Skip to main content
Print

M.J. v. Epstein, No. 9:10-cv-81111 (S.D. Fla. 2010)

Snapshot

Case name: M.J. v. Jeffrey Epstein and Sarah Kellen

Public docket caption: J. v. Epstein

Court: United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida

Docket number: 9:10-cv-81111

Filed: September 17, 2010

Terminated: December 14, 2010

Judge: United States District Judge William P. Dimitrouleas

Magistrate judge: United States Magistrate Judge Lurana S. Snow

Plaintiff: M.J., proceeding under a pseudonym

Defendants: Jeffrey Epstein and Sarah Kellen

Jurisdiction: Diversity jurisdiction, with federal and Florida claims pleaded

Nature of suit: Personal injury, other

Result: The parties entered a settlement and stipulated to dismissal with prejudice. The public docket does not disclose the settlement amount or other substantive terms.

Primary records: CourtListener docket, complaint, civil RICO case statement, and stipulation of dismissal

EFTA evidence: EFTA02821007 to EFTA02821035, complaint; EFTA02820992 to EFTA02821001, civil RICO case statement; EFTA02821558, proposed final order; and EFTA02821559 to EFTA02821560, stipulation of dismissal.

M.J. filed this civil action against Jeffrey Epstein and Sarah Kellen in September 2010. The complaint alleged that Epstein sexually abused M.J. beginning when she was 16 and that Kellen helped schedule and facilitate the encounters. M.J. alleged about 20 visits to Epstein’s Palm Beach residence from summer 2002 through approximately March 2004.

The case lasted less than three months. Most of the contested docket activity concerned whether Epstein had been properly served, requests for a protective order, and preservation of evidence. The parties settled before an answer, discovery ruling, trial, or judgment on the truth of the allegations. They stipulated to dismissal with prejudice on December 13, 2010, and the court closed the case the next day.


Why the Caption Appears in Different Forms

The complaint identifies the plaintiff as M.J. The current CourtListener docket title is J. v. Epstein. The user supplied title MJ v. Epstein refers to the same case and docket number.

The initials were used to protect the plaintiff’s identity because the complaint concerned alleged sexual offenses against her when she was a minor. EpsteinWiki preserves that pseudonym. It does not attempt to identify M.J. or connect her to any other unnamed plaintiff without a reliable public court record doing so.

The complete complaint caption named two defendants: Jeffrey Epstein and Sarah Kellen. A case title shortened to M.J. v. Epstein should not obscure Kellen’s status as a named defendant.


Parties and Counsel

M.J. was described as a Palm Beach County resident who was a minor when the alleged conduct occurred. She was represented by Bradley J. Edwards. Paul G. Cassell was later admitted to appear for her in the case.

Jeffrey Epstein was described in the complaint as a United States Virgin Islands citizen who maintained a residence at 358 El Brillo Way in Palm Beach. The docket lists Helaine S. Goodner and Lilly Ann Sanchez as his attorneys.

Sarah Kellen was described as a New York citizen and an Epstein employee. The complaint alleged that she maintained Epstein’s schedule, contacted girls, arranged transportation, greeted visitors, and escorted M.J. to the massage area. These were pleaded allegations. The short public docket does not contain a trial finding that Kellen committed the alleged acts.

The CourtListener parties and attorneys page lists Kellen as a defendant but does not show separate counsel for her.


The Complaint

M.J. filed a 29 page complaint on September 17, 2010. The filing is available through CourtListener, the CourtListener PDF, and the DOJ production preserved at EFTA02821007.

The complaint contained 113 numbered paragraphs. It combined M.J.’s personal allegations with broader allegations about Epstein’s recruitment system, employees, properties, finances, and efforts to avoid liability. Many of the broader statements were pleaded on information and belief. That phrase signals an allegation based on information available to the plaintiff rather than direct personal knowledge of every asserted fact.

The complaint alleged an amount in controversy above $15,000 and demanded a jury trial. Some claims sought compensatory damages, punitive damages, fees, and costs. Other claims requested treble damages, an accounting, asset restraints, appointment of a receiver, and a bond.

No jury heard the evidence. The settlement ended the case before the court decided whether M.J. had proved any claim or entitlement to any requested remedy.


M.J.’s Allegations

According to the complaint, M.J. was 16 and economically vulnerable when another minor told her she could earn $300 by giving an older man a massage in Palm Beach. M.J. alleged that the acquaintance telephoned Epstein and that Epstein personally asked M.J. to come to his residence.

M.J. alleged that she traveled by taxi to Epstein’s Palm Beach house. She said Kellen greeted her, escorted her upstairs, prepared a massage table in Epstein’s bathroom, showed her massage lotions, and then left her alone.

The complaint alleged that Epstein entered wearing only a towel, asked M.J. her age, and was told that she had recently turned 16. M.J. said she had no massage training. She alleged that Epstein exposed himself, touched her breasts and genital area without consent, continued after she resisted, and masturbated in her presence. The complaint said he paid her $300.

M.J. alleged that she returned to the residence approximately 20 times. She said Epstein engaged in similar sexual conduct during each visit and paid her afterward. The complaint placed the encounters from approximately August 2002 through March 2004, while acknowledging that the dates were not all documented in a diary.

M.J. further alleged that Epstein exploited her economic circumstances and offered rewards. She said he promised to buy her a computer if she graduated from high school. She alleged that he offered additional money for oral sex or intercourse and that she refused. She also said he repeatedly asked her to bring other underage girls for payment and that she refused to recruit anyone.

The complaint alleged that Epstein called M.J. directly on at least five occasions and that Kellen made approximately 15 scheduling calls. These numbers were allegations, not findings established through trial evidence.


Allegations Against Sarah Kellen

M.J. did not accuse Kellen of personally committing the physical acts attributed to Epstein. The complaint instead alleged that Kellen participated in a conspiracy and facilitated Epstein’s access to M.J.

The pleaded conduct included:

  • Contacting M.J. to schedule visits.
  • Greeting M.J. at Epstein’s residence.
  • Escorting her to the upstairs bathroom.
  • Preparing the massage table and lotions.
  • Leaving the 16 year old alone in the room where Epstein allegedly appeared.
  • Maintaining information about girls and helping conceal the operation from law enforcement.

The complaint relied partly on Kellen’s identification as a potential co-conspirator in Epstein’s federal nonprosecution agreement. That agreement protected named potential co-conspirators from federal prosecution in the Southern District of Florida. Identification in the agreement was not a criminal conviction and did not, by itself, prove civil liability in this case.

The public docket does not show that Kellen answered the complaint, filed a merits defense, or received a separate judicial ruling. She joined the stipulation that dismissed the action with prejudice.


Broader Enterprise Allegations

The complaint described an alleged enterprise centered on Epstein and supported by employees and associates. It named Kellen, Ghislaine Maxwell, Leslie Groff, Adriana Ross, Nadia Marcinkova, Jean Luc Brunel, and other staff or associates.

M.J. alleged that the system targeted underage girls, especially those with economic vulnerabilities. The complaint described a recurring method in which a girl was offered money for a massage, left alone with Epstein, paid after sexual conduct, asked to return, and offered additional money to recruit other girls.

The complaint further alleged that staff maintained scheduling and contact information, arranged transportation, and created a structure that allowed repeated access to minors while reducing the risk of detection. It alleged that modeling opportunities were sometimes used as cover or inducement.

These allegations resemble patterns later described in other civil cases and public investigations. Similarity, however, is not a substitute for adjudication. In this case, the court did not decide whether the complaint’s complete enterprise theory was true or whether every named person participated as alleged.

The complaint also included sweeping assertions concerning evidence destruction, witness pressure, charitable donations, political and social influence, blackmail, and concealment. Because the case settled early, those assertions were never tested through a merits ruling in this docket.


Claims for Relief

The complaint pleaded a large group of legal claims. The count numbering itself contains a duplication near the end, with two sections labeled Count XXV.

CountClaim as pleadedDefendant or defendants
IBatteryJeffrey Epstein
IIIntentional infliction of emotional distressJeffrey Epstein
IIIConspiracy to commit tortious assault or batterySarah Kellen
IV through XXIIISeparate federal civil claims under 18 U.S.C. Section 2255, tied to alleged violations of Sections 2422 and 2423 during approximately 20 monthly periodsJeffrey Epstein and Sarah Kellen were discussed in the federal theory, although the prayer following the counts specifically demanded judgment against Epstein
XXIVCivil remedy for criminal practices under Florida Statutes Chapter 772Jeffrey Epstein
First XXVCivil claim under Florida Statute 796.09 concerning alleged coercion into prostitutionJeffrey Epstein
Second XXVFraudulent transfer claim under Florida’s Uniform Fraudulent Transfer ActJeffrey Epstein

The federal counts alleged that M.J. was a victim of offenses listed in the federal civil remedy statute. The complaint referenced alleged use of interstate facilities to persuade, induce, or entice minors to engage in prostitution and alleged interstate travel connected to illicit sexual conduct.

The Florida Chapter 772 count presented the alleged recruitment and abuse structure as an enterprise engaged in a pattern of criminal activity. M.J. sought treble damages and related relief under that theory.

The Florida Statute 796.09 count alleged that Epstein used wealth, promises, economic pressure, and other forms of exploitation to coerce M.J. into prostitution.

The fraudulent transfer count alleged that Epstein was moving or disguising assets to frustrate M.J. and other potential creditors. It requested an accounting, avoidance of transfers, attachment, an injunction, a receiver, and a $15 million bond. These asset allegations were requests for relief, not a court finding that the described transfers were fraudulent.


The Civil RICO Case Statement

M.J. filed a ten page civil RICO case statement with the complaint. It is available through CourtListener and at EFTA02820992 to EFTA02821001.

The statement supplied additional detail for the Florida racketeering theory. It alleged participation in an enterprise through criminal activity and conspiracy under Florida Statutes Sections 772.103(3) and 772.103(4). The filing identified alleged participants, predicate conduct, victims, methods, and claimed injuries.

Filing a civil RICO statement was a procedural step required for the pleaded claim. It did not mean the court accepted the alleged enterprise, predicate acts, or damages as proven. The settlement prevented a judicial ruling on the RICO theory.


Asset Concealment Allegations

The complaint alleged that Epstein faced substantial civil exposure beginning by June 2008 and attempted to place assets beyond the reach of M.J. and other claimants. It referred to aircraft, a helicopter, cars, overseas holdings, corporations, and nominee ownership.

Specific allegations included attempted sales or transfers involving a Boeing 727, a Bell helicopter, another aircraft, a Ferrari, a Ford truck, a Land Rover, a Mercedes, and a Jaguar. The complaint named Larry Visoski in connection with several titled vehicles and entities called Shmitka Air, Inc. and JEGE, Inc.

M.J. also alleged that Epstein controlled multiple apartments at 301 East 66th Street in New York and used corporate or personal intermediaries to obscure ownership. The complaint sought extraordinary provisional remedies based on these assertions.

The docket does not show that the court ordered an accounting, froze an asset, appointed a receiver, avoided a transfer, or required the requested bond. The allegations should therefore be cited as claims in M.J.’s complaint, not as adjudicated findings about ownership or fraud.


Procedural History

DateDocket eventSignificance
September 17, 2010M.J. filed the complaint, RICO statement, civil cover sheet, and summons materialsOpened the federal civil action against Epstein and Kellen
September 21, 2010Judge Dimitrouleas ordered counsel to confer and file a joint scheduling reportRoutine early case management
October 29, 2010Epstein moved to quash service of processChallenged the method or sufficiency of service, not the merits of M.J.’s abuse allegations
November 2, 2010M.J. filed proof stating Epstein had been served on October 8Created the service dispute reflected in later filings
November 8, 2010The court denied Epstein’s first motion to quash without prejudiceAllowed the service challenge to be renewed
November 10, 2010Epstein filed a renewed motion to quashContinued the threshold service dispute
November 11, 2010M.J. opposed the motion and requested a hearing, sanctions, and accelerated discoveryM.J. disputed Epstein’s service evidence and alleged obstruction
November 11, 2010M.J. moved for a protective order and for preservation of evidenceSought limits on contact and preservation of correspondence involving the United States Attorney’s Office
November 12, 2010The court referred the pending motions to Magistrate Judge SnowAssigned management of the motions without resolving their merits
November 22, 2010Epstein filed a reply supporting the renewed motion to quashMaintained his service challenge and opposed M.J.’s requested hearing and sanctions
November 23, 2010Paul G. Cassell was admitted for M.J.Added plaintiff counsel
December 6, 2010Magistrate Judge Snow extended Epstein’s response deadline on the protective and preservation motions to December 13Set the deadline that coincided with the settlement filing
December 13, 2010The parties stipulated to dismissal with prejudiceConfirmed that they had reached a settlement
December 14, 2010Judge Dimitrouleas entered a final dismissal order and closed the caseEnded the action without a merits judgment

The complete sequence appears on the public docket.


The Service Dispute

Epstein’s principal litigated response was a challenge to service of process. His October 29 motion relied on an affidavit by Richard Barnett. A DOJ production copy of the affidavit appears at EFTA02821043. A copy of the motion appears at EFTA02821045.

The first motion was denied without prejudice. Epstein renewed the challenge on November 10. The renewed motion is preserved at EFTA02821063.

M.J. responded on November 11. She argued that service was proper, accused Epstein of submitting a fraudulent affidavit, requested a hearing and sanctions, and asked for accelerated discovery. Her response appears at EFTA02821084. Epstein denied the accusation and maintained the service challenge in a reply preserved at EFTA02821531.

The court referred the dispute to Magistrate Judge Snow. The settlement arrived before the public docket records a final ruling on the renewed motion. Nothing in the service dispute decided whether the alleged abuse occurred.


Protective Order and Evidence Preservation Motions

On November 11, M.J. filed a motion asking the court to bar direct or indirect contact by Epstein. The motion included numerous exhibits from related litigation and investigative records.

The same day, M.J. moved to preserve evidence relating to correspondence with the United States Attorney’s Office. That motion listed more than 20 attachments, including filings and correspondence from related proceedings.

Judge Dimitrouleas referred both motions to Magistrate Judge Snow. Epstein received an extension through December 13 to respond. The parties filed their settlement stipulation on that date.

The docket does not show a merits ruling granting the protective order or preservation relief. The filings remain important because they show what protection and evidence concerns M.J. raised, but a filed motion is not equivalent to a court finding.


Settlement and Dismissal

On December 13, 2010, M.J., Epstein, and Kellen filed a stipulation under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii). The stipulation stated that the action would be dismissed with prejudice.

The filing also stated:

  • Each party would bear its own attorney fees and costs.
  • The court would retain jurisdiction to enforce the settlement and an order based on it.

The stipulation is preserved at EFTA02821559 to EFTA02821560. The proposed final order appears at EFTA02821558.

Judge Dimitrouleas entered a final dismissal order on December 14 and directed the clerk to close the case.

A dismissal with prejudice ordinarily prevents the plaintiff from filing the same claims again. Here, it reflects a final settlement based resolution. It is not a finding that the allegations were true, and it is not a finding that they were false.

The public stipulation confirms the existence of a settlement but does not disclose payment, release language, confidentiality requirements, factual admissions, or other substantive terms. No reliable conclusion about the settlement amount should be drawn from this docket.


What the Case Establishes

The public record establishes that:

  • M.J. filed a federal civil complaint against Epstein and Kellen on September 17, 2010.
  • She used a pseudonym because the action concerned alleged sexual abuse while she was a minor.
  • The complaint alleged about 20 encounters beginning when M.J. was 16.
  • The complaint alleged that Kellen scheduled and facilitated visits.
  • M.J. pleaded battery, emotional distress, conspiracy, federal civil remedy, Florida racketeering, coercion, and fraudulent transfer theories.
  • Epstein contested service and opposed M.J.’s request for sanctions.
  • M.J. sought protective and evidence preservation relief.
  • All parties entered a settlement and agreed to dismissal with prejudice.
  • The court closed the case on December 14, 2010.

What the Case Does Not Establish

The case does not establish through a judgment or trial verdict that:

  • Every alleged encounter occurred exactly as pleaded.
  • Kellen knew Epstein would abuse M.J. or conspired with him.
  • Every person named in the alleged enterprise participated in unlawful conduct.
  • The federal statutory claims or Florida racketeering claim were legally or factually proven.
  • Epstein made every asset transfer alleged in the complaint.
  • Any transfer was judicially found fraudulent.
  • M.J. was awarded compensatory, punitive, or treble damages.
  • The court imposed the requested asset accounting, injunction, receiver, attachment, or $15 million bond.
  • The settlement contained an admission of liability.
  • The settlement amount was any particular figure.

Evidentiary Importance

This case is important because it provides a detailed first person civil allegation covering the period from 2002 to 2004. It also identifies Kellen as a defendant and attributes specific scheduling and facilitation acts to her.

The complaint records several details useful for cross checking other evidence: the alleged age disclosure, telephone scheduling, taxi travel, the upstairs bathroom, the massage table, $300 payments, offers tied to recruitment, the refusal to recruit others, and the approximate monthly span of visits.

The filing also preserves an early civil enterprise theory. It connected Epstein’s alleged abuse system to scheduling records, employee roles, transportation, property control, financial transfers, and efforts to avoid detection or collection.

The case later appeared as source material in broader litigation concerning institutions that allegedly enabled Epstein. That later use does not convert M.J.’s unadjudicated allegations into findings. It does show that the complaint remained relevant to attempts to reconstruct the operation and its chronology.


Privacy and Survivor Centered Handling

M.J. chose a pseudonym in a complaint addressing alleged abuse when she was 16. Her initials should not be treated as an invitation to search for or publish her identity.

The complaint contains more explicit detail than is necessary for most summaries. EpsteinWiki records the nature of the allegations and the actions attributed to each defendant without repeating every intimate detail.

Survivor centered documentation also requires precision. M.J.’s account should be presented seriously and in her own procedural context. At the same time, allegations, defense positions, court orders, and settlement facts must remain separate. This approach preserves the evidentiary value of the filing without falsely describing an early settlement as a trial finding.


Fact Check

Docket checked September 10, 2026.

StatementStatusEvidence
This is docket 9:10-cv-81111 in the Southern District of FloridaVerifiedCourtListener docket and stamped court filings
The plaintiff was identified as M.J. in the complaintVerifiedComplaint caption and paragraph 2
The public docket currently shortens the caption to J. v. EpsteinVerifiedCourtListener docket title
Epstein and Sarah Kellen were defendantsVerifiedComplaint, summons entry, parties page, and settlement stipulation
M.J. alleged abuse beginning at age 16Verified as an allegationComplaint paragraphs 24 through 44
M.J. alleged approximately 20 visitsVerified as an allegationComplaint paragraph 37 and the federal count chronology
M.J. said she refused to recruit other girlsVerified as an allegationComplaint paragraph 39
The court found Epstein and Kellen liableFalseNo merits judgment appears; the case ended by settlement and dismissal
Epstein’s first motion to quash was denied without prejudiceVerifiedDocket entry 13, November 8, 2010
The court ruled that Epstein submitted a fraudulent affidavitNot establishedM.J. made the accusation in opposition papers, but no such final finding appears
The case settledVerifiedThe parties’ stipulation expressly refers to settlement terms
The action was dismissed with prejudiceVerifiedStipulation, proposed order, and final docket entry
The settlement amount is publicNot establishedNo amount appears in the public stipulation or docket

Questions Still Unanswered

  1. What were the complete terms of the settlement among M.J., Epstein, and Kellen?
  2. Did the settlement include a payment, and if so, what amount was allocated to M.J.?
  3. Did either defendant make any factual admission outside the public stipulation?
  4. Did the agreement contain confidentiality, nondisparagement, release, or evidence preservation provisions?
  5. Did the court ever enforce or interpret the settlement under its retained jurisdiction?
  6. What records supported the complaint’s estimate of approximately 20 visits?
  7. Do telephone records, message pads, schedules, driver records, or financial records corroborate the calls and payments described by M.J.?
  8. Was M.J. included in any later federal victim identification, compensation, or notification process?
  9. What evidence supported the asset transfer allegations involving aircraft, vehicles, corporations, and nominee owners?
  10. What would the magistrate judge have concluded about service, the requested protective order, and preservation motion if the case had not settled?
  11. Why does the present CourtListener title omit M.J.’s first initial and Kellen’s name from the shortened caption?
  12. Are any settlement related filings sealed or absent from the public RECAP record?

Limitations

This article is based on the public docket, the complaint, its civil RICO attachment, selected motion papers, the stipulation, and EFTA copies available as of September 10, 2026.

The RECAP docket warns that its collection may not be complete or current. Several entries remain available only through PACER, and the public record may omit sealed or uncollected materials.

The complaint PDF is a scanned document. OCR was checked against rendered pages, but typographical errors in the original filing remain possible. The complaint itself contains inconsistent count numbering, including two sections labeled Count XXV.

No targeted Epstein sleuth Substack article focused specifically on this docket was located during the review. This absence does not mean no independent researcher has discussed M.J.’s allegations.

Most importantly, the settlement prevented adjudication. The complaint is primary evidence of what M.J. alleged, but it is not a judicial finding that every allegation was proven.


Related EpsteinWiki Pages


Sources

  1. CourtListener docket for J. v. Epstein, docket 9:10-cv-81111.
  2. Complaint, ECF No. 1, filed September 17, 2010.
  3. Complaint PDF, 29 pages.
  4. DOJ production copy of the complaint, corresponding to EFTA02821007.
  5. EFTA02821007 to EFTA02821035, complaint page range.
  6. Civil RICO case statement, ECF No. 1, Attachment 1.
  7. EFTA02820992 to EFTA02821001, civil RICO case statement.
  8. EFTA02821045, Epstein motion to quash service of process.
  9. EFTA02821063, renewed motion to quash.
  10. EFTA02821084, M.J. response to the service motion and request for hearing and sanctions.
  11. EFTA02821531, Epstein reply concerning service and M.J.’s requested relief.
  12. Stipulation of dismissal, ECF No. 27, filed December 13, 2010.
  13. Stipulation PDF.
  14. EFTA02821558, proposed final order of dismissal with prejudice.
  15. EFTA02821559 to EFTA02821560, settlement stipulation and service page.
  16. CourtListener parties and attorneys.
Previous Litigation Related to Modeling Agencies and Jeffrey Epstein
Next Mary E. Borja
Table of Contents