to proceed.
- The parties reached a confidential settlement before Andrew was deposed.
- The public settlement statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse.
- The settlement statement recognized Giuffre as an established victim of abuse.
- The case was dismissed with prejudice on March 8, 2022.
- Andrew’s public role, patronages, styles, honours and residence were affected by separate institutional decisions; their legal mechanisms and dates were not terms imposed by this court.
What the Evidence Does Not Establish
The available evidence does not establish that:
- A jury found Andrew liable.
- A court determined that Giuffre’s allegations were true.
- Andrew was convicted of a criminal offense involving Giuffre.
- The denial of Andrew’s motion to dismiss was a finding of guilt.
- The settlement was an admission of liability.
- The undisclosed settlement amount can be stated with certainty.
- The London photograph was formally authenticated at trial.
- The photograph alone proves that sexual activity occurred.
- Every statement in an investigative record has been independently corroborated.
- Andrew’s documented friendship with Epstein proves participation in trafficking.
- The 2026 misconduct investigation is a criminal determination concerning Giuffre’s allegations.
These limitations are essential to an accurate account of the case.
Investigative Assessment
Giuffre v. Prince Andrew reached a legally significant but factually incomplete conclusion.
Giuffre overcame Andrew’s attempt to end the lawsuit at the pleading stage. Judge Kaplan’s ruling confirmed that her allegations were sufficiently detailed and legally viable to proceed.
The ruling created the possibility that Andrew would have to answer questions under oath, produce records, confront witness testimony, and submit the disputed photograph to evidentiary examination.
The settlement prevented that process from reaching completion.
The documentary record strongly establishes the surrounding relationship between Andrew, Epstein, and Maxwell. It also establishes that Giuffre made detailed allegations over many years and formally presented them in federal court.
What remains absent is a verdict.
The most accurate classification is:
A civil sexual abuse case that survived dismissal, ended through a confidential settlement with no admission of the alleged abuse in the public statement, and produced no adjudication of the underlying allegations.
Key Takeaways
- Giuffre accused Andrew of sexual abuse during three encounters arranged by Epstein and Maxwell.
- Andrew denied every allegation.
- The case was civil and did not constitute a criminal prosecution.
- Andrew’s relationship and continued communications with Epstein are independently documented.
- The 2009 Epstein release did not secure dismissal because its language was ambiguous.
- Judge Kaplan allowed both of Giuffre’s claims to proceed.
- The ruling did not determine whether the allegations were true.
- The settlement ended the case before Andrew’s anticipated deposition and a public trial.
- The public statement recognized Giuffre as an established victim of abuse without admitting Andrew committed the alleged abuse.
- The case ended with prejudice, meaning Giuffre’s claims could not ordinarily be filed again.
- The litigation and its aftermath had institutional consequences; royal decisions were not sanctions imposed by the civil court.
- The record supports documenting both Giuffre’s allegations and Andrew’s denials without converting either into a nonexistent verdict.
Related EpsteinWiki Articles
- Virginia Roberts Giuffre
- Prince Andrew
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Ghislaine Maxwell
- Little St. James
- Giuffre v. Maxwell
- Epstein Flight Logs
- Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York
- Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein
- How to Read an Epstein Document
- Detailed federal docket and legal chronology
- Civil settlement, funding and confidentiality guide
- Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor: main profile
- Charles III: royal decisions and financial evidence limits
- Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein
Primary Court Records
CourtListener’s docket provides PACER-derived copies. The filed documents must be distinguished from reporting about them; the official court record remains controlling.
- August 9, 2021 complaint, Document 1: The pleaded allegations, two causes of action and requested relief; not findings of fact.
- September 16, 2021 alternative-service order, Document 16: Order permitting service through United States counsel.
- September 28, 2021 filed service stipulation and order, Document 20: Deems service effective September 21 and sets the response deadline; preserves other defenses.
- November 3, 2021 supplemental scheduling order, Document 36: Sets initial disclosures and records planned depositions, confirming pre-January discovery activity.
- December 31, 2021 discovery and domicile order, Document 61: Confirms discovery requests already existed before the motion-to-dismiss ruling; did not finally decide domicile.
- 2009 Giuffre-Epstein agreement, filed as Document 32-1: The separate $500,000 settlement and disputed release; not the 2022 Andrew settlement.
- January 12, 2022 opinion, Document 64: Denies the motion to dismiss without determining the truth of the allegations.
- January 26, 2022 answer and jury demand, Document 71: Andrew’s denials and affirmative defenses; defenses are not established facts.
- February 15, 2022 settlement-in-principle letter, Document 78: Counsel’s notice and request to suspend deadlines.
- February 15, 2022 attached public settlement statement, Document 78-1: Undisclosed amount, intended charitable donation and public acknowledgements; not the complete settlement contract.
- February 15, 2022 suspension order, Document 79: Held the action in abeyance through March 17, subject to filing dismissal; it was not the dismissal itself.
- March 8, 2022 stipulation and proposed order, Document 82: Refers to the February 12 settlement agreement, Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), dismissal with prejudice and each side’s costs and fees.
- March 8, 2022 signed dismissal order, Document 83: Judge Kaplan’s signed order dismissing the action with prejudice.
Epstein Data Evidence Sources
- EFTA00269896 preserves an investigative account concerning an alleged introduction to Andrew.
- EFTA00269967 is an overlapping production of the same March 2011 interview, not a separate corroborating account.
- EFTA00559801 documents travel coordination involving Andrew’s arrival in New York.
- EFTA02415487 records Andrew returning Epstein’s telephone call in October 2010.
- EFTA01990003 documents direct communication between Andrew and Epstein in December 2010.
- EFTA01798176 contains Andrew’s supportive message to Epstein during intensifying public scrutiny.
- EFTA02020640 documents Palace press handling of the photograph involving Andrew, Giuffre, and Maxwell.
- EFTA02687581 contains an overlapping copy of Palace communications about the photograph.
- EFTA02017536 records internal discussion concerning the response supplied to the press.
- EFTA00022062 identifies subjects federal investigators wanted to discuss with Andrew.
- R Howard Stone’s Epstein Data project: Prince Andrew investigation report organizes Andrew related documents across the released collection. This is secondary, AI-generated analysis; its conclusions should be checked against the linked underlying records.
- The Epstein Data evidence map identifies publicly released and unresolved FBI evidence references connected with Epstein’s victims and associates.
External Sources
- BBC Newsnight account of Andrew’s interview
- Associated Press report on the filing of Giuffre’s lawsuit
- PBS report on the denial of Andrew’s motion to dismiss
- Reuters report on the settlement
- PBS report on the settlement announcement
- Official United States Attorney statement concerning Andrew’s cooperation
- Buckingham Palace statement returning Andrew’s military affiliations and patronages
- Andrew’s October 2025 statement
- Buckingham Palace statement concerning Andrew’s styles, titles, honours, and residence
- Associated Press account of Virginia Giuffre’s life and death