Skip to main content
Print

EFTA00808054: Alan Dershowitz “Off the Record” Response Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

Snapshot

FieldDetails
Document identifierEFTA00808054
Complete page rangeEFTA00808054 through EFTA00808068
Length15 pages
Record typeAnnotated response to numbered journalistic questions or draft assertions
Apparent respondentAlan Dershowitz
Apparent dateJuly 2019
Exact date shownNot visible in the released pages
Sender and recipientNot identified on the face of the record
Opening heading“CONTINUATION OF OFF THE RECORD”
Central subjectsJeffrey Epstein, Alan Dershowitz, Harvard, the Palm Beach investigation, the federal non prosecution agreement, survivor allegations, and Dershowitz’s denials
Primary sourceDOJ released document
Evidentiary statusA party response containing admissions, denials, assertions, and legal positioning
Related publication“Alan Dershowitz, Devil’s Advocate,” The New Yorker, July 29, 2019

EFTA00808054 preserves a remarkable exercise in narrative control. Sixty two numbered propositions describe Jeffrey Epstein’s history, his relationship with Alan Dershowitz, the Palm Beach investigation, the defense campaign, survivor allegations, and disputed encounters. Capitalized responses attributed to Dershowitz confirm some propositions, revise others, and categorically reject many allegations.

The document is significant because Dershowitz does more than issue a blanket denial. He acknowledges a friendship with Epstein beginning in 1996, participation in Epstein’s intellectual and Harvard circles, work as a member of Epstein’s defense team, meetings with state and federal prosecutors, multiple visits to Epstein’s Palm Beach residence, one visit to Little St. James, and his willingness to continue taking Epstein’s calls.

At the same time, Dershowitz denies sexual contact with any Epstein survivor, denies seeing underage girls at Epstein’s homes, denies directing private investigators, denies involvement in surveillance of police or prosecutors, denies negotiating protection for potential co conspirators, and disputes several accounts of his role in Epstein’s defense.

The result is not a judicial finding and not an independent investigation. It is a detailed statement of Dershowitz’s position at a moment when a major magazine was preparing to examine his relationship with Epstein.


What Is This Record?

The released record begins with the heading “CONTINUATION OF OFF THE RECORD.” It then presents numbered statements followed by responses written in capital letters and in the first person.

The structure strongly suggests that a journalist or fact checker sent a list of proposed assertions to Dershowitz for comment before publication. The responses appear to have been inserted directly beneath the corresponding assertions.

The record does not include the beginning of the exchange. It starts with the word “CONTINUATION,” which indicates that at least one preceding section or communication existed. It also lacks visible email headers, letterhead, a signature, a recipient, and a precise creation date.

A comparison with Connie Bruck’s July 2019 New Yorker profile shows substantial overlap in subjects, sequence, wording, and reported incidents. It is therefore reasonable to infer that the document formed part of the reporting or fact checking process for that article. The released pages themselves do not expressly identify Bruck or The New Yorker, so that connection must remain labeled as an inference.


Source and Provenance

The public copy consists of pages EFTA00808054 through EFTA00808068. It was released within the federal Epstein records production and can be reviewed through the Epstein Data document viewer or as the complete PDF.

The public archive establishes that the federal government possessed and produced the record. Government production does not independently authenticate every factual assertion contained inside it.

Several limitations affect interpretation:

  • The first portion of the communication is missing from this item.
  • No visible sender, recipient, or transmission information appears.
  • No exact creation date appears on the released pages.
  • The pages do not explain who typed the capitalized responses.
  • Some names remain redacted.
  • OCR errors affect spelling, punctuation, and paragraph numbering.
  • Several questions summarize disputed allegations rather than established facts.
  • The heading “off the record” describes an asserted journalistic status. It does not by itself establish a binding confidentiality agreement, attorney client privilege, or any other legal protection.

The safest description is therefore: a government produced copy of an apparent prepublication response attributed to Alan Dershowitz.


What the Record Contains

ParagraphsPrincipal subjectNature of Dershowitz’s response
1 through 10Introduction to Epstein, Leslie Wexner, wealth management, and an investment involving Orin KramerConfirms parts of the relationship while disputing details of the investment meeting
11 through 18Epstein’s parties, Harvard relationships, academic introductions, donations, and disputes involving scholarsConfirms intellectual contact and seminars while denying that he introduced Epstein broadly around Harvard
19 through 28Survivor accounts, household conditions, recruitment allegations, surveillance claims, and the Palm Beach investigationChallenges allegations and offers a contrary account of surveillance cameras
29 through 42Dershowitz’s legal role, investigative tactics, prosecutors, the non prosecution agreement, and Epstein’s pleaAdmits legal work and prosecutor meetings while denying leadership, investigative control, and involvement in the potential co conspirator provision
43 through 53Civil claims involving Epstein, Maxwell, and women whose names are redactedRejects allegations involving Dershowitz
54 through 59Alleged encounters at Epstein properties and claims of sexual conductIssues categorical denials and provides alternative accounts of visits and a massage
60 through 62Continuing representation, communications with Epstein, and a possible joint defense agreement with MaxwellConfirms becoming Epstein’s lawyer and willingness to take his calls while denying that a joint defense agreement with Maxwell was completed
Final statementCredibility of two women and the proposed articleAttacks their credibility and characterizes the proposed account as false

The numbered format makes the document unusually useful for distinguishing what Dershowitz admitted from what he denied. It also demonstrates how extensively the response attempted to revise individual details before publication.


Key Evidence and Admissions

Relationship With Epstein

Dershowitz states that his discussions with Epstein focused on science, academia, and Harvard. He describes the relationship as “largely academic and then legal.”

He does not dispute that he met Epstein in 1996 or that the two developed common interests. He confirms sending Epstein drafts of several books and says Epstein provided thoughtful comments. He also confirms participating in Epstein connected seminars with professors.

These statements establish a sustained personal, intellectual, and later professional relationship. They do not establish participation in Epstein’s crimes.

Harvard and Academic Access

The questions describe Dershowitz introducing Epstein to people around Harvard. Dershowitz rejects that characterization and states that Stephen Jay Gould and Marvin Minsky had introduced Epstein to academics. He says Epstein introduced him to Harvard figures he had not previously met, including George Church and Martin Nowak.

Dershowitz confirms participating in seminars and acknowledges his connection to the academic environment Epstein cultivated.

This portion belongs within the broader record of Epstein’s use of Harvard University as a source of prestige, access, and intellectual credibility.

Work for Epstein’s Defense

Dershowitz confirms that he became Epstein’s lawyer shortly after the Palm Beach investigation began. He states that he helped assemble the legal team but was not its lead lawyer.

He describes his work as follows:

  • Writing legal memoranda.
  • Meeting with the Palm Beach state attorney.
  • Meeting with members of the United States Attorney’s Office in Miami.
  • Participating in negotiations.
  • Presenting information collected by investigators to prosecutors and police.

Dershowitz denies personally preparing investigative dossiers, hiring investigators, directing investigators, conducting background searches, or participating in surveillance.

The distinction is important. He acknowledges using investigative material during negotiations while denying responsibility for commissioning or controlling the work that produced it.

Material About Young Witnesses

The questions describe a dossier containing social media material about girls and young women who accused Epstein. Dershowitz denies personally preparing or directing the dossier. However, he acknowledges forwarding research performed by investigators to law enforcement and prosecutors.

He characterizes this as part of his responsibility as Epstein’s attorney to present potentially exculpatory information.

That admission does not prove that he selected, commissioned, or endorsed every investigative tactic. It does establish that he used at least some of the resulting material in advocacy for Epstein.

The Non Prosecution Agreement

The record discusses the 2007 federal non prosecution agreement, including its protection for “any potential co conspirators.”

Dershowitz states that he had no role in negotiating that provision and no personal interest in it. He claims that he understood the language to be intended to protect young women who had brought friends to Epstein.

The document provides Dershowitz’s explanation. It does not contain negotiation drafts, attorney correspondence, prosecutor notes, or testimony independently proving who requested the provision.

Visits to Epstein Properties

Dershowitz acknowledges visiting Epstein’s Palm Beach residence on several occasions. He identifies visits involving his nephew, a research assistant, and members of his family. He also describes additional visits for professional or academic purposes.

He acknowledges one visit to Little St. James with his wife and daughter. He says the visit occurred before the period associated with the allegations and that they spent one night in a cottage.

These are direct admissions of presence at Epstein properties. Presence does not establish criminal conduct.

Massage at the Palm Beach Residence

The record asks whether Dershowitz received a massage at Epstein’s Palm Beach home while keeping his underwear on. His response is “CORRECT.”

Elsewhere he describes the masseuse as an older Russian woman and says he refused a maneuver involving her knees on his shoulders. He states that he called his wife afterward and decided not to receive another massage at Epstein’s house.

The document establishes Dershowitz’s own account that he received one massage at the Palm Beach property. It does not independently establish the masseuse’s identity, age, or the complete circumstances.

Continuing Contact

Dershowitz confirms becoming Epstein’s lawyer after the investigation began. When asked whether he would always take Epstein’s call, he responds “CORRECT.”

This is evidence of a continuing legal or personal channel of communication. It does not establish how frequently they communicated or what was discussed.


Principal Denials and Disputed Claims

Dershowitz denies:

  • Engaging in sexual conduct with any woman identified in the questions.
  • Meeting two women whose names are redacted in the released copy.
  • Entering Epstein’s bedroom.
  • Using Epstein’s bedroom.
  • Receiving a massage from a young woman.
  • Seeing underage girls at Epstein’s residences.
  • Seeing nude girls at Epstein’s pool.
  • Directing the preparation of dossiers about witnesses.
  • Hiring or directing investigators.
  • Arranging background investigations of Palm Beach police officials.
  • Participating in surveillance, trash searches, or contacts with a police official’s former wife.
  • Investigating prosecutors or their families.
  • Negotiating immunity for potential co conspirators.
  • Having a completed joint defense agreement with Ghislaine Maxwell.
  • Representing one woman in an unrelated attempted rape matter.
  • Discouraging that woman from reporting an alleged crime.

These are denials, not adjudicated findings. They should be reported in full whenever the corresponding allegations are discussed.


People and Institutions Named

Person or institutionRole in the record
Alan DershowitzApparent respondent, Epstein lawyer, Harvard professor, and subject of disputed allegations
Jeffrey EpsteinConvicted sex offender, Dershowitz client, social acquaintance, and central subject
Ghislaine MaxwellEpstein associate referenced in survivor accounts and the joint defense agreement question
Leslie WexnerEpstein client and early connection in the Dershowitz relationship narrative
Harvard UniversityAcademic institution central to Epstein’s prestige network
Martin NowakHarvard academic associated with Epstein funded research
George ChurchHarvard scientist whom Dershowitz says Epstein introduced to him
Stephen KosslynHarvard professor identified in Epstein’s academic circle
Lawrence SummersFormer Harvard president referenced in the academic history
Orin KramerInvestment manager connected to the disputed investment account
Barry KrischerPalm Beach state attorney during the original investigation
Joseph RecareyPalm Beach detective who led important parts of the investigation
Michael ReiterPalm Beach police chief referenced in allegations concerning investigative pressure
Ghislaine Maxwell’s attorneysReferenced in connection with sealed litigation material
The New YorkerProbable recipient or intended publisher, based on comparison with the final 2019 article
Connie BruckAuthor of the 2019 New Yorker profile that closely tracks the questions

Names redacted by the government should not be reconstructed solely from context. Public litigation concerning Virginia Giuffre, Sarah Ransome, and Dershowitz provides relevant legal background, but that does not authorize reversing a particular redaction in this document.


Timeline

DateEvent
July 1996Dershowitz states that his relationship with Epstein began around this period
August 1996The document describes travel involving Epstein, Dershowitz, and Leslie Wexner
1997The record discusses investments connected to Orin Kramer
2003Epstein pledges funding for Harvard’s Program for Evolutionary Dynamics
March 2005Palm Beach police begin investigating Epstein after a report involving a fourteen year old girl
2005Dershowitz becomes one of Epstein’s lawyers and helps assemble the defense team
July 2006A Palm Beach County grand jury indicts Epstein on one felony solicitation charge
September 24, 2007Federal prosecutors execute the non prosecution agreement
June 30, 2008Epstein pleads guilty to two Florida state offenses
2009Epstein is released after serving approximately thirteen months
December 2014Allegations naming Dershowitz enter the federal Crime Victims’ Rights Act litigation
April 2015Judge Kenneth Marra strikes the allegations from that proceeding as procedurally improper and immaterial
2019Giuffre files a defamation case against Dershowitz
July 2019The New Yorker publishes Connie Bruck’s profile after an extensive fact checking process
October 2019The court denies Dershowitz’s motion to dismiss Giuffre’s defamation claim and states that the truth of the underlying allegations is not then before the court
November 2022Giuffre, Dershowitz, and David Boies resolve their connected litigation without payment or a trial

Legal Context and Later Resolution

Virginia Giuffre publicly alleged that Epstein trafficked her to Dershowitz. Dershowitz consistently denied meeting her or having sexual contact with her.

In 2015, Judge Kenneth Marra struck references to Dershowitz from a filing in the Florida Crime Victims’ Rights Act case. The court concluded that the allegations were not properly before it and were immaterial to that proceeding. The ruling did not determine that the allegations were true or false.

Giuffre later sued Dershowitz for defamation in the Southern District of New York. In an October 2019 opinion, the court denied Dershowitz’s motion to dismiss. Judge Loretta Preska expressly stated that neither the truth of Giuffre’s allegation nor the truth of Dershowitz’s denial was before the court at that stage.

In November 2022, the parties dismissed their claims with prejudice. The resolution involved no payment. Giuffre stated that she had long believed Epstein trafficked her to Dershowitz but now recognized that she might have made a mistake in identifying him. Dershowitz continued to deny the allegation and withdrew his allegations that David Boies had participated in extortion or subornation of perjury. Courthouse News reported the complete resolution and the parties’ statements.

The 2022 resolution ended the litigation. It did not produce a trial verdict or judicial finding on the underlying allegation.


What the Record Proves

The document establishes that:

  • The federal production contains a fifteen page response attributed to Alan Dershowitz.
  • The response addresses sixty two propositions concerning Epstein and Dershowitz.
  • Dershowitz acknowledged knowing Epstein from approximately 1996.
  • He acknowledged an intellectual and academic relationship involving Harvard.
  • He acknowledged sending draft books to Epstein for comment.
  • He acknowledged participating in Epstein connected academic seminars.
  • He acknowledged helping assemble Epstein’s legal team.
  • He acknowledged writing legal memoranda and meeting with state and federal prosecutors.
  • He acknowledged presenting investigative material during negotiations.
  • He acknowledged multiple visits to Epstein’s Palm Beach residence.
  • He acknowledged one visit to Little St. James with family members.
  • He acknowledged receiving one massage at Epstein’s Palm Beach home.
  • He acknowledged that he became Epstein’s lawyer after the investigation began.
  • He stated that he would continue to take Epstein’s calls.
  • He issued categorical denials of sexual misconduct and denied involvement in various investigative tactics.

What the Record Does Not Prove

The document does not prove that:

  • Every factual proposition submitted to Dershowitz was accurate.
  • Every response attributed to Dershowitz was accurate.
  • Dershowitz personally typed the capitalized answers.
  • The document contains the complete original exchange.
  • The “off the record” designation was accepted by a journalist.
  • The responses were protected by attorney client privilege.
  • Dershowitz participated in Epstein’s sexual abuse or trafficking crimes.
  • Dershowitz knew the full scope of Epstein’s criminal conduct.
  • The women discussed in the document lied.
  • The women discussed in the document committed perjury.
  • Surveillance cameras existed or did not exist in every room of Epstein’s properties.
  • Palm Beach police installed the cameras described by Dershowitz.
  • Dershowitz had no connection to investigative activity beyond the material he admits presenting.
  • He negotiated or did not negotiate the potential co conspirator language.
  • The 2015 order striking allegations constituted an exoneration.
  • The 2022 dismissal constituted a judicial finding of innocence or liability.

Reliability and Evidentiary Weight

FeatureAssessment
Federal productionStrong evidence that the government possessed and released the pages
First person responsesStrong evidence of the position attributed to Dershowitz
AuthorshipProbable but not conclusively established from the visible pages
Exact dateInferred from context, not printed
Intended recipientProbably connected to The New Yorker, but not identified on the record
AdmissionsRelevant as statements against the respondent’s broader interest in minimizing the relationship
DenialsNecessary to report but not independently corroborated by the document
Allegations in questionsMust be traced to testimony, filings, interviews, or investigative records
Redacted identitiesMust remain protected unless separately and lawfully established in public records
Legal conclusionsRequire comparison with the actual agreements, pleadings, orders, and judgments

The document is highly reliable for identifying what Dershowitz was prepared to admit, dispute, or deny. It is less reliable as proof that any disputed event did or did not occur.


Fact Check

Claim in or surrounding the recordFinding
Epstein was charged with aggravated assault in July 2006Incorrect. The Palm Beach County grand jury returned a felony solicitation charge
The federal government would “throw out its indictment” under the non prosecution agreementMisleading. No federal indictment had been filed. The agreement prevented a federal prosecution
Epstein pleaded guilty on June 30, 2008Correct
Epstein pleaded guilty to two state offensesCorrect
Epstein received an eighteen month sentenceCorrect
Epstein served approximately thirteen months with extensive work releaseCorrect
Dershowitz was part of Epstein’s defense teamAdmitted by Dershowitz and established by public records
Dershowitz helped assemble the legal teamAdmitted in EFTA00808054
Dershowitz met with state and federal prosecutorsAdmitted in EFTA00808054
Dershowitz personally created witness dossiersDenied by Dershowitz and not established by this document
Dershowitz used investigative material in negotiationsAdmitted in EFTA00808054
The 2015 court order found the allegations against Dershowitz falseIncorrect. The court struck them as immaterial and procedurally improper
Giuffre’s 2019 defamation action produced a verdictIncorrect. The case ended by agreement in 2022
The 2022 resolution involved a paymentThe parties stated that it did not
Giuffre fully declared that her original identification was falseIncorrect. She said she recognized that she may have made a mistake
Dershowitz admitted sexual conduct with an Epstein survivorNo. He categorically denied it
Presence at an Epstein property proves criminal participationNo

Related Evidence and Reporting

The document should be read beside the final New Yorker profile. Numerous propositions in EFTA00808054 correspond closely to material published in that article.

The Columbia Journalism Review examination of Dershowitz’s interactions with journalists provides additional context for his frequent attempts to negotiate whether conversations were on or off the record and his aggressive responses to reporting he considered defamatory.

The Guardian’s 2015 reporting examined disputes over investigative material used against a young Epstein accuser. Those claims should be compared with Dershowitz’s admission here that he forwarded investigators’ research while denying that he hired or directed those investigators.

Independent researchers have also traced the legal and institutional network surrounding Epstein’s defense. American Freakshow’s examination of Epstein’s lawyers provides contextual research on the larger defense apparatus. Greg Conners’s investigation of overlapping professional roles examines the relationships surrounding Dershowitz and Epstein. Ellie Leonard’s Epstein Files Breakdown provides additional document based research that should be checked against the underlying EFTA records and court filings.

These sources provide leads and context. The primary record remains the released document and the corresponding court docket.


Survivor Safety and Privacy

The record includes descriptions of alleged sexual abuse, coercion, and exploitation. Repeating every explicit detail is unnecessary to understand the document’s evidentiary importance.

Names redacted in the federal production should remain redacted. A researcher should not attempt to identify a protected person through contextual clues alone.

Publicly known survivor testimony should be summarized using the survivor’s established public name and accurate legal status. Allegations must not be converted into findings. Later uncertainty concerning one identification must not be used to dismiss unrelated testimony or the documented abuse committed by Epstein.

Dershowitz’s attacks on the credibility of two women are his assertions. They are not judicial findings.


Why This Record Matters

EFTA00808054 captures the mechanics of elite reputation defense in unusually granular form.

The document does not merely say that allegations are false. It revises language, narrows roles, disputes chronology, separates legal work from investigative work, challenges witness credibility, invokes sealing orders, proposes alternative explanations, and emphasizes procedural rulings favorable to Dershowitz.

It also preserves admissions that can disappear inside a broader public denial. Dershowitz confirms that he knew Epstein for years, participated in his academic world, became his lawyer, helped assemble the defense team, met prosecutors, used investigative material, visited Epstein properties, received a massage at the Palm Beach residence, and remained willing to communicate with him.

That combination makes the record important. It documents both the denial and the relationship the denial was designed to define.


Questions Still Unanswered

  1. What document preceded the page labeled “CONTINUATION OF OFF THE RECORD”?
  2. Who sent the numbered questions?
  3. Who received the responses?
  4. On what date were the responses created and transmitted?
  5. Did Dershowitz personally type the capitalized answers?
  6. Were lawyers, assistants, or public relations advisers involved in preparing them?
  7. Did The New Yorker agree that any portion of the exchange was off the record?
  8. Which original witness statements support each proposition in the questions?
  9. Which investigative firm prepared the social media material Dershowitz acknowledges forwarding?
  10. Who authorized the investigators’ work?
  11. What records document Dershowitz’s meetings with the Palm Beach state attorney and federal prosecutors?
  12. What legal memoranda did Dershowitz prepare for Epstein?
  13. Did Dershowitz review drafts of the non prosecution agreement?
  14. Who proposed the language protecting potential co conspirators?
  15. What records corroborate the stated dates and purposes of Dershowitz’s visits to Epstein properties?
  16. Are there household calendars, flight manifests, telephone logs, or visitor records for those visits?
  17. What evidence supports or contradicts the account of the Palm Beach surveillance cameras?
  18. Why was this response retained in the federal investigative files?
  19. Are additional versions of the document present elsewhere in the production?
  20. Does EFTA00796700 represent a duplicate, an earlier version, or a related production copy?

Related EpsteinWiki Pages


Source List

Primary and Official Records

Reporting and Research

Previous EFTA00786704: September 2018 Device Messages and Proposed Meetings
Next EFTA00827984: 2016 Email From Jeffrey Epstein Asking About Sperm Banking
Table of Contents