EFTA00005284: Inside Epstein’s “Book 5” Photo Binder of Clinton Trips, a Magazine Project and Withheld CSAM
| Field | Details |
|---|---|
| Record | EFTA00005284, a 97 page photographed binder labeled “BOOK 5” |
| Bates range | EFTA00005284 to EFTA00005380 (one Bates number per page) |
| What it is | Printed thumbnail contact sheets in plastic sleeves, photographs of CDs and DVDs, and Justice Department placeholder sheets for items that were not scanned |
| Release | U.S. Department of Justice Epstein Library, released under the Epstein Files Transparency Act; cataloged on EpsteinWiki as Data Set 3 |
| Main labels | Africa Sept. 02, Vanity Fair, Crack Whole Proposal, Hawaii, Danny Hillis Zorro, TED convention 02, Alhambra Spain 03, 727, JE 50th birthday, JE glasses Wall Street Journal |
| People named in labels | Bill Clinton, “JE” (read as Jeffrey Epstein), “GM” (read as Ghislaine Maxwell), “Les” and “Abby” (read as Les and Abigail Wexner), Danny Hillis; other names are redacted |
| Apparent time frame | Mostly 2002 and 2003, based on labels such as “Africa Sept. 02,” “Zorro Aug 2002,” “Alhambra Spain 03” and “JE 50th BD” |
| Withheld material | 12 blue “CSAM NOT SCANNED” cards with handwritten counts totaling 207 thumbnails; 6 orange “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED” cards for 7 discs |
| What it does not show | No capture data or photographer credit; only a few captions give a month or year, none of the Clinton images is dated, and nothing is a finding of wrongdoing by anyone named on a label |
| Research cutoff | November 17, 2026 |
Introduction
EFTA00005284 is one of the stranger and more important photo records in the Epstein files. It is not a single photograph. It is a photographed binder, its cover marked “BOOK 5,” that holds printed contact sheets: pages of small thumbnail images, each with a file name underneath, the way a photo editor or archivist keeps track of what is on a disc. Between the sheets sit photographs of the CDs and DVDs themselves, with handwritten titles such as “Clinton Africa/London,” “Magazine Project” and “JE pic for Wallstreet Journal.”
Why does it matter? The binder ties together, in one physical object, several threads that investigators and reporters have followed for years: Bill Clinton’s 2002 Africa trip on Epstein’s Boeing 727, Epstein’s 50th birthday, his New Mexico ranch, his private island, a “Magazine Project” filed beside a Vanity Fair label, a dinner photo labeled “JE, Abby, Les,” and a large block of images that were not scanned because scanning staff flagged them as suspected child sexual abuse material (CSAM). It appears to show how Epstein’s image was curated, retouched and stored, right next to material the government would not reproduce.
The limits matter just as much. The binder has no capture data, no photographer credit and no explanation of who assembled it or where it was seized. Many labels and faces are redacted. A file name is not proof of what a picture shows, and a person’s name on a label does not mean that person did anything wrong. This article walks through the binder page by page, separates what the record shows from what readers have inferred, and flags what is still unknown.
Key Takeaways
- EFTA00005284 is a 97 page binder labeled “BOOK 5” filled with thumbnail contact sheets and photographed discs, not individual snapshots.
- Two sections are titled for Bill Clinton’s travel: “Clinton Trips NY, LA, London” and “Clinton London/Africa,” with dozens of thumbnails captioned “Clinton, Africa, London.”
- A contact sheet titled “Magazine Project” lists 15 images marked “Finished,” including “JE & Clinton,” “The BIG plane!,” “Island.psd” and “JE, Abby, Les.” The binder’s cover also carries a “VANITY FAIR” tab.
- The government withheld 207 thumbnails behind 12 blue cards reading “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” and at least 7 discs were not scanned into this record.
- Most of the withheld thumbnails (149 of 207) sit in the final section, where every section heading is redacted.
- File names such as “Nudes,” “3nude.psd,” “showering.psd” and “girlson plane_img” appear, but their thumbnails are covered or redacted. The names alone do not establish what the images show or anyone’s age.
- Nothing in the binder is a charge or a finding against any person named on a label. Clinton has denied knowing about Epstein’s crimes.
Read the Full Record
The complete 97 page PDF is embedded below. It is large (about 45 MB) and may take a moment to load. You can also open or download EFTA00005284 directly or view it on Epstein Data.
What the Binder Is
A photo archive, not a photo album
Each page is a photograph of a sheet inside a clear plastic sleeve, with binder holes visible on the edge. The sheets are printouts from photo cataloging software. Under each thumbnail the printout lists the file name and often the file type and size, for example “8-bit RGB flat Photoshop file” or “8-bit RGB flat JPEG file, 7000×5600.” Some sheets also print the full file path. Those paths begin with “Macintosh HD:Des…” or “Scanning Mac:Des…,” and one ends in a folder whose name ends in “to burn.” In plain terms, the files sat on the desktops of Apple computers, one of them apparently named “Scanning Mac,” and at least some were staged for burning onto discs.
The working labels tell the same story. Many files end in “.psd” (Adobe Photoshop). Entries read “Retouch,” “retouche,” “Final ‘Cleaned Up’ version,” “Finished,” “Comp,” “Edit5” and “edit1.” Several images carry print resolution details such as “@ 300.00” or “@ 240.00.” This is the record of someone preparing and editing pictures, not just storing them. Who did that work is not stated anywhere in the binder.
The cover
The first page, EFTA00005284, shows a dark binder cover with typed labels pasted down its left side and a separate label reading “BOOK 5” at the bottom. Reading top to bottom, the tabs say:
- AFRICA SEPT.02
- VANITY FAIR
- CRACK WHOLE PROPOSAL
- [redacted] / HAWAII
- MISC IMAGES [redacted]
- DANNY HILLIS ZORRO
- TEDCONVENLEON 02 (as typed)
- [fully redacted tab]
- ALHAMBRA SPAIN 03
- [redacted] [redacted] 727
- JE 50TH BD
- [redacted] ZORRO
- JE GLASSES WALLSTREET JOURNAL
“Zorro” is the name of Epstein’s New Mexico ranch. “727” matches the Boeing 727 Epstein owned. “JE 50TH BD” fits Epstein’s 50th birthday in January 2003, the occasion for the 2003 birthday book. The meaning of “Crack Whole Proposal” is not explained. The same tab label appears on the cover of a different binder, EFTA00004477, which suggests the books were part of one filing system.
A numbered series
“BOOK 5” is one volume in a numbered set. Other binders in the release carry their own numbers, such as Book 16 (EFTA00004663), Book 17 (EFTA00004800) and Book 20 (EFTA00005091), according to Epstein Data’s AI-assisted deep dive on Book 17, published on Rye Howard-Stone’s research site. That report, which warns it may contain errors, describes the books as binders of contact sheets and disc photos taken from Epstein’s properties. The Book 5 record itself does not say where it was seized.
Page by Page Structure
The binder runs in labeled sections. Each section is usually a run of contact sheets followed by a placeholder card or a photo of the disc the images came from. Page numbers below are PDF pages; the Bates number is the stamp printed on that page.
| Pages and Bates | Section heading or item | What the pages show |
|---|---|---|
| p. 1, EFTA00005284 | Binder cover | Cover tabs listed above and a “BOOK 5” label. |
| p. 2, EFTA00005285 | Blue card | “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” handwritten “32 Thumbnails.” |
| p. 3, EFTA00005286 | Handwritten heading: [redacted] / Hawaii / [redacted] | Four thumbnails named DSCF0106_1.TIF to DSCF0109_1.TIF. |
| pp. 4 to 7, EFTA00005287 to EFTA00005290 | “Clinton Trips NY, LA, London…” | Four sheets of thumbnails named IMG_1339 to IMG_1415. Many faces are redacted. |
| p. 8, EFTA00005291 | Orange card | “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” description “CD x2.” |
| p. 9, EFTA00005292 | Disc photo | DVD-R handwritten “Misc High res photos.” |
| p. 10, EFTA00005293 | Disc photo | PNY CD-R with a handwritten title that includes “Clinton” and “Africa.” |
| p. 11, EFTA00005294 | Blue card | “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” “4 Thumbnails.” |
| pp. 12 to 13, EFTA00005295 to EFTA00005296 | “Misc. Images #1” | Island aerials (“Island 1.psd” to “Island 3.psd”), helicopter images (“Black Hawk.tif”), “JE and moto2,” “JE thinking,” “JE Zorro w/Dogs,” “je/gm/zorro psd co…” Several thumbnails are blacked out or covered with yellow paper. |
| p. 14, EFTA00005297 | Blue card | “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” “4 Thumbnails.” |
| pp. 15 to 16, EFTA00005298 to EFTA00005299 | “Misc. Images 2” | “Zorro Aug 2002,” “GM Columbia Retouc…,” “GM JE Ski,” “GM213.psd,” “GMandkevin-1.psd,” “girlson plane_img” (redacted), and five files captioned “Nudes” (covered). |
| p. 17, EFTA00005300 | Blue card | “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” “18 Thumbnails.” |
| pp. 18 to 21, EFTA00005301 to EFTA00005304 | “Misc. Images 2” continued | “Group Shot Africa,” “Gulf Stream Plane,” thumbnails captioned “Clinton, Morocco,” “and Clinton.jpg,” “showering.psd,” “Zorro picnic” files, “Zorro Final 2.psd,” and family portrait files. |
| p. 22, EFTA00005305 | Orange card | “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” “CD.” |
| p. 23, EFTA00005306 | Disc photo | DVD-R “Misc Images 2.” |
| pp. 24 to 27, EFTA00005307 to EFTA00005310 | “Clinton London/Africa” | Four sheets; nearly every thumbnail is captioned “Clinton, Africa, London.” Files DSCF0046 to DSCF0054, IMG_1164, IMG_1339 to IMG_1406 and IMG_1837. |
| p. 28, EFTA00005311 | Orange card | “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” “CD.” |
| p. 29, EFTA00005312 | Disc photo | PNY CD-R handwritten “Clinton Africa/London.” |
| p. 30, EFTA00005313 | “Magazine Project” | 15 thumbnails, each marked “Finished.” Detailed below. |
| p. 31, EFTA00005314 | “Scans” | A second printout of the same 15 “Finished” images. |
| p. 32, EFTA00005315 | Orange card | “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” “CD.” |
| p. 33, EFTA00005316 | Disc photo | PNY CD-R titled “Magazine Project,” with the note “Home, plane, island, GM, JE shots.” |
| pp. 34 to 42, EFTA00005317 to EFTA00005325 | “[redacted] Clinton & pilots, ted conven.” | Nine sheets of larger thumbnails, including “JE.jpg” and “MAX.JPG.” Many images are blacked out. |
| p. 43, EFTA00005326 | Orange card | “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” “CD.” |
| p. 44, EFTA00005327 | Disc photo | Memorex CD-R “Clinton & pilots,” a redacted line, and “JE pic for Wallstreet Journal.” |
| pp. 45 to 59, EFTA00005328 to EFTA00005342 | “Alhambra, [redacted] in Heli, misc” | Alhambra00 to Alhambra91, a numbered series beginning “on 72700,” helicopter files “Heli0” to “Heli5,” “JE 50 Bday0” to “JE 50 Bday7,” and “Max 2” to “Max 7.” |
| p. 60, EFTA00005343 | Orange card | “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” “CD.” |
| p. 61, EFTA00005344 | Disc photo | Apple DVD-R with “Alhambra,” a redacted name with “in Heli,” “JE 50 Bday” and “Max in snow.” |
| pp. 62 to 63, EFTA00005345 to EFTA00005346 | Blue cards | “54 Thumbnails” and “12 Thumbnails.” |
| pp. 64 to 96, EFTA00005347 to EFTA00005379 | Headings fully redacted | Image series named EC3T1487 to EC3T3794 (TIF), IMG_3728 to IMG_3972 (JPG) and “Manu” files, interrupted by five more blue cards. Most faces are redacted. |
| p. 97, EFTA00005380 | Blue card | “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” “3 Thumbnails.” |
The Bill Clinton Material
What the labels say
Clinton’s name appears more than any other name in the binder’s visible text. Two section headings are built around his travel: “Clinton Trips NY, LA, London…” (EFTA00005287 to EFTA00005290) and “Clinton London/Africa” (EFTA00005307 to EFTA00005310). On the second set, almost every thumbnail carries the caption “Clinton, Africa, London.” Two discs carry his name in handwriting, and a third is labeled “Clinton & pilots.” Other entries read “JE & Clinton,” “and Clinton.jpg” and “Clinton, Morocco.”
The binder’s first tab reads “AFRICA SEPT.02.” That matches the most documented trip Clinton took on Epstein’s plane. FactCheck.org’s timeline puts Clinton’s departure on a nine day Africa trip on September 21, 2002, with actors Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker, visiting Ghana, Nigeria, Rwanda, Mozambique and South Africa. Juliette Bryant has publicly said she met Epstein in Cape Town in 2002 during that same trip.
What the binder adds
Several Clinton images from the Epstein files were widely published after the Justice Department’s December 19, 2025 release. The Associated Press reported that the files did not say when the photos were taken and offered little context. Book 5 supplies some of that missing context in the form of organization: someone filed Clinton travel images under trip names, burned them to labeled discs and kept them in a numbered binder alongside Epstein’s own portraits, ranch pictures and editing projects. What the binder does not supply is a date on any Clinton image, a list of who else is pictured (most other faces are redacted) or an explanation of why the images were kept.
Clinton’s response
In July 2019, Clinton spokesman Angel Ureña said Clinton took four trips on Epstein’s plane between 2002 and 2003, one to Europe, one to Asia and two to Africa, tied to Clinton Foundation work, and that Clinton knew nothing about Epstein’s crimes. House Oversight Chair James Comer later claimed the committee had evidence that Clinton flew on Epstein’s plane 27 times. At his February 27, 2026 deposition, Clinton said, “I saw nothing, and I did nothing wrong.” After the December 2025 release, Ureña dismissed the pictures as “grainy 20-plus-year-old photos.” Clinton has not been charged with any crime connected to Epstein. See EpsteinWiki’s coverage of photographic evidence of Bill Clinton in the Epstein files and Clinton’s 2026 deposition.
The “Magazine Project” and the Vanity Fair Tab
What the sheet shows
Page 30 (EFTA00005313) is a printed contact sheet titled “Magazine,” with the word “Project” added by hand. It holds 15 thumbnails, each marked “Finished.” Page 31 (EFTA00005314), headed “Scans,” repeats the same set. The disc photographed on page 33 is titled “Magazine Project,” with the note “Home, plane, island, GM, JE shots.”
| File name on the sheet | Status printed | What the thumbnail appears to show |
|---|---|---|
| GM Columbia Retouc… (“Final ‘Cleaned Up’ version”) | Finished | A woman outdoors |
| JE & Clinton | Finished | Two men talking |
| JE Dog group photo | Finished | A man with large dogs in a field |
| jemotor.psd | Finished | A man and a woman on a motorcycle |
| The BIG plane! | Finished | A large jet on a runway |
| JE in red fleece | Finished | A man in sunglasses and a red jacket |
| Office 2 Comp.psd | Finished | An ornate interior |
| Small office 1 comp… | Finished | A book lined room |
| Interior.psd | Finished | A formal room |
| Dining Room Comp.p… | Finished | A formal dining room |
| Zorro Great Hall.psd | Finished | A large hall |
| JE, Abby, Les | Finished | Three people at a formal dinner table |
| Zorro ariel #1 | Finished | An aerial view of a large building |
| plane.psd | Finished | A smaller jet on a runway |
| Island.psd | Finished | An island with buildings |
The descriptions in the third column describe what is visible in small thumbnails. They do not identify anyone; the identifications come only from the file names.
Why readers connect it to Vanity Fair
The binder’s second tab reads “VANITY FAIR.” In March 2003, Vanity Fair published Vicky Ward’s profile “The Talented Mr. Epstein,” a copy of which appears in the files at EFTA01361574. In a 2019 interview with NPR, Ward said editor Graydon Carter told her there had been a sort of barter: the magazine needed photographs, and Carter had gotten Epstein to provide some. Carter has disputed Ward’s account of how her story was edited and said he lacked confidence in her reporting, as Mediaite reported.
Put together, a “Vanity Fair” tab, a “Magazine Project” of finished home, plane, island, “GM” and “JE” shots, and Ward’s account of Epstein supplying photographs make a strong reason to think this sheet is the image package for a magazine feature. That link is an inference. The binder never names the magazine on the sheet itself, and this research did not confirm which, if any, of these 15 images were printed.
“JE, Abby, Les”
One finished image is labeled “JE, Abby, Les.” Readers will recognize the names of Les Wexner, the retail billionaire who was Epstein’s most important client, and his wife Abigail Wexner. The thumbnail shows three people at a formal dinner table. The label is the only identification, and the binder gives no date or place. If the label is accurate, the image places Epstein at a social dinner with both Wexners and shows that the picture was chosen and finished for a magazine package about Epstein’s world. Wexner has said he did not know of Epstein’s crimes; see his February 2026 statement to the House Oversight Committee and our Sleuth Report on Abigail Wexner.
Ghislaine Maxwell, Zorro Ranch and the Island
The abbreviation “GM” appears on many files: “GM Columbia Retouc…,” “GM JE Ski,” “gm-1.psd,” “GM213.psd,” “GM379.JPG,” “GM386.JPG” and “GM388.JPG” (each captioned 2002 on the sheet), “GMandkevin-1.psd” and “je/gm/zorro psd co…” The binder never spells out “GM.” Most readers take it to mean Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein’s longtime companion who was convicted in 2021 of sex trafficking. That reading fits the context but is an inference. “Kevin” in “GMandkevin” is not identified, and EpsteinWiki does not assign it to any person.
Zorro Ranch, Epstein’s New Mexico property, runs through the binder: “Zorro Aug 2002,” “Zorro picnic2” to “Zorro picnic4,” “Zorro Final 2.psd,” “ZORRO2.psd,” “Zorro Great Hall,” “Zorro ariel #1” and “JE Zorro w/Dogs.” The Zorro Ranch Photographs index lists this binder and warns that it mixes projects, previews and edited files, and that the “DANNY HILLIS ZORRO” tab does not identify anyone pictured at the ranch. Danny Hillis is a computer scientist known for Thinking Machines; the tab is a folder title only.
Island images include aerials titled “Island 1.psd,” “Island 2.psd,” “Island 3.psd” and “Island.psd.” The shape matches published aerials of Little Saint James, but the binder does not name the island.
The Alhambra, the Helicopter and the 50th Birthday
The longest labeled section, 15 sheets from EFTA00005328 to EFTA00005342, is headed “Alhambra, [redacted] in Heli, misc.” The cover tab “ALHAMBRA SPAIN 03” points to the Alhambra palace in Granada, Spain, in 2003. The sheets include about 90 numbered Alhambra files, six “Heli” images taken inside a helicopter, a numbered series beginning “on 72700,” eight files named “JE 50 Bday” and six named “Max,” which the matching disc describes as “Max in snow.” The name of the person “in Heli” is redacted on the section’s first page and on the disc, and EpsteinWiki does not name this person. The file paths show these images sat on a disk named “Scanning Mac.”
The “JE 50 Bday” files fit Epstein’s 50th birthday on January 20, 2003. They are thumbnails only, and most faces are redacted. For the written tributes collected for the same birthday, see Ellie Leonard’s full transcription of the birthday book.
Withheld Material: The CSAM Cards and Unscanned Discs
What the blue cards are
Twelve pages in the binder are not images at all. They are teal blue sheets that read “CSAM NOT SCANNED,” with a handwritten count and the footer “Official DocLab Instruction(s), Revised March 10th, 2025.” DocLab is the FBI’s document scanning unit. FBI emails released in the files describe the practice: in July 2019, an FBI records employee reported that some pornographic images of young girls in the case files were not imaged, and that a DocLab kick sheet marked “possible child pornography, DO NOT SCAN” was left in their place, with the originals kept where they were (EFTA00147819; EFTA00101087). The cards in Book 5 use a 2025 revision of those instructions, which indicates this binder was processed for scanning in 2025 or later.
A card is a handling label. It records that the people scanning the binder treated those thumbnails as suspected child sexual abuse material and did not copy them. It is not a court finding about any specific image, and the public cannot see what was withheld.
The count
| Card (Bates) | PDF page | Handwritten count | Section it interrupts |
|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA00005285 | 2 | 32 Thumbnails | Opening section after the cover |
| EFTA00005294 | 11 | 4 Thumbnails | Before “Misc. Images #1” |
| EFTA00005297 | 14 | 4 Thumbnails | Between “Misc. Images #1” and “Misc. Images 2” |
| EFTA00005300 | 17 | 18 Thumbnails | Inside “Misc. Images 2” |
| EFTA00005345 | 62 | 54 Thumbnails | Start of the final, unlabeled section |
| EFTA00005346 | 63 | 12 Thumbnails | Final section |
| EFTA00005357 | 74 | 2 Thumbnails | Final section |
| EFTA00005360 | 77 | 54 Thumbnails | Final section |
| EFTA00005361 | 78 | 16 Thumbnails | Final section |
| EFTA00005368 | 85 | 1 Thumbnail | Final section |
| EFTA00005377 | 94 | 7 Thumbnails | Final section |
| EFTA00005380 | 97 | 3 Thumbnails | End of the binder |
| Total | 12 cards | 207 thumbnails | 58 in the opening sections, 149 in the final section |
This count matches EpsteinWiki’s CSAM label audit, which lists the same 12 cards and the same 207 total for this PDF.
The final section
The last 36 pages (EFTA00005345 to EFTA00005380) are the most heavily restricted part of the binder. Every section heading is blacked out. The visible sheets carry only file numbers, mostly an “EC3T” series of TIF files and a run of IMG_37xx to IMG_39xx JPEG files, with faces redacted. Eight of the twelve CSAM cards, covering 149 of the 207 withheld thumbnails, fall in this stretch. EpsteinWiki does not describe the people in these images, because they may be survivors and the government has redacted their identities.
Unscanned discs
Six orange sheets read “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED,” each with the description “CD” (one says “CD x2”), on the form “Official DocLab Instruction(s), Revised July 27, 2020.” A photo of a labeled disc follows each of them. That means at least seven discs were photographed but their contents were not scanned into this record. The public sees the disc labels and the printed thumbnails, not the full image files.
Covered and redacted file names
Some thumbnails are covered by blank yellow paper inside the sleeves, and others are blacked out. On EFTA00005299, five covered thumbnails are captioned “Nudes,” and the same sheet lists “girlson plane_img,” an 8-bit JPEG of 7000 by 5600 pixels whose thumbnail is blacked out. Other sheets list “3nude.psd” and “showering.psd.” These names are disturbing in a binder that also holds CSAM cards. Still, the file name is the only visible information. The record does not show what these images depict or the age of anyone in them, and these particular thumbnails were redacted rather than replaced with a CSAM card.
Chronology
| Date | Documented Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| August 2002 | Files captioned “Zorro Aug 2002” appear in “Misc. Images 2.” | EFTA00005299, p. 16 |
| September 21, 2002 | Clinton leaves on a nine day Africa trip with Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker; the binder’s first tab reads “AFRICA SEPT.02.” | FactCheck.org; EFTA00005284 |
| 2002 | “TEDCONVENLEON 02” tab and “Clinton & pilots, ted conven.” sheets. | EFTA00005284; EFTA00005317 to EFTA00005325 |
| January 20, 2003 | Epstein turns 50; the binder holds “JE 50 Bday” files and a “JE 50TH BD” tab. | EFTA00005284; EFTA00005334 to EFTA00005335 |
| March 2003 | Vanity Fair publishes “The Talented Mr. Epstein”; the binder has a “VANITY FAIR” tab and a “Magazine Project.” | EFTA01361574; EFTA00005313 |
| 2003 | “ALHAMBRA SPAIN 03” tab and the “Alhambra” section. | EFTA00005284; EFTA00005328 to EFTA00005342 |
| July 2019 | FBI records staff report that suspected child sexual abuse images in the case files were not scanned and were marked with DocLab kick sheets. | EFTA00147819 |
| July 27, 2020 | Revision date printed on the orange “ITEM WAS NOT SCANNED” sheets. | EFTA00005291 and others |
| March 10, 2025 | Revision date printed on the blue “CSAM NOT SCANNED” cards. | EFTA00005285 and others |
| December 19, 2025 | The Justice Department begins releasing Epstein files, including many Clinton photos with little context. | Associated Press via Star Tribune |
| February 27, 2026 | Clinton is deposed by the House Oversight Committee and says he saw nothing and did nothing wrong. | Associated Press via CFJC Today |
Evidence Appearances
| Record or ID | Date | What It Shows | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| EFTA00005284 (cover) | Undated | “BOOK 5” binder cover with 13 tab labels. | Epstein Data |
| EFTA00005287 to EFTA00005290 | Undated | “Clinton Trips NY, LA, London…” contact sheets. | Epstein Data, pp. 4 to 7 |
| EFTA00005295 to EFTA00005304 | 2002 on some captions | “Misc. Images” sheets: island, ranch, “GM” and “JE” files, “Clinton, Morocco” captions, covered “Nudes” files. | Epstein Data, pp. 12 to 21 |
| EFTA00005307 to EFTA00005310 | Undated | “Clinton London/Africa” sheets captioned “Clinton, Africa, London.” | Epstein Data, pp. 24 to 27 |
| EFTA00005313 and EFTA00005314 | Undated | “Magazine Project” and “Scans” sheets of 15 finished images. | Epstein Data, pp. 30 to 31 |
| EFTA00005316 | Undated | Disc titled “Magazine Project: Home, plane, island, GM, JE shots.” | Epstein Data, p. 33 |
| EFTA00005317 to EFTA00005327 | Undated | “Clinton & pilots, ted conven.” sheets and a disc noting “JE pic for Wallstreet Journal.” | Epstein Data, pp. 34 to 44 |
| EFTA00005328 to EFTA00005344 | 2003 on the cover tab | “Alhambra” section, helicopter files, “JE 50 Bday” files, and the matching DVD. | Epstein Data, pp. 45 to 61 |
| 12 blue cards, EFTA00005285 to EFTA00005380 | Form revised March 10, 2025 | 207 thumbnails withheld as suspected CSAM. | Epstein Data; CSAM label audit |
| EFTA00004477 | Undated | A different binder cover that repeats the “CRACK WHOLE PROPOSAL” tab. | Epstein Data |
| EFTA00004800 | Undated | “Book 17,” a companion binder of contact sheets and disc photos. | Epstein Data |
| EFTA00147819 | June to July 2019 | FBI email chain on DocLab “possible child pornography, DO NOT SCAN” kick sheets. | Epstein Data |
| EFTA00101087 | 2019 to 2020 | Follow up chain on locating the kick sheets and on copying discs. | Epstein Data |
| EFTA01361574 | March 2003 | Copy of Vicky Ward’s Vanity Fair profile. | Epstein Data |
Competing Interpretations
A publicity archive. Much of the binder looks like the working files of someone managing Epstein’s image: retouched portraits, “Finished” interiors, planes, the island and a “Magazine Project.” On this reading, Book 5 is an archive of how Epstein presented himself to the press and to powerful friends.
An evidence trail. The same binder holds 207 withheld thumbnails flagged as suspected CSAM, covered “Nudes” files and a heavily redacted final section. On this reading, the binder shows that publicity material and material flagged as suspected abuse were stored side by side in one filing system, which raises hard questions about who assembled it and who had access.
Both can be true. The record supports both descriptions at once. It does not, by itself, connect any named public figure to the withheld images.
A note on outside catalogs. An Epstein Data overview report lists the “girlsonplane_img” file under the heading “CSAM Confirmed.” EpsteinWiki does not adopt that label. On the page where the file name appears, its thumbnail is blacked out rather than replaced with a CSAM card, and nothing visible confirms what the image shows. That report also calls the file a Photoshop file, while the sheet describes it as a JPEG. Epstein Data remains the most useful public tool for working with this binder, and its own pages warn that AI generated reports may contain errors.
What the Evidence Does and Does Not Establish
| Claim | Status | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| The binder is labeled “BOOK 5” and holds contact sheets, disc photos and placeholder cards. | Established | Visible on every page. |
| It contains sections titled for Clinton trips to New York, Los Angeles, London and Africa. | Established | Printed section headings and captions. |
| Its “AFRICA SEPT.02” material relates to Clinton’s September 2002 Africa trip on Epstein’s plane. | Strongly inferred | Matching tab, captions and documented trip dates. |
| The “Magazine Project” is the photo package for Vanity Fair’s 2003 profile. | Inferred | “VANITY FAIR” tab plus Ward’s account that Epstein supplied photographs; no publication match confirmed. |
| “JE, Abby, Les” shows Epstein with Les and Abigail Wexner. | Inferred from the label | File name only; no date or place. |
| “GM” means Ghislaine Maxwell. | Inferred | Context; never spelled out. |
| 207 thumbnails were withheld as suspected CSAM. | Established as a handling decision | Twelve DocLab cards with handwritten counts. |
| Any named public figure appears in the withheld images. | Unproven | Nothing in the record says so. |
| Who assembled the binder and where it was seized. | Unknown | Not stated in the record. |
Unresolved Questions
- Who made these contact sheets and burned the discs, and on whose computers, including the one labeled “Scanning Mac”?
- Where was Book 5 seized, and when did investigators first collect it?
- Which, if any, of the 15 “Magazine Project” images ran in Vanity Fair or elsewhere?
- What was the “Crack Whole Proposal,” and why does the same tab appear on another binder?
- What is “JE glasses Wall Street Journal,” and was a photo supplied to that newspaper?
- Who are the people in the redacted section headings and the redacted tab labels?
- What do the seven unscanned discs contain, and have investigators reviewed them in full?
- Who is depicted in the 207 withheld thumbnails, and were those images ever investigated as evidence of a crime?
Conclusion
EFTA00005284 is a filing cabinet in binder form. It shows that pictures of Epstein’s homes, planes, island, ranch, birthday and famous companions were organized, retouched, marked “Finished” and burned to labeled discs, with Bill Clinton’s travels given their own sections and a “Magazine Project” filed beside a Vanity Fair tab. It also shows that the same binder held 207 thumbnails that were not scanned because scanning staff flagged them as suspected child sexual abuse material, most of them in a final section whose headings are entirely blacked out.
The binder does not tell us who built it, where it was found, what the withheld images show or what any named person knew. Those are the questions it leaves for investigators, Congress and the public. What it proves is narrower and still important: Epstein’s polished public image and material that scanning staff flagged as suspected child sexual abuse material were kept in the same place.
Questions and Answers
What is EFTA00005284?
It is a 97 page Justice Department record showing a binder labeled “BOOK 5.” The binder holds printed thumbnail contact sheets, photos of CDs and DVDs, and government placeholder cards for material that was not scanned.
Does this binder show Bill Clinton doing anything illegal?
No. It contains sections titled for Clinton’s trips and thumbnails captioned with his name. Appearing in a photo archive is not evidence of a crime, and Clinton has denied knowing about Epstein’s crimes.
What does “CSAM NOT SCANNED” mean?
CSAM stands for child sexual abuse material. The cards mark spots where the FBI’s scanning unit did not copy thumbnails because they were flagged as suspected CSAM. In this binder, 12 cards account for 207 thumbnails.
Is the “Magazine Project” the Vanity Fair photo shoot?
It may be. The binder has a “VANITY FAIR” tab, and Vicky Ward said her editor told her Epstein supplied photographs for her 2003 profile. No published photo has been matched to these files, so the link is not confirmed.
Are Les and Abigail Wexner in this binder?
One finished image is labeled “JE, Abby, Les” and shows three people at a dinner table. The label is the only identification, and the binder gives no date or place.
Why are so many faces and labels blacked out?
The Justice Department redacted victims’ names and identifying details before release. Some redactions may also cover private people. EpsteinWiki does not try to identify anyone behind a redaction.
Where can I see the original?
The full PDF is embedded near the top of this article and is also available on Epstein Data at EFTA00005284.
Sources
- EFTA00005284, Book 5 binder (Epstein Data viewer)
- U.S. Department of Justice, Epstein Library: DOJ Disclosures
- EFTA00147819, FBI DocLab scanning email chain, 2019
- EFTA00101087, FBI and SDNY follow up on kick sheets, 2019 to 2020
- EFTA00004477, binder cover with “Crack Whole Proposal” tab
- EFTA01361574, copy of “The Talented Mr. Epstein,” Vanity Fair, March 2003
- Epstein Data, deep dive on Book 17 (EFTA00004800)
- Epstein Data, “Everything We Had After Two Weeks,” February 2026
- NPR, interview with Vicky Ward, 2019
- Mediaite, Ward and Carter dispute over the 2003 profile
- FactCheck.org, Clinton and Epstein travel timeline
- Yahoo News, Clinton spokesman statement, July 2019
- Associated Press via Star Tribune, Clinton photos in the December 2025 release
- ABC7 New York, Ureña statement, December 2025
- Associated Press via CFJC Today, Clinton deposition, February 27, 2026
- EpsteinWiki, Epstein Files CSAM Label Audit
- EpsteinWiki, Zorro Ranch Photographs index