Prince Andrew Civil Settlement
This page focuses on the settlement: what was publicly filed, what remains undisclosed, the donation wording, funding reports and the legal effect of dismissal. The case overview and detailed docket chronology cover the wider allegations and litigation.
Start with the primary records: complaint, January 12 opinion, public settlement statement and signed dismissal order. The source register below explains what each does and does not establish.
Snapshot
On February 15, 2022, Virginia Giuffre and Prince Andrew announced that they had reached an out of court settlement in Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, No. 1:21-cv-06702, in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
Giuffre alleged that Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell trafficked her to Andrew for sexual activity when she was seventeen. She alleged three encounters involving Andrew in London, Manhattan, and on Little St. James.
Andrew denied the allegations and said that he had no recollection of meeting Giuffre.
The settlement ended the civil case before Andrew was required to sit for a deposition and before a jury could evaluate the evidence. The settlement amount was not disclosed in the court filing. The public statement said Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity in support of victims’ rights.
The public settlement statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse. However, the filed settlement statement recognized Giuffre as an established victim of abuse, acknowledged that she had suffered from unfair public attacks, commended her courage, and expressed Andrew’s regret for his association with Epstein.
The case was dismissed with prejudice on March 8, 2022. That dismissal permanently ended Giuffre’s civil claims against Andrew arising from the lawsuit. It was not a criminal acquittal, a finding that her allegations were false, or a jury verdict in Andrew’s favor.
The Underlying Civil Case
Giuffre filed her complaint on August 9, 2021.
The case was captioned Virginia L. Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, Duke of York, a/k/a Andrew Albert Christian Edward, in His Personal Capacity, No. 1:21-cv-06702.
The public federal docket is available through CourtListener’s Giuffre v. Prince Andrew record. The Justia docket summary identifies the complaint as Document 1 and records the August 9, 2021 filing date.
Giuffre brought claims for battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress. She alleged that Andrew sexually assaulted her while she was being trafficked by Epstein and Maxwell.
The case was filed under legal provisions made available through New York’s Child Victims Act, which created an extended opportunity for survivors to pursue civil claims involving abuse that occurred while they were minors.
Filing a complaint placed Giuffre’s allegations formally before a federal court. It did not establish that every allegation was proven. Andrew was entitled to contest the allegations, seek dismissal, conduct discovery, and demand a trial.
Giuffre’s Allegations
Giuffre alleged that Epstein and Maxwell directed her to engage in sexual activity with Andrew on three occasions.
The alleged encounters were:
- At Maxwell’s London residence in 2001
- At Epstein’s Manhattan townhouse
- On Little St. James in the United States Virgin Islands
Giuffre said she was seventeen during the London encounter. She alleged that she, Maxwell, and Andrew visited the Tramp nightclub before returning to Maxwell’s home.
A widely published photograph shows Andrew with his arm around Giuffre’s waist while Maxwell stands behind them. Giuffre said the photograph was taken at Maxwell’s London residence on the night of the first alleged encounter.
EFTA00098456 contains a sworn declaration from Giuffre describing allegations involving Andrew and other people in Epstein’s circle. The document proves that Giuffre made those allegations under oath. It does not represent a criminal conviction or jury verdict against Andrew.
EFTA00269896 preserves an investigative account concerning the alleged introduction to Andrew. EFTA00269967 contains an overlapping production of that same interview account. These records show that the allegations entered formal investigative files. They do not, standing alone, adjudicate the claims.
EFTA00098456 is a 51-page packet sent by attorney Paul Cassell to the Metropolitan Police on May 4, 2015. It includes Giuffre’s January 2015 declaration under penalty of perjury. The sworn declaration, the covering lawyer’s account and any attached investigative summaries are different source types; the packet is not a single adjudicated finding.
EFTA00269896 and EFTA00269967 are substantially overlapping twelve-page productions of the same March 17, 2011 FBI interview, recorded in July 2013. They are not two independent witness accounts or sworn transcripts. Redactions and chronology differences must be preserved, not resolved by guessing identities or silently substituting a later account.
Andrew’s Denials
Andrew denied Giuffre’s allegations.
During his November 2019 BBC Newsnight interview, Andrew said that he had no recollection of meeting Giuffre. He challenged parts of her account, including her description of him sweating at the nightclub.
Andrew also disputed the circumstances surrounding the photograph. He suggested that aspects of the image appeared unusual and said that he did not remember it being taken.
No conclusive public forensic finding established that the photograph was fabricated.
In the civil case, Andrew’s lawyers described Giuffre’s allegations as false and sought dismissal. His denials remained his position when the parties settled.
The public settlement statement did not include an admission that Giuffre’s allegations against Andrew were true; it did not publish the full agreement’s requirements. It also did not produce a finding that his denials were accurate.
Andrew’s Documented Relationship With Epstein
The civil case did not arise solely from a photograph.
Released records document a substantial relationship between Andrew and Epstein before and after Epstein’s 2008 Florida conviction.
EFTA02415487 records Andrew returning Epstein’s telephone call in October 2010. EFTA01990003 contains a December 2010 communication between Andrew and Epstein concerning a telephone conversation.
The records are relevant because Andrew later described his December 2010 visit to Epstein’s Manhattan residence as an attempt to end the friendship.
EFTA01798176 contains a later supportive message attributed to Andrew stating that he and Epstein appeared to be in the situation together and should remain in close contact. Duplicate copies include EFTA01836403 and EFTA02038795. These copies represent the same communication, not three separate incidents.
The communications establish continued contact. They do not prove that Andrew participated in Epstein’s trafficking operation or committed the assaults alleged by Giuffre.
Buckingham Palace and the Photograph
Palace press officials became involved when news organizations requested comment about the photograph of Andrew, Giuffre, and Maxwell.
EFTA02020640 contains communications involving Palace press official Ed Perkins concerning the photograph and a proposed response. EFTA02687581 contains another copy of related communications.
EFTA02017536 records internal discussion concerning what had been sent to the press and whether Palace personnel had viewed the photograph.
These records demonstrate institutional management of the media inquiry. They do not establish that Queen Elizabeth II personally examined the photograph, directed a response, or knew whether Giuffre’s allegations were true.
The Palace’s public denials expressed Andrew’s position. They were not independent judicial findings.
Service of the Lawsuit
Serving Andrew with the complaint became an early dispute.
Giuffre’s legal team attempted to deliver the legal papers at Royal Lodge in Windsor. Andrew’s representatives disputed whether the initial service was legally sufficient.
The court later authorized service through Andrew’s United States counsel. The dispute was resolved without a default judgment, and Andrew appeared through attorneys to defend the action.
The service dispute did not determine the truth of Giuffre’s allegations. It concerned whether Andrew had received the notice required for the federal case to proceed.
The 2009 Giuffre and Epstein Settlement
Andrew’s principal dismissal argument relied on an earlier agreement between Giuffre and Epstein.
In 2009, Giuffre settled a Florida civil action against Epstein for $500,000. The agreement included a release covering Epstein and certain other potential defendants.
Andrew argued that the broad language protected him from Giuffre’s later lawsuit.
The agreement became an exhibit in the Andrew case and was unsealed in January 2022. The filed copy identified the settlement amount and contained language releasing claims against other possible defendants.
Andrew was not named expressly in the agreement.
The legal dispute centered on whether he could nevertheless claim the benefit of its general release language.
Giuffre argued that the agreement was never intended to protect Andrew from personal liability for sexual assault. Andrew argued that the language was broad enough to require dismissal.
This was a question of contract interpretation. It did not determine whether the alleged assaults occurred.
The filed 2009 agreement specified $500,000, excluding attorneys’ fees and costs. That known figure belongs to the Epstein agreement, not the undisclosed 2022 Andrew settlement.
Judge Kaplan Rejects Andrew’s Motion to Dismiss
United States District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan rejected Andrew’s motion on January 12, 2022.
The complete decision is available in Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, Document 64.
The court concluded that the meaning of the 2009 release was sufficiently ambiguous that it could not eliminate Giuffre’s claims at the dismissal stage.
Judge Kaplan also rejected Andrew’s request for a more definite statement.
The decision did not find Andrew liable. At the motion to dismiss stage, the court was required to evaluate whether Giuffre’s complaint stated legally viable claims while generally accepting properly pleaded allegations as true for that limited purpose.
The ruling allowed the existing discovery process and litigation to continue, with depositions and a possible trial ahead.
The Approach of Discovery
After the dismissal motion failed, Andrew continued to face civil discovery.
Discovery could have required him to:
- Sit for a sworn deposition
- Answer questions concerning his relationship with Epstein and Maxwell
- Produce relevant communications and records
- Identify possible witnesses
- Respond to questions about his movements during the alleged encounters
- Address the circumstances of the photograph
- Explain his continued contact with Epstein after the 2008 conviction
Giuffre would also have been subject to discovery and cross examination.
A civil deposition is sworn testimony. False material statements can carry legal consequences. The transcript can also be used to challenge a witness if later testimony changes.
The settlement was announced before Andrew gave the anticipated deposition. As a result, the public never received sworn discovery testimony from him in this case.
Discovery was already under way before January 12. In the December 31, 2021 order (Document 61), Judge Kaplan recorded that Andrew had served extensive discovery, including requests concerning Giuffre’s domicile. The court denied his requested additional two-hour deposition and stay without prejudice to a later jurisdictional defense. Settlement interrupted an existing process; it did not prevent every discovery step from occurring.
Royal Consequences Before the Settlement
On January 13, 2022, one day after Judge Kaplan allowed the case to proceed, Buckingham Palace announced that Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages had been returned to the Queen.
The Palace said that he would defend the case as a private citizen.
This decision did not determine civil liability. It reflected the institutional consequences of the lawsuit and the continuing discovery process.
Andrew had already withdrawn from public duties after the 2019 Newsnight interview. The January 2022 action created a clearer separation between his civil defense and his official royal position.
The February 2022 Settlement Statement
On February 15, 2022, attorney David Boies informed Judge Kaplan that the parties had reached a settlement in principle.
The filing appears on the federal case docket as the February 15 letter addressed to Judge Kaplan.
The filed statement said that:
- Giuffre and Andrew had reached an out of court settlement.
- The parties would file a stipulated dismissal after Giuffre received the settlement payment.
- The amount would not be disclosed.
- Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity in support of victims’ rights.
- Andrew had never intended to malign Giuffre’s character.
- Andrew accepted that Giuffre had suffered as an established victim of abuse.
- Andrew accepted that she had also suffered from unfair public attacks.
- Andrew regretted his association with Epstein.
- Andrew commended the bravery of Giuffre and other survivors.
- Andrew pledged to support the fight against sex trafficking and its victims.
The Associated Press account of the filed settlement reproduces the material provisions and explains the procedural status of the case.
The statement was more than a private press release because it was filed in federal court. However, it did not disclose the complete confidential settlement agreement.
The primary records are the counsel letter (Document 78) and the separately filed statement (Document 78-1). The February 15 order (Document 79) suspended deadlines through March 17; it did not itself dismiss the action. The eventual stipulation identifies the private agreement as dated February 12, 2022.
Recognition of Giuffre as an Established Victim
One of the most important provisions was Andrew’s acceptance that Giuffre had suffered as an established victim of abuse.
That language did not say that Andrew was the person who abused her. Epstein’s abuse and trafficking of Giuffre had already been documented through litigation, public statements, and the broader evidentiary record.
The provision nevertheless mattered because Andrew’s defense had attacked Giuffre’s credibility and motives.
The filed statement also acknowledged that she had suffered from unfair public attacks. It did not identify each attack, say who was responsible for it, or specify which public claims were unfair.
The language represented a significant change in tone from Andrew’s adversarial court filings. It did not amount to a confession.
No Admission of Liability
The public settlement filing contained no admission that Andrew sexually assaulted Giuffre.
That distinction is legally important.
A civil settlement allows parties to resolve a dispute without requiring a judge or jury to decide liability. Defendants may settle to control risk, expense, publicity, discovery, or uncertainty. Plaintiffs may settle to obtain compensation, finality, acknowledgement, or protection from the burdens of continued litigation.
Reuters reported that the settlement included no admission of wrongdoing.
The public statement contains no admission of the alleged abuse, but it also contains no express no-liability clause. The full agreement is not publicly reproduced, so an exact contractual clause should not be invented. The absence of a public admission does not mean that the allegations were disproven; the case ended without a verdict.
The Undisclosed Payment
The court filing expressly stated that the settlement amount would not be disclosed.
Contemporaneous reporting by Julie K. Brown and Ben Wieder also noted the undisclosed settlement and Andrew’s intended donation. The separately filed public statement, Document 78-1, is the primary source for those terms.
News organizations reported conflicting estimates. For example, The Times’s February 12, 2026 account repeated an estimate around £12 million while noting that the Palace had not disclosed the amount or funding details. A sum reported for a private contribution, a total settlement or a currency conversion must not be treated as the same thing.
Those reports have never been reconciled through the public federal court record.
The only conclusion supported directly by the filed statement is that:
- Andrew agreed to make a payment to Giuffre.
- The parties kept the amount confidential.
- Giuffre had to receive the settlement before the stipulated dismissal was filed.
- Andrew separately intended to make a substantial charitable donation.
Reported estimates should not be presented as the adjudicated settlement amount.
Later reporting has continued to describe a figure near £12 million, but repetition does not convert an undisclosed term into a verified court fact.
Who Funded the Settlement
Reporting has attributed private assistance to Queen Elizabeth II, other family resources and property proceeds. The public settlement statement does not identify Charles, another relative or a specific account as a funder, and it does not disclose how the payment and donation were allocated.
The Treasury’s March 3, 2026 parliamentary answer states that no public money was used for the legal or settlement fees. This is an official answer to the public-funding question, not a private payment ledger.
The Times reported on February 12, 2026 that an unnamed source close to the King denied Charles contributed, responding to a report of a £1.5 million contribution. That attributed denial and earlier contribution reports cannot be combined into a verified amount without supporting records.
The separate October 2026 Royal Lodge accounts must not be imported into the 2022 settlement. The Crown Estate’s October 9 announcement records £1.8 million for dilapidations, approximately £302,000 compensation and a £1.5 million net receipt. It does not identify the ultimate funder. Reporting of a private Charles loan for those property costs concerns a different transaction.
Charles III and the Epstein Record explains those source distinctions and the attributed private-loan report. The royal-family overview covers the wider institutional history. Neither family support nor a settlement payment, without further evidence, proves knowledge of or responsibility for abuse.
The Charitable Donation
The public statement, Document 78-1, says Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity in support of victims’ rights. That is a statement of intention, not a receipt establishing that a particular charity received a particular sum.
The filing does not name the charity, disclose the donation amount, set out a payment schedule or explain administration of the funds. References to Giuffre’s survivor-advocacy work and SOAR must be distinguished from what the filed statement itself identifies.
The reviewed court documents do not establish the final disposition of charitable funds. Claims about operational status, escrow or payment require a separately identified record or attributed report; the absence of detail in the settlement statement is not proof of nonpayment or misuse.
Confidentiality: Public Records and Attributed Accounts
The full private agreement is not reproduced in the reviewed court filings. The public statement says the settlement amount is undisclosed but does not supply the complete confidentiality, non-disparagement, timing, exception or enforcement terms.
The Independent relayed Boies’s reported no-NDA comment to The Sun.
CBS reported Giuffre’s memoir account of a one-year restriction linked to the Platinum Jubilee.
Those are attributed accounts, not a published contractual text. They do not establish a permanent ban, and the public statement’s silence cannot establish that no limited restriction existed. The reviewed filings do not resolve the exact wording or scope.
The March 2022 Dismissal
The parties subsequently filed a stipulation dismissing the case.
On March 8, 2022, Judge Kaplan dismissed the lawsuit with prejudice. The CourtListener docket records the termination date, while ABC News reported the filed stipulation.
The stipulation provided that each party would bear their own legal costs and fees.
A dismissal with prejudice generally prevents the plaintiff from filing the same claims again.
The dismissal did not state that Giuffre withdrew her allegations. It did not declare Andrew innocent. It did not enter a judgment against him. It ended the civil dispute under the parties’ settlement.
The parties’ March 8 stipulation (Document 82) refers to the settlement agreement dated February 12 and Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(ii). Document 83 contains the judge’s signed dismissal order. The February statement made dismissal conditional on Giuffre’s receipt of the settlement; the dismissal itself does not reveal the amount or the private funding trail.
What Remained Untested When the Case Ended
The case ended without a public trial, a jury verdict or a judicial damages award. The public docket does not contain a completed deposition of Andrew in this action or a final ruling authenticating the London photograph.
It would be inaccurate to say that no discovery occurred. Requests and court-supervised discovery disputes already existed before the January 12 ruling. It is also unsafe to infer from the public docket exactly which documents were exchanged privately or which witnesses supplied information outside filed proceedings.
Settlement prevented the competing accounts from being tested through a completed trial in this case. That leaves unresolved evidentiary questions; it does not make every question permanently unanswerable or turn the absence of a trial into evidence for either side.
Effect on Possible Criminal Proceedings
The settlement resolved a civil lawsuit. It did not create criminal immunity.
Andrew was not a party to a criminal prosecution arising from Giuffre’s allegations. The settlement did not bind federal prosecutors, British authorities, or another government agency.
Civil settlements generally cannot prevent the government from pursuing criminal charges if prosecutors later conclude that admissible evidence supports them.
The United States had previously sought Andrew’s cooperation concerning Epstein. EFTA00022062 contains a formal request identifying subjects investigators wanted to discuss with him, including his relationship with Epstein, visits to Epstein properties, communications, travel, and knowledge of other people in Epstein’s circle.
The document shows that investigators considered Andrew’s information relevant. It does not mean that he was criminally charged.
The statute of limitations, available evidence, jurisdiction, witness availability, and admissibility rules would all affect any criminal assessment.
The later British misconduct-in-public-office investigation is separate from Giuffre’s lawsuit. The October 2026 police update says it remains ongoing. The October 8 search-warrant order is not a ruling on Giuffre’s allegations. See Andrew’s main profile for the dated procedural history.
The Settlement Was Not an Acquittal
An acquittal occurs when a criminal defendant is found not guilty.
Andrew was not tried criminally on Giuffre’s allegations. He therefore was neither convicted nor acquitted.
The civil settlement also was not an exoneration. No court found that Giuffre fabricated her account or that Andrew could not have been present.
At the same time, the settlement was not a civil judgment finding Andrew liable. Giuffre’s allegations did not reach a jury verdict.
The accurate description is:
A civil settlement whose full terms were not publicly disclosed, with no admission of the alleged abuse in the public statement, followed by dismissal with prejudice.
The Settlement Was Not a Confession
The filed statement contained language favorable to Giuffre and damaging to Andrew’s previous public posture.
Andrew acknowledged Giuffre as an established victim, recognized that she had suffered unfair attacks, regretted his association with Epstein, and commended survivor courage.
He did not state that he met Giuffre, had sexual contact with her, assaulted her, or knew that Epstein and Maxwell had trafficked her to him.
The language should not be rewritten as a confession.
It should also not be stripped of its significance. Andrew agreed to the statement after a federal judge rejected his dismissal motion and shortly before he faced sworn discovery.
Why Survivors Settle Civil Cases
A survivor’s decision to settle does not mean that the allegations were weak or withdrawn.
Civil litigation can impose years of:
- Intrusive questioning
- Attacks on credibility
- Examination of medical and personal records
- Public harassment
- Financial expense
- Repeated exposure to traumatic material
- Uncertainty about trial outcomes
- Appeals after any verdict
Settlement may provide compensation and finality without forcing a survivor to continue through every stage of litigation.
Giuffre had spent years publicly confronting Epstein, Maxwell, Andrew, and institutions connected with them. Her decision to settle must be evaluated within that history.
The Broader Historical Importance
The settlement was significant because it ended a civil case in which a senior British royal faced potential sworn examination over allegations tied directly to Epstein’s trafficking operation.
It also changed Andrew’s public position.
Before settlement, his legal team described Giuffre’s allegations as baseless and attacked her motives. In the filed statement, Andrew accepted that she was an established victim of abuse, acknowledged unfair attacks against her, and commended her courage.
The settlement did not answer whether the three alleged encounters occurred. It did establish that Andrew chose payment, charitable support, acknowledgement of Giuffre’s victimization, and dismissal instead of continuing toward deposition and trial.
What the Evidence Establishes
The available evidence establishes that:
- Giuffre filed a federal civil lawsuit against Andrew in August 2021.
- She alleged sexual assault and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- She alleged three encounters involving Andrew.
- Andrew denied the allegations.
- Andrew relied partly on Giuffre’s 2009 settlement with Epstein when seeking dismissal.
- Judge Kaplan rejected Andrew’s dismissal motion.
- The ruling allowed discovery and a possible trial to proceed.
- Buckingham Palace removed Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages during the litigation.
- Giuffre and Andrew reached a settlement in February 2022.
- The payment amount was not disclosed in the court filing.
- The public statement said Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity.
- Andrew accepted that Giuffre was an established victim of abuse.
- Andrew accepted that she had suffered from unfair public attacks.
- Andrew expressed regret for his association with Epstein.
- The public settlement statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse.
- The case was dismissed with prejudice in March 2022.
- Andrew never gave the anticipated deposition in the case.
- No jury decided whether Giuffre’s allegations against Andrew were true.
What the Evidence Does Not Establish
The available evidence does not establish that:
- The settlement was an admission that Andrew assaulted Giuffre.
- The settlement disproved Giuffre’s allegations.
- Andrew was acquitted.
- Giuffre withdrew her allegations.
- A jury found Andrew liable.
- A court found Giuffre’s account false.
- The public knows the verified settlement amount.
- Every reported source of settlement funding is accurate.
- Public money was used to pay the settlement.
- The complete confidentiality language is public.
- Giuffre was permanently prohibited from discussing Andrew.
- Andrew received criminal immunity.
- Every person associated with the Royal Family knew about Epstein’s crimes.
- The photograph alone proves the alleged sexual encounter.
- Andrew’s association with Epstein alone proves participation in trafficking.
Investigative Assessment
The Prince Andrew settlement must be described with two truths held together.
First, the settlement was not a finding of liability. Andrew denied the allegations, the public statement contained no admission of the alleged abuse, and the case did not go to trial.
Second, the settlement was not a vindication. Andrew failed to obtain dismissal, faced continuing discovery, agreed to an undisclosed payment, announced an intention to make a substantial charitable donation, recognized Giuffre as an established victim, acknowledged unfair attacks against her, and agreed that dismissal would follow Giuffre’s receipt of the settlement.
The case ended while discovery was ongoing and before the anticipated deposition and trial could test the competing accounts.
The historical record therefore remains unresolved as to civil liability, but it is not empty. It contains Giuffre’s sworn allegations, Andrew’s denials, documentary evidence of his continuing relationship with Epstein, a failed dismissal motion, a filed settlement statement, and a dismissal with prejudice following the settlement.
Key Takeaways
- Giuffre sued Andrew personally for battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- Andrew denied the allegations and attempted to dismiss the case.
- Judge Kaplan allowed the case to proceed.
- Settlement occurred before Andrew’s deposition and before trial.
- The settlement amount remains undisclosed in the public court record.
- Reported figures should be identified as estimates, not verified settlement terms.
- The public statement said Andrew intended to make a substantial donation supporting victims’ rights.
- He recognized Giuffre as an established victim of abuse.
- He acknowledged that she suffered unfair public attacks.
- He expressed regret for his association with Epstein.
- The public statement did not admit that he committed the alleged abuse.
- The dismissal with prejudice permanently ended Giuffre’s civil case against him.
- The settlement did not provide criminal immunity.
- The settlement was neither a conviction nor an acquittal.
- No judge or jury resolved whether Andrew assaulted Giuffre.
Related EpsteinWiki Articles
- Virginia Roberts Giuffre
- Prince Andrew
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Ghislaine Maxwell
- Giuffre v. Prince Andrew
- Giuffre v. Maxwell
- Little St. James
- Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein
- Epstein Flight Logs
- Civil Actions by Jane Does
- Civil case overview
- Detailed federal docket and legal chronology
- Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor: main profile
- Charles III: royal decisions and financial evidence limits
- Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein
Primary Court Records
CourtListener’s docket provides PACER-derived copies. The filed documents must be distinguished from reporting about them; the official court record remains controlling.
- August 9, 2021 complaint, Document 1: The pleaded allegations, two causes of action and requested relief; not findings of fact.
- September 16, 2021 alternative-service order, Document 16: Order permitting service through United States counsel.
- September 28, 2021 filed service stipulation and order, Document 20: Deems service effective September 21 and sets the response deadline; preserves other defenses.
- November 3, 2021 supplemental scheduling order, Document 36: Sets initial disclosures and records planned depositions, confirming pre-January discovery activity.
- December 31, 2021 discovery and domicile order, Document 61: Confirms discovery requests already existed before the motion-to-dismiss ruling; did not finally decide domicile.
- 2009 Giuffre-Epstein agreement, filed as Document 32-1: The separate $500,000 settlement and disputed release; not the 2022 Andrew settlement.
- January 12, 2022 opinion, Document 64: Denies the motion to dismiss without determining the truth of the allegations.
- January 26, 2022 answer and jury demand, Document 71: Andrew’s denials and affirmative defenses; defenses are not established facts.
- February 15, 2022 settlement-in-principle letter, Document 78: Counsel’s notice and request to suspend deadlines.
- February 15, 2022 attached public settlement statement, Document 78-1: Undisclosed amount, intended charitable donation and public acknowledgements; not the complete settlement contract.
- February 15, 2022 suspension order, Document 79: Held the action in abeyance through March 17, subject to filing dismissal; it was not the dismissal itself.
- March 8, 2022 stipulation and proposed order, Document 82: Refers to the February 12 settlement agreement, Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), dismissal with prejudice and each side’s costs and fees.
- March 8, 2022 signed dismissal order, Document 83: Judge Kaplan’s signed order dismissing the action with prejudice.
Primary Epstein Data Evidence
- EFTA00098456 contains Giuffre’s sworn declaration describing allegations involving Andrew.
- EFTA00269896 preserves an investigative account concerning the alleged introduction to Andrew.
- EFTA00269967 is an overlapping production of the same March 2011 interview, not a separate corroborating account.
- EFTA02415487 records Andrew returning Epstein’s telephone call in October 2010.
- EFTA01990003 documents direct communication between Andrew and Epstein in December 2010.
- EFTA01798176 contains a supportive message attributed to Andrew concerning continued contact with Epstein.
- EFTA01836403 contains a duplicate copy of the same communication.
- EFTA02038795 contains another overlapping copy.
- EFTA02020640 documents Palace press handling of the photograph involving Andrew, Giuffre, and Maxwell.
- EFTA02687581 contains a corroborating copy of the Palace communications.
- EFTA02017536 records internal discussion concerning the response supplied to the press.
- EFTA00022062 identifies subjects United States investigators wanted to discuss with Andrew.