Virginia Giuffre v. Prince Andrew: Federal Sexual Abuse Lawsuit and Settlement
This page is the detailed procedural and legal record of the federal action, including the complaint, service, discovery, release dispute, answer and dismissal. See the case overview for an accessible synthesis and the settlement guide for the payment, funding and confidentiality questions.
Start with the primary records: complaint, January 12 opinion, public settlement statement and signed dismissal order. The source register below explains what each does and does not establish.
Snapshot
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Virginia L. Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, Duke of York, a/k/a Andrew Albert Christian Edward, in his personal capacity |
| Court | United States District Court for the Southern District of New York |
| Docket number | 1:21-cv-06702-LAK |
| Filed | August 9, 2021 |
| Closed | March 8, 2022 |
| Presiding judge | Lewis A. Kaplan |
| Plaintiff | Virginia L. Giuffre, formerly known as Virginia Roberts |
| Defendant | Prince Andrew, Duke of York, sued in his personal capacity |
| Case type | Civil action alleging sexual abuse and intentional infliction of emotional distress |
| Statutory filing mechanism | New York Child Victims Act revival window, New York Civil Practice Law and Rules section 214-g |
| Claims | Battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress |
| Alleged locations | Ghislaine Maxwell’s London residence, Jeffrey Epstein’s Manhattan residence, and Little Saint James in the U.S. Virgin Islands |
| Defendant’s position | Andrew denied the allegations and demanded a jury trial |
| Key ruling | On January 12, 2022, Judge Kaplan denied Andrew’s motion to dismiss |
| Resolution | Confidential settlement followed by stipulated dismissal with prejudice |
| Admission in the public statement | No admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse; the full contract is not reproduced |
| Public settlement terms | Undisclosed payment and a stated intention to make a substantial donation supporting victims’ rights |
| Trial or verdict | None |
| Appeal | None identified |
| Primary records reviewed | October 19, 2026 |
Giuffre v. Prince Andrew was a federal civil lawsuit brought by survivor and advocate Virginia Giuffre against Andrew, then formally styled Prince Andrew, Duke of York. Giuffre alleged that Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell trafficked her to Andrew and that Andrew sexually abused her on three occasions when she was 17. Andrew denied the allegations, challenged the sufficiency and legal viability of the complaint, and argued that a 2009 settlement between Giuffre and Epstein released him from liability.
Judge Lewis A. Kaplan denied Andrew’s motion to dismiss on January 12, 2022. That ruling allowed the litigation and existing discovery process to continue. It did not find that Giuffre’s allegations were true, and it did not determine that Andrew was liable. Andrew filed an answer and jury demand on January 26, 2022.
On February 15, 2022, the parties announced a settlement in principle. The public filing stated that Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity, recognized Giuffre as an established victim of abuse, expressed regret for his association with Epstein, and commended Giuffre and other survivors. It contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse, but it did not expressly set out a no-liability clause. The parties subsequently dismissed the action with prejudice on March 8, 2022. The settlement amount and most other terms remain confidential.
Case Information
The exact caption on the complaint was Virginia L. Giuffre v. Prince Andrew, Duke of York, a/k/a Andrew Albert Christian Edward, in his personal capacity. The personal-capacity language meant Giuffre sought to hold Andrew individually responsible. The lawsuit was not filed against the British monarchy, the Crown, Queen Elizabeth II, Jeffrey Epstein’s estate, or Ghislaine Maxwell.
Andrew is now known as Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor following later changes to his royal status. The historical case caption should remain unchanged in court-case references because it records how the defendant was named when the action was litigated.
The federal docket is available through the CourtListener case page. The complaint and major dispositive records are also available through direct court-document links in the records section below.
Parties
Virginia Giuffre
Virginia Louise Giuffre, formerly Virginia Roberts, was a survivor of Jeffrey Epstein’s abuse and an advocate for trafficking survivors. She publicly identified herself and spoke about her experiences for years before filing this action. She alleged that Epstein and Maxwell recruited, groomed, abused, and trafficked her while she was a teenager.
Giuffre was represented in this case by Boies Schiller Flexner LLP, including David Boies and Sigrid McCawley. Her public identification does not remove the need to protect unrelated survivors, witnesses, and family members whose identities are not necessary to explain the case.
Giuffre died on April 25, 2025. Her death occurred more than three years after the lawsuit ended and did not affect the closed case. Her posthumously published memoir added her personal account and more specific chronology, but it was not evidence tested in this litigation.
Prince Andrew
Andrew was the second son of Queen Elizabeth II and, during the lawsuit, held the title Duke of York. He was sued personally, not as a representative of the Crown. His U.S. litigation counsel included Andrew Brettler and attorneys at Lavely & Singer, P.C.
Andrew repeatedly denied Giuffre’s allegations. In his January 26, 2022 answer, he denied the central factual claims, asserted affirmative defenses, and demanded a jury trial. He has not been criminally convicted or found civilly liable for the conduct alleged by Giuffre.
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell
Epstein and Maxwell were not defendants in this case, but Giuffre’s complaint alleged that they created the conditions through which she was trafficked to Andrew. Epstein died in 2019 while awaiting federal trial. Maxwell was convicted in December 2021 of federal crimes arising from her role in recruiting and grooming minors for Epstein. Her conviction did not adjudicate Andrew’s conduct or Giuffre’s claims against him.
Background to the Lawsuit
Giuffre had publicly accused Andrew years before the 2021 complaint. In a filing submitted in the federal Crime Victims’ Rights Act litigation in Florida, she alleged that Epstein required her to engage in sexual acts with powerful men, including Andrew. That 2015 filing was not a verdict. The judge later struck the disputed allegations from that proceeding because they were not necessary to decide the victims’ rights issue.
Giuffre also supplied sworn declarations and testimony in litigation against Ghislaine Maxwell. Those records described alleged trafficking, travel, recruitment, and encounters with Andrew. Andrew and Buckingham Palace denied impropriety.
The best-known image associated with the allegations shows Andrew with his arm around Giuffre while Maxwell stands behind them. Giuffre said the photograph was taken at Maxwell’s London home during the first alleged encounter. Andrew said in his 2019 BBC Newsnight interview that he had no recollection of meeting Giuffre and questioned aspects of the photograph. No trial court made a final authenticity finding in this case; the public record does not establish exactly what was exchanged privately before settlement.
The photograph is evidence that requires careful description. It depicts the three people together if authentic. Standing alone, it does not prove that an assault occurred. Later emails attributed to Epstein and Maxwell appear to acknowledge that Giuffre met Andrew and that a photograph was taken, but those later-released records were not adjudicated in this lawsuit.
The Complaint
Giuffre filed her 15-page complaint on August 9, 2021, near the end of New York’s Child Victims Act revival period. The pleading alleged two causes of action under New York law: battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
The complaint alleged that Epstein and Maxwell trafficked Giuffre to Andrew while she was under 18. It described three alleged encounters:
- At Maxwell’s home in London. The nightclub account comes from other public accounts, not the text of this complaint.
- At Epstein’s mansion at 9 East 71st Street in Manhattan.
- At Epstein’s Little Saint James property in the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Giuffre alleged that Andrew knew she was under 18 and that she was a trafficking victim. She alleged that she did not consent to the sexual acts, that Andrew used his status and relationship with Epstein and Maxwell in committing the abuse, and that his conduct caused severe and lasting physical and emotional injury.
The complaint sought compensatory damages, punitive damages, litigation costs, and other relief. It did not demand a specific dollar amount. Reports that later assigned a value to the case or settlement should not be confused with the relief stated in the complaint.
Alleged London Encounter
Giuffre alleged that the first encounter occurred in London in March 2001, when she was 17. Her public account described visiting Tramp nightclub with Andrew and Maxwell before returning to Maxwell’s home. The 2021 complaint does not mention Tramp; it alleges the London encounter at Maxwell’s residence. The nightclub account and Andrew’s response are discussed in the 2019 Newsnight interview, not established as facts by the January 2022 opinion.
Giuffre alleged that Andrew sexually assaulted her at the residence. She later described the alleged event in interviews, sworn statements, and her memoir. The complaint treated the London event as part of the battery claim and as conduct contributing to severe emotional distress.
CNN’s February 5, 2026 report of Giuffre’s memoir dates the encounter March 10, 2001. This is an attributed account, not a date established by a judgment in this lawsuit.
Andrew denied that the encounter occurred. In his 2019 Newsnight interview, he offered an account of being with his daughter at a PizzaExpress restaurant in Woking on the relevant day and said Giuffre’s description of him perspiring conflicted with a medical condition he said affected him at the time. Those statements were public defenses, not findings adopted by a court. No trial tested the competing accounts.
The January 2015 declaration included in EFTA00098456, paragraphs 34-35, describes Andrew arriving at Maxwell’s home before dinner and Tramp. This is a separately sourced sworn account, not text from the 2021 complaint or a trial finding.
Alleged Manhattan Encounter
Giuffre alleged a second sexual encounter at Epstein’s Manhattan residence. The Manhattan allegation supplied an important connection to New York, where the civil action was filed and where the Child Victims Act applied.
The complaint alleged that Andrew sexually abused Giuffre at Epstein’s home and that she was acting under coercive circumstances created by Epstein and Maxwell. Andrew denied the allegation. Because the case settled before a completed trial, the public record contains no jury determination regarding the alleged Manhattan encounter.
Andrew’s documented presence at Epstein’s Manhattan home on other occasions, including his 2010 stay after Epstein’s Florida conviction, establishes an ongoing association with Epstein. It does not independently establish that the alleged 2001 assault occurred.
Alleged Little Saint James Encounter
Giuffre alleged a third encounter at Little Saint James, Epstein’s private island in the U.S. Virgin Islands. Her accounts described group sexual activity and the presence of other girls. The 2021 complaint alleged that Andrew sexually abused her on the island as part of the trafficking arrangement.
Andrew denied the allegation. Travel records and witness materials can be relevant to whether people were present at particular places, but presence alone does not prove sexual misconduct. No factfinder evaluated the island allegation in this action.
Editors should not identify other alleged survivors from generalized descriptions of the island encounter. The complaint’s allegations against Andrew do not authorize speculation about unnamed participants.
Claims
Battery
Under New York civil law, battery generally involves intentional bodily contact that is harmful or offensive and made without consent. Giuffre alleged that Andrew intentionally engaged in sexual contact without her consent. She also alleged that the conduct qualified as sexual offenses under New York Penal Law Article 130, which was relevant to use of the Child Victims Act revival provision.
The court’s refusal to dismiss the battery claim meant the complaint sufficiently pleaded a legally cognizable claim at that stage. It did not establish that the alleged contacts occurred or that Giuffre lacked consent as a matter of adjudicated fact.
Intentional infliction of emotional distress
Giuffre alleged that Andrew engaged in extreme and outrageous conduct intentionally or recklessly causing severe emotional distress. She connected the alleged assaults, the power imbalance, her status as a trafficked minor, and later public attacks on her credibility to ongoing harm.
Andrew argued that the claim was legally deficient and duplicated the battery theory. Judge Kaplan allowed it to proceed at the pleading stage. That ruling preserved the claim for discovery and possible trial but did not award damages.
New York Child Victims Act
New York enacted the Child Victims Act to expand limitation periods for civil claims based on childhood sexual abuse and to create a temporary revival window for claims that had become time barred. Giuffre filed during that revival window and alleged she was 17 at the time of the conduct.
Andrew challenged application of the statute on several grounds. His attorneys argued that Giuffre’s claims did not fit the law, questioned whether the alleged acts qualified under the referenced New York offenses, and raised constitutional and statutory objections.
Judge Kaplan concluded that the complaint could proceed. At the motion-to-dismiss stage, the court was required to accept well-pleaded factual allegations as true for purposes of testing legal sufficiency. That procedural assumption is not the same as a factual finding after evidence and cross-examination.
Jurisdiction, Domicile, and Service
The December 31, 2021 order denied the requested domicile deposition and stay without prejudice to a future jurisdictional defense. It did not finally establish Colorado domicile or adopt the opposing assertion that the request was solely a delaying tactic.
The service stipulation and order filed September 28 (Document 20) deemed service effective September 21, 2021, set October 29 as the response deadline and reserved the parties’ other defenses.
Federal jurisdiction
Giuffre invoked diversity jurisdiction, which generally requires citizens of different states or countries and an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000. She alleged that she was domiciled in Colorado and that Andrew was domiciled in the United Kingdom.
Andrew later questioned Giuffre’s U.S. domicile and argued that evidence suggested she resided in Australia. Giuffre responded that Colorado remained her domicile and cited continuing ties, including voter registration. Judge Kaplan declined to halt the case on that basis. The dispute did not produce a final trial finding because the action settled.
Service of process
Serving Andrew became an early dispute. Giuffre’s process server stated that papers were left with police security at Royal Lodge in Windsor on August 27, 2021. Andrew’s representatives challenged whether that attempt complied with governing rules.
The parties discussed service under the Hague Service Convention and through the English High Court. Judge Kaplan ultimately authorized service through Andrew’s U.S. counsel. Giuffre’s lawyers served attorney Andrew Brettler by email and delivery in September 2021, and the litigation proceeded with Andrew represented and participating.
The service dispute concerned notice and procedure. It was not evidence for or against the underlying allegations.
Andrew’s Motion to Dismiss
Andrew filed his motion to dismiss on October 29, 2021 after preliminary disputes over sealing the 2009 Giuffre-Epstein agreement. His defense relied heavily on that agreement’s broad release language.
The 2009 agreement resolved Giuffre’s Florida civil claims against Epstein for $500,000. It released Epstein and included language concerning other persons or entities who could have been included as potential defendants. Andrew argued that he fell within this third-party release because Giuffre had previously referred to royalty and other powerful men.
Giuffre argued that Andrew was not named, was not a party to the agreement, did not know about it when executed, and was not an intended beneficiary entitled to enforce it. She also argued that the release did not cover the claims asserted in the 2021 complaint.
Andrew advanced additional arguments concerning the Child Victims Act, the adequacy of the allegations, consent, the emotional-distress count, and the propriety of applying New York law to conduct alleged outside New York. His briefing characterized Giuffre’s allegations as false and accused her of pursuing money and publicity. Giuffre disputed those characterizations and argued that the defense was improperly asking the court to decide contested facts on a motion addressed to the pleadings.
The 2009 Epstein Settlement and Release
The release became public on January 3, 2022 after proceedings before Judge Loretta A. Preska in the related Giuffre v. Dershowitz litigation. It showed that Epstein agreed to pay Giuffre $500,000 and that the parties used broad language concerning possible defendants.
The document’s existence and language are established. Its application to Andrew was disputed. The central questions included:
- Whether Andrew fell within the intended category of released persons.
- Whether Florida contract law permitted him to enforce the agreement as a third-party beneficiary.
- Whether the agreement covered claims based on Andrew’s own alleged conduct.
- Whether the release language was sufficiently clear to dispose of the case without discovery.
The court did not finally decide what the release meant. It held that the critical language was reasonably susceptible to more than one interpretation and therefore could not support dismissal at that stage.
The filed 2009 agreement specified $500,000, excluding attorneys’ fees and costs. That known figure belongs to the Epstein agreement, not the undisclosed 2022 Andrew settlement.
January 12, 2022 Ruling
Judge Kaplan issued a 46-page opinion on January 12, 2022 denying the motion to dismiss. The decision is the case’s principal judicial ruling.
The court concluded that the 2009 release was ambiguous as applied to Andrew. Both sides offered reasonable interpretations, which meant the agreement’s meaning could not be resolved solely from the text on a motion to dismiss. Further proceedings could have included evidence about the parties’ intent and the circumstances surrounding the agreement.
The court also rejected dismissal of the pleaded battery and emotional-distress claims. The opinion explained that several defense arguments depended on facts outside the complaint or asked the court to resolve contested questions that were not appropriate at the pleading stage.
The opinion carefully limited what it decided. Judge Kaplan stated in substance that the ruling expressed no view on the truth of Giuffre’s allegations or on either party’s ultimate ability to prove its case. It determined that the arguments presented did not entitle Andrew to dismissal at the pleading stage; discovery had already begun.
The denial was a significant procedural victory for Giuffre because it required Andrew to answer the allegations and left both sides subject to continuing discovery obligations. It was not a verdict, liability judgment, or criminal finding.
Two related issues remained unresolved: whether Andrew fell within the release’s category of other potential defendants, and whether the contracting parties intended him to have enforceable third-party rights. The opinion’s release analysis did not finally hold that the agreement either covered or excluded him.
Answer, Defenses, and Jury Demand
Andrew filed his answer on January 26, 2022. He denied the material allegations and stated that he lacked sufficient knowledge to admit or deny some background assertions. He asserted affirmative defenses, including consent, waiver, release, statute-based defenses, lack of damages, and challenges to the legal sufficiency of Giuffre’s claims.
An affirmative defense preserves a legal argument. Its inclusion in an answer does not establish the defense as fact. Andrew also demanded a jury trial.
The answer joined the pleaded issues while the litigation and discovery process continued. A trial window later in 2022 had been discussed, and the parties prepared for document production and depositions. Andrew was expected to face sworn questioning. Giuffre likewise would have been subject to discovery and cross-examination.
Discovery and Evidence
The case settled before full discovery or trial. As a result, several important evidentiary questions remained unresolved in this docket.
Potential evidence included:
- Giuffre’s prior sworn statements and deposition testimony.
- Andrew’s public statements and anticipated deposition testimony.
- The photograph of Giuffre, Andrew, and Maxwell.
- Travel records, flight logs, calendars, address records, and witness testimony.
- Records from Epstein’s Manhattan residence and Little Saint James.
- Communications among Andrew, Epstein, Maxwell, and their staff.
- Evidence concerning the negotiation and intended scope of the 2009 release.
- Medical, therapeutic, and damages records subject to privacy protections.
The public docket does not show that Andrew completed a deposition in this case. Settlement was announced weeks before he was expected to be questioned under oath. Because discovery did not reach a public trial, the record should not be described as though all available evidence was admitted, authenticated, and weighed by a jury.
Discovery was already under way before January 12. In the December 31, 2021 order (Document 61), Judge Kaplan recorded that Andrew had served extensive discovery, including requests concerning Giuffre’s domicile. The court denied his requested additional two-hour deposition and stay without prejudice to a later jurisdictional defense. Settlement interrupted an existing process; it did not prevent every discovery step from occurring.
The November 3, 2021 supplemental scheduling order (Document 36) set initial disclosures for November 12 and recorded that each side anticipated 8-12 depositions. A planned deposition count is not evidence that those depositions were completed.
The Photograph
The image of Andrew, Giuffre, and Maxwell became the most recognizable item connected to the case. Giuffre said Epstein took it at Maxwell’s London residence in 2001. The published image appears to show Andrew with his arm around Giuffre’s waist and Maxwell standing nearby.
Andrew acknowledged that the figure looked like him but questioned the circumstances and said he had no recollection of the photograph being taken. Maxwell later publicly called the image fake. Giuffre consistently maintained that it was genuine.
Before the case ended, the original print was not produced for a definitive forensic examination in open court. Later-released emails attributed to Epstein and Maxwell appear to support that Giuffre met Andrew and that a photograph was taken. Those documents strengthen the historical record but remain distinct from a judicial authenticity finding.
The photograph, even if authentic, establishes a meeting and physical proximity. It does not by itself establish that any later sexual conduct occurred or whether it was consensual.
Settlement in Principle
On February 15, 2022, the parties filed a letter announcing a settlement in principle. The filing said they would submit a stipulated dismissal after Giuffre received the settlement payment. It also said the amount would not be disclosed.
The public settlement statement provided that:
- Andrew intended to make a substantial donation to Giuffre’s charity in support of victims’ rights.
- Andrew had never intended to malign Giuffre’s character.
- Andrew accepted that Giuffre had suffered as an established victim of abuse and from unfair public attacks.
- The statement recognized that Epstein had trafficked countless young girls over many years.
- Andrew regretted his association with Epstein.
- Andrew commended the bravery of Giuffre and other survivors.
- Andrew intended to support the fight against sex trafficking and its victims.
- The statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse; it did not disclose the full agreement or an express no-liability clause.
The statement did not say that Andrew admitted sexually assaulting Giuffre. It also did not retract his prior denials. At the same time, its recognition of Giuffre as an established abuse victim and its rejection of unfair attacks on her marked a substantial change from the aggressive language used in parts of the defense briefing.
Document 78 is the counsel letter; Document 78-1 is the separate attached statement. Document 79 suspended deadlines and held the case in abeyance through March 17, 2022. It reserved the possibility of the previously indicated trial schedule if dismissal was not filed, so February 15 was not the case’s dismissal date.
Settlement Amount and Confidential Terms
The official settlement amount has never been publicly disclosed. Contemporary reports offered estimates ranging above $10 million, and a widely repeated estimate placed the total around £12 million. Later reports offered conflicting figures and different accounts of how the payment and charitable contribution were funded.
EpsteinWiki should describe £12 million only as a reported estimate. It is not a figure established by the public settlement letter, the dismissal, or a damages judgment. The allocation among compensation, attorneys’ fees, and charitable support is also not publicly established.
The public record does not establish whether Queen Elizabeth II, King Charles III, other royal resources, insurance, loans, or Andrew’s personal assets funded any particular portion. The Treasury’s March 3, 2026 parliamentary answer states that no public money was used for the legal or settlement fees. That statement does not publicly disclose the complete private funding structure.
Reports about confidentiality or a temporary silence provision have also varied. The complete agreement is not public. Only the filed statement, court orders, and dismissal should be treated as confirmed public terms.
Reports concerning family contributions, including an attributed February 2026 denial of a Charles contribution, belong in the settlement guide. The Charles profile also distinguishes the separate October 2026 Royal Lodge transaction. A property-cost payment must not be added to an asserted 2022 settlement total.
Dismissal With Prejudice
On March 8, 2022, the parties filed a stipulation dismissing the action with prejudice following the settlement. The parties’ filing is Document 82; Judge Kaplan’s signed dismissal order is Document 83. The stipulation refers to a private agreement dated February 12, 2022 and invokes Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii). Each party agreed to bear her or his own costs and fees as specified in the stipulation.
A dismissal with prejudice permanently ends the claims in that action and ordinarily prevents them from being filed again. It is not the same as a judgment after trial. The court did not determine liability, award damages, make credibility findings, or enter factual findings concerning the three alleged encounters.
The reviewed docket shows no appellate merits ruling. The stipulated resolution should not be confused with an appellate decision affirming or reversing the January 12 opinion.
Procedural Timeline
| Date | Event | Legal significance |
|---|---|---|
| August 9, 2021 | Giuffre filed the complaint. | Began the federal civil action within the Child Victims Act revival window. |
| August 27, 2021 | Process server delivered papers at Royal Lodge. | Triggered a dispute over whether Andrew had been properly served. |
| September 2021 | Court authorized service through U.S. counsel and Andrew appeared. | Removed service as a practical barrier to litigation. |
| October 26, 2021 | Andrew sought permission to file the 2009 agreement under seal. | Raised the Epstein release as the principal defense to the action. |
| October 29, 2021 | Andrew filed his motion to dismiss. | Challenged the release, statutory basis, and sufficiency of the claims. |
| November 3, 2021 | Supplemental scheduling order set initial disclosures for November 12 and recorded anticipated depositions. | Confirms discovery activity before January 2022; planned depositions are not proof of completed testimony. |
| December 31, 2021 | Court denied the requested additional domicile deposition and stay. | Recorded that discovery requests already existed; preserved a later jurisdictional defense. |
| January 3, 2022 | The 2009 Giuffre-Epstein settlement became public. | Allowed public review of the release language Andrew invoked. |
| January 4, 2022 | Judge Kaplan heard oral argument. | The parties presented competing interpretations of the release and statutory issues. |
| January 12, 2022 | Motion to dismiss denied. | Allowed both claims and the existing discovery process to continue. |
| January 13, 2022 | Buckingham Palace announced return of Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages. | Institutional consequence occurring one day after the ruling, not a court-imposed sanction. |
| January 26, 2022 | Andrew filed his answer and jury demand. | Formally denied the allegations and preserved affirmative defenses. |
| February 12, 2022 | Date of the private settlement agreement identified in the later dismissal stipulation. | Distinct from the February 15 public announcement. |
| February 15, 2022 | Parties announced settlement in principle. | Suspended active litigation pending payment and dismissal. |
| March 8, 2022 | Stipulated dismissal with prejudice filed and approved. | Closed the case without trial or a liability finding. |
Consequences and Institutional Response
Andrew stepped back from public royal duties in November 2019 after the widely criticized Newsnight interview, nearly two years before Giuffre filed this lawsuit. On January 13, 2022, one day after the motion-to-dismiss ruling, Buckingham Palace announced that Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages had been returned to the Queen and that he would defend the case as a private citizen. He stopped using the style HRH in an official capacity.
Those actions were institutional decisions, not remedies ordered by Judge Kaplan. The court did not remove titles, military roles, patronages, or public duties.
Further formal changes to Andrew’s styles and titles occurred in 2025 amid renewed scrutiny and new document releases. Those later events belong in Andrew’s main biographical page and a current-investigations page. They should not be retroactively described as part of the 2022 settlement unless a reliable source expressly connects them.
The broader institutional record is maintained in Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein and Charles III and the Epstein Record. The later misconduct-in-public-office investigation, still ongoing in the October 2026 police update, is separate. The October 8 search-warrant order does not reopen this civil case or adjudicate Giuffre’s allegations.
Relationship to Maxwell’s Criminal Trial
Ghislaine Maxwell was convicted in federal court on December 29, 2021, while Andrew’s dismissal motion was pending. The conviction established Maxwell’s criminal responsibility for charged conduct involving recruitment and grooming of minors for Epstein.
Giuffre was not a trial witness in the Maxwell criminal case, and the Andrew allegations were not among the charged offenses decided by that jury. The conviction provided important background about the Epstein-Maxwell trafficking operation, but it did not prove Andrew’s liability in this separate civil action.
Primary Court Records
CourtListener’s docket provides PACER-derived copies. The filed documents must be distinguished from reporting about them; the official court record remains controlling.
- August 9, 2021 complaint, Document 1: The pleaded allegations, two causes of action and requested relief; not findings of fact.
- September 16, 2021 alternative-service order, Document 16: Order permitting service through United States counsel.
- September 28, 2021 filed service stipulation and order, Document 20: Deems service effective September 21 and sets the response deadline; preserves other defenses.
- October 27, 2021 temporary sealing order, Document 29: Permitted temporary sealing while the related protective-order issue was addressed.
- October 29, 2021 motion to dismiss, Document 30: Andrew’s motion challenging the complaint; not the court’s decision.
- December 29, 2021 unsealing order, Document 59: Directed public release of the 2009 agreement on January 3, 2022.
- November 3, 2021 supplemental scheduling order, Document 36: Sets initial disclosures and records planned depositions, confirming pre-January discovery activity.
- December 31, 2021 discovery and domicile order, Document 61: Confirms discovery requests already existed before the motion-to-dismiss ruling; did not finally decide domicile.
- 2009 Giuffre-Epstein agreement, filed as Document 32-1: The separate $500,000 settlement and disputed release; not the 2022 Andrew settlement.
- January 12, 2022 opinion, Document 64: Denies the motion to dismiss without determining the truth of the allegations.
- January 26, 2022 answer and jury demand, Document 71: Andrew’s denials and affirmative defenses; defenses are not established facts.
- February 15, 2022 settlement-in-principle letter, Document 78: Counsel’s notice and request to suspend deadlines.
- February 15, 2022 attached public settlement statement, Document 78-1: Undisclosed amount, intended charitable donation and public acknowledgements; not the complete settlement contract.
- February 15, 2022 suspension order, Document 79: Held the action in abeyance through March 17, subject to filing dismissal; it was not the dismissal itself.
- March 8, 2022 stipulation and proposed order, Document 82: Refers to the February 12 settlement agreement, Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), dismissal with prejudice and each side’s costs and fees.
- March 8, 2022 signed dismissal order, Document 83: Judge Kaplan’s signed order dismissing the action with prejudice.
Epstein Data Evidence Sources
The following EFTA records provide related evidence and investigative context. Most were created in other proceedings or investigations. They are not filings from No. 1:21-cv-06702 unless the document itself says otherwise.
| EFTA record | Contents | Evidentiary caution |
|---|---|---|
| EFTA00021553 | 2015 filing in Jane Does v. United States identifying Prince Andrew in Giuffre’s allegations | A filed allegation, not a verdict or judicial finding |
| EFTA00098456 | Giuffre declaration and related material concerning Andrew | Sworn account requiring evaluation with the complete record |
| EFTA00045963 | Material summarizing Giuffre’s account of three alleged encounters | Secondary or compiled presentation, not a court finding |
| EFTA00022133 | Government spreadsheet of allegations drawn from press reporting | Labeled as press-sourced and not an FBI factual determination |
| EFTA00022062 | U.S. mutual legal assistance request concerning Andrew | Shows investigative requests and then-current evidence assessment, not guilt |
| EFTA00010321 | Correspondence stating Andrew declined a voluntary interview | Documents the government’s position in a cooperation dispute |
| EFTA00022059 | Record that the mutual legal assistance request was delivered to the United Kingdom | Establishes procedural transmission, not the result of compelled testimony |
| EFTA00017042 | Andrew’s representatives disputing the U.S. characterization of noncooperation | Defense-side account that should be read with government correspondence |
| EFTA00022980 | Additional correspondence concerning cooperation | Does not show that a substantive interview occurred |
| EFTA01660622 | FBI briefing compiling allegations and internal assessments involving prominent names | Contains allegations of differing reliability, not adjudicated conclusions |
| EFTA01866152 | 2011 correspondence referring to the Central Park photograph of Andrew and Epstein | Establishes contemporary awareness of that photograph |
| EFTA01810893 | Communication reflecting direct contact between Andrew and Epstein | Establishes contact where authenticated, not knowledge of abuse |
| EFTA02418723 | Additional direct communication linked to Andrew and Epstein | Relationship evidence, not proof of the conduct alleged by Giuffre |
| EFTA01779732 | Public-relations material concerning Andrew and Epstein | Shows reputation-management activity and attached reporting |
The Prince Andrew investigation report from R Howard Stone’s Epstein Data project provides a wider corpus map. This is secondary, AI-generated analysis; its categories and conclusions should be checked against each underlying EFTA document.
EFTA00098456 is a 51-page packet sent by attorney Paul Cassell to the Metropolitan Police on May 4, 2015. It includes Giuffre’s January 2015 declaration under penalty of perjury. The sworn declaration, the covering lawyer’s account and any attached investigative summaries are different source types; the packet is not a single adjudicated finding.
What the Court Record Establishes
The court record establishes that:
- Giuffre filed a civil action against Andrew on August 9, 2021.
- She alleged three instances of sexual abuse when she was 17.
- She pleaded battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- She relied on New York’s Child Victims Act revival window.
- Andrew appeared through counsel and contested service, jurisdictional issues, the claims, and the action’s legal basis.
- Andrew invoked the 2009 Giuffre-Epstein release as a defense.
- Judge Kaplan held that the release was ambiguous as applied to Andrew at the pleading stage.
- The court denied Andrew’s motion to dismiss.
- Andrew denied the allegations in a formal answer and demanded a jury trial.
- The parties reached a confidential settlement in principle.
- The public statement announced an intended charitable donation and the acknowledgements reproduced in Document 78-1; it did not supply proof of the donation’s payment.
- The action was dismissed with prejudice on March 8, 2022.
- No trial, verdict or damages judgment occurred; no appellate merits ruling is shown in the reviewed record.
What the Court Record Does Not Establish
The court record does not establish that:
- A judge or jury found that Andrew sexually assaulted Giuffre.
- A judge or jury found Giuffre’s allegations false.
- Denial of the motion to dismiss was a liability finding.
- Andrew admitted liability by settling.
- The settlement amount was £12 million or any other reported figure.
- The complete funding source for the settlement is publicly known.
- The photograph alone proves sexual abuse.
- The 2009 release ultimately did or did not cover Andrew after full factual development.
- Every allegation appearing in an EFTA investigative record was verified by the FBI.
- Maxwell’s conviction adjudicated Giuffre’s claims against Andrew.
- Association with Epstein, standing alone, proves participation in Epstein’s crimes.
Investigative Assessment
The case produced a meaningful but limited public accountability record. Giuffre overcame Andrew’s effort to terminate the action at the pleading stage. The ruling meant her complaint was legally sufficient and that the disputed release did not provide an immediate escape from litigation. Andrew then filed an answer and faced potential sworn testimony and document production.
The settlement prevented public testing of the central evidence. There was no deposition of Andrew on the public docket, no cross-examination before a jury, no ruling on photograph authenticity, no final interpretation of the 2009 release, and no damages record. Confidential resolution provided finality and compensation while leaving major factual questions formally unanswered.
The public settlement language matters independently of the undisclosed payment. Andrew moved from categorical public attacks on Giuffre’s allegations to a statement recognizing her as an established victim of abuse, regretting his association with Epstein, and commending survivor bravery. That language did not admit Andrew’s alleged conduct, but it was a documented reputational and institutional reversal.
Key Takeaways
- This was a civil lawsuit, not a criminal prosecution.
- Giuffre alleged three assaults when she was 17, in London, Manhattan, and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
- Andrew denied all sexual misconduct and was never found liable by a court.
- Judge Kaplan denied Andrew’s motion to dismiss because the claims were legally sufficient to proceed and the 2009 release was ambiguous.
- A motion-to-dismiss ruling does not determine whether allegations are true.
- Andrew answered the complaint and demanded a jury trial before settling.
- The public statement contained no admission that Andrew committed the alleged abuse.
- The official amount remains undisclosed, so reported figures must be labeled estimates.
- The case was dismissed with prejudice following the settlement.
- The settlement ended the litigation before discovery was completed, Andrew’s anticipated deposition and trial.
Fact Check
| Claim | Assessment | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Andrew was criminally prosecuted in this case. | False | The action was a private civil lawsuit. |
| The lawsuit alleged three encounters. | Supported | The complaint identified London, Manhattan, and Little Saint James. |
| Giuffre was 17 during the alleged encounters. | Alleged and consistently stated | The case ended without a trial finding on the underlying events. |
| Judge Kaplan found Andrew guilty. | False | Civil judges do not determine criminal guilt in a motion-to-dismiss ruling. |
| Judge Kaplan found Andrew civilly liable. | False | The ruling only allowed the claims to proceed. |
| The 2009 Epstein agreement clearly released Andrew. | Not established | The court held the relevant language was ambiguous. |
| Andrew admitted assault in the settlement. | False | The public statement contains no admission of the alleged abuse, but it does not expressly recite a no-liability clause. |
| Andrew acknowledged Giuffre was an abuse victim. | Supported | The public settlement statement recognized her as an established victim of abuse. |
| Andrew paid exactly £12 million. | Unverified | The amount was confidential and published figures conflict. |
| The case went to trial. | False | It settled and was dismissed with prejudice. |
| The photograph was judicially authenticated in this case. | False | No final evidentiary ruling occurred before settlement. |
| Andrew’s royal consequences were ordered by the court. | False | They were decisions by the royal institution. |
Questions Still Unanswered
- What was the exact settlement amount?
- How was the payment divided among compensation, legal fees, and charitable support?
- What private or institutional sources funded each component?
- What were the complete confidentiality, non-disparagement, and timing terms?
- What documents had the parties exchanged before settlement?
- What testimony would Andrew have given under oath?
- Would the original photograph or its chain of custody have been established at trial?
- What evidence would have been offered about each alleged location and date?
- What did the negotiators of the 2009 Epstein release intend the third-party language to cover?
- Would the Child Victims Act claims have survived later factual and constitutional challenges?
- Which relevant government records remain sealed, redacted, or unreleased?
- How do later-released Epstein and Maxwell communications affect the historical assessment of Andrew’s public denials?
These questions should be pursued through authenticated records, sworn testimony, and complete document context rather than speculation about survivors or guilt by association.
Related People and Organizations
- Virginia Giuffre
- Prince Andrew, now Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Ghislaine Maxwell
- Judge Lewis A. Kaplan
- Judge Loretta A. Preska
- David Boies
- Sigrid McCawley
- Andrew Brettler
- Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
- Lavely & Singer, P.C.
- Buckingham Palace
- Metropolitan Police Service
- United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York
- Federal Bureau of Investigation
- SOAR, Giuffre’s survivor-advocacy initiative
Related EpsteinWiki Articles
- Virginia Roberts Giuffre
- Prince Andrew
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Ghislaine Maxwell
- Giuffre v. Maxwell
- Giuffre v. Dershowitz
- Maxwell Criminal Trial: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell
- United States v. Epstein (S.D.N.Y. 2019)
- Little Saint James
- 9 East 71st Street
- Ghislaine Maxwell’s London Residence
- Prince Andrew and Virginia Giuffre Photograph
- Epstein Flight Logs and Manifests
- Deposition Transcript Index
- Exhibits Index
- Epstein Civil Litigation Index
- Civil case overview
- Civil settlement, funding and confidentiality guide
- Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor: main profile
- Charles III: royal decisions and financial evidence limits
- Royal Family and Jeffrey Epstein
External Sources
- Reuters, “Prince Andrew accuser’s 2009 deal with Epstein shielded others,” January 3, 2022
- The Guardian, “Prince Andrew has failed to dismiss the lawsuit against him,” January 12, 2022
- The Guardian, “Prince Andrew settles Virginia Giuffre sexual assault case in US,” February 15, 2022
- BBC News, “Prince Andrew Newsnight interview: Transcript in full,” November 17, 2019
- R Howard Stone’s Epstein Data project, Prince Andrew investigation report